John Allegro and the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis (Ascough, 2025); Richard Ascough on Psychedelics in Western Religious History

Michael Hoffman 8:18 p.m. January 21, 2026

Crop by Michael Hoffman

Contents:

Links work on desktop Edge/Chrome:

John Allegro and the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis (Ascough, 2025)

John Allegro and the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis
Richard Ascough
2025/08/08
School of Religion, Queen’s University at Kingston, Kingston, ON, Canada
https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/16/8/1029
John_Allegro_and_the_Psychedelic_Mysteries_Hypothe.pdf

https://www.google.com/search?q=richard+ascough+the+psychedelic+mysteries+hypothesis
There are reviews of the article.

My page section in mysticism Moving Past Mysticism in Psychedelic Science:

Titles of This Page

Richard Ascough on Psychedelics in Western Religious History

todo: need two pages:

  • Ascough in general (scope of present page)
  • The On John article only.

Mosurinjohn/Ascough Assert Two Contradictory Positions

A couple pairs of scholars contacted the Journal of Psychedelic History, and the Journal of Religious Anything-but-Drugs Studies.

One pair of scholars is named Mosurinjohn & Ascough.  Their position is that:

There are no psychedelics in mystery religions; Ruck is wrong and foolish and needs fundamental correction.

I flagged in bold red, around 10 phrases that assert this, and that send this signal or message.

The other pair of scholars is also named Mosurinjohn & Ascough.  Their position is that:

Psychedelics might have been used in mystery religions, but we only have a little evidence for that, and cannot draw a conclusion, and the field of entheogen scholarship badly needs our input to caution them that a hypothesis is not a fact.

I will do my 4th close reading of their article that’s been rejected by both camps: “anything but drugs” academics, and entheogen scholars:

  • One highlighter color on phrases that assert and signal “There were no psychedelics in Mystery Religions.”  (Aggressive, bailey position.)
  • Other highlighter color on phrases that pander to entheogen scholars, saying “We’re on your side, don’t be pissed off at us, alls we’re saying is merely that you guys need to gather more data before any conclusion is possible.”  (Feeble, motte position.)

If Ruck turns mere possibility (maybe there were psychedelics in mystery religions) into as-if fact (we can be certain the engine of mystery religion was psychedelics),

Mosurinjohn & Ascough do the same, in the other valence direction: they turn mere possibility (maybe there were no psychedelics in mystery religions, because eg. contemplative drama in a cave can/ could/ might/ may produce same effect as 10g of Cubensis) into as-if fact (we disproved the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis).

This way, both camps will love and accept Mosurinjohn & Ascough — or, both camps reject and are pissed off at Mosurinjohn & Ascough, the double agents who skew negative, unlike Ruck who skews positive.

They wrote an article that’s about how that selfsame article got rejected for publication by both camps, for years.

Their strategy of selling to one camp with one message, and also selling to the other camp with the opposite message, has been a terrible struggle for them, and we should feel sorry for Mosurinjohn and the dead weight of Ascough she’s dragging along with her while she avoids journal publication and instead writes a book about entheogens in esotericism, that has:

* One chapter on “the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis is false and foolish, and urgently needs correction by me”.

* Another chapter on — not contributing any new research to add substance to the field, but rather — cautioning the misguided and weak-minded entheogen scholars to remember that a hypothesis is not a fact.

Should be a great leap forward for the field.  Just pick which one chapter you agree with, and read that one.

By the time the book comes out, she hopes to figure out how to pander to both opposed camps, without them continuing to both shun her and her alter ego;

Dr. Jekyll: “We must be nuanced, balanced, reasonable, and cautiously gather more data, before we can draw any conclusions”,

and Mr. Hyde: “Entheogen scholars are fools and have BEEN DEBUNKED!”

Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, 2025)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/08/psychedelics-eleusis-and-the-invention-of-religious-experience-mosurinjohn-ascough-2025/

Richard Ascough on Psychedelics in Western Religious History
https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/22/richard-ascough-on-psychedelics-in-western-religious-history/

Video: The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences (Mosurinjohn, Sep. 2025)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/20/the-sweetest-taboo-psychedelics-and-the-invention-of-religious-experiences-mosurinjohn-2025/

Search EgodeathTheory.WordPress.com for: mosurinjohn
https://egodeaththeory.org/?s=mosurinjohn

In idea development page 30:

Book: Entheogenics: Psychedelic Experiences as Revelatory Events in the History of Western Esotericism (Mosurinjohn, in progress)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/06/11/idea-development-page-30/#book-entheogenics-psychedelic-experiences-as-revelatory-events-in-the-history-of-western-esotericism-mosurinjohn-in-progress-per-2022

The search accurately returns also, long misc pages containing research and evidence for the above, Find “mosur” in them:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/24/idea-development-page-32/
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/21/idea-development-page-31/

Concise recent summary article for publication in a church reader:
Recognizing Mushroom Imagery in Medieval Art
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/08/recognizing-mushroom-imagery-in-medieval-art/

— Michael Hoffman, Egodeath.com, the Egodeath theory (analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control)

Ascough Definitively Proclaims “They Weren’t Using Psychedelics in Mystery Religions”

Video title:
Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough
YouTube channel: Ayush Prakash
Dec. 25, 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2730s (45:30)

“She [Sharday Mosurinjohn] texted me and she said:
Richard, you knew I was working on psychedelics,
Why didn’t you tell me that [at] the root of the Eleusinian mystery religions, one of the oldest, on their very core, they were doing psychedelics?

And I would text her back: “uh, because they weren’t.”

What happened to Ascough’s nuance, his “I agree that maybe”, “we need to be cautious”, “Be a nuanced, cautiuous scholar, like wonderful me, the perfect model”?

Jekyll & Hyde:

  • Dr. Jekyll says “Maybe psychedelics in mystery religions, we need to investigate w/ caution and nuance. Follow my wise, cautious lead.”
  • Mr. Hyde says “It’s a myth, psychedelics in mystery religions. There were no psychedelics in mystery religions.”

The motte-and-bailey argumentation, slip-n-slide, what is your position?

Ascough oscillates and prevaricates between two self-contradictory positions, back and forth.

Here, he SLAMS his cards down on the table, and definitively asserts NO.

I don’t think Christian Greer waffles and contradicts himself this way.

Mosurinjohn & Ascough (When Holding Their Aggressive, Bailey Position) Present as if Fact, the Mere Possibility that There Were No Psychedelics in Mystery Religions

Abstract of Article “Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience”: Mosurinjohn & Ascough Assert No Psychedelics in Mystery Religions

From the Abstract of the article Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, 2025):

“This article corrects an idea in psychedelic science and culture that the ancient Eleusynian Mysteries used psychedelics“

“the dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages“

“the writers of this pseudo-history“

“the psychedelic hypothesis is fundamentally flawed in its study of antiquity”

“Instead of committing to a specific (and erroneous) view of history,”

Conference Schedule: Mosurinjohn Asserts no Psychedelics in Mystery Religions

From the conference schedule’s description of Sharday Mosurinjohn’s talk:

“these writers’ dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages“

From the video’s description of Mosurinjohn’s talk:

“the belief that ancient Western religions were fundamentally psychedelic [is] less a historical hypothesis but a myth“

“Why is the psychedelic discourse so intent on hanging on to this narrative?”

Hu Weblog Interview: Ascough Asserts No psychedelics in mystery religions

From the Hu weblog interview with M&A:

I shred this contradiction, below in this page, in detail.

Ascough said to Hu:

“And my response[citation?] is, no, it has been considered, [yeah ok but was it published, when, where, by who?] and it’s so wrong that we don’t need to keep repeating it! [repeating what? which articles? citation needed]

“I work on the Mystery religions, but psychedelics never show up in the academic literature about them. [Reporter’s note: Mystery religions are secret religious groups or cults from Greco-Roman times.] 

“[re: psychedelics in Mystery Religions] It’s very rare [in classicists’ publications] and if it comes up at all, it’s something like, “There is this fringe element that talks about psychedelics but they have no evidence.”

And yet, at these psychedelics conferences, it keeps coming up again and again. There’s a disconnect between what has been said by biblical scholars and classists [citations needed!], and what’s being promoted within the psychedelics community. That forced us, then, to dig deeper: Where does this disconnect come from? Why is there this disjuncture?”

Ruck Sometimes Changes the Possibility of Psychedelics in Mystery Religions into a Fact

Ascough Sometimes Changes the Possibility of No Psychedelics in Mystery Religions into a Fact

Hypocrites Sharday Mosurinjohn & Richard Ascough, in their self-promotional posturing, try to draw all attention to Ruck’s shifting from possibility to fact — while at the same time, they themselves do the same, just in the opposite direction:

  • Ruck’s feeble, motte position:
    “There might be psychedelics in mystery religions.”
  • Ruck’s aggressive, bailey position:
    “There certainly were psychedelics in mystery religions.”
  • Ascough’s feeble, motte position:
    “There might not be psychedelics in mystery religions.”
    Ascough’s aggressive, bailey position:
    “There certainly were not psychedelics in mystery religions.”

Everyone get ready, now Shift! Shift back! Shift back again!

Motte is a bad-sounding word; the undesired position of no consequence, to retreat to:

“I’m merely saying, quite unobjectionably, X.”

Bailey is a good-sounding word; the position you WISH you could defend, but can’t:

  • Ruck (when he shifts to his aggressive, bailey position): “There definitely were psychedelics in mystery religions; that’s a fact.”
  • Ascough (when he shifts to his aggressive, bailey position): “There definitely were no psychedelics in mystery religions; that’s a myth.”

Both Ruck and Ascough, when pressed, and retreat to the feeble, undisputed, motte position, have the SAME POSITION:

  • Ruck’s & Ascough’s feeble, motte position:
    “There might be psychedelics in mystery religions.”

The above is simplified, depending on which variant of the question is under dispute. There is certain evidence for certain presence of some plants in some contexts; no one disputes that.

The hardest thing in dirty entheogen scholarship debate:
What exactly is the point under dispute? It shifts in shell-game fashion.

Ascough has disproved Ruck. What exactly did Ascough disprove? Nothing of any consequence:

At most, Ascough proved that WHEN Ruck asserts that we have certainty that psychedelics were in in mystery religions, Ruck is wrong on that particular point or position.

What Ascough has NOT proved, is there were not psychedelics in mystery religions.

Yet, half the time, Ascough asserts that he has proved”Ruck is wrong”; proved “no psychedelics in Mystery Religions”.

Look at the juicy bad phrases in the Abstract of Mos & Asc Inventing Religion:

These phrases are meant to imply and assert “There definitely were not psychedelics in mystery religions”.

This is the aggressive, indefensible, bailey position that the authors attack from, when they are not retreating into their weak, motte position that no one disputes.

Video: Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough (Dec. 25, 2024)

Video title:
Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough
YouTube channel: Ayush Prakash
Dec. 25, 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M —

Gibberish, low credibility:
“the idea of synthesizing the ergot from mushrooms” —
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2901s (48:23)

The first 60% of the video is on the Birth of Xy.

The 2nd 40% of the video is on psychedelics in Western religious history, which certainly didn’t exist, and which may have existed to some extent, too early to say, therefore, [loud headline propaganda:] entheogen scholars are WRONG and foolish (ie inferior to me), and we shall analyze why they persist in their wrong folly hypothesis.

Motte –> Bailey –> Motte –> Bailey, slip-n-slide, shifty shell game con artist like all the MICA Deniers – mushroom imagery in Christian art.

Not “Logical Fallacies”; Rather, Propaganda; Narrative Framing Tactics

These are not “logical fallacies”; these are PROPAGANDA TACTICS AGAINST psychedelics in Western religious history.

Kettle logic; Ascough contradicts himself constantly.

What is your claim? It keeps shifting! It’s a contradictory shifting set of claims, elastic.

You can’t rebut his position, b/c he is dancing hard on the dance floor, or skating rink with foul dirty moves.

Ayush Prakash Podcast (YouTube playlist)
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCgU9D4fIV2pSPDElLqX0l4sxOi_l3e-2
This is episode 111.

Richard S. Ascough is Professor of Religion Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.

Motivation for this Page

Need to examine transcript of 2nd part of his talk in this interview.

Found timestamp in vid where he says “we haven’t gathered the .. we’re still collecting the evidence to see if psychedelics — ie THE EXTENT TO WHICH psychedelics in Western religious history.”

Insanely flip-flops contradicting the F out of himself. Motte & Bailey Fest.

Xn Greer has a viable, stable, coherent, consistent position he puts forth. It’s minimal/moderate, but consistent!

  • Ascough: “There was no psychedelics in Western religious history. Entheogen scholars are blundering fools, they are WRONG. Why do these stupid entheogen scholars persist in their folly and false wishful theories?
  • Also Ascough: “There MIGHT be some amount of psychedelics in Western religious history and evidence, we don’t know.”

THEN WHY DO YOU PERSECUTE, INSULT, DISRESPECT, AND TELL ENTHEOGEN SCHOLARS THEY ARE DEFINITELY WRONG?

You can’t write your abstract’s PROPAGANDA-type NARRATIVE assertions “there were no psychedelics in Mystery Religions”, yet then say “We don’t know; absense of evidence isn’t ev of ab; still collecting data, not done yet; cannot draw conclusion” — and,

“CONCLUSION: ANNOUNCEMENT IN ABSTRACT OF ARTICLE: HEADLINE: ENTHEOGEN SCHOLARS ARE IDIOTS, AND THERE IS NO EVIDENCE, AND THERE WERE NO PSYCHEDELICS IN Western religious history“

5 min later, footnote, ENDNOTE, “Look how reasonable and balanced of a thinker I am: There might have been some amount of use of psychedelics, too soon to say.”

Greer doesn’t do that sh!t. He holds a moderate position, CONSISTENTLY; artic’d w/ nuance; a defensible actual position.

Ascough’s “position” is that of a waffle.
https://www.google.com/search?q=waffle+%22motte+and+bailey%22

Animation of the Motte-and-Bailey Fallacy

A copy of this section is in my Sharday Mosurinjohn page (“Invention of Religious Experience”) and in my Ascough page.

Video: What is the difference between science and pseudoscience? (Strange Loop, Dec. 2025)

Video title:
What is the difference between science and pseudoscience?
Dec. 4, 2025
YouTube Channel: The Strange Loop
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTpxICN-O1U&t=442s [7:22]

  • Animation of the motte-and-bailey fallacy at 7:22:
    Aggressive, bailey position: “Your mind controls reality.”
    Feeble, motte position: “How you think can have some effect on what happens.”
  • There’s no hard line between Science vs. Pseudoscience.
  • Summarizes the book about how after cold war, Physics was defunded, then Marketed by Woo scientists successfully:

How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival
David Kaiser, 2011
https://www.amazon.com/How-Hippies-Saved-Physics-Counterculture/dp/0393076369/

Article: The Vacuity of Postmodernist Methodology (Shakel, 2005): Defines the Motte & Bailey Fallacy

Web search:
“The Vacuity of Postmodernist Methodology”
Nicholas Shakel, 2005
https://www.google.com/search?q=%22The+Vacuity+of+Postmodernist+Methodology%22

Transcript of Video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”

Video title:
Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2670s [44:30, start of psychedelics topic]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2670s

44:30 = cal

[The end of vid is 1:13:39 = 1:14:00 = 60 + 14 = 74 minutes. This is 44/74 = 60% into the vid before he talks about the psychedelics topic promised by the vid title.

First 60% of vid is good, summary of history of Christianity, not at all psychedelics. -mh]

I guess we should turn to psychedelics now.

This is this a new place for me but sure

I think it’s a new place for all of us

I think like religion psychedelics have

like

if there’s religion; there’s spirituality; psychedelics are kind of a third rail topic

there’s an incorporation of all of these tenants but it’s also I guess more science-backed, because there’s Neuroscience research, psychology, psychology research

all of this how

is there a history of religion and psychedelics that we should talk about

Ascough Is Not Self-Motivated Interest in Entheogen Scholarship: Mosurinjohn Pushed Him into “Psychedelics in Mystery Religions”

certainly I’m I’m happy to and this is it’s new to me because it’s my colleagues that’s pushed me

so I’ll give a shout out to Sharday Mosurinjohn who teaches religion and contemporary culture here

um and so

A colleague but also a friend

and

She was starting to investigate religion and psychedelics, and she’d be at conferences and she would

you know

We’ve worked on papers, published papers, a couple of different papers together.

below is con’t: Transcript of Video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”…

Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough (Hu, Sep. 2025)

This is just a minor copy of this citation info; see longer entry further down below.

Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough
“The professors discuss the scant evidence for the idea that the Eleusinian Mysteries used psychedelics, and why it persists anyway.”
Jane Hu, Sep. 15, 2025
https://themicrodose.substack.com/p/myth-busting-psychedelics-in-ancient
My page:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/20/psychedelics-eleusis-and-the-invention-of-religious-experience-mosurinjohn-2025/#Myth-busting-psychedelics-in-ancient-Greece

Ascough Is Storytelling an Inaccurate Narrative, According to Mosur; Not Trustworthy (nor Consistent)

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

And so she [Sharday Mosurinjohn] texted me and she said [or not -mh]:

Richard, you knew I was working on psychedelics,

Why didn’t you tell me that the root of the Eleusinian mystery religions, one of the oldest, on their very core, they were doing psychedelics?

[Sharday disputes that. That’s Ascough’s imaginative telling of what she texted him; a docu-drama fictionalized; see Hu: Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough]

[she says b.s. she did not say that. She *ASKED* his opinion. -mh]

and I would text her back uh because they weren’t

and she’d say well no no no

I’m at this conference and they just I’ve just heard all these papers on it

[by the loaded, negative word “narrative”, he means it’s false – but that is Not Proven, as he sometimes says -mh]

I’m like yeah nobody in the religious studies Fields thinks that, but in the study of psychedelics, they have this narrative that the ancient mystery religions were all about psychedelics

and and

part of their narrative is, it’s so controversial that people working on ancient history can’t face it

it’s it’s they

they’re afraid of it, so they buried it

uh and

that’s a very different argument

rhetorically it’s very clever, but it’s different than

no it’s just wrong because there’s no evidence for it

[“wrong” is not the same as “no evidence”! as Ascough says, sometimes: absense of evidence != evidence of absence -mh]

so

she and I spent last couple of years back and forth and when writing a paper now on psychedelics and the ancient Mysteries and what– where the evidence isn’t there

neither of us would say they didn’t– it didn’t involve psychedelics

[but half the time, in your sprinting between Motte & Bailey, you DO say exactly that.

it is a mere tedious, and amusing, exercise, to gather adjacently, your directly contradictory statements, and tone-soaked insinuations

WE ARE NOT SAYING IT WASN’T PSYCHEDELICS
next page:
IT WASN’T PSYCHEDELICS
-mh]

“There Is Some Evidence” (Yet Blaring Headline: “Entheogen scholars are fools, there is no evidence; there were no psychedelics in Mystery Religions”)

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

but both of us agree that that there’s very very little evidence for it and what evidence is there is it has to be nuanced and played out carefully

[that is what Greer says UP FRONT. more consistent and honest than Ascough -mh]

and there’s two books one from the 70s the road to elus and one more recently The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku.

  • [The Road to Eleusis – Ruck, along with academic fraud Gordon . . . .🔍🧐🤔 Wasson
  • The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020
    -mh]

For Better or Worse, Entheogen scholarship is now in the age of Muraresku-Centered Debate

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

so

Both of those report [purport?] to present a lot of historical evidence and a lot of scientific evidence

Ascough’s Argumentation: When you Dig Past the Rhetoric, There’s Not Much Substance to It

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

when you dig past the rhetoric there’s not much substance to it

there’s

there’s

a lot it it plays well to be honest

it reads well, but there’s a lot of

For example, the use of of words in Greek that sound like other words, and so this proves points, but they don’t emologic like linguistically it doesn’t work

sort of the

the conjecture on one page becomes fact on the next page

[science model adoption is fair, Ascough’s criticism doesn’t nece. hold water -mh]

so we

we traced it through to kind of say this is problematic

it just means their arguments are problematic so going back to you

“Students, You Are Not Wrong, But Need More Evidence”

Self-Promotional Headline: “YOU’RE WRONG!! I’m Right and Disproved, DESTROYED, the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis!”

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

what I say to my students:

not saying you’re wrong, but you’d have to give me evidence, and if I can poke holes in the evidence then we have to go back and reexamine the evidence

Poke Holes in the Ascough Wall of Fallacies

5th-Grade Just-So Story about “The Scientific Method”; “If Disconfirm a Theory, Means Instantly Must Discard It”

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

any scientific experiment you test the hypothesis again and again again each time you might Nuance the hypothesis a little bit bit so you know

logically is it conceivable that for 5 600 years or even more you have thousands of people going through these Mysteries all doing psychedelics to have the experience and not one of them not one ever put on record that this is what happened

it seems like something would slip out somewhere

um and and the you know

“Synthesizing the Ergot from Mushrooms into an LSD Type of Substance” – Ascough’s Level of Credibility

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

the idea of of synthesizing the airut from mushrooms into an LSD type of substance there just very weak basic you know we can do it now in highly technical Labs but could priests do it back then

not saying they couldn’t but I’m saying where’s it’s conjecture but it has to be proven

so we have a lot of fun kind of going back and forth on on this um

What Motivates Idiot Entheogen scholars in Their Error, Folly, and Wrongness? I Explain Their Inner, Incorrect Thoughts

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

what’s actually more interesting to me and so this is now getting to your real question I think what’s more interesting to to Professor Moz and John and myself is not

“did they or didn’t they involve psychedelics”

They Have These Strategic Motives, for their Wrongness and Error

[“i can list some actual motives of Ruck correctly, to discredit him”;
“to explain his motives, is to reveal that he’s false”.

The TONE, the framing, of Ascough’s explanation of / listing of motives, is delivered as if it is therefore disproof of psychedelics in Western religious history.

“Proof of no psychedelics in Western religious history: The motive of the entheogen scholars is to legalize psychedelics. Therefore, no psychedelics in Western religious history. Q.E.D.” -mh]

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

But why is it so important to the Psychedelic Community today that they did and part of it is they want legalization and we know that in South America they were using iasa [aya] in what we would call religious rituals long before Christianity

Indigenous Shams Are Known for a Fact to Use Aya in 3000 B.C., therefore, Entheogen scholars [think “Muraresku”] are wrong, only looking back to 30 A.D.

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

and they know this as well but that’s not where they want to find their evidence they want to find it in Greece and in Rome and where the evidence is big barely discernible and I in part of me thinks that’s because they know in North America we you know especially in the United States which has grounded itself in Roman republicanism I mean their Senate Building look exactly like the Roman senate they just want to be Roman and now probably want to be more of an Empire so that’s a whole different topic uh you might want to cut that one out um but uh they need the antecedent to be Greek and Rome not Inca

Looking for Psychedelics in Western religious history is Impermissible and False, because It Is Racism, which is the Worst Sin that Moses Listed in the 10 Commandments (Colonialist Violence!)

Redeem Yourself by Only Studying Indig Shams on Ayahuasca in 3000 B.C.

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

not my end Mayan sort of an almost an implicit racism there right that that you’ve got it right in your backyard but for it to sort of support the kind of legal arguments they’re making for for for the um wider use medicalization but even broader social use of psychedelics they they keep looking to Western history and and that’s fascinating to me absolutely they have Alternatives so that’s so this is where we’re going with this so a lot of work being done it’s it’s just so so since Professor Moz John has started working on this and sort of pulled me in a few years ago more and more work is just exploding in terms of of psychedelics and religion so it’s really exciting lots more to learn and and lots of arguments coming along but but again my question is just is the evidence there yeah we can look at that but why why does it matter to me why does it matter to me that we get a historically right because it doesn’t matter to me whether the substances are legalized or not I I have no skin in the game that way I haven’t invested in any kind of pharmaceutical companies or anything um but but I’m fascinated as the story both what they do at the ancient times but what they’re trying to do now using that evidence

Host (Ayush Prakash) Pushes Back Against Full of Sh!t Ascough

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

yeah I I do want to kind of go back and forth in this and if I might push back just a little bit yeah absolutely it it does seem kind of it would be strange that the church has this intense scrubbing of anything that goes against like directly what they want but they would include psychedelics that does that does seem to calculate that if they didn’t want these their their disciples or the working class to undergo these um sessions of spiritual enlightenment to see that there’s so much more um you know we always see you know people that undergo DMT or even high doses of LSD and pilosyan and even um what’s it even Molly I forget of ecstasy when they undergo these high doses there’s an incredibly religious experience um yeah where they they see we’re all one they interact with sentient beings if they’re on DMT or engaging in the iasa ceremonies and so all of these tenants of religion without the oppression come into being and you get a a Oneness you get a sense of unity and it would make sense that all of these oppressive authoritative dare I say totalitarian um regimes um religions would kind of hold off and say no no no those are the devil’s lettuce

Drunkenness Means Alcohol, in the Bible, No Trace of Psychedelics in the Bible

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

let’s say you know those are the devil’s compounds and not want anybody to take them to see that there’s something so much more than what they’re being offered well so to start with that then that’s exactly what they’ve done as they become aware of these kinds of of hucog genics [hallucinogens?]

right so so

we do see that

you’re right what we find and you do find that all the way back so you do find warnings in let’s stick with Christianity you do find warnings in the texts against drunkenness

They knew people were getting drunk and they were saying don’t.

What you don’t find is warnings against people getting high.

so

The absence of evidence is not evidence, but it’s

it’s

they

you are right:

they are trying to control people and people’s experiences, but that they never explicitly ban it suggests to me that maybe they’re not aware of it

[everyone knew flesh of gods

it may be happening but they’re not aware of it because if they were they would they they didn’t hold back on explicitly Banning things sure right and and so it’s like how and and it’s not that they wouldn’t have I think they would have it’s just how accessible were these things to people that that’s so for me that’s the bottom line is it’s not that these things wouldn’t have done exactly what you said and don’t do exactly what you said it’s just how accessible were they and and in the absence of evidence of their accessibility do we find are there other ways of explaining those kinds of experiences so you know I I joke with my students the guy that wrote the Book of Revelation he had to be doing something it’s just such a weird a wacky bar on the one hand I could totally see he’s on an LSD trip on the other hand we know

so maybe I should jump back to a more concrete example the elosan Myst the one the the psychedelics argument is they they take these psychedelics and they have this experience but these are people that have marched over three days from Athens to ucus they’ve had to sa sacrifice a pulet on the way they’ve been deprived of sleep deprived of food they’ve been dancing in an ecstasy they’re putting in a small closed room full of smoke and shown revealed this

do they have a altered state of consciousness

[weasel-word spotting: “AN” altered state — but is it a CLASSIC altered state that’s transformative in the classic way? -mh]

yes yeah

do they need psychedelics to get that?

not necessarily

we know enough physiologically and psychologically that people could have these kinds of experiences without alcohol or or psych doesn’t mean they didn’t but but psychedelics aren’t the only experience and so

our problem with the books like the ones I mentioned is not that they’re saying psychedelics were there;

it’s [my problem with them is] just they’re saying it was only psychedelics

and that legitimates psychedelics

as opposed to saying there are other ways of explaining it

[“Hyperventilating can/ could/ might/ may produce the same effect as 10g of Cubensis” -mh]

so you know we have have to take those into account

Snake Handling “Can” Produce the Same Transformative Effect as 10g of Cubensis

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

The modern example would be snake handlers you know in the in the Deep South they don’t need any alcohol or drugs to do the crazy things they’re doing

with playing with things

The Alien Psychology Theory: Primitive People Have Ritual to Be in the Intense Non-Drug Psychedelic State

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

but they do need rituals that put them into an altered state of consciousness that allow them to do that so I don’t I I don’t think the I think the evidence is still being collected and explored and I think it’s absolutely the case as you said what these different psychedelics can do in terms of human experiences the

the question sort of as a historian is did they right not not do they do they absolutely but did they or are there other explanations or were they working together you know were some people doing those and part of that goes to the marginalized voices were the groups that were using psychedelics have they been locked out of the dominant narrative and so I have to be open to that too and so say where’s the evidence let’s see let’s uncover it let’s let’s let those voices go through and not just believe the dominant narrative yeah absolutely and and thank you for that thank you for being open to you know um differences in and perspectives you know oh yeah like like I say I mean U and we we’ve gone in print saying the same thing like our agenda is not to say no like to the whole people the people that want to um um legalize psychedelics I mean and in some ways quite supportive of that um and and you know being Canada you know um you know

we’ve had Marana [cannabis?] at least legalized for some time now and other things that could be done um but that’s that’s different than the his so let me let back we I don’t think we need the historical argument to do that but if we get a historical argument that’s based on flimsy evidence then it’ll make it easier for those who don’t want the legalization of drugs to tear down our argument right so so you don’t want to say oh the religion is grounded in psychedelics and then have it torn down from under you because it’s historically suspect realize my light is getting very bad here so a little bit the sun is moving

um Shin you

I hope to make that clear

it’s not like psychedelics are bad or didn’t do it

it’s just if you’re going to make a very important argument on the legalization of these substances, let’s make sure it’s grounded in the best possible evidence is there and get rid of the spous [spurious] ones because the spirous ones will kill us in court

yeah there there is a kind of and I I’ll speak very carefully because I don’t want to piss off two communities at once even though we just went against the [Taylor] swifties which I’m still scared I might cut out that part

but there there is this again there’s there’s always

Captain Condescension Calls Others Sanctimonious

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

when you’re talking about religion and when you’re talking about these belief systems there’s always a sense of condescension

right being

being incredibly sanctimonious with with arguments

and I feel like

with psychedelics there is kind of like

oh your religion doesn’t matter

like this

The same arguments with atheism happen with psychedelics, where as soon as we pinpoint that a religion or Religion capital R is predicated on psychedelics, it automatically has no meaning, or the meaning is lost, and I don’t like that.

It would be interesting if there was a history, like a very blatant history of psychedelics in these major religions, and so we could explore that

We could see exactly how Altered States Of Consciousness again change history

but it’s also like

is it

just again as you were saying

The legalization

like they need that precedent in order to legalize it now

and saying

oh

“We’ve existed with these things for thousands of of years; it doesn’t make sense to ban it now”

or is there something more of like

I want to make sure that you are wrong

I think it depends on who you’re talking to in the community

and

I think there’s a bit of both of that

and and this so

the conspiracy theory that comes up through the books like Ro particularly road to eleusis of how this is so radical that we’ve been ignored

That’s an easy default, and when you have a very small community or at least early on, it’s it’s nice to feel marginalized.

what we noticed in the literature is there’s they have a bit of a bind because, on the one hand, there there is this rhetoric of classicist so people that study the classical world or ancient history like me don’t take us seriously because they’re so afraid of these arguments and so we’re A persecuted minority

but then up just up until it didn’t go through but they looked like they were going to get FDA approval for stage four testing on on on um LSD with with PST um uh veterans then all of a sudden it was becoming mainstream and it’s it’s it’s hard to say nobody takes us seriously oh but the FDA is giving us approval

right you you’re in a bit of a bind and you can’t have it both ways and and there was a tension in the rhetoric of you know again these are two different groups but of saying you know scientists and religion people and um and ancient historians don’t take us seriously when they wanted to but then when they were taken seriously it it then all of a sudden there was a whole other level of evidentiary basis that they needed and and I think think that it’s come far enough now that they could they can they

transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity” continues below, after my comments in next sections

Entheogen Scholarship (Secret, Suppressed) is Consp Theory Type Thinking

[equivalent in the Egodeath theory:

Entheogen scholars need to spare us the social drama narrative and open your eyes to the plain evidence, sans your arbitrary added framing “thank you for yet more evidence of use of psychedelics in heretical Christianity groups“.

I’m quite interested in Ascough’s treatment of such social drama narrative. ]

The Egodeath Theory: We Must Move Ahead with Firm Commitment to the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis

[Sharday Mosurinjohn keeps flip flopping on whether she agrees or disproves that.

Trying to play both sides and fence-sit, or put herself oppor’ly on both sides of the fence.

Sharday Mosurinjohn:

“I am firmly committed to debunking the fallacy of the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis. I have no quarter w/ those radical Pop Scholars. The engine of the Mystery Religions was definitely not psychedelics; it’s a myth that it was. I am superior to those pop writers.”

Also Sharday Mosurinjohn:

“We must remember, more, that even as we commit to investigating the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis, it is a hypothesis, not a fact. Look how reasonable, balanced, and nuanced I am. The engine of the Mystery Religions may possibly have been psychedelics; we’d need to collect more data to draw a conclusion.”

Unlike M&A, Greer is consistent in asserting the latter; he does not crow about “I have debunked the myth, and showed that there were no psychedelics in Mystery Religions.”

Ascough lists truths about that motivation, but I insist WE MUST MOVE AHEAD WITH FIRM COMMITMENT TO THE PSYCHEDELIC MYSTERIES HYPOTHESIS.

Ascough’s posturing and waffling and the motte-and-bailey fallacy:

THE PSYCHEDELIC MYSTERIES HYPOTHESIS HAS BEEN DEBUNKED BY THIS ARTICLE THAT GOT REJECTED BY ALL THE JOURNALS OF ALL TYPES

[Should we firmly commit to developing the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis, or should we now reject it because “THE PSYCHEDELIC MYSTERIES HYPOTHESIS HAS BEEN DEBUNKED BY THIS ARTICLE THAT GOT REJECTED BY ALL THE JOURNALS OF ALL TYPES”?

Greer aligns with me here, and Stang, probably some points Ascough makes.

There is some degree of agreement here among:

  • Stang
  • Greer
  • Michael Hoffman
  • Ascough with Sharday Mosurinjohn

I’m sure I’d want to spin it differently than them though.

keyboard shortcut

the book The Road to Eleusis, by Ruck, Hofmann, & Wasson, 1978
rte

-mh]

Transcript Con’t: Drop the Consp Theory

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

They can and probably should drop that conspiracy theory kind of rhetoric and go back and reexamine the evidence and say what can we hang on to and what can we get rid of the root to elus [the book The Road to Eleusis, by Ruck, Hofmann, & Wasson, 1978] the part of our concern is it’s coming up on its 50th Anniversary

it will be

every 10 years it’s re-released with a new introduction and inevitably the introduction says oh

“Everybody hates us because they don’t understand us and they’re wrong.”

and just drop that and and go through the evidence again and say what can we keep; what can we get rid of based on new science, new history, new ways of thinking, and build on those more solid foundations into something

right so it’s like

not throw the whole thing out, but say:

what are the possibilities

just

before as as we end off if I can put you on the spot

when we talked so much about evidence, what kinds of evidence would you be looking for when it comes to psychedelics in religion,

like what would be the smoking gun

oh that’s interesting

I don’t think

I mean I guess if

if we had a text that we uncovered that said explicitly we use these plants to to create this kind of experience

Talk About the Article “Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience”

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

hn’s talk about the article.

Crops by Michael Hoffman

I mean that’s that’s that’s the direct line kind of stuff we don’t have anything quite like that

we do have medical texts, a whole book of them that do mention Pharmaceuticals

the the pharmco the pharmacos [pharmakos?] which gets translated often as sorcerer in into English

but the the Greek word pharmacos is somebody that that deals with herbal medications

that

we know they knew about opium

that

we know they had the effects

but we it the med you know

some of the medical texts that get cited in psychedelic ler if , if you read them they say:

Use a little bit; if you use too much they die.

CLUE-LESS about Figurative Ego Death; Literalist

[I am not saying that this particular text means ego death; but Ascough shows ZILCH awareness of {death} ie awareness of eternalism; the eternalism state of consciousness – look at his OUTSIDER talking, “a great experience” – incomprehension of the richness of angel/demon experiencing; HE IS MANIFESTLY NOT QUALIFIED to interpret and read texts as an insider; ie, he is illiterate about mythic analogies, the Mytheme theory -mh]

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

But nowhere do they say in there:

If you use like the right amount, they’ll have a great experience.

it’s like little bit; healthy; a lot … and and so or so

that would be one something that sort of makes that direct line

another would be yeah more clearly

somebody Secrets leak so something out of elusive being found that does

actually we have some leaked texts some of them from Christians who are very derogatory

you don’t trust them at all but

something again that that says very explicitly that involved substances as well as these other experiences

there is one that gets cited in the book and in the literature

about

it’s from a satire and it’s about barley wrote being eaten and

the person is vilified for releasing the mystery

but he’s actually prosecuted because he’s a foreigner and not prosecuted for doing that.

Ancient Playwright Permitted to Reveal the Mysteries

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

but even more importantly, the playwright

If the characters in this satire have actually told what happened in the Mysteries, which you’re not allowed to do, and you could be prosecuted for it, the playwright should have been prosecuted for putting that into the play but he wasn’t.

So again that when he talks about the barley grows having this kind of effect, it’s probably not true; otherwise he would have been prosecuted

right so and no nobody

nobody saw oh look he mentioned this, this is a proof that the psychedelics were used in the Mysteries

Arguing Based on “Secrecy” Premise: A Mis-Emphasis that Trainwrecked Entheogen Scholarship

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

but you can’t have it kept a secret and not be prosecuted there

true so

that’s what I’d be looking for: something just very clear, and it would still not convince everyone, but something a little bit clear

it’s too

it’s too circumstantial and too much, like I say, going through the book [the book The Road to Eleusis, by Ruck, Hofmann, & Wasson, 1978], saying it might be the case that they were able to synthesize the ergot[sic], and then two pages later they say, “when the priest synthesized the ergot” — well you you didn’t prove that; you made it a hypothesis two pages earlier but now

[GTFO, this is stupid, he is misrep the nature of theory dev’mt. I don’t buy it. He’s making a big stink over “Ruck’s paradigm is circular”. WTF do you expect a new theorist to do, grovel and obscure their point, and block their every conjecture by saying “I’m probably wrong, but perhaps maybe… blah blah QUALITFY QUALIFY QUALIFY , Asc expects Ruck to POUND ON THE POINT OF “HYPOTHESIS MAYBE WHO KNOWS??” IN EVERY SINGLE SENTENCE.

Ascough Magically Moves from Possibility, to As-if Fact – EXACTLY as He Accuses Ruck of Doing

[Ascough makes much out of little, here, in this line of accusation — and Ascough himself is guilty of this very same shorthand;

Ascough very often talks as if Asc has proved that psychedelics were not the engine of the Mystery Religions.

  1. “We don’t know for certain at this time whether psychedelics were in Mystery Religions.” (possibility)
  2. “I have proved that psychedelics were not in Mystery Religions.” (fact)

Ascough himself does EXACTLY what he claims is a fatal method’y flaw by Ruck: Asc moves magically from a possibility (that Ruck is wrong), to as-if a fact (that Ruck is wrong).

M&A act like this is devastating, if Ruck ever says “The hierophant did X.”

We do not hold ppl to this standard on any topic other than this taboo topic, demanding that every statement be couched in “We really don’t know anything for certain, not even in Physics”.

To do Science per Ascough, every statement in every textbook must be timid and emphasize we know nothing about anything for absolutely certain; to attach the degree of confidence to every statement, as a mode of writing.

On topics other than psychedelics in Western religious history, we do not demand that every single sentence be couched in heavy qualifiers. This is ridiculous over-arg’n, trying to make a mountain of a molehill – and also, projecting, or, hypocrisy.

When Ruck moves from writing as possibility to writing as speculated fact, that’s bad, a method’l flaw.

When M&A move from writing as possibility (“we can’t conclude if, at this point, psychedelics in Mystery Religions”) to writing as speculated fact “We destroyed the myth that psychedelics were in Mystery Religions!“, that’s good, a victory of superior scholarship.

Self-promotional hypocrites.

-mh]

Possibility-to-fact magician Ascough con’t:

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

You’re saying they did it

and moving to the next hypothesis and so it’s hypothesis

but it’s you know turtles all the way down

but if if the bottom turtle is gonna reide

so again

Motte-and-Bailey Master of Posturing and Self-Promotion, Ascough; While Hypocritically Denigrating Entheogen Scholars for “Moving from Possibility to Fact”

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

it’s just like

let’s have a solid argument

and so this is what professor Sharday Mosurinjohn and I are pushing for.

it’s like not we don’t believe it [the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis]

[“BULLSH!T – THEN WHY DO YOU ANNOUNCE IN THE ABSTRACT OF THE ARTICLE, “WE HAVE DESTROYED THE MYTH OF THE FOOLISH ENTHEOGEN SCHOLARS!”

You should admit you keep shifting, the motte-and-bailey fallacy, your accusations and positions back and forth. -mh]

it’s like

let’s make sure it’s as solid as we can make

yeah absence of evidence is not evidence of absence

but also we need to make sure that we’re staying grounded, and not

you know

divulging to the same [todo – listen to vid]

it’s interesting that they want to be grounded, but they also say “I think or I believe I think and I believe actually”

My Students, Passion, Teaching Religion

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

going back to where I was with my students, it’s always fun yeah yeah absolutely

So speaking of your students and I guess my entire generation, I do want to ask someone like yourself

What advice do you have for them um it can be in terms of learning and education

it could be in terms of religion but we talked about you know the 20 second Tik Tok attention spans

and what we’re trying to do with this podcast as

someone like yourself who found passion and understanding and fun in a very dense and historical and um complex field

what advice would you give to Gen Z

in this way I think you’ve touched on the key word, passion

Follow Your Passion

Ascough Magically Shifts from Possibility to as-if Fact; from “We Don’t Know if Psychedelics Were in Mystery Religions”, to “We Proved Ruck is Wrong for Asserting Psychedelics Were in Mystery Religions”

[There is waffle room in the latter: do you mean [Ruck is wrong to say that we definitely know psychedelics were in mystery religions], or that [Ruck’s hypothesis is wrong]?

Ascough’s passion for hypocrisy, magically shifting from possibility to as-if fact, in his use of DIRTY RHETORIC:

“We don’t know for certain, if psychedelics in mystery religions“
— and then,
“We victoriously proved Ruck is wrong for asserting psychedelics in mystery religions“.

-mh]

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

because that’s when it gets hard

that’s what’s going to dis sustain it

so I mean I

I love what I do but there are times when I slog through some inscriptions, go oh my gosh this is killing me

you

I get the big dictionary out, trying to figure out what this grammar means,

that’s tedious but it has its reward in the end

but what push

what helps me push through is, I have a passion for it, I have a passion to know

so I would say you know

if you’re doing work on your own research on your own or in a school, do the things that drive you, that you want to know more about, that you want to learn more about, and don’t let it go

like keep

keep shaking it even when it gets hard, and then that’s where the passion part comes in

Ascough’s Motte-and-Bailey Self-Marketing Posturing

He Wants SO BAD to Say “Psychedelics in Mystery Religions Is an Easy Solution, Therefore, Wrong”

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

Don’t accept easy answers, and if they come easy [eg “simple explanation: psychedelics in mystery religions], they’re probably [YOU KNOW HE WANTS TO SAY “WRONG”!] … they probably need … that’s not that they’re wrong; they probably need to be re-examined.

[Mr. Super-Reasonable, here, after trumpeting “I DESTROYED RUCK’S CLAIM OF PSYCHEDELICS IN MYSTERY RELIGIONS!!”

This is nothing but posturing, self-marketing as “Look how skeptical I am! I’m better than those gullible Ruck & Muraresku amateur writers; buy my product!” -mh]

and yeah, don’t accept everything everyone tells you but don’t reject it outright think about it and and work your way through it yourself um and that’s hard to do we we like to be told what to do you know it’s it’s much easier if someone would just tell me to do but think more than ever right now with the way the world is sort of tilting to the right there’s a lot of people out there that want to so to the right I mean sort of not necessarily even politically but just kind of to a sort of a more right wrong black white kind of dichotomy there’s a lot of people out there that quite happy to tell us what to think and what to believe and make our life so much easier because we don’t have to think for ourselves and and I just go back to that great scene again dating myself

Life of Brian

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

In Monty Python’s Life of Brian where Brian is mistaken for the Messiah and this big crowd in front of him says

tell us Brian tell us what must we do

and he says just go away just go and think for yourself

and they kind of pause and look at us tell us Brian

tell tell us how must we think for ourselves

collectively you know it that’s easy the difficulty is you know it’s easy having someone tell you it’s it’s more difficult

and so yeah

we have the internet

we have ai now to help us

we can generate so much information

but don’t just take it at face value

push back on those topics that really drive you

yeah

a good question I like to ask myself and that I tell other people my age and even a bit younger and older is

how much of your thinking is predicated on the algorithms that you consume

yeah you know exactly that

that that gets them to stop and think

yeah

I was going to say

I didn’t know whether to go down there or not but appr propo of that you know re the internet absolutely we should use it

but remember that’s that’s not the only way of doing research or

just running a Google search is not research

you know people say I’ve researched this that because the algorithm will give you often things you already want to find

so try and get the ALG the other algorithms to give you the alternative and again it’s not that the alternative is is right and yours is wrong it’s just hear both voices

con’t below the next section(s)

Ascough Hasn’t Read the Best Entheogen Scholarship

[Ascough didn’t read the best entheogen publications – he cites my Plaincourault 2006, copyied the concl about sidelining Allegro, did he read it though? anyway my article is only negative, way-clearing, I really cared about

Not the best in POSITIVE entheogen scholarship:

The best in positive entheogen scholarship; Ascough is writing out of ignorance, until he’s read, eg:

]

Get Both Sides of the Research Story

  • [Affirmers of psychedelics in Western religious history publish lots of writing.
  • Deniers of psychedelics in Western religious history don’t write anything about that.

Wasson says art historians don’t think about mushrooms in art.;

Huggins says art historians don’t think about trees in art.

This is why, against Affirmers/mychologies,

Art historians are the authorities on mushroom-trees:

because art historians never think about or write about mushrooms or trees in art.

Art historians are expert on “related topics”

ie, they are not experts on mushroom-trees, and never gave any thought, or published anything, about mushrooms in art, or trees in art.

Thus, academic art historians are the authorities to consult, on mushroom-trees.

Ascough uses the same arg’n.]

Ascough con’t:

Opinion Column Format of Newspaper: Get Both Sides

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

I remember back in the you know because I’m a dinosaur newspapers used to have um you know the opinion piece where it be Pro and anti and you could read both of them beside each other

and the algorithms now will only give us the one that that it thinks we want and it’s okay to go and look for the other one to find the opposite and pay attention to it and get both sides

even if you end up I think if you end up not changing your opinion you’ll at least strengthen your position

yeah the confirmation bias and combined with the dun and Krueger effect is a powerful and terrifying combination

Justice, but Not Decrim of Psilocybin

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

[slight relev. psychedelic relig freedom:]

If you had a magic wand, and you could solve one problem in the world what would it be and why that’s difficult?

The obvious ones are me world peace and things like this.

If I could solve it all I would but really to to get people to having the conversations about Justice and actually acting on

Justice Transcends Politics and Religion

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

What I would want is Justice, human Justice, human rights for everybody

that transcend all the other things like nationalism and national politics, or religious rights or religious freedoms.

that Justice would always triumph over that

and to to you know have a world in which you know it’s it’s kind of like Plato’s philosopher king it’s not quite a dictator but it sort of sounds like one

but somebody that would do always do the right thing but for justice

and make sure that that that people are not being trampled

and that you know religion, governments, economics, these are not being used as tools for oppression

That’s a big wish I know but we evolve as human beings we we have more and more tools

we have AI it’s scary it’s thrilling you know it’s it’s it’s a mixed bag in terms of what the potential are for achieving some of these things.

… omitted off-topic …

Finding Richard Ascough Online

Continued transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”:

Where can we find you online?

Go to Queens University, uhca or queens you.ca

And Google my name.
https://www.google.com/search?q=richard+ascough

[Richard S. Ascough is Professor of Religion, Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.
https://www.queensu.ca/customsearch?term=richard+ascough]

I show up I have a faculty profile there

I’m on Instagram

I’m on Facebook but really that’s just my friends, I just post pictures of my travels to make my friends jealous as we all do

as we all do

as we all do yeah

but thank you for the sof tune

it’s been wonderful lots of fun great talking to you

you know I got to to look at a few of your other podcasts beforehand when you invited me

/ end last 40% of vid, transcript

End of Video Transcript

End of transcript of the video “Psychedelics and the Birth of Christianity”.

Faculty Page: Richard S. Ascough

https://www.queensu.ca/religion/people/faculty/richard-s-ascough

Has his cv.

Ascough’s research focus:

  • Early Christianity and Greco-Roman religious culture.
  • The dynamics of religious interaction and community development in small religious associations in the Greco-Roman world.
  • Modern theories of Christian origins.
  • Religion in Greek and Roman antiquity.
  • The first two centuries of the development of Christianity.
  • Religion and film.
  • Religion and business ethics.

Article: John Allegro and the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis (Ascough, 2025/08)

John Allegro and the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis
Ascough, 2025/08
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/#Psychedelic-Mysteries-Hypothesis

Cites my article:
Wasson and Allegro on the Tree of Knowledge as Amanita
Hoffman, 2006
http://egodeath.com/WassonEdenTree.htm

Why waste time on slop of off-cuff vid, when should read print article instead?

Because I happened to hear “WTF!” (ie juicy; stop-everything; must-capture timestamp and quote him) statements in the vid, nuances contradicting his OFFICIAL self-promotional narrative, and wanted to check transcript, and take 5 minutes (2 hours) to paste here to read it.

I have read his article 1-2 times; will look for this pattern of:

  • This article corrects the FALSE CLAIM of psychedelics in Western religious history. Buy my $cholarship. I correct the folly and errors of Pop, inferior entheogen scholars (ie, Muraresku train I’m riding, with Ruck footnoted underneath Muraresku).
  • I’m reasonable and balanced: There well may have been, not unlikely, some extent of psychedelics in antiquity.

Easy Mode scholarship by appearance, the appearance that I DESTROYED the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis.

Easy-Mode, Post-Muraresku-Train Scholarship by Appearance: Posturing and Giving the Appearance that I DESTROYED the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis

His message is a copypaste of bottom of my article; compare quotes, same idea:

“Sideline Allegro, do not build on him, to move entheogen scholarship forward.

“Also (volume: Max): Only fools think there were psychedelics in Western religious history; this article [the one w/ Sharday] disproved that false myth.

“And, it’s too early to know if there were psychedelics in Western religious history. Follow my reasonable lead.”

Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough (Hu, Sep. 2025)

Section of the Hu Blogpost, No Commentary

Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough
“The professors discuss the scant evidence for the idea that the Eleusinian Mysteries used psychedelics, and why it persists anyway.”
Jane Hu, Sep. 15, 2025
https://themicrodose.substack.com/p/myth-busting-psychedelics-in-ancient
My page:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/20/psychedelics-eleusis-and-the-invention-of-religious-experience-mosurinjohn-2025/#Myth-busting-psychedelics-in-ancient-Greece

copypaste from Hu, emphasis added, sentence-per-para:

“You’ve already given us some sense of this, but what do scholars make of these claims?

Do they take them seriously?

Richard Ascough:

“Well, one of the critiques is that perhaps classists don’t take it seriously because we’re afraid of it.

The narrative is we’re afraid of it because it’s so radical.

And my response is, no, it has been considered, and it’s so wrong that we don’t need to keep repeating it!

I work on the Mystery religions, but psychedelics never show up in the academic literature about them.

[Reporter’s note: Mystery religions are secret religious groups or cults from Greco-Roman times.] 

It’s very rare and if it comes up at all, it’s something like,

“There is this fringe element that talks about psychedelics but they have no evidence.”

And yet, at these psychedelics conferences, it keeps coming up again and again.

There’s a disconnect between what has been said by biblical scholars and classists, and what’s being promoted within the psychedelics community.

That forced us, then, to dig deeper:

Where does this disconnect come from?

Why is there this disjuncture?”

/ end of Hu excerpt

It’s an asymmetry:

  • Affirmers publish/ write/ think/ talk about psychedelics in Western religious history.
  • Deniers don’t publish/ write/ think/ talk about psychedelics in Western religious history.

In what sense is this situation a “disconnect”?

Section of the Hu Blogpost, With Commentary

  • Citations needed. WHERE HAVE SCHOLARS WRITTEN skeptically about the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis? (or other variant point of dispute)
  • Which specific scholars? Name names.
  • WHICH SPECIFIC ARTICLES?
  • WHICH SPECIFIC BOOKS?
  • WHICH SPECIFIC TREATMENTS OR PHONE CALLS OR TELEGRAPH MESSAGES, ON WHAT DATE?

Same hazy bluff as academic fraud Wasson telling us to “consult” the art historians – (in 2006,) I’d love to, but you censored the single lone thing they ever wrote: (revealed in 2019:)

Tree Stylizations in Medieval Paintings
Brinckmann, 1906
86 pages. 5 mentions of ‘pilzbaum’; mushroom-trees.
https://egodeaththeory.org/2020/12/11/brinckmann-mushroom-trees-asymmetrical-branching/

“You’ve already given us some sense of this, but what do scholars make of these claims? Do they take them seriously?

“Richard Ascough: Well, one of the critiques is that perhaps classists[sic] don’t take it seriously because we’re afraid of it.

“The narrative is we’re afraid of it because it’s so radical.

[weasel word: “considered”. citation needed.

His word “repeated” implies repeating publications – but doesn’t say “publications”, b/c that would be a lie.]

Against the Wasson/ Panofsky/ Ascough BLUFF, classicists have given NO thought to psychedelics in Western religious history. No discussions, no “considered”, no telegrams, no phone conversations, nothing.

Against the Wasson/ Panofsky/ Ascough BLUFF, classicists have published NO articles or works on psychedelics in Western religious history.]

Ascough:

“Psychedelics in Mystery Religion Has Been Considered by Classicists, We Don’t Need to Keep Repeating That”

“considered” is a euph. for “not considered, and certainly not published”. Ascough tries to spin academics sticking head in sand, with a rebuttal and “need for communication” but Affirmer journal eg the Journal of Psychedelic Studies​ rejects Denier article, the specific article “and the Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis”

Even the title screams “look how obnoxious we are; king of the Deniers, it’s our brand”:

Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience

For years the article was rejected by eg the Journal of Psychedelic Studies​, and religious studies journals.

Also Ascough, in the next sentence:

“Psychedelics Are Never Mentioned in Academic Literature about Mystery Religions”

So what is there to repeat? Re-publish your (non-existent) articles.

It took zero effort to not write the article the first time.

What does “considered” mean? It means: We considered what happened to Allegro.

Here’s the f-d up dynamic that Allegro caused:

  1. Allegro, to harm Church, writes against Xy by misusing entheogens topic.
  2. Backlash against Allegro by academia.
  3. No other academics dare assert psychedelics in Western religious history.
  4. Academics take empty pot-shots, like Ascough, against those who assert psychedelics in Western religious history, but not in proper academic fashion by publishing.

Classicists or other academics “considered“, and don’t want to “keep repeating” their… repeating what? Their “consideration”. Totally vague!

All that the Deniers have is alleged conversations, never publications.

Ascough ought to say “We academics have published these specific rebuttals [providing citations], and we don’t need to keep PUBLISHING these articles.”

It’s the old familiar Wasson/ Panofsky bluff.

Wasson’s bluff, since Panofsky provided a citation and two art works to Wasson, which Wasson censored, in con-artist fashion.

“And my response[citation?] is, no, it has been considered, [yeah ok but was it published, when, where, by who?] and it’s so wrong that we don’t need to keep repeating it! [repeating what? which articles? citation needed]

“I work on the Mystery religions, but psychedelics never show up in the academic literature about them. [Reporter’s note: Mystery religions are secret religious groups or cults from Greco-Roman times.] 

“[re: psychedelics in Mystery Religions] It’s very rare [in classicists’ publications] and if it comes up at all, it’s something like, “There is this fringe element that talks about psychedelics but they have no evidence.”

[True or false? “Entheogen scholarship has no evidence of entheogens in Mystery Religions.”

If you don’t look at or cite the evidence publications, you are ignorant of the field.

Ascough just reveals his exclusive view; he doesn’t want to cite anyone or do scholarship.

Letcher, the naysayers, avoid engaging the published evidence.

Ascough limits the conversation to two books. Easy Mode scholarship. He treats them as a proxy. He only knows of:

  • Works by classicists that don’t mention psychedelics.
  • The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020
  • Road Eleusis.

No other entheogen scholarship is cited.

ASCOUGH HAS READ ONLY ROAD to Eleusis & KEY, acts like that’s the only publications he has to read and cite.

He has read 2 books affirming, and has read no classicists publications because there aren’t any.

Why does he not cite the rebuttal books & articles, that he fears needlessly re-publishing?]

[weasel word: “said”. whatever. give us citations! and quotes in published works]

And yet, at these psychedelics conferences, it keeps coming up again and again. There’s a disconnect between what has been said by biblical scholars and classists [citations needed!], and what’s being promoted within the psychedelics community. That forced us, then, to dig deeper: Where does this disconnect come from? Why is there this disjuncture?”

  • Academics write nothing on the topic of psychedelics in Mystery Religions, or Western religious history.
  • Non-academics write on the topic of psychedelics.
  • Ascough false arg: “If Ruck and Muraresku had read the writings of academics, they would abandon their myth of psychedelics in Mystery Religions.” But, “Academics never write on psychedelics in Western religious history.”

What does Shar have in mind by “we need communication between the camps”. The only camp publishing is Affirmers (of “Did psychedelics have an important role in Western religious history?”)).

Affirmers publish on the topic of “Did psychedelics have an important role in Western religious history?”

Deniers don’t publish on the topic of “Did psychedelics have an important role in Western religious history?”

Ascough’s greatest fear is that scholars will have to again publish their articles and books that are negative about “Did psychedelics have an important role in Western religious history?” But he says they never published any; they have never written or even thought about this topic. Kettle logic.

We’ve already written tons disproving psychedelics in Western religious history. [no citations provided]

And, we’ve never written anything on the topic of psychedelics in Western religious history, because there is no evidence.

And, writers who publish positive articles and books [he thinks ONLY: RtE + The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020] should be in communication with classicists, who never write anything on the topic.

Sharday can be taken in a true, constructive sense: entheogen scholars SHOULD be in communication with Classicists. That’s true. Who is at fault here?

Rotten Abstract of M&A Article: “Exposing Methodological FlawS; Namely, a Single Pattern of Turning Possibility into Fact

The Abstract Commits the Same Fallacy it Claims to Report

The Abstract Acts Like M&A’s Possibility (That There Were No Psychedelics in Mystery Religions) Is Fact

“Ruck says that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics.

We show that Ruck is wrong; the engine of the Mystery Religions was not psychedelics.”

An unwarranted conclusion, as if to turn the possibility of Ruck’s wrongness, into fact.

Academics don’t know if the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics. Yet academics assert, as if fact, that the engine of the Mystery Religions was not psychedelics. And brag about having disproved Ruck’s psychedelic mysteries hypothesis.

REMINDER: NO ONE HAS DISPROVED RUCK’S PSYCHEDELIC MYSTERIES HYPOTHESIS.

NO ONE HAS DISPROVED RUCK’S PSYCHEDELIC MYSTERIES HYPOTHESIS.

the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics
emrp

My “transcript of Sharday Mosurinjohn’s talk about the article” page:
Video: The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences (Mosurinjohn, Sep. 2025)
Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, 2025)

It is potentially reasonable to “turn a possibility into as if a fact”.

You must develop a hypothesis like the heliocentric theory, and build up a model with vigor.

Limp-wristed, feeble, “We don’t know anything, nothing is certain, who knows” gets you NOWHERE.

I tend to defend this alleged “turning possibility into as-if fact”. If M&A can do that in their article’s Abstract, so can everyone else.

The Motte-and-Bailey Fallacy in the Abstract of M&A’s “Invention of religious experience” Article; a Functional Self-Contradiction

M&A Turn the Possibility That the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis Is Wrong, into the Fact that the Psychedelic Mysteries Hypothesis Is Wrong

M&A Turn the Possibility That Ruck Is Wrong, into the Fact that Ruck Is Wrong

“We point out, Ruck might be wrong in saying that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics.

That is, we point out, Ruck IS wrong in saying that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics. It is a myth, ie false, that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics.”

We must remember, the specific interactions Mosur had.

M&A are specifically pushing against The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020 (enfolding Ruck’s RtE and all of Ruck’s work).

The article is too meta: it’s an article about the rejection of the article for publication.

The Abstract alone is so nasty, cock-sure, insulting, self-assured, that’s reason enough that the article got rejected by two kinds of journals, for “years”.

The Abstract is a motte-and-bailey fallacy: in fact it does same as a… “to accuse is to confess”.

  • We do not have evidence. We don’t know, we cannot conclude if psychedelics in Western religious history / if the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis is true.
  • Ruck is wrong to claim psychedelics in Western religious history.
    Ruck is wrong to assert that the engine of Mystery Religions was psychedelics. In fact, the engine of the Mystery Religions was no psychedelics.

M&A in the Abstract assert:

The Abstract presents possibility as if fact. It’s possible Ruck is wrong, in claiming that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics; we don’t know if that claim is true or false.

M&A in the Abstract also assert:

We correct Ruck’s false claim that the engine of the Mystery Religions was psychedelics; the fact is, the engine of the Mystery Religions was not psychedelics

When I read Andy Letcher’s book Shroom, 2006, I noticed the same tactic, the motte-and-bailey fallacy. He acts as if he is certain that no mushrooms in Western religious history.

“No evidence for X, means that you are false in asserting X.”

the motte-and-bailey fallacy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy

the motte-and-bailey fallacy
mbf

Inflated Bragging About Methodology

Have Mos & Asc been studying Thomas Hatsis’ superior historiographical methodology?

Which means Hatsis spilling ink on that claim, while failing to deliver even basic, simple, elementary scholarship.

eg the Psychedelic Mystery Traditions page, “Been debunked; see my writings online”.

Making it worse, Hatsis deleted that site, breaking my wonderful, valuable Thomas Hatsis Gallery of Mushroom Imagery in Christian Art – the best thing Hatsis contributed to the field.

Mushroom-Tree & Hell-Mouth

Crop by Michael Hoffman
2nd attempt, crisper
“Canterbury-f109-mushroom-tree-hell-mouth.jpg” 515 KB 9:47 p.m. January 21, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f109.item.zoom

Canterbury folio image f109: lifted up in ossuary by Christ

Full Res Library:
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f109.item.zoom

My f109 Page:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/25/f109-great-canterbury-psalter-hellmouth-net-ossuary-cloth-looking-out-from-temple/

Fullscreen of WordPress gallery image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/canterbury-f109.jpg

See Also

Site Map: Ronald Huggins
https://egodeaththeory.org/nav/#Ronald-Huggins

Site Map: Sharday Mosurinjohn
https://egodeaththeory.org/nav/#Sharday-Mosurinjohn

https://cyberdisciple.wordpress.com/site-map/ –

  • Classicist.
  • Psychedelics in Western religious history.
  • The Egodeath theory.
    • Eternalism-driven control-transformation.
    • Analogical psychedelic eternalism with 2-level, dependent control.
    • The Mytheme theory.

https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/

Video: The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences (Mosurinjohn, Sep. 2025)

Michael Hoffman 9:23 p.m. January 19, 2026
Scope/motivation: transcript of Mosurinjohn’s talk about the article.

Crops by Michael Hoffman

Contents:

Links work on desktop Edge/Chrome:

Article: Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, Jul. 2025)

Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience
Sharday Mosurinjohn & Richard Ascough
July 2025
https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1177/28314425251361835

Web search:
“Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience”
https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Psychedelics%2C+Eleusis%2C+and+the+Invention+of+Religious+Experience%22
I have that article (printed out twice, marked up twice, read twice).

10-minute talks.

My earlier, Aug. 2025 page I forgot about:
Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, 2025)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/08/psychedelics-eleusis-and-the-invention-of-religious-experience-mosurinjohn-ascough-2025/

Abstract of “Invention” Article

Introduction

“This article corrects an idea in psychedelic science and culture that the ancient Eleusynian Mysteries used psychedelics, as claimed by Carl Ruck and co-authors in The Road to Eleusis: Unveiling the Secret of the Mysteries (1978), revitalized by Brian Muraresku’s The Immortality Key: The Secret History of the Religion with No Name (2020), and popularized by social media heavyweights such as Joe Rogan.

Methods

“It begins by exposing critical methodological flaws in the arguments, namely, a pattern of presenting claims, followed by mild circumstantial evidence, rhetorically solidifying the interpretation of this evidence into a “fact,” on which is built each subsequent round of conjecture.

Analysis

“We then explore how the dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages contributes to the project of establishing a western civilizational pedigree to dignify the use of stigmatized drugs and revitalize experiential religion.

Discussion

“Although the desire for legitimacy and meaning is understandable, the strategies used by the writers of this pseudo-history constitute a kind of religious fundamentalism.

“Their writing attempts to show that a relatively new practice is the old, true religion, in this case, the “religion with no name” that underlies every religious tradition.

“In doing so, they miss seriously relating to the many well-documented historical and living Indigenous histories of psychedelics, or seeing contemporary psychedelic practice in continuity with other, and maybe even older, nonpharmacological methods of changing consciousness.

“Overall, the “psychedelic Eleusis” discourse focuses on the purported Eleusynian drug and its phenomenology rather than focusing on practices for taking up the spiritual injunctions of those psychedelic experiences.

Conclusions

“We conclude that, given how the psychedelic hypothesis is fundamentally flawed in its study of antiquity, it is a shaky foundation on which to build an argument for modern psychedelic use for therapeutic and spiritual practice.

“Since scholarly research is key to moving forward decriminalization, legalization, medical regulation, and other roles for psychedelics in society, it is crucial that scholars and popular audiences communicate effectively around psychedelic history and culture.

“Instead of committing to a specific (and erroneous) view of history, psychedelic scholarship must commit to academic discussion and debate.”

My analysis and commentary is in a copy of this Abstract, or of the similar, Conference Schedule’s summary of the talk, below.

Conference Schedule’s Description of the Talk (Mar. 5, 2025)

The obnoxious summary of the talk that’s in the Conference Schedule is mostly the same as the Abstract of the article.

For a copy of this Desc interleaved w/ my commentary, see a below section; find “schedule”.

https://www.psychedelicsandreligion.info/schedule –

“This talk responds to the idea that the ancient Eleusynian Mysteries were psychedelic, as claimed by Carl Ruck and co-authors in The Road to Eleusis (1978), revitalized by Brian Muraresku’s The Immortality Key (2020), and popularized by the Overton window-widening Joe Rogan.

“It begins by exposing critical methodological flaws in the arguments, namely, a pattern of presenting claims, followed by mild circumstantial evidence, and then rhetorically solidifying the interpretation of this evidence into a “fact,” on which is built each subsequent round of conjecture.

“In The Road To Eleusis, a speculation like “It seems obvious that an hallucinogen must have induced it” (2008: 47) immediately furnishes the next premise “To identify the Eleusynian drug…” (2008: 47) that begins the following paragraph.

“I argue that these writers’ dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages has to do with wanting a western civilizational pedigree to dignify the use of stigmatized drugs.

“This myopia is rooted in colonial violence that precludes seriously relating to the many well-documented Indigenous histories of psychedelics, as well as a sort of functional fixedness that prevents seeing contemporary psychedelic practice in continuity with other, and maybe even older, non-pharmacological methods of changing consciousness. 

“I conclude that, given how the psychedelic hypothesis is fundamentally flawed in its study of antiquity, it is a shaky foundation on which to build an argument for modern psychedelic use for therapeutic and spiritual practice.

“I also report on the multi-year history of the rejection of the manuscript on which this talk is based as it is emblematic of the way popular audiences and scholars fail to communicate around psychedelic history and culture, even as psychedelic bioscience scholarship is at the centre of today’s social mainstreaming.”

/end of description of the talk in the conf. schedule

Video of Talk: The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences (Mosurinjohn, Sep. 29, 2025)

Video title:
The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences | Sharday C Mosurinjohn
Sep. 29, 2025
YouTube channel:
Harvard Law School Program on Jewish & Israeli Law
HARVARD LAW SCHOOL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k858spSK-bQ —

Audio: The first minute is too quiet, it gets louder.

Video’s Description (Mosurinjohn’s Talk)

“The persistence of the belief that ancient Western religions were fundamentally psychedelic [is] less a historical hypothesis but a myth serving cross purposes for different psychedelic communities.

“Why is the psychedelic discourse so intent on hanging on to this narrative?

“Why is improvement to the empirical and theoretical rigour of psychedelic history resisted rather than welcomed?

“Why accept a swath of self-serving speculation drawn from the humanities, and then insist on resisting critical analysis?”

Transcription of Video (Mosurinjohn’s Talk), No Commentary

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn 2025.

Cleaned up, formatted, and clarified by Michael Hoffman.

“Search for pre-Christian origins.

What happens when that search for origins focuses on the finding of the drug and the phenomenology of the drug as the way to find the drug?

I’m talking about the claim that the Eleusinian mysteries were psychedelic, as claimed by Carl Ruck & authors in the Road to Eleusis 1978 and revitalized as my colleague Dr. [Richard Ascough] mentioned in Brian Murarescu’s The Immortality Key in 2020.

These books attempt to shed light on the enigmatic rituals of the elusinian mysteries.

They argue that the consumption of a psychoactive substance played a pivotal role in the rituals which dramatized Persephone’s underworld death rebirth journey nested in the cosmic fractal cycles of destruction and creation.

These books are really popular, and they’re very mainstream, and they’re almost totally ignored by scholars.

I’m going to draw out something important about this reception and response history.

Let me detail it a little bit.

Until a couple of weeks ago, in response to The Immortality Key, for instance, I was only aware of one great paper, and the fact that both Dr. Charles Stang and I both independently presented papers on it in the summer of 2023.

Mine was with my colleague Dr. Richard Ascoff.

Dr. Stang’s excellent essay is now published in Harvard Theological Review.

There also recently appeared a new piece in Reason magazine.

Otherwise, this psychedelic mysteries hypothesis [Ascough’s term] was not being engaged in religious studies.

There is some work [scholarly critique] on Road to Eleusis.

Not a lot, but I saw the claim that “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic” constantly repeated at psychedelic conferences.

I saw it especially on the slide of the presentations that gave the cultural historical background.

Particularly the psychedelic science [~= Tim Leary-type psychometric q’airs] presentations included this [such a] slide. [saying “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic”]

There would be the bas relief of Demeter handing Persephone a mushroom.

Apparently, the alleged mushroom.

Seeing this all over the place [the claim that “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic”], I wanted…

Having colleagues always coming up to me going
“Did you know — you’re in religion; you’re a religious studies scholar —

“Did you know that the ancient mysteries were psychedelic?”

There’s not evidence for this.

So I thought,

“Let me put this piece in a psychedelic science journal to speak particularly to that crowd.”

The psychedelic science journal did not want to critique Ruck and Wasson and Hofmann.

[It] seemed [to me they’re reluctant] to undermine some of the bedrock on which rests
the popularization of psychedelics and
the dignification of psychedelics as old and religiously serious, and
on which therefore rest certain arguments for the legalization of psychedelics.

After a year of back and forth, we tried to publish it in a religious studies journal that after another year turned out didn’t want to touch psychedelics.

This publication non-history, or non-publication history, is emblematic of a larger problem.

The siloing of academic disciplines and academia from popular discourse means that sometimes an idea gets picked up like the “psychedelic mysteries” claim from a classicist, and then it gets repeated in another discipline, such as psychedelic science work, but it’s then insulated from getting evolved by interdisciplinary critique.

The contribution that I want to make is towards supporting:

the discussion of psychedelics coming into mainstream culture on sound historical footing
and to emphasize drawing on
sophisticated frameworks for working with the psychedelic experience
rather than
the finding of the drug, and the phenomenology of the drug.

I want to foreground the importance of
scholars bringing our subjectivity to the claims that we are making –
which for all of
the talk of positionality becoming de riguer during the academy,
it’s not exactly often that academia trains us to make a practice of
inventorying what we’ve disowned and avoided knowing about ourselves and projected onto others or the past
and so on in order to continually
come into integrity around what we’re doing.

But our work is deeply served by inquiring into what our “come from” is with it.

What stands out for me with the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis is the strength of the desire to have
a western civilizational pedigree
to dignify the use of stigmatized drugs.

Other psychedelic histories don’t seem to do it.

Other non-drug modes of changing consciousness.

The Eleusist discourse is very focused on mushrooms [differentiate Ama vs. Psilo -mh] and acid [sic; ergot, or LSA] and
aligning with an older and truer religion.

Now the “come from” is an understandable defense against anti-drug attitudes.

There’s a case making
by appealing to ancient authority
speaking back to anti-drug authority today saying:

“Drugs aren’t going to fry my brain; they shouldn’t be illegal.

“Real religion is about drugs, and it feels ecstatic, and you’ve kept good stuff from me, and now I’m going to take it back.”

Don’t mis-hear me: There is nothing wrong with looking to the past and wanting to know what is there.

There’s nothing wrong with wanting to inquire about Western psychedelic histories. That’s valuable.”

The growth edge in this psychedelic mysteries discourse is
instead of appealing to ancient authorities
to create a normative landscape that can hold,
rather than wage war on psychedelics;
to become grounded in, and advocating for, one’s own experiences and values and practices.

So, hear this critique not as a dismissal of the inquiry into ancient psychedelics,

but as being about what to emphasize,
and
the importance of a grounded, centered “come from” to integrate toward.

What happens when we focus on finding the drug in history,
and
finding that drug through a phenomenological comparison of “this is what I think this drug felt like to me, now”
and
“this description in an ancient text sounds like what I felt like, and so therefore that’s probably this drug“.

When that happens, it means that it focuses on
the task of that finding [ie which plant] [BAD] and
the phenomenology that authorizes the linkage, [BAD]
rather than
a program of creative work for taking up an injunction in the psychedelic space [GOOD]
from spirit,
from the divine,
from the higher truth,
from personal and human potential,
from a deeper level of consciousness;
however you model it.

And so again, hear this as a matter of emphasis, not a dismissal of studying phenomenology.

I’m talking about what happens when a discourse focuses on
the drug per se,
rather than what is the work that you do once it gets you into a state.

How do we model the parameters and the ends of spiritual evolution of God waking up in form of connecting with the fundamental waveform of the universe that might be best described in human terms as love.

Thank you Jim Fadiman for that amazing phrase.

However you model that work.

How this plays out in Road to Eleusis, for example, is that the authors present a case for the use of ergot ritually drunk at the ceremony to peak at the climax of the hierophants’ drama.

Wasson, Hofmann, and Ruck write that given the size of the audience (thousands) and their reactions, it quote “seems obvious that an hallucinogen must have induced it”, end quote.

This sort of thing is repeated frequently throughout the book.

They make this assumption based on
their interpretation of
the phenomenology of psychedelics,
specifically of ergot, which is a source of LSD precursors, but which they assume felt like a mushroom trip.

Wasson writes:

“I am certain that this word ‘ecstasy’ came into being to describe the effect of the mystery of Eleusis. Can you find a better word than that to describe the be mushroomed state?”

We have this claim that experiences described in the ancient texts (which are few) obviously fit with modern psychedelic experiences, and the focus is on finding the drug by using the phenomenology.

The problem is that it’s underwriting a cultural container for psychedelic practice being forwarded through biomedical therapeutic mainstreaming by gesturing to an uncertain history based on a phenomenological comparison and circumstantial evidence, absent of modeling of the gnosis and the practical modeling of the processes for working with it.

; integrating the eternal potential into the temporal manifest of daily life.

In this space, some philosophers have attempted to introduce secular resources for this modeling, such as Peter Sjöstedt-Hughes’ “metaphysical matrix”.

I’ve tried to do something similar with modeling experiences, particularly of evil and suffering, which appeared in this wonderful collection that came out of last year’s CSWR “Psychedelic Intersections” conference.

My final remark is:

To the extent that
what frames the West’s cultural historical resources for psychedelic practice,
is an attempt to authorize it [psychedelic practice] by
finding drugs in the past

by way of phenomenological identification.

Those coming to psychedelics through this route are learning form over content.

What they really need is bodybuilding for the disclosure, and to know that the divine disclosure is not one ceremony in the Telesterion.

It is a lifetime of successive increasingly subtle deepening.

Thank you.

[Applause]

/ end of transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, 2025

Video: Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough (Dec. 2024)

Search YouTube for ascough psychedelic:
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ascough+psychedelic

Search web for ascough psychedelic:
https://www.google.com/search?q=ascough+psychedelic

Video title:
Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough
Dec 25, 2024
Channel: Ayush Prakash
Ayush Prakash Podcast
This is episode 111.
Richard S. Ascough is Professor of Religion Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.
The topic of psychedelics starts at 44:30:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2670s [44:30] —

The idea of of synthesizing the ergot from mushrooms into an LSD type of substance, there’s just very weak basi– you know we can do it now, in highly technical labs, but could priests do it back then? Not saying they couldn’t, but I’m saying where’s– it’s conjecture, but it has to be proven.

48:21, Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity, [48:21] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2901s

Flip, flop;
we know there was no psychedelics = we don’t have evidence for psychedelics;
Motte <–> Bailey <–> Motte <–> Bailey.

In characteristic entheogen denier fashion, Ascough shifts his position back and forth like Hopkins’ Buddha statue moving back and forth between the trip room and the closet (mystic Roland Griffiths vs. naturalist Matthew Johnson).

See new Ruck article:

Article: Investigating the psychedelic hypothesis of kykeon, the sacred elixir of the Eleusinian Mysteries (Ruck, Oct. 2025)

Investigating the psychedelic hypothesis of kykeon, the sacred elixir of the Eleusinian Mysteries
Oct. 2025
Ruck Committee
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/397335329_Investigating_the_psychedelic_hypothesis_of_kykeon_the_sacred_elixir_of_the_Eleusinian_Mysteries

Interview blog: Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough (Hu, Sep. 2025)

Academic Indoctrination in Realtime: Ascough Prevents Mosurinjohn from Affirming Entheogen Scholarship

Title of blog post:
Myth-busting psychedelics in ancient Greece: 5 Questions for religious studies professors Sharday Mosurinjohn and Richard Ascough
The professors discuss the scant evidence for the idea that the Eleusinian Mysteries used psychedelics, and why it persists anyway.
Jane Hu, Sep. 15, 2025
https://themicrodose.substack.com/p/myth-busting-psychedelics-in-ancient

Transcription of “Sweetest Taboo” Video, with Commentary, Added Headings, and Citations of Works Mentioned

Video title:
The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences | Sharday C Mosurinjohn
Sep. 29, 2025
YouTube channel:
Harvard Law School Program on Jewish & Israeli Law
HARVARD LAW SCHOOL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k858spSK-bQ —

Audio: The first minute is too quiet, it gets louder.

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, 2025

Cleaned up, formatted, and clarified by Michael Hoffman. Research on mentioned works; added headings; commentary, etc. by Michael Hoffman.

~~

[00:00]

“Search for pre-Christian origins.

What happens when that search for origins focuses on the finding of the drug and the phenomenology of the drug as the way to find the drug?

I’m talking about the claim that the Eleusinian mysteries were psychedelic, as claimed by Carl Ruck & authors in the Road to Eleusis 1978 and revitalized as my colleague Dr. [Richard Ascough] mentioned in Brian Murarescu’s The Immortality Key in 2020.

[did Richard Ascough talk at this conference? Not mentioned in schedule. -mh]

These books attempt to shed light on the enigmatic rituals of the elusinian mysteries.

They argue that the consumption of a psychoactive substance played a pivotal role in the rituals which dramatized Persephone’s underworld death rebirth journey nested in the cosmic fractal cycles of destruction and creation.

These books are really popular, and they’re very mainstream, and they’re almost totally ignored by scholars.

I’m going to draw out something important about this reception and response history.

Let me detail it a little bit.

Until a couple of weeks ago, in response to The Immortality Key, for instance, I was only aware of one great paper, and the fact that both Dr. Charles Stang and I both independently presented papers on it in the summer of 2023.

Mine was with my colleague Dr. Richard Ascoff.

Dr. Stang’s excellent essay is now published in Harvard Theological Review …

Psychedelic Futures and Altered States in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean (Charles Stang, Dec. 2024)

Web search:
https://www.google.com/search?q=Charles+Stang%27s+%22Harvard+Theological+Review%22
Web search:
“Psychedelic Futures and Altered States in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean”
https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Psychedelic+Futures+and+Altered+States+in+the+Religions+of+the+Ancient+Mediterranean%22
Sharday’s article’s References section has 1 entry for Stang:

Psychedelic Futures and Altered States in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean
Charles Stang
December 31, 2024
Harvard Theological Review
Published online by Cambridge University Press.

I have Stang’s entire article. -mh]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

There also recently appeared a new piece in Reason magazine.

Otherwise, this psychedelic mysteries hypothesis [Ascough’s term] was not being engaged in religious studies.

[See https://cyberdisciple.wordpress.com/site-map/ – Find “mura”, “ruck”]

There is some work [scholarly critique] on Road to Eleusis.

Not a lot, but I saw the claim that “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic” constantly repeated at psychedelic conferences.

I saw it especially on the slide of the presentations that gave the cultural historical background.

Particularly the psychedelic science [~= Tim Leary-type psychometric q’airs] presentations included this [such a] slide. [saying “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic”]

There would be the bas relief of Demeter handing Persephone a mushroom.

Apparently, the alleged mushroom.

Seeing this all over the place [the claim that “the ancient mysteries were psychedelic”], I wanted…

Having colleagues always coming up to me going

“Did you know — you’re in religion; you’re a religious studies scholar —

“Did you know that the ancient mysteries were psychedelic?”

There’s not evidence for this.

Sharday Unable to Get Either Type of Journal to Publish Her Critique: Journals Affirming or Denying Psychedelics in Religious History

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

So I thought,

“Let me put this piece in a psychedelic science journal to speak particularly to that crowd.”

Possibly Rejected by the Journal of Psychedelic Studies​ (M. Wink.) probably

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

The psychedelic science journal did not want to critique Ruck and Wasson and Hofmann.

[It] seemed [to me they’re reluctant] to undermine some of the bedrock on which rests the popularization of psychedelics and

the dignification of psychedelics as old and religiously serious, and

on which therefore rest certain arguments for the legalization of psychedelics.

Religious Studies Journal Rejected Her Critique Article: Journal Allergic to Psychedelics

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

After a year of back and forth, we tried to publish it [citation? of her conf presentation above, not found yet? mh] in a religious studies journal that after another year turned out didn’t want to touch psychedelics.

This publication non-history, or non-publication history, is emblematic of a larger problem.

Larger Problem: Isolation and Separation of Academic Scholarship vs. Popular Scholarship, produced the False Lie and Blundering Error, the “psychedelic mysteries” Pseudo-Fact

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

The siloing of academic disciplines and academia from popular discourse means that sometimes an idea gets picked up like the “psychedelic mysteries” claim from a classicist, and then it gets repeated in another discipline, such as psychedelic science work, but it’s then insulated from getting evolved by interdisciplinary critique.

Scholarship Should Evolve by Communication FROM Academic True Scholarship, TO Popular Reception of Correction

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

[I suspect Mosur of credentialism, authoritarianism, institutionalism: She likely imagines stupid pop scholars need to be informed by omniscient-like-her, academic authorities, in a strictly 1-way communication -mh]

The contribution that I want to make [having entered the field 5 minutes ago and seeing a self-promotion and instant leadership opportunity for myself -mh] is towards supporting:

the discussion of psychedelics coming into mainstream culture on sound historical footing
and to emphasize drawing on
sophisticated frameworks for working with the psychedelic experience
rather than
the finding of the drug, and the phenomenology of the drug.

Change from Looking for Which Plant (Based on Phenomenology of Your Trips); Instead

She Said “Positionality”

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

I want to foreground the importance of
scholars bringing our subjectivity to the claims that we are making –
which for all of
the talk of positionality becoming de riguer during the academy,
it’s not exactly often that academia trains us to make a practice of
inventorying what we’ve disowned and avoided knowing about ourselves and projected onto others or the past
and so on in order to continually
come into integrity around what we’re doing.

[you entered the field 5 minutes ago, haven’t read the published evidence, and presume to lecture others about proper scholarship. Proper scholarship is good, but bully in a china shop
I need to find her unpublishable article to clarify her recommendations for changing how entheogen scholarship, or psychedelic science, is done – mh]

But our work is deeply served by inquiring into what our “come from” is with it.

What stands out for me with the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis is the strength of the desire to have
a western civilizational pedigree
to dignify the use of stigmatized drugs.

[she’s not representing my scholarship, theorizing, and motivations -mh]

Other psychedelic histories [?] don’t seem to do it. [???]

She Pontificates on Non-Drug Psychedelics (Academia-Approved)

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

Other non-drug modes of changing consciousness.

The Eleusist discourse is very focused on mushrooms [differentiate Ama vs. Psilo -mh] and acid [sic; ergot, or LSA] and
aligning with an older and truer religion.

Now the “come from” is an understandable defense against anti-drug attitudes.

There’s a case making
by appealing to ancient authority
speaking back to anti-drug authority today saying:

Drugs aren’t going to fry my brain; they shouldn’t be illegal. Real religion is about drugs, and it feels ecstatic, and you’ve kept good stuff from me, and now I’m going to take it back.”

Sharday, in a moment of clarity of thought and expression

Don’t mis-hear me: There is nothing wrong with looking to the past and wanting to know what is there.

There’s nothing wrong with wanting to inquire about Western psychedelic histories. That’s valuable.”

[5:45]

[She says the exact opposite of her bullying, cocky, pushy phrases in her Abstract.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k858spSK-bQ&t=345s [5:45]

TODO: QUOTE HER ARTICLE ABSTRACT, NOXIOUS PHRASES CONTRADICTING THAT. At top of present page, copypaste to here, the bold markup of best bad phrases, in the Abstract of the article and in the Conference Schedule’s description of her talk.]

Conference Schedule (extra link)

[In contrast, see her written description of the talk, from the conference schedule, where she rudely attacks and dictates what scholars are permitted to investigate
https://www.psychedelicsandreligion.info/schedule
— copied to below. We are not “mis-hearing” you; we are READING your Abstract ~= conf Schedule summary, which says exactly the opposite of what you’re now saying, now that your TEXT finished insulting entheogen scholars. Motte and Bailey arg’n; shifting what your position is, opportunitically, a shell game.

Like Andy Letcher’s book Shroom:
“No Secret Christian Amanita Cult, b/c the Liberty Cap(!) mushroom tree on Bern door is not hidden, as Stamets & Gartz in 1996 in typical fashion say [false; those mycologists wrote no such thing, only “matches Liberty Cap”];
Thus I have proved:
No mushrooms in W relig history.”
– mh]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

The growth edge in this psychedelic mysteries discourse is
instead of appealing to ancient authorities
to create a normative landscape that can hold,
rather than wage war on psychedelics;
to become grounded in, and advocating for, one’s own experiences and values and practices.
[as long as they center on Indig Shams, and are limited to that -mh]

So, hear this critique not as a dismissal of the inquiry into ancient psychedelics,

[but quote her writeup of the talk, where she dismisses and forbids and demonizes inquiry into ancient psychedelics -mh]

Important: Have a Grounded, Centered, “Come-from” to Integrate Toward

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

but as being about what to emphasize,
and
the importance of a grounded, centered “come from” to integrate toward.

[this newcomer to field dictates what we have to emphasize -mh]

What happens when we focus on finding the drug in history [BAD],
and
finding that drug through a phenomenological comparison of “this is what I think this drug felt like to me, now” [BAD]
and
“this description in an ancient text sounds like what I felt like, and so therefore that’s probably this drug“. [BAD]

[I rail against overemph of Amanita directly at the expense of Psilocybin.
Irvin commits that bad move:
The Holy Mushroom: Evidence of Mushrooms in Judeo-Christianity (Jan Irvin, 2008) https://www.amazon.com/dp/1439215170
-mh]

Important: Do Creative Work for Taking up an Injunction in the Psychedelic Space from Spirit

[academic bafflegab meaning nothing – maybe after I read her article cover-to-cover the FOURTH time, I can translate this to STEM normal talk.

She talks about “need for communication” between smart academics and stupid pop audience – ie, from academic authorities of which she is the exemplar, to stupid pop audiences — yet she can’t communicate.

She hides her lack of substantive ideas, by needless academic bafflegab. -mh]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

When that happens, it means that it focuses on
the task of that finding [ie which plant] [BAD] and
the phenomenology that authorizes the linkage, [BAD]
rather than
a program of creative work for taking up an injunction in the psychedelic space [GOOD]
from spirit,
from the divine,
from the higher truth,
from personal and human potential,
from a deeper level of consciousness;
however you model it.

And so again, hear this as a matter of emphasis, not a dismissal of studying phenomenology. [eg how your trip felt, like ancient religion reports]

[phenomenology? I thought the dispute is whether it’s ok for scholars to look for particular entheogen plants in religious history –
shifts the topic of discussion -mh]

[Her field-changing revolutionary advice:
don’t emphasize “which plant“;
don’t emphasize “what phenomenology effects?”;
instead, emphasize:
“creative work for taking up an injunction in the psychedelic space from [the transcendent
;
the work that you do once the drug gets you into a state.
-mh]

[Ruck says: Gnosis is the Amanita.
I say: gnosis is psilocybin 10x, giving eternalism-driven control-transformation, adding the eternalism POV to the possibilism POV. -mh
]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

I’m talking about what happens when a discourse focuses on
the drug per se, [BAD]
rather than what is the work that you do once it gets you into a state. [GOOD]

[equivalent idea in the Egodeath theory:

I de-emphasize psychedelics themselves; it’s all about loose cognition; the loose cognitive state, and how the mental model of control is transformed from possibilism-thinking, to add eternalism-thinking.

She’s scrambling, thrashing around looking for something to correct you on.
The work is 10 psilocybin sessions, adding eternalism-thinking to possibilism-thinking. -mh]

How do we model the parameters and the ends of spiritual evolution of God waking up in form of connecting with the fundamental waveform of the universe that might be best described in human terms as love.

[wtf are you even on about? relational mysticism instead of positive unitive model? -mh]

Thank you Jim Fadiman for that amazing phrase.

However you model that work.

[Mosur chastises Ruck and Muraresku:
instead of looking for which plant, based on which phenomenology
(eg eternalism-driven control-transformation?),
you should instead model the work.
See the closest Ruck & M. Hoffman comes: book:
Entheogens, Myth & Human Consciousness. -mh]

How this plays out in Road to Eleusis, for example, is that the authors present a case for the use of ergot ritually drunk at the ceremony to peak at the climax of the hierophants’ drama.

Wasson, Hofmann, and Ruck write that given the size of the audience (thousands) and their reactions, it quote “seems obvious that an hallucinogen must have induced it”, end quote.

This sort of thing is repeated frequently throughout the book.

They make this assumption based on
their interpretation of
the phenomenology of psychedelics,
specifically of ergot, which is a source of LSD precursors, but which they assume felt like a mushroom trip.

[Sharday says: Ruck is bad for having mushroom/ acid journey, then using his phenomenology to try to identify which plant in ancient mystery religions. -mh]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

Wasson writes:

“I am certain that this word ‘ecstasy’ came into being to describe the effect of the mystery of Eleusis. Can you find a better word than that to describe the be mushroomed state?”

We have this claim that experiences described in the ancient texts (which are few) obviously fit with modern psychedelic experiences, and the focus is on finding the drug by using the phenomenology.

[just texts? then, “evidence is few” —
Peak transformative experiences are also described by the best world religious mythology, and the best mythic art -mh]

The Problem Is, Underwriting a cultural container for psychedelic practice, via psychedelic science, historical uncertainty, based on experience descriptions, without modeling the processes for gnosis

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

The problem is that it’s underwriting a cultural container for psychedelic practice being forwarded through biomedical therapeutic mainstreaming by gesturing to an uncertain history based on a phenomenological comparison and circumstantial evidence, absent of modeling of the gnosis and the practical modeling of the processes for working with it.

[Egodeath theory’s equivalent call for a change of focus:
Don’t focus on psychedelics themselves; or generic trip report effects;
model the mental model transformation process, from possibilism to eternalism; eternalism-driven control-transformation — and how myth and art depict that by analogies. -mh]

Sharday, Expert in Modelling Gnosis and the Processes for Working with Gnosis

[See her article in which she supposely models Gnosis, and models the processes for working with Gnosis.

Ruck & Hoffman try that, sort of, in the book Entheogens, Myth & Human Consciousness, but I couldn’t find anything about consciousness in that book.

Probably its content is invisible on my radar because Ruck & Hoffman probably use the positive unitive model of “mystical experience” (Popular Neo-Advaita), which is nothing to me, compared to eternalism-driven control-transformation to add the eternalism POV to the possibilism POV. – mh]

Model the Integrating of Gnosis into Daily Life

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

; integrating the eternal potential into the temporal manifest of daily life.

In this space, some philosophers have attempted to introduce secular resources for this modeling, such as Peter Sjöstedt-Hughes’ “metaphysical matrix”.

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t below the next section:

Video: Dr. Peter Sjöstedt-Hughes – ‘Metaphysics and Psychedelics’ (The MIND Philosophy Series #3) (Jun. 2022)

https://www.google.com/search?q=Peter+Hughes+metaphysical+matrix

Video title:
Dr. Peter Sjöstedt-Hughes – ‘Metaphysics and Psychedelics’ (The MIND Philosophy Series #3)
June 21, 2022
Channel:
MIND Foundation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJ6UDyF4KWo —

Vid desc: “Psychedelics can occasion intense #metaphysical experiences – are such shifts delusional, or might they carry an element of truth?

“Continuing our Philosophy Series, Dr. Sjöstedt-Hughes, research fellow and associate lecturer at the University of Exeter (UK), will speak of how we might:

Make sense of such [psychedelic] experiences by critically framing them through several rational metaphysical systems.”

/ end of Desc from Sjöstedt-Hughes video

Modelling Experiences

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

I’ve tried to do something similar with modeling experiences, particularly of evil and suffering, which appeared in this wonderful collection that came out of last year’s CSWR “Psychedelic Intersections” conference.

[“current year” = 2025; “last year” = 2024]

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t below the next section

Collection Including Modelling Experiences of Evil and Suffering: Center for the Study of World Religions’ “Psychedelic Intersections” conference

[Found the paper, seems relevant to the Egodeath theory.

Clearly relevant (sarcasm) — her previous 200 articles not about psychedelics, and her johhnny come lately discovery of Get Rich Quick opportunities in this newly reopened field.

So, 5 minutes ago, she started trying her hand at co-authoring articles with people, and trying to pose her totally NON psychedelic articles as if relevant to psychedelics -mh]

  1. Search web:
    “Center for the Study of World Religions” “Psychedelic Intersections” conference
    https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Center+for+the+Study+of+World+Religions%22+%22Psychedelic+Intersections%22+conference
  2. Find a “Mosurinjohn” webpage mentioning her Modelling Experiences of Evil and Suffering.

Alt try 2:

search web:
“Center for the Study of World Religions” “Psychedelic Intersections” conference Mosurinjohn 2024

might be it:
https://dash.harvard.edu/entities/publication/3d3ddf54-e092-419c-a61c-cb3800b05831 mentions article:
Toward a Psychedelic Theodicy: Psychedelic Biomedicine and the Concept of Risk

Toward a Psychedelic Theodicy: Psychedelic Biomedicine and the Concept of Risk (Mosurinjohn, 2024)

Paper, 7 pages, looks interesting for me: bad trip of evil demons & fear of God.

Search web for her title:
Toward a Psychedelic Theodicy: Psychedelic Biomedicine and the Concept of Risk
https://www.google.com/search?q=Toward+a+Psychedelic+Theodicy%3A+Psychedelic+Biomedicine+and+the+Concept+of+Risk
Read it as a webpage, or download as a PDF, at:
https://cswr.hds.harvard.edu/publications/psychedelic-intersections/psychedelic-theodicy-mosurinjohn

Final Part of Her Talk

Transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, con’t:

My final remark is:

To the extent that
what frames the West’s cultural historical resources for psychedelic practice,
is an attempt to authorize it [psychedelic practice] by
finding drugs in the past

by way of phenomenological identification.

Those coming to psychedelics through this route are learning form over content.

[“form” [BAD] means:
identifying which drug in ancient texts or myths or images; and
doing that by matching current altered effects with past descriptions of experiences]

What they really need is bodybuilding for the disclosure, and to know that the divine disclosure is not one ceremony in the Telesterion.

[She assumes entheogen scholars say,
“A single experience with a single drug, in antiquity, is what we must identify the plant for; then we have understanding.”]

It is a lifetime of successive increasingly subtle deepening.

[cliche: “Is enlightenment in a pill, or not?”
Complete initiation, actual “complete mystical experience”, is 10 psilocybin sessions, producing eternalism-driven control-transformation, adding the eternalism POV to the possibilism POV.
Been developing & deepening this explanatory model since 1988-2026. -mh
]

Thank you.

[Applause]

[we’re being incoherently chastised and lectured by a newbie who hasn’t read the basic literature in the field, fishing around for some sort of appearance of correcting the field. What are the executive takeaways: none?

  • “Learn form over content.”
  • “Stop looking for plants based on phenomenology.”]

This is not all academic hot air without useful, actionable substance.

/ end of transcription of video of the talk “The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences” by Mosurinjohn, with Commentary, Added Headings, and Citations of Works Mentioned

Video’s Short Description, with My Commentary (Mosurinjohn’s Talk)

“The persistence of the belief that ancient Western religions were fundamentally psychedelic [is] less a historical hypothesis but a myth serving cross purposes for different psychedelic communities.

[a mere zoom-out rough desc of video. Elastic wording immediately: “less X than Y”, Y = “a myth serving cross purposes – “cross purposes”? How many assertions, ever-vaguer, try to slip in here? -mh]

“Why is the psychedelic discourse so intent on hanging on to this narrative?”

[I could ask similar about dominant Pop narrow theory, Secret Christian Amanita Cult. vs. the important BROAD question,
“What’s the extent of psychedelics in religious history?

Is Sharday HELPING OR NOT, TO ANSWER (POSITIVE SCHOLARSHIP):
TO WHAT EXTENT PSYCHEDELICS IN RELIGIOUS HISTORY?

There are various ways to define the scope of such questions.

There are variant Q’s, w/ broad or narrow scoping:

  • To what extent psychedelics in religious history?
  • To what extent did religious myth serve as analogies describing eternalism-driven control-transformation in religious history?
  • Is religion legit when, in places & times, it failed to be analogies describing eternalism-driven control-transformation?
  • Are brands of Transcendent Knowledge bogus and lower, exoteric reductions that perpetuate deluded possibilism-thinking, when they fail to be analogies describing psychedelic eternalism-driven control-transformation?
  • To what extent psilocybin mushrooms in earliest Xn history?
  • When was the peak of using psilocybin mushrooms in Medieval Xy – or, Medieval Europe?

/ end of mh interjection

Desc con’t:

“Why is improvement to the empirical and theoretical rigour of psychedelic history resisted rather than welcomed?

“Why accept a swath of self-serving speculation drawn from the humanities, and then insist on resisting critical analysis?”

/ end of video’s Desc with my commentary

Summary of “Invention” Article (Liebert Inc., Aug. 5, 2025)

Summary:
https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1093678
Aug. 5, 2025

In that 6-paragraph summary, watch out for “secret”, “suppress”, “hidden”, “key”, etc.

Delete all that junk, it prevents evidence & theory development.

The obsession with secret/suppressed, as we see well in Shroom by Letcher, ENTIRELY DERAILS what topic we’re even investigating. Letcher is under the delusion that we are investigating the narrow specific pop Secret Christian Amanita Cult theory.

Far more important is to investigate the broad, general question: the extent of psychedelics in history, including in Christendom. That in no way implies that the primary structure of the investigation, the #1 question:

  • Which groups had the Secret Amanita Gnosis?
  • Which groups lacked the Secret Amanita Gnosis?
  • Which groups suppressed the Secret Amanita Gnosis?

The mis-focus on “which groups” shuts out the far plainer question, more basic and elementary: did Christendom have psychedelics, or not? What are all types of evidence, and particular evidence of such types, for SHEER PRESENCE. Do not say per Ruck,

“Thank you for finding yet more evidence of SECRET psychedelic use by HERETICAL GROUPS.”

Ruck should instead halt at:

“Thank you for finding yet more evidence of psychedelic use by people within Christendom.”

People act like that speculation about “which groups” is a required, main part of theorizing — it’s not!

Delete the social drama narrative, and do scholarship instead; evidence + theorizing — sans made-up (to feed Popular Audience Demand) storytime speculation that’s not needed, and is unhelpful, and distracts the conversation in an irrelevant direction.

Got Nothing to Contribute, Not that Bright, and Don’t Feel Like Reading the Literature in the Field? Become an Entheogen Scholarship Critic, and Guide the Field

Pollan and Muraresku invaded the field suddenly, and were investments in astroturfed “overnight bestsellers”.

Now anyone feels they can invade the field, not read the bulk of the literature, and operate as a Wise Critic: On Easy Mode; just criticize The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020 – way easier than contributing to the field.

Greer doesn’t have to backpedal and contradict himself, b/c starts off w/ a balanced, nuanced stance – and hopefully isn’t promoting himself by denigrating everyone in a field he entered 5 minutes ago as Shar did.

Greer gives a better balanced arg’n than very lopsided denier Mosur – she has to catch up w/ Greer’s quality of arg’n in realtime.

Watch Mosur scramble to counter her article’s Abstract and her talk’s desc in the conf Schedule.

Direct self-contradiction, she’s scrambling in her talk: move those goalposts! “Motte! No, Bailey! No, Motte! No, Bailey!”

Greer doesn’t directly contradict himself / his Abstract like Mosur does.

Everyone was PISSED OFF at Shar’s POS lopsided, self-righteous, self-assured article sh*tting on the entire psychedelic mysteries hypothesis for self-promotion.

Can tell that by her self-contradiction during her talk; her defensiveness; her article being hated and rejected by all types of journals.

Greer: “my pal erik davis”, “a christ trip”. “This micro-tradition“

Insults; Self-Assured; Botches Basics: “Wasson Used Illegal Amanita”; Low Credibility Greer

Overconfident and biased, lopsided, oft clumsy loaded characterization. Histo article.

p. 281: “Wasson, Hofmann, and Ruck violated law and schol decorum and used Amanita” – face palm, there went all your credibility, Greer. Read a book.

Wasson, Hofmann, and Ruck violated law and schol decorum and used Amanita.

Xn Greer, newbie to the field

“The amateurs boldly go where no scholar has gone before, both intellectually and experientially.

“Wasson, Hofmann, and Ruck ([1978] 2008: 34) repudiated “armchair” scholarship and instead defied legal prohibitions and scholarly decorum by experimenting with Amanita muscaria themselves as a means of testing their hypotheses.

“They even went so far as demanding their detractors do the same before passing judgment on their arguments.”

F*CKING TERRIBLE WRITING!

A botched smear job by blundering Greer the Pop Sike zine contributor writing for the Pop Sike audience.

Greer’s Article about Amanita Being Illegal

https://www.academia.edu/129077372/Historians_on_Drugs_Towards_an_Empirical_Historiography_of_Global_Psychedelic_Cultures
Historians on Drugs: Towards an Empirical Historiography of Global Psychedelic Cultures
Christian Greer

2025, South Atlantic Quarterly

Religion,
Drugs And Addiction,
Psychedelics,
Global History,
Western Esotericism
https://doi.org/10.1215/00382876-11626593

Abstract of Article “Historians on Drugs” (Greer)

“Scholarship on the global history of psychedelics is divided into two rival approaches.

“This article analyzes these approaches, emphasizing the way in which ideological biases on both sides have stymied serious research on the use of psychedelic substances across space and time, before introducing the empirical approach as an alternative.

“The most prevalent view, “pharmacological Calvinism,” essentializes mind‐altering drugs and their users as degenerate or antisocial.

“This reductive approach has defined the intellectual mainstream across academic disciplines to the present.

“In contrast to pharmacological Calvinism, the entheogenic school offers a maximalist interpretation of psychedelics’ impact on human culture and cognition, presenting consciousness‐expanding drugs as the “secret key” behind the world’s religious traditions, mythology, and folklore.

“This article proposes that the empirical approach offers a corrective to the overstatements of both schools,

“as it is defined by comparatively granular research that draws from a deep understanding of primary sources

“placed in conversation with the intellectual apparatuses of the secondary literature.

“Distinctly uninterested in unveiling psychedelics as the “key” to any tradition, this approach interprets the multiplicity of meanings and values associated with powerful psychotropics, alongside other modes of ecstasy and transpersonal relationality, as an integral dimension of the human story.”

Abstract of Article “Historians on Drugs” (Greer), with Commentary

“Scholarship on the global history of psychedelics is divided into two rival approaches.

“This article analyzes these approaches, emphasizing the way in which ideological biases on both sides have stymied serious research on the use of psychedelic substances across space and time, before introducing the empirical approach as an alternative.

“The most prevalent view, “pharmacological Calvinism,” essentializes mind‐altering drugs and their users as degenerate or antisocial.

“This reductive approach has defined the intellectual mainstream across academic disciplines to the present.

“In contrast to pharmacological Calvinism, the entheogenic school offers a maximalist interpretation of psychedelics’ impact on human culture and cognition, presenting consciousness‐expanding drugs as the “secret key” behind the world’s religious traditions, mythology, and folklore.

[every last one of ’em is OBSESSED by the secrecy/suppression social drama narrative (not Stamets/Gartz 1996, against Andy Letcher’s Shroom’s botched endnote 31), but the secrecy/suppression premise is actually distinct from the broad general proposal; don’t conflate.

In some ways, the Egodeath theory = the empirical approach, moderate middling way; theory-driven maximal entheogen theory of religion -mh]

“This article proposes that the empirical approach offers a corrective to the overstatements of both schools,

[fallacy of the middle

you need to prove it by throwing the Walburga tapestry in the river, like the perfect, reasonable middle-men, J & J Brown -mh]

“as it is defined by comparatively granular research that draws from a deep understanding of primary sources

[how about start by just reading Samorini 1997, Samorini 1998, & “Conjuring Eden”? not being completely unread in the field, for 2nd-generation entheogen scholarship (the Explicit Psilocybin paradigm). -mh]

“placed in conversation with the intellectual apparatuses of the secondary literature.

[d/k all this “key” business, — oh, I see: these latest batch of writers is pushing against The Immortality Key by Brian Muraresku, 2020: playing the “entheogen scholarship critic, buy my book” game on Easy Mode. -mh]

“Distinctly uninterested in unveiling psychedelics as the “key” to any tradition, this approach interprets the multiplicity of meanings and values associated with powerful psychotropics, alongside other modes of ecstasy and transpersonal relationality, as an integral dimension of the human story.”

/ end of Abstract of Greer article

I sent to Greer at Academia, Jan. 20, 2026:

“Defining a middle way.

I have lots of intensive critique of entheogen scholars.

Entheogen scholarship needs internal critique from within the field.

Butthead academic naysayers, ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

The field of psychedelic science needs internal critique from within the field.

This psychedelic pseudo science incorp’s the 1893/1960, ultra narrow (eliminative, reductionist), Popular Neo-Advaita, positive unitive model of “mystical experience”.

Breau 2023 adds negative unitive experience, but is stuck within the 1893/1960 bubble still.

Taves 2020 is broader, at least nominally: she remains stuck within the narrow “mysticism = unitive” bubble, but calls to broaden the field from only Unitive effects, to “altered sense of self”.

/ end of msg to Greer

Bully Opportunism

Sharday is a bully/opportunist version of Greer & Ascough article/talk.

Takes advantage of work by Greer & Ascough to self-promote — by smearing and insulting Pop Entheogen Scholarship and striking the relative stance of cautionary wise advisor — but doesn’t move the field of entheogen scholarship forward.

Look how awful entheogen scholars suck, those fools – I advise them, and buy my book.” -mh]

Self-assured denier of … “no solid proof” re specifically, ancient Xy.

Greer says “Colleague of Stang.

“psychedelics make feel chosen for a mission”, “ego inflation”, an “all too real danger”.

Video: Psychedelic Christianity: Real and Imagined | Christian Greer

Video title:
Psychedelic Christianity: Real and Imagined | Christian Greer
Harvard Law School Program on Jewish & Israeli Law
Uploaded Sep. 9, 2025
HARVARD LAW SCHOOL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYlotZTyOFA —

“We can accept that SOME Xns used SOME plants.”

Video’s Description: Psychedelic Christianity: Real and Imagined (Greer)

“Was the original Eucharist a psychedelic?

“Were the original Christian communities entheogenically supercharged?

“Was Jesus actually a mushroom? [he ridicules the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis]

“These are simply some of the questions that historians of drugs field on a regular basis.

“And to be clear, our answers are almost always disappointing. Let me explain why.

“All of the arguments that suggest a psychedelic origin of Christianity are pure conjecture.

“There is simply no solid proof that Christianity had a psychedelic origin or that ancient Christians used psychedelics.

Yet, as the expression goes, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

And I anticipate that some archaeo-chemists will eventually unearth a vessel that demonstrates some Christians in some part of the ancient world use some sort of psychedelic sacrament in their worship.

[Greer here makes Mosur look TERRIBLE & unbal – ppl are not PISSED OFF at Greer, but at Shar]

Greer is willing to play, w/ entheogen scholarship – Mosur garbage-cans the entire entheogen scholarship field. She makes enemies; Greer less so. -mh]

“And why not?

Over the last few millennia, humans across the globe have used a variety of psychedelic substances to access visionary states of consciousness.

This vast pharmacopoeia includes plants, roots, vines, cacti, nuts, herbs, nectar, roots, snuffs…. you get the picture.

There is no doubt that psychedelic substances have played a key role in human culture, animating religious rituals, rites of passage, communal ceremonies, not to mention healing, sorcery, divination, communion with the dead.

And all of that continues to the present day. But again, there is still no proof that they were used amongst Christians in the ancient world.

I’m not going to belabor this point by mapping all of the deficiencies in the arguments suggesting a psychedelic origin of Christianity.

Rather, I’m going to focus on the real stakes involved with this preoccupation with an imagined psychedelic Christian origin, as opposed to the real traditions of psychedelic Christianity.”

/ end Greer vid desc.

Commentary about Video: Psychedelic Christianity: Real and Imagined (Greer)

Christian Greer (conference Mar. 2025, uploaded Sep. 2025)

Greer makes Mosurinjohn look bad; he affirms reasonable though “no proof ancient Christian use of plants”.

“Avoid pharm’l Calvinism” (one extreme).

“Avoid ___” (other extreme; entheogen scholars see mushrooms everywhere)

He argues for this middle way, like tapestry-discarder Browns.

Mosur’s talk follows Greer’s talk.

Greer makes her look dull and obstinate; looking for a cheap opportunity to denigrate entheogen scholars, in order to elevate herself.

She overshoots, insults the hell out of the entire broad notion of history of psychedelics in religion, pisses off everyone in entheogen scholarship, then has to backpedal and say she didn’t say what she, hamfisted, clearly said:

You’re not allowed to study psychedelics in Euro history, because that is violence against Indig Shams, and is ignoring Indig Shams.

Sharday’s clumsy, rude, ignorant, biased message:

“Foolish, blundering entheogen scholars:
Do not research & theorize about the past 3000 years in Europe.
You have to restrict your research & theorizing to only the past 100 years, in the Americas.
Because there’s only evidence for psychedelics in Indig Shams history, not in other cultures.
You need to start reading and investigating history of Indig Shams, which no one has covered.”

Video’s Description Again, Mosur’s Talk, with Commentary

Video’s Desc: [it’s below, but cluttered w/ my commentary – re-post here, todo, w/o my commentary]

The talk was probably given on March 5, 2025. Vid uploaded Sep 2025.

The video’s description is as obnoxious, cocky, ignorant, & unprofessional, as the written summary of the talk, in the conference schedule:

Video’s Desc:

“The persistence of the belief that ancient Western religions were fundamentally psychedelic less a historical hypothesis but a myth serving cross purposes for different psychedelic communities.

“Why is the psychedelic discourse so intent on hanging on to this narrative?

“Why is improvement to the empirical and theoretical rigour of psychedelic history resisted rather than welcomed?

“Why accept a swath of self-serving speculation drawn from the humanities, and then insist on resisting critical analysis?”

Reminds me of this hack journalist:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2020/12/04/scholarly-fail-quotes-hall-of-shame/#plaincourault-been-debunked
Rude and Wrong deserve to be married.

If the idea of the Plaincourault fresco depicting a hallucinogenic mushroom has been debunked, repeatedly, by scholars in the best position to interpret it, why does it persist?

Emma Betuel

Reasons:

  • Plaincourault as mushroom has not debunked repeatedly, or ever.
  • The Plaincourault fresco means mushroom-tree. The medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees} depicts by analogies, mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism, during 10 psilocybin sessions. Via {mushrooms}, {branching}, {handedness}, and {stability} motifs.
  • Various other reasons for entheogen scholarship (or rather, psychedelic science?) to persist, are named by Mosur. and suchlike writers/articles that I’m reading on mysticism, entheogen history, and psychedelic science.
  • The Baier article High Mysticism is good, tracing cultural history & motives of, not entheogen scholarship, but psychedelic science & its model of mystical experience (narrow, Popular Neo-Advaita).

Distinct topics:

  • entheogen scholarship; extent of psychedelics in relig hist?
  • psychedelic science: Learyean psychometric questionnaires that totally buy into the narrowing, selective, exclusively positive unitive model of mystical experience.
  • philosophy of mystical experience (ie, welding in place, the narrowing, exclusively positive unitive model of mystical experience).

Her Rejected Article: Accepted by “psychedelic medicine” journal

I have 3 articles on desk:

  • Likely: Mosurinjohn & Ascough: Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience – July 2025
  • Not: Mosurinjohn, Roseman, Girn, April 2023: “Drug mystical experience critique“
  • Not: Richard Ascough (not Shar Mosur): Allegro & the the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis, Aug 2025

link to that paper: not yet at my Moving Past Mysticism in Psychedelic Science page. does belong? anyway link it here, then. done.

Comments about Video’s Desc

Who is she pushing against: Muraresku specifically? It’s the history of her rejected article, rejected by both camps of journals:

  • Extremist entheogen scholars pushing maximal entheogen theory of religion (eg Brown 2019 lists first, Michael Hoffman of Egodeath.com)
  • Extremist ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

I have her referenced article. I know it, have it, have read it.

Pop social drama narrative of Secret Christian Amanita Cult? the Secret Amanita paradigm? Or ergot equiv of that.

Mosurinjohn Doggedly 🐶 Pursues Her Mirage 👻 of Non-Drug Entheogens, Committing Myopic Indigenous Shams propaganda against presence of psychedelics in non-Sham’ic religious history

Crop by Michael Hoffman
On left, R thumb (non-branching) holds {lifted garment}; pairs of hands below: YI (thumb & fingers) above, & Y (fingers, no thumb) below. 11:19 p.m. January 19, 2026

Hold branch in L hand.

Need a name / label / symbol for “one hand fingers no thumb; and other hand thumb as well as fingers”. Y + YI. The YI Hand shape, plus fingers-only:

{fingers only vs. fingers & thumb}
fft

On left, R thumb (non-branching) holds {lifted garment};
pairs of hands below:
YI (thumb & fingers) above, &
Y (fingers, no thumb) below.
11:19 p.m. January 19, 2026

It’s puzzling why this set of conference videos (including one of my colleagues), are at the channel “Harvard Law School Program on Jewish & Israeli Law“. Half the talks in the conference/set are not Jewish.

Her Outrageous Written Description/Summary of Her Talk

Her written desc of the talk, from conf schedule, where she rudely attacks and dictates what scholars are permitted to investigate.

https://www.psychedelicsandreligion.info/schedule —

Sharday Mosurinjohn, The Sweetest Taboo: Psychedelics and the Invention of Religious Experiences

“This talk responds to the idea that the ancient Eleusynian Mysteries were psychedelic, as claimed by Carl Ruck and co-authors in The Road to Eleusis (1978), revitalized by Brian Muraresku’s The Immortality Key (2020), and popularized by the Overton window-widening Joe Rogan.

“It [the talk] begins by
exposing critical methodological flaws in the arguments,
namely,
a pattern of presenting claims, followed by mild circumstantial evidence, and then rhetorically solidifying the interpretation of this evidence into a “fact,” on which is built each subsequent round of conjecture.

“In The Road To Eleusis, a speculation like “It seems obvious that an hallucinogen must have induced it” (2008: 47) immediately furnishes the next premise “To identify the Eleusynian drug…” (2008: 47) that begins the following paragraph.

Any Scholar Who Looks for Psychedelics in Religious History (Other than Indig Shams) = “These writers’ dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages“

Please Scream “I’m Ignorant, Vague, Myopic, and Mean” Louder

“I argue that
these writers’ dogged pursuit of evidentiary mirages

[unprofessional, rude, rhetoric, ignorant jerk; rude & wrong are married forever, deserving each other -mh]

has to do with wanting
a western civilizational pedigree
to dignify the use of stigmatized drugs.

[is that so? is that the motive of 2nd-generation entheogen scholarship (the Explicit Psilocybin paradigm: Samorini, Michael Hoffman [theorist of eternalism-driven control-transformation], & Browns? -mh]

This myopia is rooted in colonial violence

🤦‍♂️ 🤦‍♂️ 🤦‍♂️ 🤦‍♂️

that precludes seriously relating to [??? do you not know that the same entheogen scholars covering Europe covered Americas? WTF does that even mean, “precludes seriously relating to”?? -mh] the many well-documented Indigenous histories of psychedelics, [far back as 100 years!]

Another Plug for non-drug entheogens, As Ever, by Fake, Posturing Academics

ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state

Shar con’t, in writing:

“as well as a sort of functional fixedness that
prevents
seeing contemporary psychedelic practice in continuity with other, and maybe even older, non-pharmacological methods of changing consciousness.”

[Shar args: If you are a dog, pursuing evidence that is known to certainly be a mirage, then you cannot perceive current psychedelics use “in continuity with” older, original, non-drug methods of entering the psychedelic state. -mh]

Shardog the female dog of a scholar, doggedly continues in her evidentiary mirage hallucinating non-drug psychedelics in religious history:

I conclude that, given how
the psychedelic hypothesis is fundamentally flawed in its study of antiquity, it is a shaky foundation on which to build an argument for modern psychedelic use for therapeutic and spiritual practice.

Her Paper Was Rejected Again

I also report on the multi-year history of
the rejection of the manuscript on which this talk is based
as it is emblematic of
the way
popular audiences and scholars fail to communicate around psychedelic history and culture,
even as psychedelic bioscience scholarship is at the centre of today’s social mainstreaming.”

[by “communicate” she means, scholars – of her persuasion – to pop audience? 1-way?]

Psychedelic Bioscience Scholarship (ie, psychedelic pseudo science founded on ultra-narrowing, Popular Neo-Advaita)

[translation: psychedelic pseudo science, using Leary’s psychometrics q’airs, with Popular Neo-Advaita — extremely eliminative narrowing of what’s “real mysticism” — baked-in as the “science foundation”]

/ end of Shar Mos’s written summary of the talk

[How is the psychedelic [mysteries] hypothesis “fundamentally flawed in its study of antiquity” – fundamentally flawed, in what sense? See her mystery article. -mh]

Self-Contradictory Flip-Flop: “Euro Entheogen Scholarship is False and Foolish, but I’m Not Saying Euro Entheogen Scholarship Is False and Foolish”

Self-contradictory, Mosur’s article Abstract saying you’re not allowed to do entheogen scholarship other than centered around and limited to Indig Shams, because there is no evidence (of any kind) for any other psychedelics history – she backpedals and contradicts that in her talk.

She bluffs as if we “misheard” her Abstract, her demonization and ridiculing of entheogen scholarship except for on Indigenous Shams.

You can tell, from her defense in her talk: entheogen scholars hate her article, and called her on her “absence of evidence is evidence of absence” fallacy. The old flip flop, I’ve seen it before, in Andy Letcher, see my review of Shroom:

“We don’t know entheogen history for a fact.”
<- flip/flop->
“We know for certain it wasn’t drugs.”

“ONLY IF WE LOOK CLOSELY DO WE FIND SOMETHING DIFFERENT”
– That’s an important pattern, eg Mosur wrote (in the Abstract of the 2025 article Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience, copied into the conference schedule):

“My talk is about: You must not do research in Euro history of psychedelics in Euro religious history, else guilty of Colonialist Violence;

“you are only permitted to focus on Indig Shams and make that your boundary of thought.

I suspect she’d ok Jewish , just not Xn — she, like John Lash, is trying to prohibit Xn history (specifically Mr. Jesus; Mr. Moses, Mr. Paul) from having psychedelics.

But in her actual talk [= more detail, more precise], Mosur. defensively backtracks from that f*cking obnoxious, outrageous dictate.

Every entheogen scholar hates her crummy, namecalling, insulting article.

She can’t retract the wording on the conf sched b/c its a copy of the article’s Abstract, which she can’t change.

She ATTACKS and INSULTS the entire field of entheogen scholarship, and I can tell that other entheogen scholars were as offended as me.

She tries to tell the same self-assured narrative in her talk, but, she’s intensely defensive, and denies smearing the entire entheogen scholarship field.

I have sound criticisms of entheogen scholarship and its contradictions.

The journals wouldn’t publish her article: neither the Journal of Psychedelic Studies​ (I’m guessing), nor a Religious Studies journal.

Mosurinjohn = authoritarian dictator, projection, colonialist-type violence, bossing around ppl in the field for which she hasn’t read the basic articles, and entered 5 minutes ago.

She wrote a hundred articles over decades, and a week ago comes into entheogen scholarship for the first time, immediately throwing punches, strutting around, dictating “you can’t study entheogens in Euro history, b/c you are a Colonialist Violence against Indig Shams by not making your world revolve around alien Shams.”

Giving vague recommendations: Instead of looking for which plant, based on your phenomenology experience effects, you should instead [academic bafflegab] … attend to the “spiritual work”.

Her recomm for how to conduct entheogen scholarship is pretty empty of meaning; escapes into POSTURING AND ABSTRACTION.

Reactionary Against Newbie Bully Sharday Mosurinjohn Dictating What We Are Permitted to Study

Correct reaction against Mosur:

F*CK INDIGENOUS SHAMS (Mexico psilocybin; Amazon Aya), THEY ARE LOWER, CRUDE RELIGION; EURO HISTORY IS HIGHER, PROPER Transcendent Knowledge.

INDIG SHAMS HISTORY IS WORTHLESS; EURO ENTHEOGEN HISTORY IS WHAT IS WORTHWHILE TO STUDY.

p. 389 Baier: “For him [Frits Staal] South Asiatic mystic religions are not irrational but quite rational explorations of mystical experience that foreshadow a holistic scientific psychology”

Like saying “Popular Neo-Advaita is bunk, insane, and irrational, but Ken Wilber’s ultra sophisticated Advaita is REAL Advaita; Popular Neo-Advaita doesn’t count”.

I reject that. What ruined psychedelic science is mostly Popular Neo-Advaita: “You must stop thinking; cease constructing the self-other boundary; that’s what Transcendent Knowledge is all about.”

Transcendent Knowledge is actually all about, centrally, the process of mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism (ie to integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking).

The pop, avoidance tactic is take fav 1% of mystical experience (positive unitive), and declare that to be the entirety of mystical experience thus rejecting and discarding 99% of mystical experience.

The all-dominant model of mystical experience (positive unitive model) is so wrong, to this extent: it’s a model selectively based on just 1% of a thing, pretending to be the entire thing. The result is not merely “wrong emphasis”; the result is entirely false, wrong, misrepresentative FUNDAMENTALLY.

Mystical experience is NOT about positive unitive; actually, mystical experience is about eternalism-driven control-transformation.

I refuse to grant any high, ultimate, central focus to “positive unitive realization”, when ALL the action is re: the eternalism-driven control-transformation process.

The positive unitive model is nothing but an avoidance tactic and popular sales.

re: Reactionary against Indig Shams propaganda, see:

Mosur Elevates Presupposed Non-Drug Methods of the Mystics “can/ could/ might/may” Produce Psychedelic Effects, As Every Academic Does

To absolute hell with “fasting, breathing, sens dep” – this is sheer agenda-driven posturing and buttheadedness; ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

My challenge: PLEASE DEMONSTRATE how other methods work to “can/ could/ might/ may” produce the same effect as psychedelics.

Starving = 10 g of Cubensis? Sheer bull sh!t & self-righteous posturing. A tired, cliche argument, very worn out.

Ruck’s symbolic-only entheogens; Hanegraaff’s non-drug entheogens.

The left statue is modern, AI gen’d? Fails to fit classical style:

https://media.licdn.com/dms/image/v2/D5622AQE7F_yNnZ5JXw/feedshare-shrink_1280/B56Ziepa.NG4Ak-/0/1755008316079?e=2147483647&v=beta&t=OsVF3I503xqWjikQBKQbdQyIFT_qTkNuRDC2uxpAr2s

Henry Winslow’s Motte & Bailey Sleazy Strategy: “There’s No Evidence” = “Been Debunked”

After I showed the fallacious arg’n in
Foraging for Psychedelic Mushrooms in the Wrong Forest: The Great Canterbury Psalter as a Medieval Test Case (Ronald Huggins, 2024) https://www.academia.edu/118659519/Foraging_for_Psychedelic_Mushrooms_in_the_Wrong_Forest_The_Great_Canterbury_Psalter_as_a_Medieval_Test_Case & https://egodeaththeory.org/2024/11/23/huggins-foraging-psychedelic-mushrooms-wrong-forest/ —

I have no respect for deniers of the entheogen theory of religion.

Their arguments are fallacious, and posturing to ingratiate themselves with the butthead committed skeptics in academia, who say chanting and watching drama is likely to produce mystery religion intense mystic altered state.

The ABD Apologists say that asserting that “the intense mystic altered state in mystery religion required psychedelics” is “unreasonable” and has “no evidence” and “debunked”.

What do you think of the articles by Samorini 1997, 1998, & Ruck 2001 “Conjuring Eden”? Oh, you haven’t read them – you only are aware of 1st-generation entheogen scholarship.

But you know “There is no evidence.”

Cheap reasoning, lazy scholarship. Establishment-compliant propaganda by professional academics – who retain their “competent scholar” status by their affiliation proclamations:

“I solemnly swear, I disavow Allegro’s theory, that psychedelics had a major role in European religious history. Please don’t kick me out of the club of competent scholars.”

The deniers propose intense mystic altered state through fasting. They say that’s a more sensible explanation than psychedelics. A really weak position, they have.

I’ll gladly bet on and commit to the entheogen hypothesis ANY DAY, just like I’m glad to own the Psilocybin hypothesis of what was the engine of the mystery religions, & mixed wine.

You can have your 3rd rate, Amanita single-drug fallacy.

And fasting to produce the full, transformative psychedelic effect – you can have that solution, and the hyperventilation method, while I’m stuck just owning Psilocybin as the explanation.

Henry Winslow really likes and repeats the very worst arg’n from Sharday Mosurinjohn.

It’s false “there’s no evidence”.

No evidence, for what, precisely?

Absense of evidence is not evidence of absense.

The post is rotten arg’n and POSTURING and bluffing; RHETORIC of the butthead ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/henrywins_what-do-joe-rogan-a-freshly-minted-neoshaman-activity-7361038406467948546-63ak —

Henry Winslow posted:

“What do Joe Rogan, a freshly minted neoshaman, and half the speakers at psychedelic conferences have in common?

“They all love telling people that the ancient Greeks’ rites of passage were psychedelic ceremonies.

“According to this popular theory, the secret sauce behind the legendary Eleusinian Mysteries was ergot-laced barley that sent initiates on revelatory, near-death-like psychedelic journeys. But is it even true?”

[is what true: how much evidence we have? whether psychedelics were used? do we know the fact of that? do we know for certain that Eleusis was NOT psychedelics? according to this sleazy wording, acts as if “yes, we know Eleusis was not psychedelics”.

Henry Winslow LAPS UP THE SWILL, BAD ARG’N (Motte & Bailey flip-flop of exactly what’s being asserted], SHARDAY DISHES OUT.]

—

“Researchers from Queen’s University think not. [YOU MEAN, THEY POSTURE AGAINST ENTHEOGEN SCHOLARSHIP, TO INGRATIATE ESTABLISHMENT. THEY DO NOT IN FACT SAY “WE KNOW KYKEON WANS’T PSYCHEDELICS”]

WORLD’S SLEAZIEST WRITING (Sheer Propaganda): “a thorough takedown of the whole theory”

There’s pushback in comments, even glad to see accusation of Henry Winslow’s camp “posturing”.

Note the weasel wording: “a takedown”.

Henry Winslow didn’t say “proved kykeon wasn’t psychedelics”. He vaguely said “a takedown” of “the theory” — which theory, precisely?

This is a con artist shell game via vague, elastic use of language. This is rhetoric, posturing, propaganda:

“So they just dropped a thorough takedown of the whole theory in the journal Psychedelic Medicine. “

What does “dismantle” mean? This is not precise determinate language!

That style of writing is highly suspect; internet flame war mode, not factual debate. “Destroyed by facts and logic!“

“Drs. Sharday Mosurinjohn (whom I interviewed in April) and Richard Ascough systematically dismantle what they call “the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis,” pointing out there’s zero archaeological evidence for psychedelics at Eleusis. “

Sharday markets herself as “Proving no psychedelics in Euro history”, but when pinned down, she claims “I’m merely pointing out that it’s a hypothesis, not proved.”

Letcher/Mosurinjohn: “We Don’t Have Evidence” = “We Know Entheogen Scholarship Is False”

“Absence of Evidence Is Evidence of Absence.”

Sharday’s arg’n paraphrased; posturing, Motte and Bailey, flip-flop, moving the goalposts arg’n:

  • “I totally disproved the psychedelic hypothesis, we now know psychedelics did not have a major role in religious history.
  • My point is, the entheogen theory of religion is not proved, but a hypothesis.
  • How can ppl be so stupid as to assert what we definitely know to be false.
  • I disproved psychedelics’ role in religious history.
  • I’m merely cautioning you scholars [after having entered the field 5 minutes ago, and seeing self-promotional opportunities in this field] we must differentiate hypothesis vs. proved fact.
  • Thus I have proved, no psychedelics in European history.

Henry Winslow continues his Motte and Bailey fallacious arg’n game:

“They say proponents are presenting speculation as fact, and the entire narrative is built on shaky foundations and circular reasoning.”

[these are typical, weak, ineffectual objections, as discussed in Phil & Hist o Sci -mh]

“So why does the myth persist?”

This is fallacious and vague writing, “the myth”. Vague.

What aspect of the hypothetis is “the myth”, here?

Are you claiming that we know for a fact, ppl at Eleusis tripped out without using psychedelics?

Henry Winslow SOUNDS like he’s claiming that, when he says, with Sharday, “Why does the myth persist?”

Didn’t sharday write same words? he interv’d her.

Henry Winslow con’t: [this is practically a quote from Sharday:]

“The authors argue it’s about legitimacy.

“People want to believe there’s a ‘respectable’ Western pedigree for psychedelics with our European ancestors. “

Next, he repeats the arg, “European not allowed to have entheogen history; scholars must worship Indig Shams else guilty of Colonial Violence”:

Henry Winslow con’t:

“Never mind that there are plenty of Indigenous lineages around the world that have preserved psychedelic wisdom for millennia.

“If we need history’s stamp of approval to justify research and policy reform today (we don’t), surely that’s enough.”

Who says our goal is “to justify research and policy reform”? That’s part of it, but “YOU ARE WRONG AND UNETHICAL TO LOOK FOR PSYCHEDELICS IN EUROPEAN HISTORY” – STFU

ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

Sharday’s Proclamation of What’s Good and Bad

Sharday Mosurinjohn. 2023 article, June 2025 article.

Begs for a Parody Article inverting her bad logic especially her super-bad logic in her summary of her 10-min talk at Jewish Harvard Law.

Haven’t figured out where the Jewish comes in, why the conference (not advertised as Jewish) has the video talks (including Christian) at the Jewish YouTube channel.

She args:

Good: Focusing on history of Indigenous Shams.

citation: Alan Houot 2019 masters thesis: shamans good, have full control on psilocybin; mystics bad; pursue loss of control & surrenderism. He strangely omitted this topic/argument from the 2025 book Rise of the Psychonaut.

Good: Focusing on history of entheogens in Jewish history (not directly asserted, but implied on some adjacent talks at the conf).

Bad: Focusing on Western, Christian history of entheogens, = colonialist violence, because fails to put the central focus on Indig Shams.

“IT’S AN EVIDENCED FACT THAT SHAMS HAVE LONG HISTORY OF LOFTY WISE SPIRITUAL RELIGIOUS USE OF PSILOCYBIN”

Sharday must be ignorant and uninformed of Safford’s authoritative 1915 article finding that there’s no psilocybin was used in Central America, but only peyote.
https://egodeaththeory.org/2024/12/12/aztec-narcotic-safford-1915/

cit: Jan Irvin’s 2022 book God’s Flesh: Teonanacátl: The True History of the Sacred Mushroom, August 2, 2022 https://www.amazon.com/Gods-Flesh-Teonanac%C3%A1tl-History-Mushroom/dp/0982556225/ & https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/03/27/gods-flesh-teonanacatl-the-true-history-of-the-sacred-mushroom-irvin-2022/

“IT’S AN ESTABLISHED SCHOLARLY FACT THAT GRECO-Christianity HAS NO EVIDENCE OF A HISTORY OF LOFTY WISE SPIRITUAL RELIGIOUS USE OF ENTHEOGENS”

SHAMS: ALL YOUR ENTHEOGEN ARE BELONG TO US.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_your_base_are_belong_to_us

Her article is cliche stereotypical anti-Christian.

Hatsis book Psychedelic Injustice.

f156 Spain: Dogged Pursuit of Deer with Branching Antlers

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“f156 Spain.jpg” 235 KB Dec. 28, 2024 7:01 pm
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f156.item.zoom
Crop by Michael Hoffman
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f156.item.zoom
Fullscreen zoom WordPress image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/f156-center.jpg

Features:

  • guy near cloud: {fingers only vs. fingers & thumb} motif;
    L hand: IY;
    R hand: non-branching index finger, no thumb.
  • table leg touches {stable column base}.
  • harpist looks wrong: should not show both thumbs.
  • Branching antlers of deer nearly touch the L, branching side of {YI tree}.
  • Hunting dogs to kill the deer are touching the {cut right trunk}.
  • Nose of dog touch tail of deer.
  • {cut right trunk} touch L leg of dog. {cut left arm} motif.
  • Tree branching morph’y: bottom up as always: YI w/ {cut right trunk}; I-trident-I (L ‘I’ is {cut left branch}; R ‘I’ like a mushroom); trident.
  • Probably drawn by Eadwine, painted by Spain.
  • Eadwine probably would’ve painted as a mushroom tree.
  • Eadwine would’ve painted R foot forward, not L foot forward; the kneel stance.
  • {stable column} motif indicates probably drawn by Eadwine, painted by Spain.
  • Compare water through chute/frame, vs. f177’s dross chute to hellmouth.
  • Rescued guy’s YI hands above the mushroom dining sacred meal table.

{stable column base}
scb

Mythic Image: Bull Dragged Sees Snake Next to Trunk of Tree

Snake is far from branching, near ground.

Compare the reversible tauroctony: front: top: bull carried away looks in terror at snake at trunk of tree.

Dogs; Liberty Cap Roofs
https://www.kornbluthphoto.com/images/BernwardColumn_76.jpg
https://www.kornbluthphoto.com/BernwardColumn.html

Video: Between Sacred & Profane: Psychedelic Culture, Drug Spiritualities, and Contemporary America (Greer, Davis)

Video title:
Between Sacred & Profane: Psychedelic Culture, Drug Spiritualities, and Contemporary America
June 2, 2021
https://cswr.hds.harvard.edu/news/2021/06/02/video-between-sacred-profane-psychedelic-culture-drug-spiritualites-and-contemporary
Desc:

I need a topic classification, eg:

  • entheogen scholarship – extent of psychedelics in religious history; “the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis” (Ascough).
  • theory of psychedelic mental model transformation – the Egodeath theory: STEM-expressed positive, can-do explanatory model; Loose Cognitive Science; the {gate} requirement to enter the experiential space: stand on right foot; know eternalism-thinking as well as possibilism-thinking. Know that more wisdom = more control instability; to soar upward is to go unstable and fall down, thus forming a boundary limit, regardless of insane Pop Advaitababble about “all boundaries are unreal”, “your mind is an illusion”, “everything is illusion” – unhelpful, irrelevant, exact opposite of STEM and development progress.
  • Philosophy of Mystical experience (totally taken over by the positive unitive model of “mystical experience”; Popular Neo-Advaita).

“As part of the “Psychedelics and the Future of Religion” series, Dr. J. Christian Greer hosted a discussion panel with Dr. Erik Davis and Dr. Gary Laderman, focusing on the intersection of:

  • psychedelic culture
  • sacred drugs
  • the modern American zeitgeist
  • spiritualities centered on psychoactive substances
  • the material culture of psychedelia
  • the potential role humanities scholars could play in the current wave of clinical research on psychedelics“

Greer Video with Richard Miller

https://www.mindbodyhealthpolitics.org/p/the-past-and-present-of-psychedelic

Greer: Video, 2022, Richard Miller

LSA testimony: Ego Death from Morning Glory, 400 seeds, Heavenly Blue, experienced Ego Death, at 12:30.
https://www.mindbodyhealthpolitics.org/p/the-past-and-present-of-psychedelic?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&timestamp=866.4

I don’t go for, much, current events; current Pop Sike, and 20th C popular psychedelic spirituality. I shun popular writing like that.

In such a Pop Sike Cult book, I pick out & extract my topics:

  • entheogen scholarship; psychedelics in religious history
  • theory of mystical experience (“Philosophy of mysticism”)
  • psychedelic science; Learyan psychometrics questionnaires
  • STEM explanatory model of mental model transformation, from possibilism to eternalism; Loose Cognitive Science.
  • myth, mythic art, and analogies
    • the ahistoricity of religious founder figures
    • astral ascent mysticism
    • eg my correction of Hanegraaff and everyone who says “the 7 spheres of the visible cosmos, then leave cosmos and arrive at the Ogdoad/Ennead, which is outside the cosmos” — as if there are not 4000 stars but only 5 or 7. A few paragraphs later, safely separated, they say, contradicting: “8th sphere contains evil zodiac; avoid it”. “OGDOAD GOOD; 8TH SPHERE EVIL” (obv. they are the same thing).
    • Tauroctony interp per David Ulansey.
    • the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}

Ogdoad good; 8th sphere bad.

Wouter “Star Destroyer” Hanegraaff

Richard Miller’s book Psychedelic Wisdom sounds like folly [joke]
https://www.amazon.com/Psychedelic-Wisdom-Astonishing-Mind-Altering-Substances/dp/1644115433/ —

https://www.mindbodyhealthpolitics.org/p/the-past-and-present-of-psychedelic – desc:

About “Psychedelic Wisdom” Series

“Welcome back to Psychedelic Wisdom https://www.mindbodyhealthpolitics.org/s/psychedelic-wisdom – a Mind Body Health & Politics production.

“This publication features insights gleaned from thousands of psychedelic experiences of healing, creativity, connection, and consciousness expansion.

“I invite you to become a monthly subscriber or, if your budget allows it, a founding member.

“As a member of our tribe, your financial support will help sustain my team as we continue to provide bold, unabashed interviews on topics that require careful handling.

con’t:

Greer

con’t from above webpage about a video with Richard Miller & Xn Greer

[SAY EVERY WORD AT THE SAME VOLUME. 1 out of 10 words, Greer whispers:

“BEAR WAS THE SOUND ENGINEER

[whispered: for the grateful d..]

As a member of the WELL, I was in the Dead/Internet before the Web; I was one of the first couple people to announce the Web on the WELL. -mh]

“This week I have the privilege of bringing to you an academic researcher – Dr. J. Christian Greer – a scholar of religious studies, specializing in the global history of psychedelic spirituality.

“Several of Christian’s findings threaten to overturn a number of sacred cows in both academia and organized religion, but his diligent scholarly approach has led him to his current lecturing position at Stanford in the American studies department, where he can freely explore his controversial thesis regarding the prominence of psychedelics in modern American spirituality.

“We discuss this thesis with reference to bands like the Grateful Dead, charismatic figures like Timothy Leary, and authors like Aldous Huxley, along with the ancient history of psychedelics and the handful historians who have been brave enough to study it.

Christian [Greer] asks me [Richard Miller] whether I think the current renaissance in psychedelic research taking place is a sign of greater things to come, or represents a brief island of sanity before resumption of the long Dark Age I’ve lived under for more than 50 years.

[but “the current renaissance in psychedelic research”, which suicided in 2025 w/ Religious Leaders Study conflicts-of-interest fiasco, and self-destruction of the Hopkins inner circle team — is premised 100% on Popular Neo-Advaita, the positive unitive model of “mystical experience” – an extremely narrowed, exclusionary, narrowing, thus reductionist model -mh]

You can listen to the entire interview free of charge, or read the transcript for subscribers only below:”

Contradictory Writing – Best Bad Quotes & Backtracking & Shifting the Claim

Animation of the Motte-and-Bailey Fallacy

A copy of this section is in my Sharday Mosurinjohn page (“Invention of Religious Experience”) and in my Ascough page.

Video: What is the difference between science and pseudoscience? (Strange Loop, Dec. 2025)

Video title:
What is the difference between science and pseudoscience?
Dec. 4, 2025
YouTube Channel: The Strange Loop
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTpxICN-O1U&t=442s [7:22]

  • Animation of the motte-and-bailey fallacy at 7:22:
    Aggressive, bailey position: “Your mind controls reality.”
    Feeble, motte position: “How you think can have some effect on what happens.”
  • There’s no hard line between Science vs. Pseudoscience.
  • Summarizes the book about how after cold war, Physics was defunded, then Marketed by Woo scientists successfully:

How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival
David Kaiser, 2011
https://www.amazon.com/How-Hippies-Saved-Physics-Counterculture/dp/0393076369/

I sent someone a capture of an animation of animation of the Motte and Bailey fallacy. (Found it; above.)

Nice town hard defend –> Bad building easy defend

More powerful a term than “move goalposts”: you move them in, then out, then in; wide, narrow

Now we can employ both fallacies variants

move goalpost

the motte-and-bailey fallacy

Nice town hard to defend <–> Bad building easy to defend

What does Sharday do; which is which?

  • Sharday’s feeble motte position: “Maybe there were no psychedelics in mystery religions.”
  • Sharday’s aggressive bailey position: “There definitely were no psychedelics in mystery religions.”

Do not look for psychedelics in Western history.

You must make Indigenous Shams the central focus of your scholarship, and the boundary limit of your research.

How dare you, Shard and Cough, dictate in your Invention Abstract what we may or may not study, or must study or else colonial violence GTFO fake scholar, biased AF, shamelessly brazenly biased Shard & Cough. We entheogen scholars who MADE the field of Indigenous Shams, will study whatever the f*ck we want – F off, interloper, interfering, the outsider’s outsider.

Mosurinjohn & Ascough Are Guilty of Colonialist Violence because they Fail to Make Euro Psychedelics the Center of their Historical Research

They Must Not Study Indigenous Shams, because I Am the Declarer of the Correct Topics to Research

Shard and Cough are a laughingstock, look at her backpedal, DOES THEY NOW WANT WISH TO CHANGE THEIR RUDE IGNORANT UNPROFESSIONAL SMEAR-PHRASES IN THEIR ABSTRACT?

My god is the body of the article – read it 4th time – filled with gold nuggets of badness like the Abstract

Amateur outsider hacks, namecalling, bully argumentation. Hey Shard and Ascough you have to study what I tell you to, blundering disproved Pop Scholars.

Flip around all the badness.

The Egodeath theory Is the Correct Dictator of What People May and May Not Research

It’s good of Mosurinjohn and Ascough in their invention abstract to declare they are the dictators of entheogen scholarship

they mistake tho

the Egodeath theory is the dictator of entheogen scholarship

You must not study Indigenous Shams.

Mos & Cough: Per the Egodeath theory’s wise and correct, superior judgment, you and other scholars must not study Indigenous Shams. You must study only Western psychedelics history.

psychedelics myth demote history

the Egodeath theory is a history-free theory of myth and history of religion myth tripping

First get the the Mytheme theory right, global myth whatever era, all eras

global myth all eras

all regions

all eras

myth

psychedelics in myth i was glad to find ruck greek myth textbook but it miss heros, MONSTERS

Ruck’s Myth Textbook Suppresses Monsters

pushing positive unitive model – does

Does the book Consc Ruck push positive unitive model the positive unitive model of “mystical experience” like – it turned out recently, why i preorderd Wm Richards bk but it was nothing- is it the positive unitive model of “mystical experience”? How much?

How heavily d

How much do I dislike……it’s invis neutral book, made no impression at all, no takeaway at all

Sacred Knowledge

Wm Richards

~2016

like as much as ZZZ

Why am i as unimpressed by Richards as by Badiner? Allan ZZZ

in diff’t ways

like food gods, i hate how it takes as given, no psychedelics in relig origins … myth is my strong point.

history psychedelics myth

the history of myth

history of psychedelic myth

Sometimes i like history perspec.

dislike “history” usu

theory good

history bad

weed out history from the Egodeath theory

Brazenly Biased Shard & Ascough Dictate What We Must and Must Not Study, but the Egodeath theory Is the Correct Dictator of That: No More Indigenous Shams Research; You Must Study only Western Psychedelics History

Ascough and Mosurinjohn must submit to the authority of the Egodeath theory and must not study Indig Shams and must devote all their research to European psychedelics history.

Ascough and Mosurinjohn Must Not Study Indigenous Shams, and Must Devote All Their Research to Western Psychedelics History

Tip: You gotta want it, to find “evidence”, and data is theory bound

Tip: The Egodeath theory is the correct interpretive/ explanatory framework for the data and evidence, to generate the evidence and data that successfully supports the theory. The two legs work together: the best psychedelic myth proves the egodeath core theory

YOUR THEORY IS GARBAGE, BLUNDERING ASCOUGH AND MOSURINJOHN, Pop Scholars. Xn Greer writes Pop Esotericism for a popular audience. He ought to listen to the authorities: the Egodeath theory the Egodeath community secret hiden suppressed group that has the Secret Amanita Gnosis

On the mythic plane where is Amanita the super psychedelic, the master ultimate psychedelic like Rutajit book says: step aside 5MeO here comes Amanita:

The cybernetic theory supports the Mytheme theory,
the Mytheme theory supports the cybernetic theory.

psychedelic cybernetic eternalism analogy

the two fit:

psychedelic cybernetic eternalism

psychedelic analogy [not ‘myth’?] myth functions as analogy describing / for referent domain item {myth m}.

The Analogies chapter in Creating Scientific Concepts.

The Mytheme theory proves the Egodeath theory core theory, and
the Egodeath theory core theory proves the the Mytheme theory.

ALL YOUR RESEARCH ARE BELONG TO US.

Obnoxious Phrases in the Abstract or Schedule, of “Psychedelics, Eleusis, & the Invention of religious experience

I do a lot of internal correction of the field of foo.

keyboard shortcut

psychedelic science with psychometrics questionnaires – the name of a distinct field of debate articles; my page Moving Past Mysticism in Psychedelic Science

psychedelic science with psychometrics questionnaires
pspq

psychometric drugs

a psychometric trip

psychedelic science with psychometrics questionnaires

vs.

entheogen scholarship – insider tech term

whats that about?

psychedelics

religion

ancient

the “ancient psychedelic religion” theory
aprt

that’s my equiv of Ascough term:

the psychedelic mysteries hypothesis

long ago

field This is the era of internal correction of the field of foo

foo =

  • psychedelics in religious mythology
  • the history of psychedelics in religious mythology
  • entheogen scholarship – obscure, opaque, dark term: no one has ever heard the term ‘entheogen’. wtf is “scholarship” could be anything. u have to b expert in this field like me to decode WTF is intended… the bad term assumes that you already know:
  • ‘entheogen’
  • scholarship on WTF precisely could be anything

The Term ‘Entheogen Scholarship’ a poor description of the field

Slip n slide the domain of contention.

I already analyzed in detail connots of … least talked is psychotomimetic, WAY more accurate than totally wrong term ‘hallucinogen’

Must say psychedelic in the…. but name of the field but ….

entheogen scholarship is a good term sometimes, for insider writing

‘entheogen scholarship’ a very insider term – doesn’t mean “never use it!” I work hard to at least have available alien external lexicon:

the Egodeath theory is like

  • ego dissolution
  • in the DMN
  • of Popular Neo-Advaita
  • positive unitive model
  • the positive unitive model of “mystical experience” – SIMPLY TRASHCAN ALL OF YOUR THINKING, GET RID OF THE SELF-OTHER BOUNDARY: THAT’S SUPER PROFOUND TYPE OF Transcendent Knowledge – eliminate thinking and the mind and the world, …. THIS IS SHEER DEGENERATE REGRESSION this direction of Popular Neo-Advaita caricature revel in bad ways of shirking proper correct use of lang. Enthusiastic obfuscation and revelling in … even STace calls it or Pahnke calls it ALLEGED “ineffabilty”.

entheogen scholarship -thta’s that’s a more abstract term than descriptive term:

psychedelics history of mythology

the psychedelic history of mythology

the history of psychedelics in religious mythology

January 21, 2026: grid cap = multiple = branching; pages of book = multiple = branching; fingers often touch pages of book (side of book); thumb is against open page. in Great Canterbury Psalter.
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f109.item.zoom

Angel feathers are YI; a single feather is sep. from the rest. f109. God’s R hand touches the “thumb” (sep. feather) of angel L wing.

Motivation for this Page

I’ve been activated by Mosur’s atrocious, intensely offensive written desc of her talk.

Hu’s interview of them shows indoctrination in realtime; Ascough prevents Mosur from affirming entheogen scholarship.

Need transcription of the actual talk [done], to see in what way she vigorously backpedals during her talk.

What exactly are her positive recommendations for entheogen scholarship? Do they amount to anything of substance? No, or barely anything. She says focus on psychedelic transformation process, not just an isolated psychedelic session.

The Egodeath theory does not look for psychedelics (in isolation) in history of religious myth; the Egodeath theory looks for analogies of mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism, from a series of 10 psilocybin sessions.

Status of this Webpage

12:48 p.m. January 21, 2026 — This page is very good now.

At the start of the video “Psychedelics, and the Birth”, Ascough disparages athiests for being condescending and insulting; he’s an atheist.

I now think much of the condescending tone in the article’s Abstract, and in Schedule, is from the SMUGLY SELF-ASSURED AND CONDESCENDING (& ignorant) atheist Ascough. He’s not in the field of entheogen scholarship.

Ascough’s Credibility Level: “synthesizing the ergot from mushrooms into an LSD type of substance”

Ascough is just another cheap lazy careless fly-by “demolishing” of entheogen scholarship by yet another outsider with no credibility, who talks (Birth video) of “ergot from mushrooms” nonsense:

The idea of of synthesizing the ergot from mushrooms into an LSD type of substance, there’s just very weak basi– you know we can do it now, in highly technical labs, but could priests do it back then? Not saying they couldn’t, but I’m saying where’s– it’s conjecture, but it has to be proven.

48:21, Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity, [48:21] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2901s

Video title:
Psychedelics, and the Birth of Christianity – Dr. Richard Ascough
Dec 25, 2024
Channel: Ayush Prakash
Ayush Prakash Podcast
This is episode 111.
Richard S. Ascough is Professor of Religion Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.
The topic of psychedelics starts at 44:30:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8GcCjja74M&t=2670s [44:30]

At least Letcher wrote a book, can’t call him lazy except he got 1 image from Stamets and neglected to read any other art evidence.

Mosur should break away from Ascough’s mental cell.

I titled this page “Mosurinjohn” not “Ascough”, because the motivation for creating this page is her video, specifically for me:

To compare her transcript vs. her description of the talk in the conf Schedule.

That description is 95% same as her & Ascough’s paper’s Abstract.

  • contains transcription of her 10-minute talk, which is a summary of her article, that finally got pub’d July 2025:
    Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience
  • Contains her written summary of her talk – and of her paper – from the conf schedule.

I’ve only read her article with Ascough 3 times; need 4th, now.

Now after I threw together this page, I’m ready to re-read my two printouts of her article, which is same as her talk and her summary of the talk, including self contradictions.

She makes several points including “study non-drug psychedelics”.

I consistently get the feeling that little is contributed by Mosur., but, need to read the article more.

Need to convert her academic wind into an executive summary list of takeaways.

See Also

Earlier, Aug. 2025 page I forgot about:
Psychedelics, Eleusis, and the Invention of Religious Experience (Mosurinjohn & Ascough, 2025)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/08/psychedelics-eleusis-and-the-invention-of-religious-experience-mosurinjohn-ascough-2025/

https://cyberdisciple.wordpress.com/site-map/ –

  • Classicist.
  • Psychedelics in Western religious history.
  • The Egodeath theory.
    • Eternalism-driven control-transformation.
    • Analogical psychedelic eternalism with 2-level, dependent control.
    • The Mytheme theory.

https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/

⚰️ Canterbury f107: Lifted from Ossuary by Right Arm

Michael Hoffman, 2:27 p.m. January 16, 2026

Crop by Michael Hoffman
fullscreen

Contents:

The Full Image f107

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107.jpg” 899 KB [9:30 a.m. April 4, 2023]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
Fullscreen WordPress image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/canterbury-f107.jpg

Non-Branching Thumb Over Open Scroll

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-thumb-over-open-scroll.jpg” 478 KB, 11:26 p.m. Feb. 7, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen, details

Angel’s Non-Branching Thumb Over Open Book

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-angel-thumb-over-open-book.jpg” 437 KB, 11:27 p.m. Feb. 7, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen, details

Guy’s Non-Branching Thumb Over Open Book

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-guy-thumb-over-open-book.jpg” 445 KB, 11:29 p.m. Feb. 7, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen, details

Phases of Work on this Webpage

  1. done: Create webpage, with the picture and sketch of features list / headings.
  2. done: Analyze full image, brainstorm on all aspects.
  3. todo: Clean up webpage:
  4. Move out unrelated idea development.
  5. Create & add more crops.

Mushroom-Trees with 3-7 Caps

How many mushroom-trees in Great Canterbury Psalter have 4 caps/crowns, like fingers? f177?

5 caps would work if one ~= thumb. eg:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/25/f109-great-canterbury-psalter-hellmouth-net-ossuary-cloth-looking-out-from-temple/

not hand-like: 5 caps + {cut right trunk} = thumb
https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/03/17/canterbury-f145-king-orders-shipments-of-blue-fruit-to-storage-lockboxes-with-blue-stemmed-mushroom-tree/
7 caps:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/03/12/4-horses-mushroom-tree-right-foot-balancing-great-canterbury-psalter-f177/

Guy in fire no left arm, YI hand reaching toward Christ, implies leaving fire via ossuary. Ossuary guy has cloak, = improved mental world model; improved personal control system.

11:24 a.m. January 19, 2026 — there are 4 caps of mushroom-tree and there are 4 fingers; caps = fingers. cut branch = thumb.

todo: crop rightmost 1/8 of picture:
black key tree
mushroom-tree
guy touching mushroom-tree

todo: blurry image below; redo w/ correct capture sequence:~~

White Boxes on Guy’s Hands and Tree’s Hands

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“canterbury-f107-mushroom-tree-like-hands-boxes.jpg” 416KB, 8:26 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen / f107 crops

f107: Sleeping guy {fingers touch face}

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“f107-sleeping-man.jpg” 398 KB, 11:48 Feb. 3, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen

f107: Sleeping guy {fingers touch face}, Detail

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“f107-facepalm.jpg” 74 KB, 11:55 Feb. 3, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom

Summary: The Meaning of the Image and Genre

The message is:

Psilocybin mushrooms reveal purification by repeated immersion in the psychedelic state, harrowing, corrective demons fire, done cooking and transforming when made to make the YI sign w/ thumb & fingers.

Then rescued from experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control , when lose left arm & lose left leg, and receive thumb, along with fingers.

Elab’d:

Then rescued from experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control , when lose left arm & lose left leg (those = branching thinking​; possibilism-thinking) and receive thumb (non-branching; eternalism) along with fingers (branching; possibilism).

Receive ‘I’ along with ‘YI’;
Receive eternalism-thinking added to possibilism-thinking.

The psilocybin mushroom revelation of eternalism causes panic, dread, control instability;
control stability occurs after mental model transformation;
end up with integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking.

Revelation of:
eternalism — that is:
eternalism-thinking
analogical psychedelic eternalism
analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control
analogical psychedelic eternalism with 2-level, dependent control
analogical psychedelic eternalism thinking with 2-level, dependent control

instead of only knowing:
possibilism — that is:
possibilism-thinking
literalist ordinary-state possibilism
literalist ordinary-state possibilism with autonomous control
literalist ordinary-state possibilism with monolithic, autonomous control
literalist ordinary-state possibilism thinking with monolithic, autonomous control

End up with:

  • 2POV
  • two different points of view
  • two different mental models of possibility and control
  • qualified possibilism-thinking along with basic eternalism-thinking
  • integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking

f107 Proves Previous Hypothesis Reading Fingers and Thumb as Branching vs. Non-Branching

When did I first try to map possibilism & eternalism to hand / finger shapes? March 21, 2022, when emailing Jerry Brown re: Marcia Kupfer art historian re: “cuts the branches” in St Martin … maybe. That email made term “branching-message mushroom trees”, but did that email thread include figuring out finger shapes by Jesus on donkey? Same week probably.

3:39 p.m. January 19, 2026 – important: this picture PROVES my previous speculations about fingers and thumb.

This image clearly links on the right:
cut branch ~= thumb,
4 mushroom branches ~= fingers.

Other motifs in f107 that corroborate that:

  • Angel’s thumb against open book.
  • Sage’s thumb against open book.
  • Policeman’s thumb against open scroll touching God’s cloud; fingers not touching scroll.
  • God’s thumb touching God’s cloud; God’s fingers not touching God’s cloud.
  • Hellmouth fire pit guy making IY shape with thumb & fingers reaching to Christ via ossuary.

In the course of this decoding, 11 p.m. January 17, 2026, I analyzed (in max detail) dancing man: fingers touching head, came away with the same type of creativity:
3 fingers splayed touching L of forehead;
Index finger separate, touches R of forehead.
Has closed eyes, same as f107 sleep guy.

Bad Conjectures by ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs

Deniers of mushroom imagery in Christian art
dmica

ABD Apologists: Anything But Drugs is to be considered a “reasonable” and “evidenced” cause of the intense mystic altered state.

Clueless outsiders crying “no evidence” have zero chance of reading this picture.

1:40 p.m. January 19, 2026

Is the message “Jesus was a mushroom?”

Is the message “secret hidden suppressed heretical Amanita Gnosis”?

Keyboard shortcut can paste an image URL

[weird idea: a keyboard shortcut can’t paste a picture, but can paste a fullscreen picture’s URL 🤔] b/c I wish to quickly paste pictures:

Dec 2024 in WordPress gallery

A First: Keyboard Shortcut Containing an Image URL

Dionysus and Ariadne victory wedding procession mosaic https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/dionysusmosaichires-branch.jpg
d v p
[= Dionysus Victory Parade]

rebis holding a Y https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/y-held-by-rebis-1.jpg
rhy

Rebis Holding a Y

tests:

Dionysus and Ariadne victory wedding procession mosaic https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/dionysusmosaichires-branch.jpg

rebis holding a Y https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/y-held-by-rebis-1.jpg

Alan Houot talks about Engineering-type, technical UX progress toward Transcendent Knowledge – I do it. Invented the acronym in April 1987, on expansive, wide-ruled paper.

Not the case: you might speculate, as implied by naming:

  • Wide ruled = high school, to 12th grade.
  • College ruled = college. College freshman+.

But the official story is very different:

  • Wide ruled paper = grade school, but only through 4th grade.
  • College ruled is for upper grade school (5th grade) and after. ie, you are expected to have your hand writing dialed in by end of 4th grade, age 9. When turn 10, expect small excellent hand writing (5th grade) suitable for college hand writing.

In April 1987, I threw away 6″ x 8″ blank books with maybe college ruled, and did a fresh start (when father died), using binder filler paper Wide ruled.

That change of paper & binding hugely blew open the horizon, and I started explicitly, consciously, doing theory development for the first time.

I became a theorist of mental construct processing and STEM-expressed Transcendent Knowledge, in April 1987, by moving to Wide ruled paper; in start of binders series: around April 1987 through June 1987.

Then, having really gotten routine doing this theory devmt, I switched from Wide ruled binder sheets, to College-ruled binder sheets, keeping some expansiveness, but miniaturizing the lines.

I cannot just use College Ruled paper, now, to tap into that consciousness;
I must also use the pivotal key expansion: Wide Ruled binder sheets.

d a t v i r l [l = long]
“Daturas for the Virgin” by Ruck & Celdran, in Entheos 2, 2001
(no urls? non-fancy)

Non-Branching Dionysus and Branching Ariadne: Dionysus and Ariadne Victory Wedding

WordPress gallery April 30, 2022 – todo: crop with chariot visible
Dec 2020 in WordPress gallery
Crop desired: [not top pri]
Not leopard / bottom.
Not vines on top.
Not tiger 3 & 4.

Dionysus and Ariadne victory wedding procession mosaic https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/dionysusmosaichires-branch.jpg

Ariadne only has branching hand (fingers only).

Dion has branching hand (fingers only) and also has YI hand (thumb + fingers).

Dionysus is not exclusively eternalism-thinking; he integrates possibilism-thinking. 2POV.

Lower Y Hand : Upper YI Hand = Mushroom-Tree’s Lower Cut Trunks : Upper YI Branching

White Boxes on Hands and Tree-Hands (v3; Final)

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“canterbury-f107-mushroom-tree-like-hands-boxes.jpg” 416KB, 8:26 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen / f107 crops

hand = tree; {hand mushroom-tree}

The above {hand mushroom-tree} image is crisp; used the correct recapture sequence.

White Boxes on Hands and Tree-Hands (v2)

The below {hand mushroom-tree} image is blurry, don’t use:

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-mushroom-tree-like-hands.jpg” 115 KB [12:36 Noon January 19, 2026]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen of WordPress image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/canterbury-f107-mushroom-tree-like-hands.jpg

Top Row: YI Tree, Closed/Open Book, YI Tree

todo: crop: top row, 3 features:

  • left YI tree
  • middle: closed book on left, open book on right
  • right YI tree

thus: TAKEWAY KEY to help decode mushroom-tree:

closed book = branching (bad)
open book = non-branching (good)

Now apply that KEY to the mushroom-tree on bottom R, along with guy touching it:

the tree of the knowledge of branching (unstable control) vs. non-branching (stable control)

the tree of the knowledge of branching and non-branching

4 Color Boxes on Hands and Tree Hands (v1)

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-right-trees-guy-boxes-br-nb.jpg” 144 KB 11:46 a.m. January 19, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen WordPress pic:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/canterbury-f107-right-trees-guy-boxes-br-nb.jpg

compare black key tree (upper part of picture) to upper half of mushroom-tree:

  • black key tree: YI (3 stems) bracketed by cut L trunk & cut R trunk.
  • mushroom-tree upper half: there are 3 stems at first, bottom-up; bracketed by cut L branch & cut R branch.

His 4 fingers ~= 4 caps of mushroom-tree.
His thumb ~= the cut branch of mushroom-tree.

{hand showing fingers but not finger tips} = “branching, negated”.

Notation: Read “~=” as “is like” or “maps to”.

{thumb} : {cut branch} :: {4 fingers} : {4 branches}

11:56 a.m. January 19, 2026 — solved! decoded! in both trees, the count of cut branches, or cuts, or etc.: just like I found a mushroom-tree often has 4 protrusions, like 4 limbs – or here, 4 fingers.

mushroom-tree: 4 cut trunk at bottom, maps to his 4 fingers, or the 4 caps/crowns of the tree.

black key tree: 2 cut trunks & 2 branching leaves (Y on left)

mushroom-tree: 4 cut trunks, 4 caps/crowns; his 4 fingers. 2 visual cuts of 2 of the 4 branches/stems.

12:00 Noon January 19, 2026 – semi correction: below, bottom of mushroom-tree, is 4 cut trunks, maps to his lower hand showing 4 fingers visually bent/cut.

keyboard shortcut:
black key tree
bkt

mushroom-tree, upper half: each of the 3 branches that ends w/ cap/crown, has a cut:

from bottom up:

  • L branch has cut L branch.
  • M branch has visually cut stem, 1 cap.
  • R branch has visually cut stem of L branch.

Key to box colors:

  • bold red (main point) = branching; possibilism, of tree (matching fingers)
  • bold green (main point) = non-branching; eternalism, of tree (matching thumb)
  • light red = other instances of branching motif
  • light green = other instances of non-branching motif

View Fullscreen without Going to Library UI

Click to open image in new tab:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/canterbury-f107.jpg

THAT IS A GREAT FEATURE! APPLY EVERYWHERE:
JUMP PICTURE OUT OF WEBPAGE, WITHOUT FOLLOWING LINK TO LIBRARY.

My procedure to do that, in desktop browser:

  1. View the rendered webpage.
  2. Right-click the picture, and then select Copy image address. eg:
    https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/img_8885.jpg?w=1680
  3. In editing page, paste url without the ? suffix, eg:
    https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/img_8885.jpg

the diffc:

  • with suffix: reduces resolution to 1600 * 1318.
  • without suffix: full resolution; 2000 * 1570.

Features of f107

High-level overview.

  • Left Tree: YI Sun Light
  • Right Tree: YI Moon
  • Mushroom-Tree with Grid Caps
  • Hellmouth Demons
  • Open Scrolls
  • Cut Left Limb
  • The YI Hand Shape
  • Splayed Fingers Touching Face (Dancing Man, Golden: Jonah Gourd); row 1 R: Sleeping Sage has L hand showing fingers & thumb, R hand at forehead showing fingers, no thumb.
  • Lower-Level Guys Aware of Stood on by Upper-Level Guys
  • Boundary Between Lower and Upper Level
  • Ossuary Rescue
  • Closed Books on Left, Open Books on Right

todo: bulk create crops:

  • each row, each panel.
  • boxes/lines eg pairs of books, vertical pairs of figures.

Karl Baier Article High Mysticism p. 366: Features in f107, January 18, 2026

Great Canterbury Psalter f107

Notes and Photo: Michael Hoffman, 11:00 p.m. January 17, 2026.
Orig device metadata: 2.4 MB, 9 MP, 3548 x 2786 px.
WordPress metadata: img_8885.jpg, January 19, 2026, 1,004 KB, 2000 x 1570 px.

Fullscreen image: click:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/img_8885.jpg

I finish transcribing the notes (to the present page) from page 366/367 Baier article, about features of Canterbury Folio f107, 10:17 a.m. to 11:10 am, January 19, 2026.

Acronyms/ Keyboard Shortcuts/ Key Concepts

[PSM] & [ETM]
[PT] & [ET]
[LOP] & [APE]
[LOPAC] & [APEAC]
[MCAC] & [TLDC]
[LOPMAC] & [APE2DC]
[LOPTMAC] & [APET2DC]

Possibilism and Eternalism Are Cumulative, Not Mutually Exclusive, per Ken Wilber’s “Embrace and Include” the Earlier, Lower Developmental Structure

Since 2025 April/Aug 2POV breakthrough way of thinking and expressing, I fear to say “vs” as in, “possibilism vs. eternalism”.

Possibilism and Eternalism are not pitted against; mut exclusive.

possibilism-thinking and eternalism-thinking are not mutually exclusive. Gaining eternalism-thinking does not mean “get rid of possibilism-thinking” like insane Popular Neo-Advaita says.

Ken Wilber tries to distance from Popular Neo-Advaita, calling for more sophistication. This is No True Scotsman fallacy: “Real Advaita is not insanely deleting egoic structures.”

I don’t care about irrelevant, alleged postdoc University Academia Armchair Learned Sophisticated PHILOSOPHY THEORY of Advaita that has a buried footnote “Strictly speaking, ego is relatively real.”

That precision doesn’t matter. Shell game, move goalposts, bait & switch.

The only thing that matters is Popular Neo-Advaita, which is insanity and developmental ruin. The model of mystical experience that’s baked into psychedelic pseudo science is not “sophisticated nuanced real Advaita”; but rather, Popular Neo-Advaita in its simplified insanity:

  • you don’t exist
  • nothing is real
  • your mind doesn’t exist
  • nothing exists
  • lang is incapable
  • truth cannot be in words (functional self-contradictions L & R)
  • ineffable
  • apophatic
  • Transcendent Knowledge cannot be explained per STEM, clearly and explicitly.

In 1985-1987, I required a clear, rational, useful model of Transcendent Knowledge, articulated exactly same as any field explained per STEM fashion.

Frits Staal’s 1975 book Exploring Mysticism agrees with me: rejects the premise of “Transcendent Knowledge is non-rational” (in 4 religions, he lists). p. 390 of Baier article High Mysticism:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/#High-Mysticism —

Baier wrote: p. 390: “Staal accuses Learn and Alpert for having ceased to be rational explorers”

Baier quotes Staal there: “They seemed to have lost their rational mind, and founded instead a religious sect.” Staal p. 188.

“The academic research of mysticism is not even developed enough to provide a valid definition of mysticism”

Baier wrote: “According to him [Staal] at the present time [1975] the academic research of mysticism is not even developed enough to provide a valid definition of mysticism.”

Alan Houot in Rise of the Psychonaut says “be rational”. He thus implicitly rejects “Transcendent Knowledge is non-rational.”

Staal wrongly, like EVERYONE other than me, imagines that “mysticism” = the Unitive experience (he probably gives away that specifically, he imagines mysticism = positive unitive model.

Read the word choice loosely in such articles about mysticism & psychedelic mysticism. Notice every time the writer uses, for any purpose/point, words like: 3 groups of key words:

EXAMPLE 9:24 a.m. January 19, 2026 —
“ego dissolution” a la Dittrich OAV 1994: or the guy who in 1985 extracted the OAV dimensions from Dittrich’s 1975 v1 APZ questionnaire:
ego dissolution connotes what they are thinking, everyone who assumes mysticism = positive unitive model: “dissolution = separation != unitive”; You were supposed to have unitive experience, but instead, you had dissolution into multiplicity/ separation, so, bad trip.” Their off-based explanation.

  1. unitive (union, merging, oceanic)
  2. non unitive (separation, multiplicity, dissociation, angst)
  3. positive (bliss, pleasant, joy)
  • union
  • non separation
  • non multiplicity
  • boundary
  • encapsulated
  • merging
  • oceanic
  • bliss

also trace words that carry the paradigm “anti-rational”:

  • non-rational
  • irrational
  • ineffable
  • apophatic
  • words cannot explain

Quotes from Staal High Mysticism re: Rejecting the Anti-Rational Premise

“anti-scientific exoticism“: p. 389 top: Baier wrote that Staal is “not a naive adherent of the countercultural worldview and criticized a hippie-like anti-scientific exoticism.” Staal wrote: “Those who have had enough of science and rationality [eg anti-rational interps of QM] … look at exotic repositories of the irrational; the Oriental religions and cults seem to meet such a description very well. ONLY IF WE LOOK CLOSELY DO WE FIND SOMETHING DIFFERENT” …

Or find something self-contradictory, like Mosur’s article Abstract saying you’re not allowed to do entheogen scholarship other than centered around and limited to Indig Shams, because there is no evidence (of any kind) for any other psychedelics history – she backpedals and contradicts that in her talk.

QM, Hidden Variables

see interps of Quantum Mysticism other than Bohm’s hidden variables & superdetermism: my complaint is that these are gleeful anti-rationalists, who WANT physics to be irrational, and do not even TRY to find a way of “the particle has a position, we just are ignorant of what that position is”; they DESIRE the particle to have no position until we, magically, “observe/measure it consciously” which then “gives” the particle a position. -mh

The “Positive Unitive” Model Is Disproved by the {shadow dragon monster}

Be suspicious of the connotation network they try to weave via word-choice; even when not directly talking about nature of mystical experience, the articles are flooded with flavor-connotation words to paint that paradigm.

Paradigm-driven lexicon and word-choice.

the positive unitive paradigm vs.
the eternalism-driven control-transformation paradigm.

Sure, control might transform into unitive, but it is spiritual bypassing to do as __ says, and just skip over control transformation to cheat and jump straight to unitive, bringing possibilism-thinking pollution –> PRODUCES CONTROL INSTABILITY.

{SHADOW DRAGON MONSTER} = EXPERIENCE OF THE THREAT OF CATASTROPHIC LOSS OF CONTROL DISPROVES THE POSITIVE UNITIVE MODEL.

Mysticism: Rename the positive unitive model of “mystical experience” to add: {shadow dragon monster} ie control instability

The positive unitive mystical experience comes with the shadow dragon monster.

The “shadow” that matters is NOT personal “material coming up”.

The shadow monster is transpersonal; universal in all minds, which start with possibilism-thinking then learn eternalism-thinking, producing integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking.

Mysticism in Psychedelic Science: Good Friday Experiment at Marsh Chapel: “frightened by loss of control; terrifying fight to overcome”, & tower escapee was given tranquilizer (both omitted by Pahnke)

The Baier article High Mysticism shows Doblin’s redo of the Good Friday Experiment at Marsh Chapel on April 20, 1962 by Walter Pahnke under the advisor Tim Leary , censored:

  • a guy was terrified of loss of control and had bad trip fighting against that threat – Baier article High Mysticism p. 386 middle.
  • a guy was brought down to baseline w/ a tranquilizer eg Thorazine/ CPZ, in stairwell postal message to the university leader. – Baier article High Mysticism p. 387 bottom.

the control instability that is produced by combining psilocybin with positive unitive model, disproves that Unity is the central focus and activity of the mystical experience process

Unity is nothing but an alleged end-state, skipping all the fullness of the process/ ladder/ path which would be needed to get to the alleged destination of Unitive experience/ “realization”

psychedelic mysticism
psmy

Mysticism: The ‘positive unitive’ model of “mystical experience” (Popular Neo-Advaita) is insanity, chaos, developmental failure, avoidance of Transcendent Knowledge

Positive unitive Pop Neo-Advaita is insanity destroying previous developmental structures.

Ken Wilber warned about this.

Must “embrace and include” the earlier developmental structure (egoic personal control system; possibilism-thinking).

Must Integrate and Differentiate, Preserve and Include, Childish “Separation”/ “Multiplicity”, by which they should say instead, egoic control thinking.

Popular Neo-Advaita
pna

ADDITIVE, NOT REPLACIVE!

The “spiritual work” that must be done: In 10 psilocybin sessions, add the eternalism POV to the possibilism POV.

The final, verbose term has APET2DC; has all 4 basic components:
analogical psychedelic eternalism thinking with 2-level, dependent control

  • analogy
  • psychedelic (loose cognition)
  • eternalism
  • control-type: dependent, 2-level d2lc d2c

monolithic, autonomous control
mcac (c = comma; don’t want “mac”)

2-level, dependent control
tdc
tldc ( ‘t’ not ‘2’, b/c ‘2’ prefix is unreliable.)

Practice:
m c a c
t l d c
monolithic, autonomous control
2-level, dependent control

keyboard shortcut review of the full long term; long version of “LOP” & “APE”:

Short:

  • possibilism
    psm
  • eternalism
    etm
  • possibilism-thinking
    pt
  • eternalism-thinking
    et
  • literalist ordinary-state possibilism
    lop
  • analogical psychedelic eternalism
    ape

— imprecise: no focus on control, just “eternalism”.

Medium length:

  • literalist ordinary-state possibilism with autonomous control
    lopac
  • analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control
    apedc

— omits “monolithic”, omits 2-level.

Long, verbose, precise:

  • literalist ordinary-state possibilism with monolithic, autonomous control
    lopmac
  • analogical psychedelic eternalism with 2-level, dependent control
    ape2dc

— omits “thinking” or “mental model”.

  • literalist ordinary-state possibilism thinking with monolithic, autonomous control
    loptmac
  • analogical psychedelic eternalism thinking with 2-level, dependent control
    apet2dc

The referent, decoded message of motif
{cut left arm touches open scroll touching God’s cloud} =
“Transcendent Knowledge = non-branching = eternalism = analogical psychedelic eternalism thinking with 2-level, dependent control”

The Message of Image f107

The referent, decoded message of motif
{cut left arm touches open scroll touching God’s cloud} =
“Transcendent Knowledge = non-branching = eternalism = analogical psychedelic eternalism thinking with 2-level, dependent control”

Features:

  • 8:33 a.m. January 19, 2026: {cut left arm} of ossuary guy touches {open scroll} that touches God’s cloud. The referent meaning: “Transcendent Knowledge = non-branching; eternalism; analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control .”
  • thumb is main motif, representing non-branching, representing
  • Strictly speaking, handedness is used in a few spots, only. Nimble selective application. eg God doesn’t show L hand, but R.
  • Upper L: Light and awake on L w/ L tree
  • Upper R: Dark (dim reflected moon light) and asleep on R with black key tree compare pink key tree’s simplifying function in f134 row 1 L.
  • Holds wisdom-{beard} with thumb and fingers; non-branching & branching; knows 2POV: integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking. His branching fingers (no thumb) touch his closed non-awake eyes.
  • Billow cloth behind sleeping eyes / grabbing beard.

Most of this anlysis — receiving Eadwine msg — isn’t adding much new, just new combinations & implementations.

mental model transformation from fingers to fingers and thumb.

Transformation from Y to YI; fingers to fingers and thumb

Transformation from Y [bad] to YI [good].
It’s bad to have only Y;
It’s good to have YI.
YI =
Y & I =
possibilism + eternalism =
integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking

possibilism-thinking is not bad; having ONLY possibilism-thinking is bad. Good is having both possibilism-thinking & eternalism-thinking; YI. Hand showing YI shape.

Pair of hands showing YI & Y; YI vs. Y. 5:50 pm Sun 1/18/26.

The Y + I hand = Transcendent Knowledge. especially when favor thumb as done in f107. Y hand = egoic thinking/ folly; from Y to dest: Y fingers branching + add thumb.

from [branching [fingers] possibilism]
to [branching [fingers] possibilism + non-branching [thumb] eternalism]
bottom of notes written on p 366 Baier

Notes Written on Baier p. 367, Top

non-branching = sun light, standing; thumb on scroll.
branching-demon = S [?] each branching-demon has ears like Y horns.

{thumb over heart} motif 6x because YI mushroom-tree (lower R) naturally maps to hand as:

  • cut branch of mushroom-tree is to
    the branching part of the mushroom-tree, as:
  • thumb is to
    fingers.

a:b = c:d

{cut branch of mushroom-tree} : {the branching part of the mushroom-tree} =
{thumb} : {fingers}

a:b :: c:d

wiki: “A statement expressing the equality of two ratios A:B and C:D is called a proportion, written as
A:B = C:D
or
A:B∷C:D
The latter form, when spoken or written in the English language, is often expressed as:
(A is to B) as (C is to D).”

branching = moon, eyes closed, sitting on ground, not seeing (yet, hold beard, w/ thumb & fingers)

God’s non-branching thumb touches God’s cloud, fingers don’t. That’s like: Police’s L hand: thumb over/above scroll that’s touching non-branching branch of tree that’s touching the Sun Light cloud;
Police’s R hand: thumb against open scroll that’s touching God’s cloud.

  1. Thumb vs. fingers; eternalism vs possibilism; non-branching vs branching
  2. Favor thumb over fingers
  3. Favor YI (thumb & fingers) over Y (fingers, no thumb).

Notes Written on Baier p. 367, Right Margin

Consistent:

Closed book how favor — .. correction: No hand at closed book.
Hand holds book / Police’s L [R hand is favored: evidence: A scroll]

ie, we can’t say Police’s L hand is favored over R hand, b/c both are affirmed:

  • L hand is affirmed by being against open scroll that’s touching God’s cloud.
  • R hand is affirmed by holding an open scroll that’s touching non-branching branch of tree that’s touching cloud of Sun Light.

Police looks at top of Sun Light, as if looking above the folio image.

Sleep guy: HOLDS Holds beard (enlightenment/ wisdom); = holding the open scroll.
Problem: Not holding the end of the open scroll.
Solution: His L hand shows thumb and fingers holding beard, = holding the end of the scroll.

Inventory of Trees

Left YI Tree

circular leaves

cut left trunk

no cut right trunk

sun light is not only touching non-branching R branch; it’s also touching the R branch of the Y on the L.

all 3 leaves touch sun light cloud; affirm Y & I; affirm possibilism-thinking & eternalism-thinking & contrast (= integrate + differentiate) between possibilism & eternalism

That’s per the 2POV philosophy.

The two different points of view, two different mental models

(against the “Get rid of possibilism, it’s bad” error, bad like Popular Neo-Advaita’s insanity, “get rid of the self”).

{cut left trunk} is equivalent to non-branching branch on right

{cut left trunk} is on the lower level

(always interp the branching morphy of a mushroom-tree starting at bottom upward)

Right YI Tree

trident leaves

{cut right trunk} & {cut left trunk}

only 1 of 3 branches touches the moon cloud: the leftmost, = max branching.

Compare the {cut right trunk} & {cut left trunk}
with
mushroom-tree’s 2 pairs of same.

Mushroom-Tree

midway up: {cut right branch} & {cut left branch}
near-bottom: {cut right trunk} & {cut left trunk}
very bottom: {cut right trunk} & {cut left trunk}

Two visually cut branches.

Bottom has 4 cut trunks, matching a hand’s 4 fingers w/ fingertips hidden.

Guy has form of lifted garment, John Rush calls “celestial erection” motif.

Inventory of Books

Closed Book on Upper Level

No hands.

Open Book on Upper Level

1 hand, YI, {thumb against open book}, fingers are not against open book but touch multiple pages.

1 hand behind it, not shown.

Closed Book on Lower Level

L hand, hidden, holds book and forms lifted garment motif.

Image has {mushroom hem} motif ~20x; ~10 guys have it.

The hook demon does The Kneel stance, R leg forward.

Open Book on Lower Level

R hand no thumb, only fingers.

L hand YI thumb & fingers, {thumb against open book}.

{thumb} maps to “non-branching” via __ (mushroom-tree)

{thumb} maps to “rescue from control instability” via __ (demon hook touch R leg…) .

Inventory of Scrolls

Scroll 1

Scroll 1: L end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 1: R end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 2

Scroll 2: L end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 2: R end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 3

Scroll 3: L end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 3: R end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 4

Scroll 4: L end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 4: R end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 5

Scroll 5: L end is held up by, or touches: __

Scroll 5: R end is held up by, or touches: __

Notes Written on Baier p. 367, Bottom

{beard} = YI hand (shows fingers & thumb) of sleep under moon w/ closed eyes = branching (Y) (no thumb) … by branching tree = moon.

Vertical Notes on Baier p. 367 (Left Margin)

Middle vertical notes on p 367, written last:

Upper right: brings togeher:

  • moon
  • asleep
  • closed eyes / not seeing
  • Y-fingers
  • branching on L part of black key tree.

Sleeping guy joins 2 motifs: [closed eyes / not seeing = Y fingers = branching thinking​].

enlightenment (light, sun) = revealed non-branching thumb vs. branching fingers. Favor thumb, and favor [Y vs. I]; ie:

  • favor thumb over fingers, of a hand
  • favor hand showing Y-vs-I, over a hand showing just fingers.

I really want to see which other folio I was struggling to interp before (couple weeks ago), re: the “only showing one of his two thumbs” motif. I was struggling w/ Handedness, in that other folio:

“the thumb moves from L hand on this guy, to R hand on that guy, so is thumb = good = Right??

Ans: I doubt specifically handedness is utilized there; I doubt the meaning utilizes L vs R.

The meaning is just, “inferior hand shows fingers; superior, other hand shows THUMB AS WELL AS FINGERS, regardless of whether L or R.
10:36 a.m. January 19, 2026

This nuance (that when you get non-branching, you retain branching thinking​) conveyed by Eadwine f107 corroborates my April/Aug 2025 2POV breakthrough, like the two images that breakthrough was based on:

  • Dionysus + Ariadne mosaic, victory procession wedding chariot. Incl 5 {mushroom hem} + Amanita leopard fountain, and mushroom-shaped bunches of grapes.
  • Rebis holding a Y.

mental model transformation from branching thinking​ to non-branching thinking​ .

You don’t go from fingers to thumb; you go from fingers to [thumb as well as fingers], favoring thumb but still having fingers. “embrace and include” fingers (branching thinking​; egoic thinking; possibilism-thinking) per Ken Wilber.

Contrast fingers and thumb, and favor thumb – but honor fingers, if thumb is present, complementing.

Jesus holds cross staff with fingers working together with thumb.

When you hear “eternalism-thinking”, or abbr as simply “eternalism”, it does not mean get rid of possibilism-thinking; rather, think:
integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking; qualified possibilism-thinking + eternalism-thinking;

“eternalism” is shorthand for:
integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking;
qualified possibilism-thinking + eternalism-thinking

from possibilism to eternalism

from possibilism to possibilism + eternalism

from fingers to fingers + thumb

mental model transformation from:
possibilism
to:
possibilism + eternalism

eternalism is revealed, open book; thumb against open book, 2x

from possibilism to integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking

Transcribed Baier Article p. 366 Notes about Image f107

Thumb
——
Fingers

Thumb+Fingers
————-
Fingers

Degrees of goodness.

Upper level = reconciled with non-branching ; lower level = embed in branching.

mushroom-tree (lower R) = emphasize cut trunk; it signals:
“{cut branch} is important motif.”

mushroom-trees are higher psychedelic religion/ mysticism

indigenous shams are lower psychedelic religion / mysticism

(reacting to page James & Leuba make a value scale, like Zaeh: there’s

Git

Big

Hierarchy of Inferior Mysticism and Superior Mysticism

The best model of mystical experience is the Egodeath theory; eternalism-driven control-transformation.

The worst model of mystical experience is reducing narrowing mystical experience to nothing other than positive unitive experience.

They say introvertive mysticism is higher mysticism
extrovertive mysticism is lower mysticism

ackshually,

eternalism-driven control-transformation is higher mysticism
unitive mysticism is lower mysticism

L tree has L cut trunk; cut trunk signals “non-branching is important”

same role as pink key tree in f134

The black key tree reinforces/ confirms/ establishes interp of the mushroom-tree below it: note that a cut branch touches his elbow/arm / left limb, which hand shows IY, thumb against heart,

Does f107 have any features that are not listed in my article “Recognizing Mushroom Imagery in Medieval Art”?
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/08/08/recognizing-mushroom-imagery-in-medieval-art/

Eternalism-Thinking (in the Broad Sense) Is Integrated Possibilism/ Eternalism Thinking

mental model transformation from possibilism to possibilism + eternalism [the big 2025 2POV idea]

1st-order, simp’d crude model: imprecise:
“mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism” [true if “eternalism” includes integrated qualified possibilism-thinking] – not exclusively eternalism-thinking; an eternalism-thinking that “”embrace and include” per Ken Wilber, possibilism-thinking.

1st-order, simp’d crude model: imprecise:
“mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism”

2nd-order, sophisticated model: precise:
“mental model transformation from possibilism to possibilism & eternalism”

3rd-order, sophisticated model: precise:
“mental model transformation from possibilism-thinking to integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking”

Major:

  • God’s thumb touches God’s cloud.
  • God’s fingers don’t touch God’s cloud.
  • Police’s thumb is within the open scroll that touches God’s cloud.
  • Police’s fingers don’t touch the open scroll that touches God’s cloud.

Great Canterbury Psalter folio f107

Non-Branching Thumb = Message from God: Thumb in Middle of {open book} 2x

White box around each pair of hands

Corrected to Include 4 Cut Trunks

admittedly that is a harder task than ppls hands, THINKING POSITIVELY U COULD SAY MY STRATEGY WAS A SUCCESS: FIRST *TRY* PUTTING AROUND PAIRS OF HANDS, THEN THE 4 TRUNKS STICKS OUT SUPER MUCH, TO SOLVE IT IN 2ND PASS JUST LIKE I PLANNED (NOT) (SORTA)

White Boxes on Pairs of Hands-Including Both Hands of the {hand mushroom-tree} This Time!

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-white-boxes-hands.jpg” 761 KB 10:40 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen / f107 crops

As a memento of the blood/toil, flaws in R white box remain. I patched the white bar midway up the {hand mushroom-tree}.

FAILED to Perceive 4 Cut Trunks, was still mystified puzzling over them

Eadwine got me. Too dumb to pattern-match despite clearly trying. I tried, I failed. Welcome to this puzzle-genre, or encoding-to-communicate and teach, genre.

The first-time fails I keep falling into, demonstrates in detail what’s involved in the decoding project. It’s not trivially easy.

Crop and annotations by Michael Hoffman.
White boxes around pairs of hands. Folio f107, Great Canterbury Psalter.
“Canterbury-f107-white-boxes-hands.jpg”, 749 KB, 8:44 a.m. January 18, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen of WordPress: https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/canterbury-f107-white-boxes-hands.jpg

Error: if draw box around upper part of mushroom-tree, must include in that box, the 4 cut trunks (= lower hand of tree).
1:55 p.m. January 19, 2026
I hadn’t yet figured out the mapping of 4 trunks ~= 4 fingers of lower hand.

Hand showing fingers and also thumb is favored over hand showing only fingers but no thumb.

Thumb is favored over fingers, on the YI hand (ie showing thumb and fingers).

Decoded motif: {pair of hands, one hand showing fingers, the other hand showing fingers and thumb}

11:10 p.m. January 18, 2026

The message of the {pair of hands, one hand showing fingers, the other hand showing fingers and thumb} is:

You start with branching thinking​ (possibilism-thinking), [fingers, no thumb]
you end up with integrated branching thinking​ and non-branching thinking​; integrated possibilism/eternalism thinking. [fingers and thumb]

todo: re-analyze my other top images, with hand shape, re: pairs of hands; both of a person’s hands:

Which other Canterbury folio(s) did I see that shows often, something like:
one hand w/ fingers, other hand with fingers and thumb? It seemed to switch around a lot, which hand showed thumb.

Thumb = non-branching = eternalism-thinking
Fingers = branching = possibilism-thinking

Emphasis is on non-branching thumb. Branching fingers only on one hand (possibilism); fingers and non-branching thumb on other hand (thumb = eternalism).

mushroom-tree:
IY branching morphology of hand touches cut tree branch on L, branching of tree on R.

upper trees: both are YI, yet have cut left trunk forming at bottom level, IY.

Mushroom-tree bottom emph. cut trunk 4x.

Ossuary guy has no left leg or left arm – cut. Hook touches left missing leg.

Jesus non branching right big toe on ossuary; left toes = branching, on unstable ground. Angel behind has similar toes, right foot on boundary, left foot on lower level head of sage who is aware of being stood on.

Thumb Against Open Scroll or Open Book 3x

  • Police officer’s thumb against open scroll of God’s cloud.
  • Angel’s thumb against open book.
  • Sage’s thumb against open book.
  • Lower right: thumb against open scroll 2x.

Angel left wing touch moon cloud
Angel right wing touch God cloud

The Thumbs of Demons: One Hand Fingers & Thumb, Other Hand Fingers, No Thumb

Earth Mounds: Altered Ground Unstable

Left Tree: YI Sun Light

Right Tree: YI Moon

Mushroom-Tree with Grid Caps

Hellmouth Demons

Open Scrolls

Cut Left Limb

The YI Hand Shape

Inventory of Fingers and Toes

Inventory of Pairs of Hands: One Hand Showing Thumb and Fingers, Other Hand Showing Fingers, Not Thumb

Splayed Fingers Touching Face (Dancing Man, Golden: Jonah Gourd)

11 p.m. January 17, 2026 — Dancing Man: Three Branching fingers touch L side of forehead/mind; index finger, alone, touches R side of forehead/mind. This is discussed in voice recording DR-O5B-2814.wav, p.m. January 17, 2026, where I talk through much of f107, and switch out to Dancing Man to analyze f107 row 1 R: Sleeping Sage, who has L hand showing fingers & thumb, R hand at forehead showing fingers, no thumb.

  • Branching fingers (pinkie, middle, ring) = L side of forehead
  • Non-branching index finger = R side of forehead

Lower-Level Guys Aware of Stood on by Upper-Level Guys

Boundary Between Lower and Upper Level

Sleeping guy’s open scroll is re: boundary.

His R foot is above the boundary.

His L foot is below the boundary, on lower guy’s head.

Ossuary Rescue

Closed Books on Left, Open Books on Right

f107: Lifted Up from Ossuary by Right Arm

Gallery image:
https://egodeaththeory.wordpress.com/2023/06/07/eadwine-images-great-canterbury-psalter-catalog-gallery/#f107

Jesus Lifting from Ossuary by God’s Hand

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“f107 ossuary lifted.jpg” 396 KB [12:53 a.m. August 21, 2025]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom#
fullscreen of WordPress:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/f107-ossuary-lifted.jpg

Jesus Lifting from Ossuary

Crop by Cybermonk. Detail from image f107.
“Canterbury-f107-lifted-ossuary.jpg” 264 KB [9:55 a.m. April 8, 2023]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom#
fullscreen of WordPress image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/canterbury-f107-lifted-ossuary.jpg

Moliero version

Mol https://www.moleiro.com/en/biblical-books/the-great-canterbury-psalter/miniatura/253 – I can see the page below when in Edit mode:

Christ lifts him up from ossuary by right hand / right hand. demons roasting hell pit flames, sun vs. moon

1 mushroom tree, 2 YI vine-leaf trees

a tree touching Sun

a tree touching Moon

f107 = f177, Key Connecting-Motifs, to Cross-Decode Folio Images

f177:

Crop by Michael Hoffman
fullscreen of WordPress image:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/canterbury-f177-whole-image.jpg

Canterbury f177: 4 Horses, Balancing on Right Foot
https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/03/12/4-horses-mushroom-tree-right-foot-balancing-great-canterbury-psalter-f177/

To help decode important themes in f177:

  • Held up by right hand by Christ pointed by hand of God in 107 = held up (above ossuary) by right arm by right hand of God in 177.
  • Left-foot rams in furnace (f177) = hellmouth fire pit (f107).
  • Ossuary in 107 = ossuary in 177

Motivation for Creating this Page

in 2025, discovered motifs linking the important f177 (well studied) & f107 (not well studied).

Sequence of decoding selected entire folio pages in detail; dedicated page per folio:

  1. f134 – Nov. 2020; page: July 2022:
    https://egodeaththeory.wordpress.com/2022/07/19/psalter-rows/
  2. f145 – March 2023:
    https://egodeaththeory.wordpress.com/2023/03/17/canterbury-f145-king-orders-shipments-of-blue-fruit-to-storage-lockboxes-with-blue-stemmed-mushroom-tree/
  3. f177 – March 2023:
    https://egodeaththeory.wordpress.com/2023/03/12/4-horses-mushroom-tree-right-foot-balancing-great-canterbury-psalter-f177/
  4. f109 – May 2025:
    https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/25/f109-great-canterbury-psalter-hellmouth-net-ossuary-cloth-looking-out-from-temple/
  5. f11 – Jan. 2025, May 2025
    top half only: Jan. 2025:
    https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/01/18/the-six-days-of-creation-in-great-canterbury-psalter/
    top and bottom half: May 2025
    https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/25/f11-great-canterbury-psalter-6-days-of-creation-eden/
  6. f107 – Jan. 16, 2026
    https://egodeaththeory.org/2026/01/16/canterbury-f107-lifted-up-from-ossuary-by-right-arm/

Archived

blurry, don’t use
Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-right-trees-guy.jpg” 132 KB 11:28 a.m. January 19, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen WordPress pic:
https://egodeaththeory.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/canterbury-f107-right-trees-guy.jpg

See Also

f177 similar theme of corpse, ossuary, held up by God

The Importance of (Least) Ceremony

Michael Hoffman, Saturday, January 3, 2026

Photo: Michael Hoffman, 2025. Bird’s Nest Mushroom.

Contents:

links work on desktop Edge/Chrome

List of Reasons Why Ceremony Is Important

  • To contribute to legal protection.
    Risk, critique: “Gaming the system with theology”.
  • Community/group helps support difficult or ambitious experiences.
  • To build community bonds.
    The entire purpose of church is community – as opposed to individual journeying or a random crossing of paths of journeying individuals.
    Even a Rock Festival has some ceremony aspects.
  • To increase control of the event and give insurance, to some extent.
  • To reduce chance of one person commandeering the event.
  • For increased safety (vs. “member-disorganized non-events”).
  • To avoid chaos & leaving group formation to chance.
    Negative reasoning: If you don’t define or have a ceremony, the result is no ceremony, and less group cohesion in that way.
  • Meanings of ‘ceremony’.
  • Group prep is ceremony.
  • The sequence [group prep; group journey; group integrate] is ceremony.

Least Ceremony: Steps in Liturgy, the Prep portion of Journey/Practice

Do prep steps as ceremony.

Contributors to this list: church members and friends, including latecomers; this exercise to define Least Ceremony was a group successful group project.

  1. Days before: Announcement of planned event; invitation to come to location.
    Risk: “member-organized events that use non- or sched- subst.”
    Consider keeping the two separate, not interwoven in church conversation:
    Discussion of indiv sched journey.
    Discussion of group non-sched journey, eg religiously traditional Welch’s grape juice & cracker.
  2. Gather in a circle.
    risk: people arrive & leave at different times.
    How can official church events and member-organized events manage to get ppl there on time, together?
  3. Write down the time, T0.
  4. Have water available.
  5. Give an altar item, eg Pentel P205 pencil. [todo: image]
  6. What’s your first & last name?
    risk: social freeze; excess privacy; legal worries in favor of anonymity.
  7. What’s your contact info? Does someone have it?
    Community requires contact info.
  8. Which sacrament are you taking?
    eg Welch’s grape juice & cracker; red wine & bread.
  9. What dosage of sacrament?
    image: {balance scale} motif is 8x in Great Canterbury Psalter, meaning: to balance amount; to balance control.
  10. Do you plan to consider redosing, re-sacrament, at 3 hours? eg more Welch’s grape juice & cracker.
  11. Do a reading from a church document.
  12. Are you making a contribution/donation?
  13. State intention, in some sense, open or specific. See “Care”, in About page.
  14. Take sacrament together: see each other take it.
    Risk; negative clarification: Not: go off alone doing/taking who knows what, when. Be able to answer: “Did person X ingest [item/qty]?”
    Risk: group cohesion falls apart during/after this step. Solution: Prayer after ingest.
  15. Prayer together.
    Risk; negative clarification: Avoid multiple conflicting theologies. We only have 1 theology, Least Dogma; recite that as prayer.

/ end of Least Ceremony section

/ end of talk: The Importance of (Least) Ceremony.

A Pastor on Ceremony

A pastor emailed:

“I appreciate a beautiful ceremony.

“Least Dogma suggests that – while “ceremonial ritual” may be important to many lineages and paths, our way can support diverse (more or less ‘ceremonious’) forms of practice, 

“For example:

“very basic (little or no detailed performative ritual),
silent group meditations, 
more or less ‘traditional’ forms of ceremonies, 
much ritual, 
little ritual…

“As long as we bring care, respect, integrity / trust, and attention to basic steps including: 

  1. “Navigation
  2. Preparation [standard]
  3. Initiation 
  4. Practice [standard]
  5. Integration [standard]
  6. Community Integration. 

“It’s wonderful that our community can welcome detailed ceremonial forms as well as ‘least ceremony’ in our practices. 

“That opens the question: What is ceremony?  

“May sitting quietly at the beach with no explicit ritual behavior be considered ‘ceremonial’? That includes following our Wheel of Practice for practical guidance.”

moved draft content from here to idea development page 31, jan 7 2026

See Also

“psychedelic church”
https://www.google.com/search?q=%22psychedelic+church%22

https://www.ligare.org
https://www.ligare.org/about

https://www.sacredgarden.life
https://www.sacredgarden.life/about

Confirmation Liturgy page 1

Read from a church’s home page
https://www.sacredgarden.life
https://www.sacredgarden.life/about
https://www.ligare.org
https://www.ligare.org/about

Images Upload

Michael Hoffman, draft started Aug. 2025, accidentally published Dec. 1, 2025

Photo: Michael Hoffman

Contents:

links work in desktop Edge/Chrome:

Incoming

Photos: Michael Hoffman
Crop by Michael Hoffman, Mar. 3, 2026
Crop & annotations by Michael Hoffman
Crop by Michael Hoffman
Crop & annotations by Michael Hoffman, Mar. 4, 2026

which artist?

Douce Apocalypse

Pulled-from-Banquet guy

Crop & annotations by Michael Hoffman, Mar. 1, 2026

heading

Soma p. 180 & 181

Zep Book

von Trimberg

4 sets favor upper hand — 9:02 p.m. Jan. 30, 2026

stand on right foot all 4

subtle jewhat {left foot lifted} like/ corrobs

subtle favor upper hand

Guild

a.m. Jan. 30, 2026

The Psychedelic Gospels (Browns 2016)

Mushrooms and Mankind (Arthur 2000)

Entheos Issue 1 – The Journal of Psychedelic Spirituality – Entheogens and the Judeo-Christian Mysteries 

Sharday Mosurinjohn

“Conjuring Eden” First Page, Crediting Paul Lindgren

“Conjuring Eden” Endnote 134 Crediting Paul Lindgren

Mushrooms and Mankind Crediting Paul Lindgren

White Boxes on Pairs of Hands-Including Both Hands of the {hand mushroom-tree} This Time!

Crop by Michael Hoffman
“Canterbury-f107-white-boxes-hands.jpg” 761 KB 10:40 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom
fullscreen / f107 crops

I should have included wings. d/k why i didn’t, b/c known already.

11:02 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026: L wing touch moon, R wing touch god cloud

Eadwine got me. Too dumb to pattern-match despite clearly trying. I tried, I failed. Welcome to this puzzle-genre, or encoding-to-communicate and teach, genre.

f107 white boxes on pairs of hands Great Canterbury Psalter

THE MAIN IDEA AND CHALLENGE IS TO EXPALIN THE WTF TRUNKS. TEACHER DOESN’T EXAP EXPECT ME TO IMMED GET IT, 1ST TIME. MY TECHNIQUE WAS A SUCEESS, REQUIRING TWO PASSES — I LITERALLY PLANNED SOME SORT OF 2-PASSES ATTACK APPRAOCH, WHICH PAID OFF. After the sort of … In a way, I planned a 2nd pass; when I drew white boexs last night p.m. Jan. 23, 2026 , i was thinking: invest in this straetgey , to flush out something interesting. i spent next day drawing on the tree correctly, then I came back to fix this 1st-pass whole image.

  1. Draw white boxes, miss the trunks though. they are not hands, but are like hand of guy.
  2. I figured out the 4 trunks, created zooms 3 of them! of best way … an hour ago i decided best to simply 4 white boxes on guy + tree.
  3. I came back to this 1st pass entire pic, gave it thought 40 minutes ago, “yea, i HAVE to apply my solution and go back to v1 entire pic, and fix it.
  4. So, strategy worked, as planned.

I only thought of the boxes as a setup for discovery; in that sense, my failure was a planned success. Obviously missing lower right white box.

Below, the more I thought about it, I had to proceed w/ my sort of planned 2nd, correction pass.

The purpose of the white boxes 1st pass was exactly to flush out the right decoding, in a subsequent pass, so, my overall strategy is effective, just not immed.

I certainly did not think I was completed.

I KNEW I was missing something. That’s kind of a given, I have learned.

I never claimed or EXPECTED the 1st pass to be complete. I at that ttime, REGISTERED 4 TRUNKS AS PUZZLE UNSOLVED, TO BE SOLVED, which I immed did. I take It takes time to propagate my findings / corrections by making and fixing my annotated crops, in f107 page of crops. and here. It’s in this images upload page where I realized the first pass is so gappy, must fix.

This picture is embarrassing not having a white box on the 4 trunks lower right = lower hand of guy – this feeling of embar and missing the mark in those boxes, confirms to me that, re: successfully interp this puzzle / pattern match training device, a MAJOR requirement is {4 cut trunks} = 4 fingers of guy’s lower hand.

I SHOULD HAVE PUT WHITE BOX AROUND ENTIRE TREE WHICH STANDS FOR ISMOROPHICALLY, PAIR OF HANDS: UPPER + LOWER HAND.

Hey idea — 10:17 p.m. Jan. 24, 2026: Idea for what to do with the small {cut right branch}, was “dangling” unaccounted for, halfway up: map it to guy’s hidden thumb of lower hand.

-Tree’s Lower Cut Trunks : Upper YI Branching

Crop by Michael Hoffman
fullscreen / f107 crops

hand = tree; {hand mushroom-tree}

Non-Motivation of this Page

This page is a utility page to upload images from mobile device.

Dec. 1, 2025 – published this utility page by accident. Draft started August 2025.

Before that, to upload images from mobile device, I used the following page which I started, then thought too negative, then eventually published:
The World’s Dumbest Footnote: Ruck Committee: Why We Can’t List Allegro in the References Section, but Only in This Footnote

Bird’s Nest Fungus

Bird Nest Mushroom, photo credit: Michael Hoffman, Sunday, Nov. 30, 2025

https://www.google.com/search?q=bird%27s+nest+fungus&udm=2

Web image search: strange mushrooms
https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=strange+mushrooms

Huggins’ Inane Argument: Great Canterbury Psalter Day 3 Can’t Be Mushroom, b/c Has Branches – That Exactly Match Cubensis 🤦‍♂️

This is infinitely weak of an argument, just like every argument from the deniers of mushroom imagery in Christian art, but they try to make up for it in quantity.

An infinite number of worthless arguments.

Great Canterbury Psalter, Day 3 of Creation, folio f11: Tree 1 & 2

Huggins’ Brazenly Biased “Conclusion” Section: Every Mushroom Tree Has Both Tree Features and Mushroom Features, Therefore It Must Be a Tree, Not a Mushroom

Foraging for Psychedelic Mushrooms in the Wrong Forest: The Great Canterbury Psalter as a Medieval Test Case
Ronald Huggins, 2024
https://www.academia.edu/118659519/Foraging_for_Psychedelic_Mushrooms_in_the_Wrong_Forest_The_Great_Canterbury_Psalter_as_a_Medieval_Test_Case
https://egodeaththeory.org/2024/11/23/huggins-foraging-psychedelic-mushrooms-wrong-forest/

Screengrab of top of “Conclusion” section of article: soak-in the badness of arg’n:

“noted” = censored by the lying, bully, academic obstructionist & fraud Wasson, banker for the Pope; world’s record for maximum Conflict of Interest.

The “Conclusion” section’s argumentation backfires left and right:

Mycologists (affirmers of mushroom imagery in Christian art) must trust the art authorities (deniers of mushroom imagery in Christian art) because:

The art authorities never wrote anything about trees, which are unimportant and merely peripheral (argues Huggins)

The art authorities never wrote anything about mushrooms, because Christians have no reason to think about mushrooms (argues Panofsky via Wasson).

The art authories are expert in related matters (ie, are NOT expert, in fact are utterly ignorant, on THIS topic). – Wasson’s gaslighting phrasing.

The censored – I mean, “noted” – exception, the lone exception, is a flimsy, thin, old book, which doesn’t say what Panofsky claims it says, and only mentions pilzbaum a few times, before knowledge of psychedelic mushrooms.

Even if the book were to claim what Panofsky says (over time, the images shift from umbrella pine to “emphatically” mushroom-shaped imagery), that shift would in no way indicate that the mushroom form was unintended and accidental, and implies the opposite: intentional use of mushroom imagery.

Tree Stylizations in Medieval Paintings (Brinckmann 1906)

Erwin Panofsky’s Letters to Gordon Wasson, Transcribed – “emphatic” sentence:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/01/07/panofskys-letters-to-wasson-transcribed/#Sentence-1-7 –

Just to show what I mean, I enclose two specimens: a miniature of ca. 990 which shows the inception of the process, viz., the gradual hardening of the pine into a mushroom-like shape, and a glass painting of the thirteenth century, that is to say about a century later than your fresco, which shows an even more emphatic schematization of the mushroom-like crown.

Erwin Panofsky to Gordon Wasson, May 2, 1952

Alan Houot: Mystics Bad, Shamans Good; Masters Thesis: PASS

Hatsis 2025: Psychedelic Injustice, p. 260: Totally Omits Scholarship when Summarizing the Pop “Suppression of Psychedelics” Premise

See my book review, which is scathing re: this passage:

Psychedelic Injustice: How Identity Politics Poisons the Psychedelic Renaissance (Hatsis, 2025)

God Is the Creator of Evil; Radical Monotheistic Hyper-Calvinism; Universal Puppetmaster

Experiencing this can so contradict egoic thinking, risk of psychosis in psychedelic peak state.

This experiential perspective is a major strain on the immature, daily mental model.

What’s There to Be Afraid Of? Identifying the Shadow Dragon Monster

i think i credit the artist w/ url in my page that uses this image, August 2025

Transcendent Knowledge (Enlightenment) Is About Vulnerability, the Pedestal and Serpent of Vulnerability on a Pole

Greater knowlwedge and wisdom is of vulnerability. Merkavah palace 6: regardless of your knowledge and wisdom, ANGEL 6 GUARD MIGHT KILL YOU RANDOMLY.

image: Great Canterbury Psalter > king holds open scroll in left hand from God/ of God [God-shaped knoweldge; the harsh shaping = {angel harassing mystic}], open scroll in right hand to lion threat … the threat-vulnerability gate.

To comprehend that clear knowledge of cybernetics = know where the boundary line is forming two 2 2-level, dependent control – Eastern Advaita sucks b/c lacks structure, [long long list of bad things about Adv]

CAn we make long list of suchlike badness in W relig or phil of religion or theory of mysticism eg Neoplatonism overlaps – even advaita articles say The One… not only was Vivek guy forced through Christian schools, Greco Roman Christian, actually, including Neoplatonism; likely, this Theosophy Advaita nonduality incorps Neoplat; these writers studied Neoplatonism and then studied Advaita into the frame of Neoplatonism, the One, inarticulate,

  • the One [recast as “nonduality”]
  • nonduality Advaita
  • ineffable
  • apophatic mysticism [recast as “Eastern ineffability”]

Is Neo-Advaita Orientalized Neoplatonism? First, intensively study Neoplatonism. Afterwards, study Neo-Advaita, into the lens frame of Neoplatonism. Neoplatonic Advaita

Neoplatonic Advaita

It’s the same badness: overfocus on self/other boundary, along w/ inarticulate glorification of inarticulate and lacking structure in important areas of psychedelic experienceing.

  • Neoplatonism: insufficiently coming from psychedelics; coming from Pop armchair unaware of psychedelics, subst’g non-drug meditation instead, building up timeframe expectations, 70 years of meditation required. Expectations are unhinged.

pass through gate = comprehend inherent cybernetic vulnerablility threat.

f107

f107: Lifted Up from Ossuary by Right Arm

Crop by Cybermonk
“Canterbury-f107.jpg” 899 KB [9:30 a.m. April 4, 2023]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f107.item.zoom

Commentary & crops

open scroll = understand vulnerability; being threatened; PEAK THREAT / PEAK DIVINE MADNESS;

Merkavah: the child studied too young and died, threatened to death.

12:36 a.m. December 2, 2025 – hand shape, nonbr thumb against open scroll, fingers off scroll, turn look right, L hand hand shape

demon has almost hook in guy rescued, others have open scroll

i need entire panel analysis: https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/06/07/eadwine-images-great-canterbury-psalter-catalog-gallery/#f107

Sanitized Neoplatonism, battle transformation instability realization of cybernetic vulnerability omitted like the Challenging Experience Questionnaire (CEQ) omits 18 of 21 Angst/Dread effect items from OAV 1994.

OAV (ideally) is a (sometimes called 5D-ASC, which is conflated w/ — i should call it 13 FActors since they so, so weakly brand the Studerus questionnaire. 15 Factors = Studerus, != 5D-ASC which contains OAV (3 hi-lev dims) + 2 other irrel dims no one cares about, that vary per substance.

15 Factors starts w/ OAV, combines O & V into Pleasant hi-lev dim, A = Unpleasant hi-levl dim, and ADD sub-dimensions (factors), eg in A, add sub-dims: ICC; ANX; and Shadow Factor 13.

f60: Double {balance scale}, Lion Den, Two Tables

awareness of inherent vulnerability cybernetic: open scroll touching lion. youths learn YI hand shape (2 POVs) and are starting to discover the vulneratibility threat; they know 2 POVs but — although they are experienced psychonauts — they have not yet wisdom about inherent vulnerability threat.

youths know YI contrast but not yet baby lion threat sleeping baby lion, youths not yet awakened to the peak climax threat:
Dread ETCLOC
the experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control by being made to focus on vulnerability threat, driving control transformation.

Crop by Cybermonk
“Canterbury-f60.jpg” 823 KB [10:42 p.m. June 10, 2023]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b10551125c/f60.item.zoom

Commentary & crops

Little Dolls, Diary of a Madman, LP liner sleeve lyrics

Block-Universe Eternalism Slide 1, by Church Leader

Block-Universe Eternalism Slide 2, by Church Leader

Block-Universe Eternalism Slide 3, by Church Leader

Karl Baier Article High Mysticism p. 366: Features in f107, January 18, 2026

From this hardcopy, I transcribed the notes about features of f107 in my new dedicated page about f107.

[re-inserted from gallery]
Why did the picture, uploaded from mobile, go missing? Could be a version conflict between devices, I’m on desktop rn.

Sharday Mosurinjohn

See Also

pending

Taves and Breau Further Entrench the Wrong, Unity Model of Peak Mystic-State Experience, while Critiquing Stace/Pahnke’s Neo-Advaita, Positive-Unity Model

Michael Hoffman, draft 6:37 p.m. November 28, 2025

Contents:

links work in desktop Edge/Chrome:

Motivation for this Page

My article prior to Merkavah is about Pahnke 1962/1963 PhD Good Friday, and contains this 3-article content, that doesn’t fit best in the Merk or Stace-specifiec article.

Moving that content to this new page.

Studying these 3 papers together has been rewarding, a leverage point.

Dump on Shamanism & insult and reject it; reactionary pushback against the dominant paradigm.

Dump on Eastern Phil o Religion [disparagement of Boomers’ [ie 20th C] Orientalism]; reactionary pushback against the dominant paradigm.

Advocate Western mysticism / Western Esotericism as (relatively) superior.

Laugh at Psychedelic pseudo science and the Deserved Hopkins DISASTER.

Move writers from Centering Positive Unity, to centering eternalism-driven control-transformation.

Neo-Platonism = Neo-Advaita

The closest thing Western mysticism has to Pop Modern Advaita’s negativity of expression and glorification of being inarticulate, is Neoplatonism and apophatic theology.

Oneness per Neoplatonism, or Unity per Neo-Advaita, are a part of Transcendent Knowledge & mystical experience.

Oneness and Unity are a false model of the central experience of mystic-state transformation. Papers such as Pahnke & Breau explicitly state and emphasize, that Unity is the essence of mystical experience.

The essence of mystical experience is eternalism-driven control-transformation. Mysticism is actually from psychedelics, not “traditional methods of the mystics” fabricated by academics; and the essense and characteristic hallmark of psychedelic experience is encountering eternalism instead of familiar possibilism — the eternalism state of consciousness. Not, as Breau writes, “the Unity state of consciousness” — a charged, telling phrase.

The Foo state of consciousness.

What word you use for Foo, is your paradigm and proposal for the central focus.

the Eternalism state of consciousness

the Unity state of consciousness

the altered state of consciousness [general; particular isn’t specified; altered in what essential way?]

Image: Pahnke, Taves, Breau Papers on Neo-Advaita Premise Driving Psychedelic Science

It is so profitable critically reading these 3 papers together, I’m considering making a page covering the set of them. Taves and Breau tinker with fine-tuning the Unity model, but they merely develop and entrench the wrong, Unity model.

Between 1500 and 1687, the geocentric model lost its hegemony but people didn’t yet settle on the heliocentric model.

Model 1: Unity-Centric: Stace 1960 / Pahnke 1962

Pahnke start of psychedelic pseudo science 1962 incorp’ing Stace 1960 (Unity per Neo Advaita).

Model 2: Unity-Centric: Ann Taves 2020

“We should study negative ego dissolution boundary ailment; negative Unity, not only positive Unity which = mystical experience. We should study alterations of sense of self.”

Model 3: Unity-Centric: Jeffrey Breau 2023

Breau advocates:

“We should not only study the Neo-Advaita brand of Unity; we should study ALL brands of Unity.

Neo-Advaita is bad, it’s only one interp OF UNITY, OF THE UNITY STATE OF CONSCIOUSNESS, = perennial philosophy, armchair philosophy.

Unity is good, experiential, we need to model Unity better than Neo Advaita does.”

The Egodeath theory equates the Unity paradigm = the Neo-Advaita paradigm [= Neoplatonism in Wester armchair philosophical ‘mysticism’].

Breau acts like Neo-Advaita isn’t the exact same shiite as the Unity model altogether.

Breau rejects Neo-Advaita yet totally affirms Unity – which, re: essential central emphasis, is same thing as Neo Advaita.

Model 4: Eternalism-centric: Michael Hoffman 2025

Psychedelics and myth (Western culture’s mysticism) are centrally reporting eternalism transformation encounter, not Unity.

Sledge equates mysticism with Neoplatonism, and says Merkavah mysticism isn’t mysticism if we define “mysticism is Neoplatonism”, but says obviously Merkavah mysticism is mysticism.

Neo-Advaita & Neoplatonism Are Irrelevant Armchair Philosophies Useless for Actual Psychedelic Altered-State Experience; Myth Is Closer and a More Trustworthy Description

Neoplatonism is wrong, a false, poor model – misrepresentative – a poor explanatory framework, delivering little explanatory power, with LOW RELEVANCE to actual altered-state experience.

Diagrams: 4 Models of “Mystical Experience”; 3 Center Unity instead of Eternalism

back page of printout of Taves 2020 article, probably Sunday, Nov. 23, 2025

transcription below

Top of Diagrams Page

transcription:

[key strategy: pay total attention to the] Emphasis [in the various writers’] Use of Unity

Breau [says we should] include dualistic [relational mysticism]

who wrote Stace is covert Christianity? Breau p. 14 bottom: Mosurinjohn & Girn 2023

My [work is like a dissert for] PhD proves Eadwine [Great Canterbury Psalter] threat-driven 2-level, dependent control / eternalism-driven control-transformation, vs. [Breau] only have POV of possibilism / monolithic, autonomous control, including Unity Advaita pantheism with carrying a load of [arbitrary metaphysics additions such as “pure consciousness” – but that’s a mere side-concern which Katz latches onto in order to refute – instead – the common core Unitive theory of mystical experience]

Stace/Pahnke 1960 (Diagram): Neo-Advaita’s Unity Paradigm

Main, Outer Circle: The Center and Boundary of Stace/Pahnke’s Conception of Mystical Experience

Positive Unity

per English Advaita 19th-20th Century Advaita Vedanta Hindu Pantheism.

A Contained, Subset Circle: Where Unity Functions within the Stace/Pahnke Paradigm

No contained circle. Positive Unity is the entire extent of the model.

Notes to the Left of the Stace Diagram

“Western mystical union, Abrahamic, is inferior, indirect; Advaita is superior, direct: Unitive/Unity”

Notes to the Right of the Stace Diagram

Positive Advaita Unity, along with “pure consciousness” , Metaphysics, subtractive explanation; Paradigm.

Notes Below the Stace Diagram

Advaita’s positive unity = mystical experience. “Advaita”, including theory-traits:

  • subtractive explanation
  • a particular, elaborated Metaphysics
  • pantheism

“Phenomenology” According to Neo-Advaita’s Unity Model of Mystic-State Experience

(to the lower left of the diagram)

The “phenomenology” of Positive Advaita Unity; Neo-Advaita: armchair philosophy model treats mystic-state phen’y as nothing other than Positive Unity; the experience of cessation of the mind constructing the self/other boundary experience.

This cessation (this boundary alteration) is Transcendent Knowledge, revelation, gnosis, satori, etc.

The center and boundary: Unity, Unitive, union.

Taves 2020 (Diagram): Unity Includes Negative Valence (Ego Dissolution) as Well as Positive Unity; also Altered Sense of Self Other than Unity

Main, Outer Circle: The Center and Boundary of Tave’s Conception of Mystical Experience

experiences of altered sense of self

Her nominal outer circle is broad “altered sense of self”

Taves gives a few sentences worth of lip service to experiences outside of the Unity paradigm – which she expanded from only positive Unity to also negative Unity ie ego dissolution.

But in practice, her paradigm is nothing more than [expanded] Unity.

She continues centering Unity as the main mystical experience.

A Contained, Subset Circle: Where Unity Functions within the Taves Paradigm

separate alterations in sense of self from valence
+ also negative unity/ ego dissolution, positive unity , valence: positive / negative Unity

the “mysticism” construct

alterations in sense of self

unusual sense of self

change in sense of self

altered sense of the self/world boundary

key word: valence [as in, assumed-positively experienced unity vs. assumed-negatively experienced ego dissolution]

Notes to the Left of the Taves Diagram

Critiques centering “boundary” alteration, like she critiques centering Unity; she wraps “boundary” and “unity” in scare-quotes (which is good to do; a very good sign).

Notes to the Right of the Taves Diagram

  1. Positive Unity
  2. She first adds: Negative Unity [eg ego dissolution] [she clearly does this]
  3. She then adds: Any altered sense of self [not just versions of Unity experience. she’s hazy and advocates this, but doesn’t propose any specific substance – b/c she’s actually limited to the Unity paradigm.]

Notes Below the Taves Diagram

see Phen’y section below

“Phenomenology” According to the “Positive Unity, Negative Unity (Ego Dissolution), and Other Alterations of the Sense of Self” Model of Mystic-State Experience

The “phenomenology” of (nominally: altered sense of self) positive unity and also add negative unity

compare per the Egodeath theory: transformation from:
literalist ordinary-state possibilism with autonomous control
to:
analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control
(actually includes the first, ending up w/ 2 POVs)

Breau 2023 (Diagram): Unity Includes Interpretations Other than the Neo-Advaita Interpretation of Unity

Main, Outer Circle: The Center and Boundary of Breau’s Conception of Mystical Experience

Unity [is the whole circle; the whole of mystical experience: central focus & boundary]

Dualism (relational mysticism); mystical union [emphasiszes “union” to force this into the Unitive paradigm], Abrahamic mysticism & pantheist Unitive

A Contained, Subset Circle: Where Unity Functions within the Breau Paradigm

Neo Advaita (a contained circle eg merely 1 interpretation of Unitive)

One instance of the Unity model (one circle within the global Unity space) is Neo-Advaita.

Breau thinks that Unity is the case, and that Neo-Advaita is to be rejected or demoted as merely one interpretation of “the Unity experience” and not the best interpretation.

But Breau doesn’t suggest any other specific interpretation of “the Unity experience”, which is a red flag proving that his favored concept, Unity, is identical with Neo-Advaita’s notion of Unity.

It’s nonsensical for Breau to reject the Neo-Advaita interpretation of Unity, while advocating some vague, unspecified “real, correct” interpretation of Unity.

Neo-Advaita is precisely the wrong selfsame model as Unity in general, against Breau.

Rejecting Neo-Advaita is practically the same as rejecting the Unity model.

What’s wrong is not merely Neo-Advaita’s interpretation of Unity; what’s wrong is the Unity model altogether.

The Unity model doesn’t need broadening or adjustment; we need to stop using Unity as the model of mystical experience, and put eternalism-driven control-transformation in place of Unity.

Breau wants to broaden — thus entrench even deeper — our commitment to the Unity model, retaining the Neo-Advaita interpretation of Unity, along with any and every other (vaguely hypothesized) model of Unity.

Notes Above the Breau Diagram

[Breau advocates:] “Don’t only focus on Advaita-styled Unity

[when writers employ the Neo-Adv model, they] must explicitly state [that they are using the Neo-] Advaita interpretation, [as an eliminative] subtractive filter [ie elim ASC experiences that don’t fit the Neo-Advaita model, as “non-mystical”].

Notes to the Left of the Breau Diagram

“the Unity state of consciousness” [vs. saying “the Eternalism state of consciousness”]

What does Breau do with negative, challenging experience? negative unity, ego dissolution

Notes Below the Breau Diagram

Mystical experience = the Unity state of consciousness, all versions, not only the Advaita version ie Pantheist Unitive per Advaita

eg union dualistic relational per Abrahamic religions

“Phenomenology” According to the General Unity (not only Neo-Advaita’s) Model of Mystic-State Experience

missing, intended: “phenomenology” of what, in this paradigm? Of the Unity state of consciousness.

Breau critiques using only the Neo-Advaita model of Unity, advocates considering other models of Unity other than Neo-Advaita’s model of Unity – but doesn’t suggest a different model, because in fact, centering Unity is the same thing as Neo-Advaita.

Hoffman 2025 (Diagram): The Central Focus of the Best Mystical Experience is Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation, not Alleged Eventual Unity

the Hoffman (Eternalism/ Control) Paradigm

Main, Outer Circle: The Center and Boundary of Hoffman’s Conception of Mystical Experience

eternalism-driven control-transformation
eternalism-driven control-transformation
mytheme analogy
2-level, dependent control
best is via psychedelics

A Contained, Subset Circle: Where Unity Functions within the Hoffman Paradigm

Unity [ie, minor, incidental, included but not central nor boundary]

visual distortion

Notes about why have circle showing visual disotrtion: ie, Unity is as unimportant and non-central to mystical experience as mere visual distortion

key, to make sense of OAV dimensions:
Ocean = positive unity;
Angst = negative unity = ego dissolution;
Vision = perceptual distortion

Unity is minor, incidental, included but not central nor boundary.

Unity is as unimportant and non-central to mystical experience as mere visual distortion.

Notes Above the Hoffman Diagram

The essence of mystical experience = eternalism-driven control-transformation

Notes to the Right of the Hoffman Diagram

the Egodeath theory

analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent control

Notes Below the Hoffman Diagram

the Egodeath theory

eternalism-driven control-transformation

“Phenomenology” According to the “Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation” Model of Intense Mystic-State Experience

“phenomenology” of what, in this paradigm? of psychedelics, depicted in the best religious mythology & art & Metal lyrics.
not of cave meditation sensory deprivation;
not of armchair philosophy;
not of academics’ fantasized, outsider constructions.

About the 4 Models of Mystical Experience

In my characterization of the dominant, Unity paradigm, I put ‘Advaita’ first, before ‘Unity’, b/c this model is intensively a whole raft of specific arbitrary philosophies per the neo-Adv. package deal, eg fused with “pure awareness” — such that Katz doesn’t attack unity; he attacks ‘pure awareness’ as a proxy, changing the subject from Unity to awareness.

We can often simply critique “Advaita” instead of “Modern Advaita”; discussing Pop Advaita in current culture. My shorthand for Pop Neo Modern Advaita is just “Advaita”. Actual traditional Advaita is lower relevance for this critique.

It is NOT necessary to deeply analyze Neoplatonism or Advaita in a generous and charitable way, to reject and critique them & how they are used as a safe neutral dummy substitute for the intense mystic altered state.

No matter how great “real Neoplatonism” or “real Advaita” are, they are bogus in that they are used to replace intense mystic altered state by armchair philosophy sky-castles, an avoidance tactic.

The dirty strategy of Neo-Foo is to get rid of the hardest part of control transformation, the mythic peak part, replacing it by elaborate philosophy model of the alleged final, eventual, ultimate, end-state, of positive Unity or harmonious mystical Union.

They are dirty attempts to get God’s mercy, without God’s wrath.

Selling Positive Unity by Censoring Negative Drama of Transformation

Everyone in psychedelics agrees that we need to address risks and not whitewash them. Every article does give some attention to risks – but the Unity paradigm ends up eliminating the risks, exactly as we see in phase 2 of how the the Challenging Experience Questionnaire (CEQ) was constructed.

In phase 1 of making the the Challenging Experience Questionnaire (CEQ) (“initial item pool”), there was balanced attention to risks.

In phase 2 of making the the Challenging Experience Questionnaire (CEQ), the risks were simply discarded by the Marketing dept, so that the Scoring appendix shows that only 3 of 21 Angst items from OAV 1994 were retained, and there is no explanation of judification of omitting 18 of 21 challenging effects — so they silently deleted eg:

  • OAV 1994 Item 54: I was afraid to lose my self-control.
  • MEQ147/129 per Pahnke 1962: Item 15: Fear of losing control. Deleted from MEQ43, and diluted as an item in the broader SOCQ which had 57 distractor items; the item was replaced by a lame distractor item.

todo: MEQ30: are there now 70(!) “distractor items” in the SOCQ that contains Grifty’s shrunken MEQ30?

ie 30 “mystical” items + 70 “distractor” items = 100 items in revised SOCQ?

This item always silently goes missing:
Dread ETCLOC: the experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control.

Neoplatonism and Neo-Advaita sell and market God’s mercy and blissful positive Unity/union, by deleting the scary central part – passing through the threat-guarded gate – and denying God’s wrath.

Positive Advaita Unity, along with “pure consciousness” (an arbitrary addition), and a particular entire Metaphysics brand, bolstered by impotent subtractive explanation (and “ineffability” as an excuse, which even Stace couldn’t swallow and he wrote ALLEGED ineffability.

This “Unity” (covert Neo-Advaita) is an entire, narrow, particular Paradigm, a bad, package deal.

Translating OAV’s Dimension Names, to Expose Dittrich’s Use of the Same Old Unity Paradigm

To make sense of OAV dimensions, “decoding” their coded language into what the writers are actually thinking:

Ann Taves exposes that “ego dissolution” is actually firmly conceptualized within the Unitive paradigm; it’s “ego dissolution” as an inexplicable, “negatively valenced” side-effect that often occurs within the Unity experience/ state of consciousness.

The clueless writers in the Unity paradigm attempt to explain ego dissolution — = what we dread = in terms of the Unity paradigm.

O = Ocean = positive unity per the Neo-Advaita model.

A = Angst/Dread “of ego dissolution [sic]” = negative unity = ego dissolution (for when the Neo-Advaita model CONSTANTLY FAILS in actual, psychedelic practice – the inexplicable bad trip is explained as, “it’s your fault, for resisting unity and cessation of the self/other boundary illusion” (per a recent paper)).

Vision = perceptual distortion (the theorists don’t attempt to force visionary perception into their Unity paradigm; these items/effects are treated as non-Unitive)

Walter Stace 1960 Insults and Disparages Western Mysticism, Elevates Crude, Inarticulate Eastern Religious Philosophy Instead

Exposed by Jeffrey Breau 2023 article. Against Mosurinjohn’s 2023 article that claims that Stace overly favored Christian mysticism.

I don’t have her article he cites; I expect it to be as mediocre as a recent Mosur. article I wrote about (probably in email).

Articles Reference:
Moving Past Mysticism in Psychedelic Science (Article Debate Series)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/

Houot Insults and Disparages Western Mysticism, Elevates Crude Sham Instead

Shamans have control in the Psilocybin state.

Western mystics fail to have control in the Psilocybin state.

How do we assess “having control”? Apples and oranges. I assume Western mysticism runs circles around shamanism re: height of development represented in the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}, and in Merkavah mysticism.

Theory-Driven, not Crude Notion of “Evidence” Driven: Reconceiving “Evidence” and “Theory”

I aim for cartoon approximation that has great explanatory power.

I don’t care what happened historically. I’m a theorist, not a historian. Good historiography first needs a good, sound, compelling, coherent theory. Not “more evidence”, crudely conceived.

I’m against dumb focus on “evidence” done with crude Theory.

Critique of the “Positive Unity” Model of “Mystical Experience” vs. the “Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation” Model

A Development: Instead of Hazily Dismissing the Pop Positive Unity Model of “Mystical Experience” as “a Mere Beginners’ Experience & Model”, I Now Appreciate the False, Unity Model as a Fully Articulated, Detailed, Particular, Dominant, “The Old Theory” (per Thomas Kuhn’s Model of Paradigm Replacement)

It is useful for the Egodeath theory (analogical psychedelic eternalism with dependent, 2-level control) to define a specific “the old theory” to help define “the new theory”.

I previously posted a ton against Amanita, Secret Christian Amanita Cult, Eleusis, ergot, … in favor of Explicit Cubensis paradigm;

Canterbury replaces Plaincourault

Forget the Amanita-based proxy lone art, Plaincourault fresco.

Replaced by Great Canterbury Psalter & the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}; following Huggins call for a new proxy image: bet everything, on the single image: Day 3 of Creation, folio f11 of Great Canterbury Psalter by Eadwine.

Mythology, Classic Metal, & the Medieval Art Genre of {mushroom-trees} Corroborate Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation, and Disconfirm Hindu, Indian, Eastern, Orientalist, Neo-Advaita Vedanta

Everything disconfirms Neo-Advaita.

Many things confirm the Egodeath theory and disconfirm the “Positive Unity” model that’s all-dominant and entrenched (and produced garbage like the Hopkins Religious Leaders study with its Conflicts of Interest section; fake Science for purchase):

  • religious mythology
  • acid Metal
  • Merkavah mysticism
  • the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}

Attack on Neo-Advaita: Anti-Rationality; Inarticulate; Useless; Fantasy-Based; Orientalist; Subtractive Explanation

People are understandably going insane from Pop Advaita propaganda that doesn’t even try to explain anything, like:

  • you don’t exist
  • nothing is real
  • eliminate thinking
  • the mind is an illusion
  • the world doesn’t exist
  • everything is unreal
  • eliminating the self/other boundary = Transcendent Knowledge & enlightenment.

It’s beyond parody.

Subtractive Explanation Is Failure of Model Specification

My term subtractive explanation: Neo Advaita SUCKS because it communicates in vague, inarticulate ways:

“X doesn’t exist”

“the self/other boundary is an illusion that ceases being projected by the mind”

True explanation – a real explanatory model – speaks positively.

Fake pseudo-explanation is parasitical and destructive: it takes mental constructs and then smashes and deletes them, replacing them with inarticulateness, giving the EXCUSE of “ineffable” and “beyond description”. FAIL.

Ways of Thinking of Eastern Peoples (Nakamura, 1981)

Ways of Thinking of Eastern Peoples: India, China, Tibet, Japan
East-West Center Press
Hajime Nakamura, 1981 (revised edition)
https://www.amazon.com/Ways-Thinking-Eastern-Peoples-Translation/dp/0824800788/

My mood or inspirational mood lately is to DUMP on [Psychedelic] Sham [anism] narrative, and DUMP on Eastern religion.

I want to cast Neo Advaita in the worst possible light, which is all too easy.

Against Ken Wilber (Yet More Covert-Advaita)

Given that what Ken Wilber is selling, a bunk product, is Neo Advaita, it’s bad that he doesn’t make that clear.

Even before my Jan. 1988 breakthrough — since 1986 — it was obvious that Ken Wilber had severe limitations.

Wilber presents an elaborate, 16-stage developmental model built around a bunk engine, of covert Neo Advaita.

Advaita = Pop Nonduality; Late 1800s Covert Transnational Political Unity Disguised as Mystical Experience

‘Advaita’, especially Modern Advaita or Neo Advaita, means a certain particular package deal of Eastern non-thinking; Advaita means non-duality, of a very particular brand and flavor with a ton of useless and alien metaphysics]

text messages today, Nov. 26, 2025, [todo: Turkey emoji] sent to A. about the comeuppance and poetic justice, the Hopkins disaster article about 2015 psilocybin Religious Leaders study:
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/11/27/metal-merkavah-mysticism-the-perfect-antidote-to-fake-neo-advaita-positive-unity-sledge-2025/#text-message-thread-wed.-nov.-26-2025

“Author Disclosure Statement” Section of Hopkins Religious Leaders Study

Would you like to purchase some Science Conclusions?

The psilocybin was ingested in 2015 [confirm].
The article was published in May 2025.

Copy/pasted from .pdf, formatting added:

Article title:
Effects of Psilocybin on Religious and Spiritual Attitudes and Behaviors in Clergy from Various Major World Religions

Author Disclosure Statement (p. 17-18)

“The Johns Hopkins Medicine Institutional Review Board (JHM IRB) conducted an audit of the JHU site (IRB00036973—“Effects of Psilocybin-facilitated Experience on the Psychology and Effectiveness of Professional Leaders in Religion”) and concluded that the following must be reported to all journals and disclosed in all publications where data related to this study may be published:

(1) There were two unapproved study team members, one who was also a study funding sponsor, directly engaged in the research.

(2) There was an additional approved study team member whose role as a
funding sponsor of the study was not disclosed to the IRB and who directly led the qualitative analysis.

(3) Conflicts of interest related to the two individuals who were engaged in the research and also served as funding sponsors were not appropriately disclosed nor managed.

(4) The funding sponsorship for this study was not disclosed
to the JHM IRB.”

Planned/Needed Posts

Inventory of {balance scale} Motifs in Great Canterbury Psalter

https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/06/11/eadwine-images-in-great-canterbury-psalter-commentary-interpretation/#balance-scale
Sunday, Nov. 30, 2025: I finally added pictures in that section.
todo: each folio image (8x) should have a detailed zoom crop and the full image crop.

Conflicts of Interest (“Author Disclosure Statement”) in Hopkins “Religious Leaders Study”

Maybe post an article specifically about the Conflicts section of Hopkins article, it’s that much of an important milestone for Kitchens to document psychedelic pseudo science. See present article, section:
“Author Disclosure Statement” Section of Hopkins Religious Leaders Study
Would you like to purchase some Science Conclusions?

Slagging on Ken Wilber

I’m slightly disgusted (since before 1988) with Ken Wilber. A long time ago (though seemingly recently), I posted at Egodeath Yahoo Group revealing that Ken Wilber is nothing but warmed over, junk Advaita that totally fails to deliver its vague, mirage-like, ever-receding promises.

Wilber’s airplane never gets off the ground, and never can, inherently, because his engine is bunk: Neo Advaita.

The Death of Hopkins Psychedelic Mystical Science Is an Opportunity for Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation

December 1, 2025

Don’t battle competitors; wait for them to fail on their own, just keep standing while the bad theories fall.

The Advaita Positive Unity model of “mysticism” is a bad, failed, irrelevant, useless theory with a hidden political agenda, lacking psychedelics (Vivek 1893 – Stace 1960, taken up by Leary/Pahnke 1962, through Griffiths 2025 TERMINUS). My collegauees …. 3 names I try to recall:

Wm Richards (w/ W Pahnke)

Thom Robts – i preordered his book and “hated” it; puzzled over why does this book leave me utterly cold? Doubt I posted a review at https://www.amazon.com , b/c I couldn’t figure til lately, why I hated it. Recent answer: b/c it’s Neo Advaita Positive Unity, a false model of Transcendent Knowledge.

CSP

I now relate to the article title “Moving Past Mysticism” in a new way: we in Psychedelic Science indeed must move past “Mysticism” Misconceived as Centered on Nondual Unity.

I’m firmly committed to maximal entheogen theory of religion. If it’s not psychedelic, it’s not real religion.

Any exceptions prove the rule.

Spare me the cliche from every lame academic, “other methods can/ could/ might/ may produce same effect as 10 hits of acid” – to the extent that’s true, that’s irrelevant and inconsequential, and beside the point.

By far the main point of reference is ingesting the flesh of Christ, the Teacher of Righteousness.

I made that move in 1997 summary spec, listing psychedelics alongside schizophrenia.

I am hypocrite but I can justify why I wrote that, better justification than other writers have.

My 1988 theory, summarized in 1997, is FIRMLY from study of psychedelics, NOT substantially coming from meditation or drumming (rhythmic driving) or dancing or hyperventilation or not of hyperventilation during cave meditation sensory deprivation while dancing, chanting, and drumming after fasting [I here mock by piling up & summing, every stupid academic theory at the same time].

My point, and view, didn’t change from 1988 to 1997, and that remains a fair point.

I don’t deny that other ways sometimes produce same effect as high dose psychedelics – but that’s of little importance or relevance.

I do not give a public professaion of faith like every academic, for purpose of appeasing critics.

Unlike academics, I don’t “punch radical” by saying “Some ppl go too far by saying only psychedelics work; other ways can/ could/ might/ may produce psychedelic effects.”

I don’t market myself as more trustworthy and moderate, by lowering psychedelics and elevating other ways. I loathe that strategy and self-marketing.

I am committed to being the most radical and extreme, not allowing evil future-me to be more radical.

Other ways give a tiny glimpse of a weak psychedelic experience, no more than that.

Non-drug methods fail to deliver the full eventual control transformation that psychedelics potentially deliver and sometimes do deliver.

I hold, in 2025 as in 1988: the best mystics, best art, best myth, best shamanism, comes from none other than psychedelics.

That’s the best shape and balance of the best theory of entheogen scholarship and mental model transformation.

It is indeed noteworthy that the mind can produce same state — to some extent — without psychedelics, but that is no more than a minor side point, and we MUST keep the focus firmly centered on none other than psychedelics.

Do not elevate other ways to same high level as psychedelics; do not lower psychedelics to the same level as other ways. Psychedelics utterly and totally tower over other ways.

Johnson’s right that psychedelic pseudo science must move past “mysticism” – b/c every time any of those articles say “mysticism”, they do not mean mysticism; they mean Neo-Advaita.

I mean Neo-Advaita in a looser, more informal sense than the Wiki article of that title, that’s more narrow and specific.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-Advaita

Deliver a Successful Explanatory Model of Psychedelic Eternalism-Driven Control-Transformation [PEDCT]

For that purpose, chronology revisionism (subtract 700 revolutions of the Earth between 1 AD & 2000 AD) is outer periphery, non-essential. Inner periphery: …. revisit the 4 onion layers now with failure of Hopkins in mind.

Ahistoricity of religious founder figures is peripheral not Core, for the Egodeath theory. Add Mister Jesus, and the Egodeath theory remains basically the same.

The Hopkins Faceplant of Psychedelic Pseudo Science Is an Opportunity for Transformative Rebirth of the Field of Cognitive Psychedelics

December 1, 2025

The Doorway / Guarded Gateway of Cognitive Psychedelics is, experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control.

Replace Neo-Advaita’s Paradigm/ Worldview/ Project by Plain Scientific Model of Possibilism experiential mode psychedelic eternalism eternalism-driven control-transformation Steering by the Stars of:

  • Psychedelic Experience (More Like OAV [Ocean/ Angst/ Vision] 1994 than Mystical Experience Questionnaire (MEQ) 1962) and
  • The Best Religious Mythology (including the best religious art ie the art which best analogizes psychedelic eternalism-driven control-transformation.

Stace 1960 Positive Unity model of “mystical experience” is an entire Game: with its own internal

  • system of value judgment; its own
  • definition of the goal of the game;
  • what are we to aspire to;
  • what’s the goal of Transcendent Knowledge,
  • what’s the standard reference to look to, to define what Transcendent Knowledge should be? A paradigm; worldview; game; value-system; purpose in life.
  • A set of questions, answers, standards of reference, objectives, rules, and end-state.

Why are we here?

  • Per Neo-Advaita: to experience lack of self/other boundary.
  • Per the Egodeath theory (psychedelic eternalism): eternalism-driven control-transformation; mental model transformation from possibilism to eternalism (to end up w/ 2 POVs).

“The best religious mythology” includes the best religious diagrammatic art, ie:

  • Great Canterbury Psalter – eg f134 row 1, left 2/5, ie, what John Lash uploaded around 2008, re-found by me mid-Nov 2020: that portion in particular was a God-send, confirming the Egodeath theory — like what I wished for from Jesus & Paul in 1998 before those figures instantly became mythic-only.
  • the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}
  • branching-message mushroom trees;
  • {mushrooms}, {branching}, {handedness}, and {stability} motifs

[funny, i only remember the finger muscle memory of [m b h s] keyboard shortcut – i remember the location of the keys, not which letters or motif-words]

Text Message, December 1, 2025

final nail in coffin, for Pop Psychedelic pseudo science, as far as im concerned, is the conflicts of interest in the Hopkins Religious Leaders Study – where the industry leader, J Hopkins Medical, faceplanted-to-death.

that failure, like an ego death, cleared the way for what regrouping/ reframing/ rebirth opportunity?

past tense: what WAS the Vivek/ Theosophy/ Stace model of “mystical experience”?

A life philosophy, set of values, outlook, & transnational political philosophy; a Trojan horse, grand narrative that took advantage of / leveraging “mysticism”, up to Stace 1960

Pahnke 1962 folded that model (master narrative of What Transcendent Knowledge Is All About) into psychedelic science

the latter agenda is, according to Christian whistleblower /critic/ watchdogs, to replace Christianity by a new, global religion

Phase 1: engineer a political-tuned scheme around “mysticism” – culminated in Stace 1960. book Phil & Mysticism (out of print, its so outdated)
Phase 2: add: psychedelic, leveraging Big Pharma; started with Pahnke 1962.

am i merely, narrowly quibbling over what “mystical experience” should most accurately mean? or, replacing an entire covert-agenda PROJECT of social engineering??

what should we care about, in mysticism / psychedelc alt-state/ religious mythology?

what is the best source of truth for defining what sort of scope of theory to construct?

Discard the Theosophy Modern Advaita Agenda & its value-system (killed by Hopkins Religious Leaders Study fiasco a few months ago); replace that by a sufficiently encompassing paradigm that sails by the stars of:

psychedelic experience (per OAV 1994 questionnaire)

religious myth as analogy describing the best, peak asc

Since the English-translated, Transnational paradigm died in Johns Hopkins (even the topmost inner circle of Roland Griffiths & Matthew Johnson imploded!), what replacement opportunity is there, to Reset?

[WHAT DATE OF DISASTER HOPKINS ARTICLE? May 31, 2025 – same day as my church’s inaugural yurt gongs event!
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/#Effects-of-Psilocybin-on-Religious-and-Spiritual-Attitudes-and-Behaviors-in-Clergy

The day the Psychedelic Nondual Unity model of “mystical experience” died.]

Form a model of how the mental world model transforms, centered on the transformation process – not centered on the idealized, alleged, final, ultimate, tranquil Unitive nondual state.

In Jan 1988, I said: Here is a way to absolutely cancel egoic thinking and transform to another specific model, far more than the [Theosophy] Neo Advaita brand of “nondual Unitive” concern that’s driving the Journal of Transpersonal Psychology & Ken Wilber.

Separation = Bad Trip = Ego Dissolution = Non-Mystical Experience, in Breau’s Paradigm

If mystical = positive Unitive, non-mystical = negative Separative.

Every word, as used by a paradigm, is a paradigm-loaded code word:

  • “multiplicity”
  • the self/other boundary
  • self = boundary = the separate self
  • mystical experience (= the Positive Nondual Unitive experience, AS conceptualized by Theosophy Neo-Advaita – welded together, as a package deal, with a Trojan horse-load of arbitrary additional metaphysics premises: “pure awareness”, “ineffability”, “common core” [a good idea, badly implemented]; “the perennial [armchair] philosophy”, etc.)

Every word and phrasing that I employ, is loaded carrying the Egodeath theory.

See Also

Walter Pahnke 1962/1963 PhD thesis
Asserts the 1960 Stace narrow concept of mystical experience; asserts Neo-Advaita nondual, suspension of the self/other boundary = mystic-state enlightenment & Transcendent Knowledge.
Unitive Mysticism, shuts out Relational Mysticism [eternalism with 2-level, dependent control depicted in Great Canterbury Psalter f177 and f107 (lifted up by God/Christ)]
Drugs and Mysticism: Psychedelic Drug Experience and the Mystical State (Pahnke, 1963)

Alan Houot 2019 Masters thesis
Asserts: Shamanism good, mysticism bad
Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control (Houot, 2019)

Ann Taves 2020
Asserts: Mystical positive unity should be considered together with non-mystical, negative, ego dissolution [resistance to removal of the self-other boundary]
Mystical and Other Alterations in Sense of Self: An Expanded Framework for Studying Nonordinary Experiences (Ann Taves, May 2020)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/#mystical-and-other-alterations-in-sense-of-self-an-expanded-framework-for-studying-nonordinary-experiences-taves-2020

Jeffrey Breau 2023
Psychometric brahman, psychedelic science: Walter Stace, transnational Vedanta, and the Mystical Experience Questionnaire (Breau & Gillis-Smith, Nov. 2023)
https://egodeaththeory.org/2025/05/15/moving-past-mysticism-in-psychedelic-science-article-debate-series/#psychometric-brahman

Metal Merkavah Mysticism: The Perfect Antidote to Fake Neo-Advaita Positive Unity (Sledge, 2025)

Michael Hoffman, draft started 8:15 p.m. November 26, 2025

Contents:

links work on desktop Chrome/Edge:

Video Series: Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism and Hekhalot Literature Seminar (Sledge, Nov. 21, 2025)

Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism and Hekhalot Literature Seminar Announcement
YoutTube channel: ESOTERICA [Dr. Justin Sledge]
https://youtu.be/J8QE5Fsse1A

Videos: Merkavah Mysticism Seminar (Sledge, ESOTERICA, 2025)

YouTube playlist by Dr. Justin Sledge:
Title of playlist:
Merkavah Mysticism Seminar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8QE5Fsse1A&list=PLZ__PGORcBKxbM4y3wcYSObaUsr4guYAn
Parts 1-15+

Intro vid:
June 27, 2025
title:
Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism and Hekhalot Literature Seminar Announcement

“Hundreds of years prior to the rise of the Kabbalah, shaman-like rabbinic mystics were described as having made the terrifying and awe-inspiring descent into the Divine Palaces.

“There they met with and bypassed fearsome angels with magical codes, gained control over angelic powers, became transformed into beings of fire, gained vast wisdom and mounted the very throne of G!d to carefully measure the vast dimensions of the divine body, join in the heavenly liturgy or be transformed into beings of fire.

“These experiences and their praxes are recorded in about 50 manuscripts now known as the Hekhalot (lit. palaces) literature.

“Outside of specialists this late-classical form of (a)(de)scent mysticism is poorly understood and little appreciated.

“In this course, we will explore the foundations, social origins, myth-world, praxes and the afterlife of Merkavah Mysticism over the course of 12-14 weeks starting Sunday July 20th at 2pm EST a bit like the Agrippa seminar last year.”

Course Syllabus: To Behold the Throne: An Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1URUIb_AkZGM3hXzTnPFAwQYkZf_WgL0Q9wWWqSr2ug0/edit?tab=t.0

Course Materials & Readings: Merkavah Class
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1-93Z0g92p4xMTFRjk5KznFvh65oRjFAo

Merkavah Course, Part 15 of 15

video title:
Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism – 15 of 15 – The Twilight of the Merkavah
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8f7euCwchs
Nov. 21, 2025
Desc: slightly different than for Intro:

“Hundreds of years prior to the rise of the Kabbalah, shaman-like rabbinic mystics were described as having made the terrifying and awe-inspiring descent into the Divine Palaces.

“There they met with and bypassed fearsome angels with magical codes, gained control over angelic powers, became transformed into beings of fire, gained vast wisdom and mounted the very throne of G!d to carefully measure the vast dimensions of the divine body.

“These experiences and their praxes are recorded in about 50 manuscripts now known as the Hekhalot (lit. palaces) literature.

“Outside of specialists this late-classical form of (a)(de)scent mysticism is poorly understood and little appreciated.

“In this course, we will explore the foundations, social origins, myth-world, praxes and the afterlife of Merkavah Mysticism.”

Text Message Thread Wed. Nov. 26, 2025

The day before Thanksgiving. 🦃

Forbidden to Behold the Throne; Here’s How We Do It

it is strictly prohibited to behold the throne

it is customary to ignore this prohibition

here’s how to behold the throne, in a 15+ part Summer university course 4 days ago

Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism and Hekhalot Literature Seminar Announcement
YoutTube channel: ESOTERICA [Dr. Justin Sledge]
https://youtu.be/J8QE5Fsse1A

Merkavah Sledgehammer to Entrenched All-Dominant False Model, Advaita

perfect antidote & sledgehammer ⚒️💥 to the all-dominant, totally entrenched, fantasy-based Positive Advaita, false & fabricated model of “mystical experience”

partially exposed by Taves 2020 & sgc Harvard member Jeffrey Breau 2023 who reached same concl as me-independently:

Walter Stace 1960 makes a narrow model of “mystical experience” thats just Neo Advaita w/ its raft of metaphysical interp, a package deal. a particular Positive Unity phil of religious experiencing

Stace (& therefore ALL psychedelic pseudo science, based directly on Stace lineage) — and Alan Houot Masters dissert 2019 — insults & demotes Abrahamic, Relational Dualistic mysticism as inferior and amateur and failed, because resorts to “surrender” and fear

“Mysticism” marketed as unicorns & rainbows is a fake product; the ulterior motive: transnational political unity disguised as nondual Advaita Unity boundary-removal —

but Relational mysticism in Abrahamic religions deeply disagrees (& has been silenced by psychedelic pseudo science)

🦄💨🌈 💦🔫🤨

Metal mysticism & myth disproves fake pop Neo-Advaita’s coverup operation

A’s Reply: Bias Against Relational Mysticism in Favor of Westernized Advaita’s Unitive Mysticism; Theosophy’s Biased Conception of “World Religions”

“I need to find some of my papers from my graduate course, as this bias goes back to the historical origins of comparative religious studies and the influence of the Theosophy movement on the idea of “World Religions” in the 19th c.”

Disaster of the Long-Awaited Hopkins Religious Leaders 2015 Psilocybin Research

im perversely revelling in the total disaster of the long-awaited Hopkins Religious Leaders 2015 psil research:

poetic justice for the entire field & the entire related field of “theories of mystic-state enlightenment”, that wrongly made narrow Neo-Avaita (the self/other, boundary-suspension model [Positive-only Unitive]🦄💨🌈) the be-all, end-all, definitive, all-dominant model adopted wholesale hook/line/sinker by EVERY writer:

when the Hopkins paper finally flopped across the finish line a month ago, has a big Conflicts of Interest section. “science conclusions” for purchase
$$$ 🤑💰🤥👖🔥🤞
i hope to send u screengrab of that pdf section

Describes Merkavah Mysticism as Metal

effective subtitle of Dr Sledge series:
Metal Merkavah Mysticism
🤘🎸😈😱

🤘🎸😈😱

Mythology, Metal Lyrics, & Art Disprove Relevance of Unitive Mysticism

myth, acid Metal, & Merkavah, & the medieval art genre of {mushroom-trees}, confirm my centering of threat-driven fearsome boundary-crossing, against Pop Neo Avaita eg Ken Wilber (bleh) that cant get off the ground 🚫🛫
the planned, companion Hopkins article was cancelled in disgrace,
as explained to us by Michael Pollan at UCBerk a few months ago (some [of our church members] were there in person)

Michael Pollan Replied: The Bogus “Mystical Experience” Questionnaires Are Already Being Replaced by Broader, More Realistic Questionnaires

Pollan replied to my extreme/ harsh question:
“Will the bogus “mystical experience” questionnaires be replaced by broader, more realistic ones?”
“yes, theyre already working on it”

A’s Reply: More Varied Perspectives Needed in Psychedelic Research

“So clear that more varied perspectives are needed in psychedelic research”

Angels at War with the Mystics

Sledge manages to tell a consistent, useful, coherent presentation, 

despite freaky fractured sources

angels at war with the mystics

“This Myth Is Psychedelic-Styled (without Using Psychedelics)”

Sledge constantly, casually describes journeying-myth as “psy’c”

 – while claiming, “no evidence”

i say: 

sound theory interacts with the ability to discover various evidence – proved resoundingly _in general_, eg Great Canterbury Psalter 

many kinds of evidence are plentiful, from a suitably informed pov

effective theory/evidence feedback, across the broad genre of the best religious myth

not super concerned about evidence re: any one brand of such myth

Ezekiel eat scroll sweet in mouth bitter in stomach then visions

In Mythology, Ingesting Always Means Psychedelics

their rule:
u must bake ur bread urself

/ end of text message thread

Mushroom Bread 🍄‍🟫🥖

Video title:
Introduction to Merkavah Mysticism – 11 of 15 – Qualifications & Praxes of the Merkavah
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBBRSqCqKSI&t=2176s (36:16)

Dr. Justin Sledge’s YouTube series just finished, about Merkavah (Merkabah) / Hekalot (palaces) mysticism.  

In episode 11, Sledge says:

* There’s no evidence of psychedelics in the Hekalot literature.

* The only ingesting reported in the literature was bread and water. See “raven’s bread” in entheogen scholarship eg Ruck. See ergot leavening in Dan Merkur book.

* They (men; husbands) were required to bake their own bread.  The cover-story that Sledge swallows is: wife might be unclean. Real reason: keep control of psilocybin bread.

* There was no wine in this tradition.

Dr. Sledge doesn’t discuss the recipe for this bread; that’s a wide opening for the maximal entheogen theory of religion: 

Psilocybin, such as Liberty Cap (grows everywhere) doesn’t doesn’t break down at 425 degrees F (baking temp.)

Sledge simply takes for granted, that “bread” means ordinary bread – which makes no sense for the genre of altered state mythology, in which the suitable kind of ingestion is magical bread.

Assume such a magical ingredient in the Merkavah mystics’ (“descenders to the throne”) self-baked bread – now we have a workable explanation, instead of fabricating made-up explanations for how they battled with angels to behold the throne.

Sledge attempts to make the following techniques produce the same effects as high-dose psychedelics:

  • isolation
  • bathing
  • fasting

ie, a list of all academics’ usual stand-ins – ANYTHING BUT DRUGS.

If isolation and bathing and fasting produced the same effects as high-dose psychedelics, high school & college students would be using isolation and bathing instead of psychedelics.

The sensible, plausible solution, based on relatively reliable effects, is psychedelics such as Liberty Caps, more than accompanying techniques such as isolation, bathing, or “contemplative prayer” (academics’ code-word for Meditation).

Merkavah Is Mysticism, Despite Leading to Encounter with God but not Union with God

I’m alienated from Neoplatonism and apophatic theology.

Episode 1 of Merk Seminar raises the question of “Is this mysticism? If mysticism = Neoplatonism union with God, Merkavah isn’t mysticism.

The proposition that Merkavah isn’t mysticism b/c Merkavah only leads to encountering God, but not identifying with God, is patently nonsense and too narrow, arbitrarily narrow of a definition of ‘mysticism’.

My 4 diagrams of:

  • Stace model, per 1963 Walter Pahnke PhD dissertation under Tim Leary.
  • Ann Taves model in 2020 article.
  • Jeffrey Breau model in 2023 article.

Image: Ezekiel Eating Scroll

Features:

  • Weight on Right foot
  • Left hand makes the YI shape; “the hand shape”
  • Eats the open scroll
  • God’s Right hand from hidden in cloud, holds scroll.

image search
https://www.google.com/search?udm=2&q=merkavah+mysticism
https://www.google.com/search?udm=2&q=merkabah+mysticism

See Also

pending

Drugs and Mysticism: Psychedelic Drug Experience and the Mystical State (Pahnke, 1963)

Michael Hoffman, mobile draft started 6:41 pm sat, Nov. 15, 2025

photo: Michael Hoffman, 7:00 pm Sat, Nov. 15, 2025
photo: Michael Hoffman, 7:00 pm Sat, Nov. 15, 2025

Contents:

  • headings

Citation

inferior, condensed title on cover:

Drugs and Mysticism: An Analysis of the Relationship between Psychedelic Drugs and the Mystical Consciousness

better, expanded title on p. 2:

Drugs and Mysticism: An Analysis of the Relationship between Psychedelic Drug Experience and the Mystical State of Consciousness

Harvard University Press
Walter Pahnke, June 1963

Psilosophy.info – Full text of Pahnke’s 1963 dissertation book, created from MAPS scans of the typed dissertation:
http://en.psilosophy.info/drugs_and_mysticism.html 

Thanks to 2015 site that converted MAPS’ scans to formatted text w links: psilosophy.info

References page for psychedelic pseudo science:

References for Psychedelic Psychometrics Questionnaires

SOCQ/Mystical Experience Questionnaire (MEQ) lineage:

expose: claims there are item-count 147 in Apx C, but only 129 items:

WHERE ARE THE OTHER 18 items?? MEQ147/129. a problem.

this shows again how powerful my analysis and B S uncovered simply by the technique of “item counts”.

Date of Marsh Chapel Good Friday Experiment

determined & added to wikip by Michael Hoffman:

April 20, 1962 (4/20)

phd thesis June 1963

pdf scans on web (by MAPS) in year: __

text provided on web apparently 2015 (check same url at Archive)

also see Harvard dissertations catalog?

Motive of this Page

in conjunction w Taves 2020 then Bro 2023 questioning A LITTLE the Unity model, but really merely tweaking it; no real challemge is offered to the terrible all-dominent, entrenched model – diespite all the scare quotes and empty promises of internal critique and empty lip service talk of :

Expanding “to all changes of sense of self” (Taves) &

“negative as well as positive experiemce of Unity” (Bro).

& critique of Otto p 32 in Pahnke.

these acknowledgments and field-internal critiques are merely corrective circles epicycles — essentially just more of the same wrong core model — to try to bolster the field’s failed model like the earth-centered, circles-committed, Old Theory, before the circa 1687 switch to the sun-centered, New Theory.

both the field of Ken Wilber Advaita model of Transcendent Knowledge (mysticism sans psychedelics ) , and, psychedelic pseudo science per Griffiths, Leary, etc (mysticism model with psychedelics )

remember: EVERY writer holds the unanimous false dichotomy: “mysticism was not via psychedelics”. The wrong, Unity model is fully entrenched; even adjustments efforts just further entrench the same old, same old. inorder to avoid the real deal, E D C T

eternalism-driven (threatened-driven) control transformation [EDCT]

driven by revelation perceptionof the experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control

Item 54 in OAV’94: I was afraid to lose my self-control.

Item 15 in SOCQ/MEQ147[Pahnke 1962]: Fear of losing control. p. 97 Apx C; p 113 — Disturbing – Fear & Anxiety group of 6 items. in the Not Mysticism Apx G; relegated to the next to last page of thesis body. https://en.psilosophy.info/drugs_and_mysticism.html#group_ii_disturbing_changes_in_attitude_and_behavior

todo: link to sections of thesis like above! 👍

Must Read Chapter III: The Definition of Mysticism

if you read any passage, other than the spot-quoted passages, read the entire chapter 3 of this thesis. https://en.psilosophy.info/drugs_and_mysticism.html#chapter_iii_the_definition_of_mysticism

the orig meq / socq questionnaire is in Apx C: https://en.psilosophy.info/drugs_and_mysticism.html#appendix_c_post_drug_questionnaire_with_significance_levels_of_the_difference_between_scores_of_experimentals_and_controls

see the many motifs of “open scroll held by sage = awareness of being under threat” in Great Canterbury Psalter

This thesis is the Best Document to Track How the Unity model of mystical experience was baked into psychedelic pseudo science

We must study this thesis, to grasp psychedelic pseudo science – how the wrong model of mystical experience came to totally dominate non psychedelic & psychedelic models conceptions of ASC/ mystical experience/ the mystic altered state.

it’s a super-key doc; the pivotal moment when psychedelic pseudo science was spawned around incorpg Stace lineage model of mystical experience as Unity, Modern Advaita, non-dual, Eastern non-explanation non relevant non useful substitutive avoidance to shut out Eternalism control transformation.

The Later-Censored Item 15: Fear of Losing Control

item 15 mentioned 2x:

Apx C p 97; see pic

next -to-last page: Disturbing instead of mystical experience p 113 good grouping of items in “Fear and Anxiety”, 6 items:

5. Terror or fear.

8. Panic.

15. Fear of losing control.

46. Insecurity.

51. Anxiety.

Cover-Up of the Tower Escapee

“one door was not possible to lock” p. 42 pahnke

https://www.en.psilosophy.info/recollections_of_the_good_friday_experiment_interview_with_huston_smith.html —

“As the chemical came over me, I began to be aware of a mounting disorder in the chapel. …

“from out of this bizarre mix [of jealous, joking, short-changed controls & the winning experimentals], one of our number emerged.

He arose from his pew, walked up the aisle, and with uncertain steps mounted the chapel’s modest pulpit.

Thumbing through its Bible for a few moments, he then mumbled a brief incoherent homily, blessed the congregation with the sign of the cross, and started back down the aisle.

But instead of returning to his pew, he marched to the rear entrance of the chapel and exited.“

Mentions of fear, control transformation, eternalism

Item 15: Fear of losing control

expose! where did this go in meq43 (year?), followed by meq30? deletion of psychedelic effects, like during awful construction of the Challenging Experience Questionnaire (CEQ)

The Mysteriously Shrinking MEQ147 [but only 129] in 1962; MEQ43 in 1969 or 1975; MEQ30 in 2012 (MEQ0 when?)

2012: https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/01/17/references-for-psychedelic-psychometrics-questionnaires/#SOCQ-MEQ30

from alleged 147 / actual 129 items in Pahnke 1963, to only 43 items — the “positive = mystical” items only?? — in Richards 1969 or 1975

SOCQ = 100 items incl 100-43=57 Distractor Items); those 43 Positive Unity items are the MEQ43.

Solved!

Q: What became of Item 15: Fear of losing control? in 1963 MEQ147/139?

Ans: The items not positive unity were relegated to “Distractor items” in SOCQ

my SOCQ page: https://egodeaththeory.org/2022/12/23/socq-states-of-consciousness-questionnaire/ — find item 15… lame!

It became:

Item 66. Frustrating attempt to control the experience.

https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/01/17/references-for-psychedelic-psychometrics-questionnaires/#MEQ43-Pahnke-1969

Frightened by loss of control

“The tenth experimental subject had what he termed an interesting “psychological” and “aesthetic” experience for the first three-fourth of his experience, but then became frightened by loss of control and spent the remaining time in a terrifying fight to overcome the drug effects.

“He would not be interested in repeating the experience because his most predominant memory of the experience was that of fear.

“Six months later, in Part I of the followup questionnaire, he considered this fear-experience slightly harmful because “in a mob panic-situation, I feel I would be less likely to maintain a calm objective position than I might have formerly.”

“During the interview he admitted that he had gone into the experience “as a psychological experiment” and had done no serious devotional preparation.

“His “inspirational” reading while the drug was taking effect consisted of studying some Psalms for a course in the Old Testament.

“His interpretation of his experience was a “psychotic episode.””

Passages to Excerpt

Find: psychotic, psychosis

Find: dread

Find: fear

Find: separateness [grouped w fear, in the Unity paradigm]

The “Unity” vs. “Eternalism-driven control transformation” model of mystical experience

map the equivalent constructs across the two paradigms, to compare & contrast the two explanatory models.

Eternalism ~= Unity

“the One” is soaked with eternalism; its not the same as Eastern, Modern Advaita, nondual Unity.

this Eastern bad style of expl is not the same as the One in antiquity. tho comparable.

Eastern, subtractive, pseudo-explanation has no useful/ relevance to control transformation that’s driven by threat; by the experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control

Eastern Bad; Shams Bad; Western Good, More Developed

Eastern, unitive mysticism is less developed than Western, Relational, eternalism-driven control transformation.

2-level, dependent control = Relational mysticism; see Great Canterbury Psalter f177 Left; & the other folio similar w God making Jesus lift the demon-threatened guy by right arm from rock ossuary.

Shamanism is bad/ inferior/ underdeveloped, too: against Alan Houot’s masters thesis , Shams fail to engage & discover eternalism-driven control transformation.

Shams are inferior to Western mystical experience that’s eternalism-driven control transformation.

Eastern phil’ers of religion are inferior to Western mystical experience that’s eternalism-driven control transformation.

the Unity, non-dual, Modern Advaita, boundary-removal, Eastern crude non-explanation” model of the mystic altered state/ mystical experience

the awful, subtractive mode of “explanation” – eastern _ways of thinking of Eastern Peoples_ book: “X is an illusion” , “no X” = enlightenment.

Transcendent Knowledge = non boundary exper. [bad: explanation by subtraction]

good: the Eternalism / control transformation” model of the mystic altered state / mystical experience, per psychedelic eternalism ; the Egodeath theory.

See Also

Taves 2020

Bro 2023

Kitchens entries — remember, for all , misled scholars, ‘MYSTICISM’ & its “phen”, ALWAYS MEANS THE UNITY PARADIGM — instead of the correct, “eternalism-driven control transformation”, relevant, useful , helpful explanatory model.

the old theory = Stace lineage, Modern Advaita, nondual, Unity model, see Taves expose then Bro who builds directly on her

yet Taves & Bro give just enough lip service to “other than Positive Unity”, to ensure the permanent entrenchment of the wrong, Unity model.

like u can find Fear (indicative of eternalism-driven control transformation) buried hidden in Pahnke’s thesis, in “Sacredness” & “non mystical” & Otto & relational eg Hasidic Jewish mysticism

Pahnke explains-away and categorizes-away, Western, Abrahamic, Relational, Christian mysticism & Jewish mysticism.

He acknowledges these problems, but plows ahead w the Unity model and applies his eliminative filter & neutralizing categories. Find: Otto

todo: transcribe my cover-page notes, shown in photo – not needed; already summarized here.

equates negative, separateness, fear

equates positive Unity

gives lip service to fear/negative, to ack it to explain it away into the Stace lineage: mystical experience = positive unity modern Advaita motive of political transnatiinal unity; the fakse false, subst religion in order to shut out Dread Eternalism control transformation.

avert & ward off, apotropaic, the experience of the threat of catastrophic loss of control , via neutered, substitutive, dummy, harmless, panic-free, pretend-mysticism

All modern scholars are stuck in wrong theory, in every word & explanatory construct they use.

todo: delete entries other than relevant Kitchens entries: (copy of toc of fav page)

photo: Michael Hoffman, Sunday, Nov 9, 2025

Liberty Caps and Panaeolus Caps in the Canterbury Psalter

Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control (Houot, 2019)

Michael Hoffman, September 17, 2025

The present page is full text of dissertation.
My orig. notes page: https://egodeaththeory.org/2023/01/22/toward-a-philosophy-of-psychedelic-technology-an-exploration-of-fear-otherness-and-control-houot-2019/
Citation/link:
Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control, A. M. Houot, 2019
https://www.academia.edu/38583547/Toward_a_Philosophy_of_Psychedelic_Technology_An_Exploration_of_Fear_Otherness_and_Control

Site Map: Alan Houot

Contents:

Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control [cover page]

By A.M. Houot

A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Behavioural, Management and Social Sciences of the University of Twente in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science MSc Philosophy of Science, Technology and Society

First supervisor/examiner: Dr. Michael Nagenborg

Second reader/examiner: Prof. Dr. Lissa Roberts

Defended on 25 February 2019 Enschede, Netherlands

Page ii

By A. M. Houot © A. M. Houot 2019

Page iii

Abstract

The central question guiding this study is:

In what ways can modern users conceptualize the psychedelic experience that counters the current fear-laden discourse on drugs?

Misconceptions and falsehoods conflate current ways of considering drugs in general and psychedelics in particular.

Fears of psychedelics serve as the framework to apply philosophies of mind and technology to the reexamination and amendment of psychedelic concepts and terms.

Governmental and religious institutional actors fear psychedelic users will:

  • harm one’s self and others because psychedelics are still falsely believed to have analogous properties to mental illness;
  • the incommunicability of seemingly non-rational states cause disjunction between shared sociocultural knowledge; and
  • psychedelics are arguably similar to mystical experiences, thus mainstream religion fears individuals’ direct access to divine realms, which could upend their hierarchical and spiritually monopolistic power structures.

Next, modern researchers commonly advise users to “surrender” to psychedelic experiences, a term likely adopted from mysticism.

Since surrender implies a master role is at play, a discussion on master-subject relations emerge when confronting the “psychedelic Other,” i.e. the spatial context, experiential content, and originating from within or without users’ minds.

To better understand users’ fears, an analysis of known and unknown fears provide context to the ultimate psychedelic fear, that of a conscious and intelligent unknown presence.

Against these fears of psychedelic Others, a new conception of (altered) states of self develops that considers the current debate in cognitive neuroscience and philosophy.

Narrative and minimal selves are co-present during psychedelic experiences depending on dosage and intoxication levels, and a new qualitative framework is proffered to understand these implications.

Finally, it is suggested that modern psychedelic users need not abandon the prototypical mystic to conceptualize their experiences, but instead might consider another prototypical figure, the shaman.

Rather than dealing in surrender and fear like mystics and modern users, drug-taking shamans control and master their experiences through the joint use of symbolism, techniques, and technologies.

A change in prototype also has epistemological significance, that is, from perennialist to constructivist approaches when considering psychedelically subjective knowledge.

In view of built narratives regarding self and knowledge, i.e. narrative self and epistemological constructivism, analysis shows how shamans use symbols with technologies to control their experiences and the idea of symbolico-technological relations is proposed.

The above philosophical insights have prescriptive consequences that provide new opportunities for modern society and users to conceptualize psychedelic experiences, to control them, and as a result, to reduce fear.

Page iv

Preface

This philosophical work addresses fears of psychedelics and proposes new ways of conceptualizing modern society’s and individuals’ relationship to these substances.

Tackling such a project, to rationalize about the seemingly non-rational, was not only demanding but also fun.

I am convinced there is a need to philosophize further about psychedelic experiences since they question the foundations of human thought and experience.

Within the field of philosophy of technology, I applied a humanities approach to my research; however, the engineering/design and ethical approaches should also be researched to expand a philosophy of psychedelic technology.

I want to thank both of my supervisors: Dr. Michael Nagenborg and Prof. Dr. Lissa Roberts.

Michael initially took my project onboard and showed enthusiasm for a subculture he wanted to know more about (that is to say, academically, not experientially).

I believe I can speak for Michael in that we enjoyed scratching our heads during meetings while trying to untie psychedelic knots with our philosophic tools.

And it worked! Thank you Lissa for partaking in shaping my critical mind, pushing us to do our best, and for having reservations about my first “final” thesis proposal.

I know now, only in retrospect, that this was the thesis I was supposed to write and am extremely pleased at what was discovered along the way.

As for MasterLab class, I appreciate the patience of instructor, Dr. Lantz Fleming Miller, who said it was like going on a “trip” merely reading early outlines of this project; I took this as a compliment and knew I was onto something.

I am grateful for the feedback I received from my peer review group, Roos d. J. and an anonymous Finnish man, for their suggestions throughout much of the writing process.

Thank you Alice F., Jonathan d. H., and Patrick M., who gave helpful, and at times, critical, comments at different points in the writing process, and Sam V. and Alessio G. for the living room chats.

Within the Faculty of Behavioural, Management and Social Sciences, I thank the faculty members of the Department of Philosophy and the Department of Science, Technology, and Policy Studies for the brilliant job they do and the intellectually stimulating environment they provide.

The Philosophy of Science, Technology and Society (PSTS) master’s program has given me so much and I hope to give back one day in any way that I can.

Last but not least, I thank my family and friends who supported me and for listening and politely nodding their heads, i.e. not fully understanding my ideas because of my inarticulateness, which compelled me to become clearer in my thinking and writing.

A. M. Houot

Page v

Einstein Quote

The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious.  It is the source of all true art and science.

He to whom this emotion is a stranger, who can no longer pause to wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead: his eyes are closed.

This insight into the mystery of life, coupled though it be with fear, has also given rise to religion.

To know that what is impenetrable to us really exists, manifesting itself as the highest wisdom and the most radiant beauty which our dull faculties can comprehend only in their most primitive forms—this knowledge, this feeling, is at the center of true religiousness.

In this sense, and in this sense only, I belong in the ranks of devoutly religious men.

—Albert Einstein (1931)

Sayim Quote

An encounter with an unknown encourages us to reconsider mental processes that are non-rational, speculative, and intuitive—processes that complement general modes of thinking, which are often ruled by requirements of efficiency and productivity— without disqualifying them a priori as useless, unnecessary, and distracting.

To lose the known, to see the apparently impossible, and to be pushed to guess and speculate, and attend to the transient, faint, and intangible may make us more open to seeing the ordinary as it ultimately is—unknown.

This could be a source for expanding common modes of thinking and of acquiring and producing knowledge—the possibility to review what reality consists of and to imagine and explore the structures and relations that we exist in and create.

—Bilge Sayim and Ivana Franke (2018)

Page vi

Table of Contents

todo: make sure toc at top of present webpage matches this content from the pdf:

Introduction …1

1. Social Order Shakeup …5

1.1 Institutionalization of the human, sane and insane …6

1.1.1 Perceived inhumanness of non-rational persons …7

1.2 Harm to others …9

1.3 Incommunicability of experience and direct access to the divine …11

2. Psychedelic Other and the Self …16

2.1 Master-subject relations …17

2.2 Psychedelic matrix of knowability …21

2.2.1 Known knowns: Bodily surrender …22

2.2.2 Known unknowns: Death, or rather, nondualism …23

2.2.3 Unknown knowns: Unconscious mind …25

2.2.4 Unknown unknowns: Human absence and nonhuman presence …27

2.3 The self: Narrative vs. minimal …31

2.3.1 Understanding self in the presence of psychedelic Other …32

3. Psychedelic Symbolico-technology …36

3.1 Epistemological framing …37

3.2 Practical insights …38

3.2.1 Shamans …39

3.2.2 Modernists …40

3.2.3 Between two world(view)s …41

3.3 Form and technology …42

Conclusion …48

Bibliography …52

Page 1

Introduction

Renewed interest in psychedelic substances is opening up research in therapy and neuroscience.

Scholars and lay experts claim:

  • psilocybin (i.e. visionary mushrooms) alleviates headaches (Sewell et al, 2006);
  • lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) and mescaline help patients in psychotherapy (Masters and Houston, 1966);
  • Silicon Valley technologists “microdose” LSD for cognitive enhancement (Brodwin, 2017; Hogan, 2017);
  • 3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA) aids in couples therapy (Waldman, 2017) and to relieve posttraumatic stress disorder (MAPS, n.d.);
  • ayahuasca and iboga help opioid addicts overcome additions (Winkelman, 2014), and so on.

Additionally, neuroscientists and philosophers study psychedelics’ effects on the brain when looking for neural correlates of: consciousness, mystical experiences, and selfhood (Lebedev et al, 2015; Millière, 2017; Barrett and Griffiths, 2018).

The abovementioned practices intrigue, and, benefit many people in need; yet, the opposite side of the psychedelic coin is hardly discussed in great detail, that of the negative experience or “bad trip,” the fear people experience.

In a recent psilocybin study at John Hopkins University, nearly 40% of hallucinogen-naïve participants reported “extreme ratings of fear, fear of insanity, or feeling trapped at some time during the session” with 44% reporting delusional or paranoid thinking (Griffiths et al, 2011, 656).

I want to know more about the why and what people are fearful of.

Aldous Huxley (2013) writes about fear of mescaline-induced altered states in his seminal work, The Doors of Perception:

The fear, as I analyze it in retrospect, was of being overwhelmed, of disintegrating under a pressure of reality greater than a mind, accustomed to living most of the time in a cosy world of symbols, could possibly bear.

The literature of religious experience abounds in references to the pains and terrors overwhelming those who have come, too suddenly, face to face with some manifestation of the Mysterium tremendum.

In theological language, this fear is due to the incompatibility between man’s egotism and the divine purity, between man’s self-aggravated separateness and the infinity of God (34-35).

For Huxley, the symbols humans create play a comforting role because they represent and define sober reality.

Psychoactive agents such as mescaline put pressure on, or rather, amplify, one’s senses and mind, altering one’s sense of reality, perhaps even revealing obfuscated realities of sublimable significance.

Terence McKenna (1998), another well-known psychedelic writer, says all psychedelics are experientially the same at low doses.

Sub-perceptual and sub-threshold states do not induce the kind of fear I intend to investigate; instead, large doses—or what McKenna (1998, 15) calls “heroic” or “committed” doses (i.e. five dried grams of mushrooms) and what psychologist Stanislav Grof (1980, 2 18-20) calls “single overwhelming dose” (i.e. 250 micrograms of LSD)—tend to induce the most fear.

Fear caused by the overwhelming disintegration of one’s ego and (symbolic) reality depends on dosage, as I shall argue in subsequent chapters.

For example, to understand what the experience entails, McKenna (1998) summarizes the tryptamine family of psychedelics as “interesting” because of: [T]he intensity of the hallucinations and the concentration of activity in the visual cortex.

There is an immense vividness to these interior landscapes; …When one confronts these dimensions, one becomes part of a dynamic relationship relating to the experience while trying to decode what it is saying (35).

Thus, it seems that the vivid vastness of psychedelic dimensions/realities can be too much for the human organism to bear for there is difficulty and potential frustration in translating the experience with the (sober) symbols to which one is accustomed.

Furthermore, the psychedelic experience can be equally as hellish as it is mystical or therapeutic as Huxley suggests from the title of his book, Heaven and Hell.

It is the overwhelming fear, “the Fear1,” brought on by large doses of psychedelics that I will philosophically explore.

In an attempt to rationalize psychedelic experiences, modern scholars since the 1950s commonly equate them to Eastern religious and philosophic traditions such as Buddhism and Vedanta, and more importantly to mysticism (Leary et al, 2007; Huxley, 2013; Shipley, 2015); hence, members of psychedelia2 likely applied the surrender motif found in mystical traditions to their psychedelic experiences.

On the other hand, shamans do not surrender but instead are said to control the psychedelic experience through the use of techniques and technologies.

In this thesis, I reflect upon the use of symbols and technology during seemingly non-rational psychedelic experiences to know more about the interaction between self, Other, human and nonhuman actors.

The central question I am concerned with is: In what ways can modern users conceptualize the psychedelic experience that counters the current fear-laden discourse on drugs?

My aim is to provide new conceptions of psychedelics within the broader field of philosophy of drugs.

I criticize illogical categories, unspecific terms, and dosage and levels of intoxication not being carefully considered.

Properly defining and deconstructing terms allows a clearer picture of what is meant when psychedelics are discussed and how this relates to fear.

Further, I apply the abovementioned critiques to fears stemming from current discourse surrounding psychedelics from the perspectives of modern society/institutions and users.

Considering modern narratives shape my

Footnotes:

1 Journalist Hunter S. Thompson (2005), arguably one of the most eccentric and known drug users of the twentieth century on record and in rumor, recalls a particular weekend in Las Vegas in which his attorney refers to the overwhelmingness of the mescaline experience as “getting the Fear” (47-48).

2 Refers to the psychedelic subculture or community (Sessa, 2012).

Page 3

thinking—particularly when analyzing dualities between sober and intoxicated states, experiential content from within or without the user’s mind, and shamanic and modern worldviews—I do not claim to fully understand societies, cultures, and states of consciousness different to my own.

Rather, I draw on modern academics’ research about other (sub)cultures and their practices in order to confront fear-laden discourse about psychedelics in society, resulting in conclusive prescriptive consequences for modern audiences—academics and users alike—to conceptualize psychedelic experiences anew.

In Chapter 1, I examine modern society’s fears of psychedelic users, represented as (society<–>individual) relations, by asking: How do psychedelics threaten the idea of being a rational subject in modern society where there exists established behavioral norms and shared knowledge among the citizenry?

Society expects individuals to be rational agents making rational decisions, ensuring a synchronization of common knowledge and behavior, i.e. how one should act, (perhaps) think, and speak as a member of society.

I focus the analysis on two institutions threatened by psychedelics: government and religion.

First, through Foucault’s historical analysis on asylums and the mentally ill and a number of pioneering psychedelic researchers, I show that the outdated conception of psychedelics as producing temporary states of mental illness fabricates fears that drug users will harm themselves or others.

Second, Stace’s philosophical analysis of mysticism highlights the incommunicability/ineffability of perceivably non-rational psychedelic experiences that confronts ideals of being a rational subject, causing fear in non-users because users have access to un-relatable experiences.

Furthermore, religious institutions fear psychedelics, and by comparison, mystical, experiences because of their claimed divine nature, thus, direct access to divine realms bypasses mainstream religions’ hierarchical power structures.

In Chapter 2, I aim to understand (self<–>psychedelic Other) relations, posing the question:

To what extent do Otherness and the unknown contribute to individuals’ fears of psychedelics in a modern context?

Individuals’ fears are also modern society’s fears because of the realness and profundity of altered states and nonphysical entities, for example, that confront notions of shared sociocultural knowledge.

Modern psychedelic users’ adoption of mystics’ surrender paradigm, or what I call “surrenderism,” induces fears when confronting what I call the psychedelic Other: the context and content of people’s altered minds.

Surrender implies a master role, and thus, three mastersubject relations emerge to understand in which kind of relationship self and Other engage.

The philosophies of Hegel, Derrida, and Tupper inform master-slave, master/host-guest, and master/teacher-student relations respectively during encounters with psychedelic Others.

Next, I use a framework that I call the psychedelic matrix of knowability to delve into individuals’ likely fears from known knowns (i.e. bodily surrender) to unknown unknowns (i.e. human absence vs. nonhuman presence) borrowing from a multitude of thinkers such as Shanon, Freud, Lovecraft, and Harman.

The ultimate fear, I argue, is of a seemingly conscious and intelligent unknown presence.

Finally, I expand the current debate in cognitive neuroscience and philosophy regarding the concept of self, i.e.

Page 4

between narrative and minimal self, basing my arguments on Gallagher, Zahavi, Millière, Stace, and Pahnke.

Although I make a case that narrative self is dominant in sober states, I propse a new framework accordant with surrenderism, suggesting that both narrative and minimal selves are present during psychedelic experiences depending on dosage and intoxication levels.

In Chapter 3, I pit modern notions of surrender and fear of psychedelic experiences against shamanic traditions of control and mastery.

I contend that modern users need not abandon mystical traditions to explain their psychedelic experiences, however, to consider another prototypical figure, the shaman, to control, thereby reduce, users’ fears discussed in Chapter 2.

Regarding symbols, techniques, and technologies that couple with psychedelics, I investigate: How can technology and the symbol provide a greater sense of control to psychedelic users? First, I explore contrasting epistemological claims within philosophy of religion, offering a rebuttal to the largely perennial arguments used thus far by Stace and Pahnke by bringing in Katz’s epistemological constructivism.

Interestingly, just as narrative and minimal selves are possibly both present during psychedelic experiences depending on dosage, so too, constructivist and perennialist approaches to subjective knowledge are likely also co-present depending on dosage.

Second, I offer practical insights into shamans’ and modern users’ psychedelic techniques and technologies, arguing that one’s worldview determines what kind of knowledge is sought and the means used.

It would be unwise to assume that modern users can use shamans’ methods ipso facto and vice versa.

Finally, I base my final arguments on Cassirer to extrapolate the role of psychedelic symbols and technologies in (self<–>symbolicotechnological<–>psychedelic Other) relations.

I propose that combining symbols with technologies, as drug-taking shamans ostensibly do, form symbolico-technological relations that offer promising avenues of psychedelic research and exploration.

Page 5

Chapter 1: Social Order Shakeup

In an interview called The Rhetoric of Drugs, Jacques Derrida plays devil’s advocate taking policymakers’ position: “…Institutions protect the very possibility of the law in general, for by prohibiting drugs we assure the integrity and responsibility of the legal subject, of the citizens, and so forth.

There can be no law without the conscious, vigilant, and normal subject, master of his or her intentions and desires” (1995, 230).

As Derrida points out, the prohibition of drugs aims to guarantee basic, rational standards are in place.

Drug use manifests another kind of rationality during and after the experience—one that may seem non-rational to most people.

Psychedelic use is not prohibited in all countries and cultures.

For the purpose of this discussion, I focus mainly on modern societies, using the United States as a case study where psychedelics are illegal for general consumption.

I do not intend to give a comprehensive account of modernity, society or social order for they comprise entire academic fields on their own.

Nevertheless, I offer the following definitions below.

Sociologist Anthony Giddens has written extensively on modernity, defining it as: “modes of social life or organization”; originating in seventeenth-century Europe eventually spreading to other parts of the world; and characterized by four main institutions: capitalism, industrialism, surveillance, and control of the means of violence, i.e. warfare (1990, 1, 55-63).

Important to note is industrialism because this institution requires science, technology, and rationality.

Furthermore, Giddens views modern society as a “post-traditional order” that “institutionalises the principle of radical doubt and insists that all knowledge takes the form of hypotheses: claims which may very well be true, but which are in principle always open to revision and may have at some point to be abandoned” (1991, 2-3).

Constantly doubting knowledge creates a society that values objectivity, repeatability, and justification through methods such as the scientific method.

Society can be seen as a collective of individuals governed by multiple institutions that promote shared common denominators, such as language, culture, history, and so forth.

Everyone in a society is unlikely to be homogenous; yet, it is assumed that all members have a baseline level of understanding and knowledge about their sociocultural constitution wherefore members can smoothly function with one another.

I define society institutionally rather than normatively (i.e. social norms, values) because institutions deal with insubordinate behavior through laws and sanctions whereas violated norms might result in mild reprimands.

Therefore, the informal rules that are social norms (bottom-up approach to social order) are but one part of the larger, formal institutional system (topdown approach) (Miller, 2011; Bicchieri et al, 2018; see also: Elster, 1989, 97-107).

I allude to two ubiquitous institutions in modern society threatened by psychedelics: government and religion.

This chapter is about modern society’s fears of individuals taking psychedelics, asking: How do psychedelics threaten the idea of being a rational subject in modern society where there exists established behavioral norms and shared knowledge among the citizenry? I answer this question by 6 drawing on the work of Gehlen, Berger, and Luckmann to establish the arguable need for institutions in society that give stability to people’s (“undirected”) lives.

Foucault’s historical analysis of madness and asylums provides context to the institutionalization of individuals who do not or cannot conform and highlights the pivotal moment when mad persons were segregated from sane, albeit immoral, individuals.

While I focus on the potential for self-harm in Foucault’s analysis, and past academics’ false assumptions that psychedelics share analogous properties with mental illness, I argue that the government fears psychedelics’ degenerating/maddening effects, and thus, their potential to harm others.

Finally, through Stace’s philosophical analysis on mysticism, I show how governmental and religious institutions fear psychedelics because the incommunicability of altered experiences confront shared knowledge of members of society, and religious power structures are threatened by psychedelic users’ access to possible divine realms.

1.1 Institutionalization of the human, sane and insane

Individuals learn to depend on institutions for society’s functioning since they provide a sense of social stability.

Sociologists Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann (1991) define institutionalization as: “…Whenever there is a reciprocal typification of habitualized actions by types of actors” (72), and more precisely as, “…the sum total of ‘what everybody knows’ about a social world, an assemblage of maxims, morals, proverbial nuggets of wisdom, values and beliefs, myths, and so forth” (83).

Institutions provide direction and structure to humans that lack the arguably stable biological condition present in other animals.

Philosophical anthropologist, Arnold Gehlen, argues that humans’ biological instability take the form of “undirected drives,” and thus non-biological methods of containing these drives, such as culture and institutions, provide stability “to relieve [humans] of the tensions caused by the accumulation of these drives” (Berger and Kellner, 1965, 111-112).

Animals may not act rationally in the way humans do; however, animal biology, according to Gehlen, gives stability and order to their lives.

Animals’ instinctual drives are directed towards an environment suited to them, while humans lack such specialization of drives, born into an “open world” (Weltoffenheit), i.e. not a “species-specific environment” (ibid., 111).

Undirected drives and desires, especially in groups, can be detrimental to the survivability of the human species.

Humans’ ability to rationalize can be used for good or ill; in other words, humans are able to plan and execute their drives on a grander scale than animals, which is contradictory, at times, to peaceful co-existence between humans and/or other living organisms.

The human being becomes accustomed to and accepts being one of many individuals in a collective through stabilization, routinization, and habitualization.

In addition to acting as outlets to channel undirected drives, institutions also act as moral yardsticks, so to speak, to quell the drives that do not serve the collective good.

For Gehlen, this “mechanization of consciousness” through shared sociocultural media simultaneously constrains and supports individuals: constraining in that once individuals are “collectivized” they “only give out such fragments of desire …as the large group will 7 accept” (2003, 218-219), and supporting since “the burden of human living would be too heavy without a ‘background’ of routinized activity the meaning of which is taken for granted” (Berger and Kellner, 1965, 112).

For example, one can call a simple three-digit telephone number in an emergency and expect police, fire, and/or medical services to arrive shortly thereafter.

Berger and Luckmann (1991) concur with Gehlen, saying that institutional habitualization narrows the choices for individuals, hence, “…Freeing the individual from the burden of ‘all those decisions,’ providing a psychological relief that has its basis in man’s undirected instinctual structure” (71).

Gehlen, Berger, and Luckmann show the necessity of social institutions to account for the biological lack in “normal” human beings.

Nevertheless, some individuals operate outside of commonly accepted reason and rationality.

Eventually, there comes a moment when society is tested, resulting in society taking action appropriate to the threat.

The fear of madness led the sane to establish asylums, i.e. mental institutions, to confine the mentally ill—including deviants and dangerous individuals—with the hope of ensuring the orderliness3 of society.

The mental order of the masses can be viewed as a microcosm of social order just as mental disorder in large numbers is a microcosm of social disorder.

I examine madness and its containment in the following.

1.1.1 Perceived inhumanness of non-rational persons

Michel Foucault historicizes the conceptual evolution of madness in Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason.

For Foucault (1988), the forerunner to modern psychiatric hospitals took the form of confined leper colonies on the outskirts of urban settlements.

As leprosy declined, the empty edifices used to house lepers were converted into workhouses.

French society, among other European countries, confined a slew of “undesirable” people to workhouses from the medieval period until the late-eighteenth century, such as lepers, criminals, delinquents, the poor/unemployed/mad, etc.

A defining moment in the way madness (mental illness) is portrayed today, to some extent, occurred when early-eighteenth-century prisoners implored Hôpital directors to separate them from the cries and confusion of the madmen:

Hence an abyss yawns in the middle of confinement; a void which isolates madness, denounces it for being irreducible, unbearable to reason; madness now appears with what distinguishes it from all these confined forms as well.

The presence of the mad appears as an injustice; but for others (Foucault, 1988, 228).

In this way, sane criminals were shown mercy when hospital directors segregated the mad from living quarters and workshop floors.

Footnotes:

3 The confinement of selected (mad) individuals was not only to protect society’s sane and moral, but also could be construed as a guise to lock up all “undesirables,” representative of Foucauldian power relations.

See next section.

Page 8

What does it imply about the mentally ill if they must segregate from sane, albeit immoral, individuals?

Foucault’s analysis focuses on four types of madness—melancholia, hysteria, hypochondria, and mania.

All four share varying degrees of irrational behavior in Foucault’s (1988) definition of madness: “Madness begins where the relation of man to truth is disturbed and darkened.

It is in this relation, at the same time as in the destruction of this relation, that madness assumes its general meaning and its particular forms” (104).

In eighteenth-century France, mania instilled the most fear in the sane, for it was the most extreme and disruptive form of madness.

Hospital directors’ definition of mania is as follows: prone to violence, frenzy, elevated spirits, audacity, fury, explosive gestures, agitation, unaffected by extreme cold temperatures, and, “a tension of the fibers carried to its paroxysm, the maniac a sort of instrument whose strings, by the effect of an exaggerated traction, began to vibrate at the remotest and faintest stimulus” (ibid., 122-129).

An updated understanding of mania is found in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.

The DSM-5 states mania is common among schizophrenic and psychotic disorders with a range of symptoms depending on the severity of the manic episode, such as: “inflated self-esteem or grandiosity, decreased need for sleep, more talkative than usual, racing thoughts, distractibility, psychomotor agitation, and excessive involvement in activities that have a high potential for painful consequences” (American Psychiatric Association, 2013, 124).

The eighteenth-century definition of mania is quite different from today’s understanding of mental disorders and may refer to different illnesses altogether.

However, the point stands that non-rational behavior might be something to be cautious of or contain if necessary, irrespective how it is defined.

The above accounts of madness, particularly mania, were seen as reminiscent of animalistic behavior, at the very least when juxtaposed to sane individuals.

What is it about animals and the inhuman behavior of the insane that broods fear in society? Foucault (1988) says, “The animality that rages in madness dispossesses man of what is specifically human in him” (74).

That is not to say sane people are exempt from fits of passion; however, according to Foucault’s historical analysis, the untamedness of arresting bestial-like passions is to be animal-like, to be inhuman.

Where does one draw the line between reason and unreason, human and animal, human and inhuman? In moving from historical to contemporary thoughts on this matter, philosopher of mind and mental illness, George Graham, offers practical boundaries for disordered minds in orderly society.

For Graham (2010), there are three main reasons why mental disorders are undesirable for individuals and society: 1) disorders can be harmful or dangerous leading to incomprehensibility or death, 2) disorders are of a non-voluntary and uncontrollable nature, and 3) disorders upset the functioning of general mentality and cannot be restored by simply adding other psychological resources (46-47).

Unpredictability and harm are important to note.

An individual unbound from reason could act highly irrationally and erratically, and thus, such unpredictability could lead to harming oneself.

The insane might not comprehend the potential harm they could inflict for they know not what they do or why they do it.

“Being in the dark about one’s own person means that an individual is incapable of rational 9 self-scrutiny or taking proper responsibility for self” (ibid., 46).

It is no wonder individuals who fit Foucault’s and Graham’s descriptions were feared and confined.

Various degrees of mental illness test the bounds of rationality and perceived humanness of individuals.

Since the widespread outburst of psychedelic use in the mid-twentieth century, namely during the 1960s in United States, until now, modern society has been confronted with serious questions concerning supposed temporary states of mental illness caused by psychedelic substances.

I discuss next the claimed analogous properties between mental illness and psychedelics, and what regarding psychedelics alarms government.

1.2 Harm to others

From modern society’s perspective, concerns of unpredictability and potential for self-harm in insane individuals, as mentioned above, are comparable to psychedelic use since early researchers considered psychedelics as temporary states of mental illness.

Early- to mid-twentieth century psychiatrists and psychologists took an interest in, and doses of, psychedelics because of psychedelics’ perceived ability to produce states of insanity in otherwise healthy subjects.

Psychiatrist Humphrey Osmond (1957) mentions Gerard’s (1956) term, psychotomimetic, to describe compounds that alter individuals’ minds, i.e. mimics states of psychosis, schizophrenia, and delirium (see also: Osmond, 1970; Strassman, 1984).

In Osmond’s estimation, one cannot fully understand something unless one experiences4 it:

“There is one golden rule that should be applied in working with model psychoses.  One should start with oneself” (1957, 421).

Former Czechoslovakian researchers in the 1950-60s self-experimented with LSD to grasp a richer understanding of non-ordinary psychological states and mental illness, to learn more about the substance, and thus to be able, so they thought, to help their patients more effectively (Winkler and Csémy, 2014).

Erich Guttmann (1936), another psychedelic pioneer, wrote a paper called Artificial Psychoses Produced by Mescaline in which he details the alteration and amplification of his subjects’ senses, including reports that schizophrenics given mescaline had more auditory hallucinations than their non-schizophrenic counterparts.

At least two observations can be deduced from the above research foci: psychedelics allegedly mimic states of mental illness (1) artificially (not in a synthetic substance sense but rather the ability to experience an altered mental state at will merely ingesting a substance), and (2) temporarily.

The aforementioned researchers among others were under the impression that there was something to learn about mental illness from artificial and temporary psychedelic states.

Early researchers were motivated to compare the reported effects experienced by individuals suffering from mental illness with psychedelics’ believed temporary maddening effects in healthy individuals.

4 Don Ihde (2004) argues similarly that philosophers of technology “must ‘go native’” to some degree regarding the technologies and practices they study, becoming more than distant observer toward informed participant (91).

Page 10

Historical and current conceptions of mental illness, and “temporary mental illness” via psychedelics by extension, were/are assumed to produce inhuman qualities in users, leading to unpredictable consequences for drug users and others.

Thus, the second worry society might have about psychedelics concerns harm to others.

John Stuart Mill (1996) asks when society should intervene in individuals’ actions, concluding that society should restrict an individual’s autonomy when the individual’s actions directly or indirectly harm others: “That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others” (110).

Mill does not concern himself with people “[mature] of their faculties” (ibid); though, it can be argued that sane or insane people harming themselves costs taxpayers through hospitals, police, and other public services, thus the State may deem it necessary to intervene.

For example, the psychiatric division of a hospital in New York City during the 1960s reported a surge in self-experimenting individuals who took between 200-400 micrograms of LSD and needed treatment (Frosch et al, 1965).

From health and financial perspectives, the State could deem such “surges” as grounds for regulating particular substances to protect people from themselves and others, and to save taxpayer money.

The counterculture movement of the 1960s produced a turbulent era in U.S. history.

In September 1968—amid the Vietnam War, the draft, civil/gay/environmental/women’s rights movements, and vast experimental drug use—Nixon denounced drugs in his campaign to be president: “Narcotics are the modern curse of American youth” (Musto and Korsmeyer, 2002, 42).

While only three percent of polled citizens thought drugs and alcohol posed problems to the nation (ibid., 39), Nixon believed that all drug use—particularly heroin and cocaine (ibid., 43) but including psychedelics—led to crime, deviance, and social disorder.

The public soon adopted Nixon’s views when reports surfaced of increased drug use among soldiers stationed in Vietnam.

The impact of drugs on combat readiness, coupled with the belief that soldiers were on drugs during the My Lai Massacre in March 1968 (ibid., 48-50), further compounded by increased use of LSD and other drugs back home, prompted Nixon to sign into law the Comprehensive Drug Abuse Prevention and Control Act (CDAPCA) in 1970, in effect banning most psychedelics as Schedule I drugs (the most severe classification).

Foucault (1988) speaks of a “great fear” spreading after the “great confinement” of society’s debauchees; citizens were scared of the unknown and mysterious evils housed in the asylums, of the “fermentation” of a “contagious atmosphere” that could contaminate the cities (ibid., 202-207).

Similarly, the current “war on drugs” does not take issue with psychedelics being regarded as nonaddictive 5, but rather from the fear of drugs’ ability to degenerate and deprive the minds of unwitting individuals.

Footnotes:

5 Psychedelics are not proven per se to be non-addictive; nevertheless, many researchers regard them as such considering LSD, peyote, ibogaine, and ayahuasca have the ability to reduce cravings for addictive drugs (Winkelman, 2014).

This would suggest that even if psychedelics were addictive, frequent use of them would annul addictive effects.

It is argued as

Page 11

Greater homogeneity of the collective ideally leads to greater social conformity, and thus, agreement of foundational sociocultural norms and knowledge.

Deviants who do not conform to endorsed principles face fines and confinement among other penalties to steer behavior.

Change, especially of the minds of citizens via drugs, is conceivably daunting for modern society to endure.

As seen from the government’s continuance of drug prohibition, institutions thereby suggest the direction of individuals’ drives to prevent deviance from spreading.

Hence, the perceived drug-addled individual is less likely to conform to the collective than sober individuals and potentially could be more dangerous to one’s self and others.

Until now, I centered on the government’s fear of harm caused by drugs.

In the following final section, I address another of society’s fear of drugs, that of the incommunicability of the psychedelic experience and direct access to possible divine realms.

1.3 Incommunicability of experience and direct access to the divine

Foucault (1988) was interested in mad persons and their work, such as de Sade, Artaud, Nietzsche, Bosch, and Goya to name several.

There is something peculiar about such works in that the average person may be unable or not inclined to identify with the mad artist’s creative expressions; something is lost in translation between the insane and the sane person’s “dictionaries,” so to speak.

It could be argued that many people do not take the insane seriously and therefore their art, or their art may be upsetting to experience, as a quick Google search for “schizophrenic art” shows.

Likewise, modern society fears psychedelics since: the

(1) incommunicability of such experiences lead nonusers to question the accounts of psychedelic users who employ

(a) different vocabularies in their attempts to

(b) explain mystifying experiences that are probably not relatable, and

(2) mystical-like psychedelic experiences might offer direct access to otherworldly and divine realms that threaten the hierarchical power structures of religious institutions.

The first likely umbrella term for “hallucinating substances” was called phantastica, given by German pharmacologist Louis Lewin (1924).

Until Osmond coined the term psychedelic to mean, “mind manifesting,” psychoactive compounds were called by a number of off-putting names by psychiatrists; for instance: psychotomimetic, schizogen, psychotica, psychotogen, phantastica, hallucinogen, and elixir (Osmond, 1957).

Even today, the idea of taking a schizogen or psychotogen might impress fear upon the minds of users and non-users alike.

As for recreational users prior to the term psychedelic, I have yet to find any literature of amateurs referring to a particular class of drugs that refer to what are known today as psychedelics.

The only difference between terminology used by academics/professionals and amateur researchers/recreational users seems to be that the latter refer to drugs by their specific name as Huxley does in The Doors of Perception and Heaven and Hell.

Footnotes:

[con’t from previous page:] well that the intense side effects of psychedelics do not make them addictive, i.e. these are substances one would not take everyday as done with other drugs (Lerner and Lyvers, 2006).

Furthermore, rapid tolerance of LSD use shows psychic effects “significantly diminished” by the second or third consecutive day (Trulson and Jacobs, 1979), making the drug inconsequential to users who took it for its desired effects.

Page 12

Ruck et al (1979) argue for a new term, entheogen, to describe the experience produced by psychedelic compounds since the root psycho- is reminiscent of psychosis and psychotic.

Entheogen means to “generate the divine within” and is better suited, according to Ruck et al, to mean “prophetic seizures, erotic passion and artistic creation, as well as to those religious rites in which mystical states were experienced through the ingestion of substances that was transubstantial with the deity” (1979, 146).

On the one hand, highly addictive drugs like heroin (opioid) and cocaine (stimulant) are undoubtedly degenerative, wasting away one’s body and mind; on the other hand, the above proponents of psychedelics claim that entheogens are generative, particularly of “the divine within.”

Interesting to note is the terminological shift of psychedelic experiences from temporary state of mental illness to mystical experience, and the principal users of these substances shifting from psychiatrists, academicians, and shamans to eventually include average modern persons.

In a recent study, 667 participants were surveyed of which more than one third of participants report using psychedelics for “autognostic” purposes—religious or spiritual practices, self-knowledge and self-inspection, and self-medication—and half say they use all types of drugs for the same reasons (Móró et al, 2011, 193-194).

Whether the reconceptualization of psychedelics to entheogens had a positive effect on people’s autognostic motives for taking these substances today is still unclear, but possible.

Ruck et al (1979) mention “religious rites” and “mystical states” in their definition of entheogen; what is the connection between mystical states and psychedelics to which they refer?

Philosopher of mysticism, Walter Stace (1960), identifies a “common core” of universal characteristics found in mystic traditions across religions and cultures: unity/union (unifying vision or consciousness); non-spatiality/non-temporality; sense of objectivity or reality; blessedness and peace; feeling of the holy, sacred, or divine; paradoxicality; and ineffability (131-132).

Techniques used by mystics to access these states include but are not limited to: heavy breathing, shouting, singing, selfflagellation, and fasting to increase carbon dioxide (in the blood and lungs), and histamine and adrenaline (leading to shock), affecting the brain, which ultimately affects the subject’s consciousness (Huxley, 2013, 90-97; see also: Masters and Houston, 1966, 248-250).

Psychedelics also affect the brain to produce mystical experiences.

For example, Philosopher of religion, Walter Pahnke (1963), discovered in his now famous Good Friday Experiment that psychedelics replicate mystical experiences: Psychedelic-naïve divinity students receiving psilocybin in a double-blind experiment had more of a religious/mystical experience compared to students given a placebo.

(Pahnke uses Stace’s typology of characteristics found in mysticism to gauge participants’ experiences.)

In a similar experiment, 58% and 67% respectively, of psychedelic-naïve volunteers “rated the psilocybin-occasioned experience as being among the five most personally meaningful, and among the five most spiritually significant experiences of their lives,” with 58% of volunteers meeting the criteria for a “complete” mystical experience after a 14-month follow-up (Griffiths et al, 2008, 621; see also: Griffiths et al, 2011; Grob et al, 2013).

Yaden et al (2017) take the psychedelic-mysticism connection one step further, claiming that religious, spiritual, or mystical experiences 13 (RSMEs) brought on by psychedelics are more mystical, spiritual, and meaningful than RSMEs caused by non-psychedelic means.

The empirical evidence above suggests the competence of psychedelics to occasion mystical experiences including the potential to surpass traditional mysticism techniques.

When asked whether drug and mystical experiences were similar, Stace went so far as declaring: “It’s not a matter of its being similar to mystical experience; it is mystical experience” (Smith, 1964, 523-524).

In light of psychedelics being experientially similar6 to mysticism to a great degree, another similarity psychedelics presumably share with mysticism is the ineffability reported by mystics about their experiences.

The symbolic language used to describe intense emotional experiences of immensity, sublimity, and formlessness (i.e. “the void”) (Stace, 1960, 287-288) and “‘fading away,’ ‘melting away,’ ‘passing away’ into the infinite or the divine” (ibid., 301) leads Stace to construct a “theory of unconceptualizability.”

Such a theory suggests mystical experiences are: [W]holly unconceptualizable and therefore wholly unspeakable.

This must be so.

You cannot have a concept of anything within the undifferentiated unity because there are no separate items to be conceptualized.

Concepts are only possible where there is a multiplicity or at least a duality (ibid., 297).

The core of the ineffable nature of mystical experiences stems from the idea that in order for concepts to emerge—an X vs. a Y, a subject vs. an object—the individual is dependent upon and must be working with non-mystical consciousness where the rules of logic can be applied.

For this reason, it is difficult to understand what mystics mean by a fading individuality, the Universal Self, or the One, and by default, such ineffability can be applied to psychedelic experiences as well.

Likewise, McKenna (1998) comments on the unspeakableness of psychedelic experiences: “Reality is truly a creature made of language and of linguistic structures that you carry, unbeknown to yourself, in your mind, and that under the influence of psilocybin these begin to dissolve and allow you to perceive beyond the speakable.

The contours of the unspeakable begin to emerge into your perception, and though you can’t say much about the unspeakable, it has power to color everything you do …it is the invoking of the Other” (69).

The unconceptualizability, and thus ineffability, of mystical and psychedelic states suggest that mystics and psychedelic users’ egos merge into a “nondualistic” state of being.

Stace says the difference in interpretation between Eastern and Western mysticism is similar, but varies somewhat.

The Vedantic (Hindu) interpretation says “the individual self and the Universal Self are not two existences but [were always already] identical,” that is, the individual’s pure ego merges with the pure ego of the Universe in a sort of homecoming; whereas the Christian, Islamic, and Judaic mystic

6 See also Stace’s (1960) “principle of causal indifference”: If mystical and drug-induced experiences are phenomenologically indistinguishable it matters not how they are caused (29-30).

Page 14

interpretation is one of “union with God,” i.e. union of mortal and deity (Stace, 1960, 90).

In either case, the nondual state indicates individuals surrendering, and then merging, into a unitary state with the Other.

Religious institutions are arguably threatened by psychedelics, but also by mystics’ practices, because one potentially bypasses the mediated means, i.e. the priest class, to commune with God, being able to experience the divine directly.

Users’ motives in taking psychedelics are not always spiritual.

Psychiatrist Ben Sessa (2012) says people take psychedelics for a number of reasons depending on what they want to get out of the experience, such as: synesthesia effects, access to archetypal legends, contact deceased family members, access memories and events from one’s past, experience heightened states of empathy toward others, or experience alternative ways of being and knowing in “hyperspace” dimensions (17- 20).

Furthermore, psychedelic users would disagree with the claim that psychedelics degrade or degenerate the body or mind, makes one less human, digresses one into animalism, or causes one to lack in some way.

Rather, they would argue the opposite, in that, psychedelics extend the mind, allowing one to transcend the biological, sensorial apparatuses with which one was born to experience altered states of consciousness (ASC), thought, reality, and the Other.

In a subchapter titled “Notes from the Psychedelic Underground,” Masters and Houston (1966) state that psychedelic users “feel very strongly that their motivation is healthy and ethical” and that users see these drugs as a “tool for bringing about changes which they deem desirable …emphasis is on enhancement of inner experience and on the development of hidden personal resources” (57-58).

The mentally ill, mad artists and thinkers, mystics, and psychedelic users share something in common that modern society fears: an incommensurability of experience by a large portion of the population and thus a difficulty in expressing such experiences.

As for mystics, but also applicable to anyone experiencing drug- and nondrug-induced ASCs, Stace (1960) says they can and do explain quite well their experiences; however, “the language is only paradoxical because the experience is paradoxical.

Thus the language correctly mirrors the experience” (305).

The synchronization of sociocultural common denominators become out of sync when modern users recount their psychedelic experiences, which ultimately have not been approved by modern society as expressed by past and current drug laws.

Perceived threats and non-rationality stemming from psychedelics—i.e. harm to self and others, insufficiently communicating experiences, and accessing divine realms—could create fearful tensions between users and non-users since nonusers do not share a common understanding of psychedelic experiences and in some cases work with outdated conceptions of what psychedelics are and what they do.

Modern society asserts that drugs deprive and degenerate, while mystics and psychedelic users appeal to notions of generating the divine within, extension, enhancement, and transcendence.

All psychedelics are drugs but not all drugs are psychedelics; a present-day reexamination is needed to dissociate the two categories.

Insofar as psychiatrists have learned much about mental illness since the time of eighteenth-century France, it is conceivable that academics will make further discoveries 15 that validate psychedelic users’ claims, and as a result, change society’s perception of psychedelics as well.

Whereas (society<–>individual) relations were discussed in this chapter, the next chapter examines (self<–>psychedelic Other) relations.

Many, if not most, psychedelic experiences appear to be positive and insightful; yet bad experiences can and do happen, which leads to an investigation of individuals’ fears of the experience itself, namely: the Other, knowns and unknowns, and the self.

Page 16

Chapter 2: Psychedelic Other and the Self

As I argue in the previous chapter, there are numerous testimonial and empirical evidence and philosophical analyses suggesting that mystical and psychedelic experiences are very similar.

Psychedelic users in modern society—who I refer to as “modernists” henceforth—recognized and lionized many parallels with mystical traditions such as the surrender motif.

Before addressing drugtaking shamans’ role in philosophic and psychedelic discourse in Chapter 3, I analyze modernists’ borrowed notion of surrender as it relates to the prototypical nature of the mystic in addition to individuals’ psychedelically-related/amplified fears and concepts of self.

Modernists inspired this chapter.

But it is not written for them; rather, it is for philosophers and neuroscientists to rationalize and make sense of psychedelic experiences, and to shed some light on concepts of self when confronted with the “psychedelic Other.” I define psychedelic Other as: alterations in spatio-temporal context, experiential content such as entities, and stemming from within or without the user’s mind.

In consideration of fearful individuals, to what extent do Otherness and the unknown contribute to individuals’ fears of psychedelics in a modern context? Chapter 2.1 deconstructs the concept of surrender, which involves one actor submitting to another, thereby signaling a master-subject relation.

Through Hegel, Derrida, and Tupper, I deduce at least three kinds of relationships that psychedelic users find themselves in when confronting a psychedelic “master” so to speak: master-slave, master/host-guest, and master/teacher-student respectively.

All three relations signify an inward struggle between the sober self and intoxicated self before and after surrendering to the psychedelic Other, although such relations might also manifest in struggles with external entities, as discussed in Chapter 2.2.4 Chapter 2.2 discusses four categories of what is known about individual psychedelic fears borrowed from Rumsfeld’s famous “there are known knowns” comment regarding terrorist risk assessment.

In what I call the psychedelic matrix of knowability, known knowns: bodily surrender (e.g. purgation), known unknowns: death and nondualism, unknown knowns: Freud’s concept of unconscious mind, and unknown unknowns: human absence and nonhuman presence, provide a framework to conceptualize the progression of psychedelic fears from within to potentially from without the user’s mind.

Upon establishing the surrendering motif represented in master-subject relations and what psychedelic users likely fear during their experiences, I aim in Chapter 2.3 to understand what kind of self confronts psychedelic Other(s).

Gallagher and Zahavi argue that self is a “minimal self” in sober conditions and Millière argues for minimal self also during intoxicated states.

Conversely, I argue that self is mostly of the “narrative” sort in sober conditions and during most phases of the psychedelic experience.

However, I show that self can be narrative and minimal depending on dosage and during which stage of experience is considered, thereby suggesting a new framework to qualitatively analyze psychedelically intoxicated conceptions of selfhood that coincide with modernists’ surrenderism.

Page 17

2.1 Master-subject relations

The narratives one tells about one’s self do not develop in a vacuum.

Individual narratives budge against the narratives of others, including the grand social narratives discussed in Chapter 1.

One facet of the narrative self approach7 is that subjects are embodied, and thus embedded, in a society wherein interaction between other selves occur (Schechtman, 2011, 404-405).

Individuals arguably have an (informed, fairly good) idea who they are and where they stand in contrast to other humans and perhaps other living organisms; but how should the individual consider him- or herself when confronted with the psychedelic Other?

In the following, I discuss the concept of surrender and how one might conceptualize (self<–>psychedelic Other) relations.

Mystics and modernists encounter “the Other” during their experiences.

Surrendering to this Other, whatever it may be, gives credence to its overwhelming nature and incomprehensibleness.

William James says in his psychological analysis of self-surrender in religious contexts, “There are only two ways in which it is possible to get rid of anger, worry, fear, despair, or other undesirable affections.

One is that an opposite affection should overpoweringly break over us, and the other is by getting so exhausted with the struggle that we have to stop—so we drop down, give up, and don’t care any longer” (2002, 167).

More specifically, the mystic yields to a similar kind of “abeyance” or passive state in which he or she is “grasped or held by a superior power” (ibid., 295).

Modernists can strive to be unafraid and/or in control to counteract fears brought on by mystical states; however, if or when such measures prove unsuccessful, the individual will, according to James, surrender to the experience with no choice but to let it happen.

The concept of surrender in modern psychedelia is largely found in therapy and harm reduction texts8 (Masters and Houston, 1966; Blewett, 1970; Leary et al, 2007; Johnson et al, 2008; Girón, 2013).

As James notes, an unsustainable struggle leads to exhaustion, which leads to surrender.

Likewise, modernists give themselves over to the substance when they eventually let their “defenses” down: [T]he individual must either struggle to reassemble his shattered defenses …or he must forgo his customary defenses and surrender them by accepting a revision of his self-concept.

This point of surrender is the crux of the experience, for it forms the great divide in the individual’s psychological response to the impact of the drug (Blewett, 1970, 346).

Footnotes:

7 To be discussed in detail in Chapter 2.3.

8 For details on psychedelic users’ personal accounts of surrendering, see: Erowid.org’s Experience Vaults (https://erowid.org/experiences); Fadiman’s (2011) research with LSD; and Strassman’s (2001) research with DMT, to name several.

Page 18

It appears that intense psychogenic effects escalate toward a crescendo at which point the self cannot cope and then gives up.

For this reason, psychedelics force the modernist9 to accept: his or her predicament, a loss of partial or total control over the body and mind, and submission.

How then should the psychedelic Other be regarded when individuals must surrender to it and on what foundation is this relationship based?

There seems to be a master role at play by way of surrender.

What is, or can be assumed of, the narrative of the psychedelic Other?

Answers to the above question help inform the following:

When confronted with a master-like, psychedelic Other, what role does the submitting individual assume?

Next, I examine three master-subject relations such as

  • master-slave (Hegel),
  • master/host-guest (Derrida), and
  • master/teacher-student (Tupper) to draw out the psychedelic Other regarding how it confronts the self.

Master-slave relation

Hegel’s master-slave dialectic is a paradoxical exercise in recognizing self-consciousness in others and oneself.

For Hegel (1977), two persons meet and become uncertain of themselves as independent, essential beings in the presence of the other.

Both persons desire to be certain of their being through the other’s recognition, but there can only be a “recognized” and a “recognizing” (Hegel, 1977, 112-113).

With one’s “being-for-self” at stake, both persons fight to the death until one submits to the other for fear of dying, resulting in one master and one slave: the master risked his life for the recognition he so desired, thus attaining the status of an essential being by negating the slave (ibid., 112-116).

In one sense, the master is independent because he gained his recognition and freedom from the other; however, he is dependent on the slave for said recognition.

The person that risks life attains the truth that he is an essential being and attains a sense of freedom in knowing that fact for he won the struggle.

The slave recognizes being-for-self in the victor and negates himself just as the master negates the slave, since the slave lost the life-or-death struggle for recognition.

In modern notions of the psychedelic experience, the pre-surrender stage is equivalent to two competing states of mind: that of sober self and intoxicated self.

As both selves fight for recognition from each other, or rather for control over the individual’s single mind, sober self (slave) surrenders to the overpowering intoxicated self (master) in the face of ego dissolution/death.

As understood in Hegel’s analysis, the master is dependent on the slave; likewise, the psychedelic post-surrender stage consists of a dependence relationship where intoxicated self presumably uses sober self—i.e. the sober self’s lived experience or narrative self as it were—for inspiration, ideas, addressing repressed feelings and traumas, etc., to evaluate, activate, and manipulate for the sober self to process during the experience.

For the sober self’s part, “work” is thus required to attain being-for-self just as the master had achieved through the initial struggle for recognition.

Hegel says, “…Although the fear of the lord [master] is indeed the beginning of wisdom, consciousness is not therein aware that it is a being-for-

9 I say modernist specifically because shamans are said to control experiences and appear to not experience psychedelics in the same way.

See Chapter 3.

Page 19

itself.

Through work, however, the bondsman [slave] becomes conscious of what he truly is” (1977, 118).

The master learns one lesson in being-for-self insofar as winning the initial life-or-death struggle; the slave effectively learns many lessons in his attainment of being-for-self by shaping himself through introspection and the skills learned in serving the master.

For the slave, attainment of self and thus recognition is learned through the initial fear of the Other (master) and “self-will” to improve (ibid., 119).

As will be discussed in Chapter 3, modern users may be able to learn from shamans and their practices to control psychedelic experiences when facing the psychedelic Other.

Master/host-guest relation

Another way to understand master-subject relations is through Derrida’s (2000) analysis of hospitality.

In this scenario, there is a host or master of the house, and a guest or foreigner/stranger.

Derrida demonstrates the notion of hospitality requested by Socrates in Plato’s Apology of Socrates.

Socrates is foreign to the courts and thus does not speak the legal jargon.

He asks to be treated as a foreigner, and as such, to be shown hospitality as was customary in ancient Athens.

Two forms of hospitality emerge through Derrida’s analysis: conditional hospitality (hospitality by right) and unconditional/absolute hospitality.

Conditional hospitality gives rights to foreigner and host.

The foreigner has a right to hospitality if he or she enters into a “pact” with the host, to mean a declaration of name and identity, where he comes from, perhaps how long he will stay, etc., and thus is subject to the laws of the host nation or the individual’s/host’s home (Derrida, 2000, 23-25).

The host also has rights to know a guest’s name and to dictate the laws of his home, i.e. to set boundaries for his guests (ibid., 27).

The paradox is whether the host is being hospitable by interrogating the guest and setting boundaries.

Unconditional hospitality is paradoxical as well, for if the host welcomes anyone and everyone into his home, foreigner or absolute other (with whom there is no pact), the host losses control of his home and no longer remains the host, but instead becomes the hostage:

“…It’s as if the master, qua master, were prisoner of his place and his power, of his ipseity, of his subjectivity …indeed the master, the one who invites, the inviting host, who becomes the hostage” (ibid., 123-125).

There are paradoxes in the psychedelic experience as well related to Derridean hospitality.

Sober self (for most people) is master of his own mind until he willingly relinquishes sovereignty in surrendering to intoxicated self.

In a sense, sober self practices unconditional hospitality; intoxicated self practices conditional hospitality viewed, thus, as hosting one’s sober self.

Sober self is on a “trip” and is no longer at home—i.e. baseline consciousness/reality—and depends on intoxicated self to offer refuge, or at least to not be too strict on rules and boundaries of the temporary visit.

One rule is certain: sober self surrenders to gain access to the psychedelically altered space.

Unclear are the other boundaries of which sober self is unaware.

It is paradoxical that intoxicated self is not as welcoming as the sober self who volunteered to leave the comfort of his home.

From a Freudian psychoanalytic perspective, the unconscious mind, in combination with an intoxicated self, continues to keep secrets or at the very least trickles insights to sober self.

Also noteworthy is the idea of the pact; the sober self post ego dissolution cannot introduce himself to the intoxicated self/host for there is nothing, or 20 hardly anything resembling sober self, to introduce, and thus a possible tension between the two selves.

It is customary to know whom one lets into one’s home.

On the one hand, sober self takes a leap of faith10 and hopes for the best, and on the other, intoxicated self is reserved and less forthright.

Master/teacher-student relation

Finally, the master-subject relation can be viewed as master/teacher-student.

Here, the relationship between psychedelic Other and user finds new meaning in shamans’ use of “plant teachers,” namely ayahuasca.

The Peruvian shamans believe that with the help of certain psychoactive plants, many of which have their own “mother/spirit,” they gain powers how to diagnose illness, knowledge of plants to cure sick patients, how to defend themselves from evil spirits and other shamans, and acquire traditional magic/healing songs known as icaros (Luna, 1984, 139-142).

Shamans’ claims to acquiring knowledge through plant teachers offer promising avenues for academic research.

Canadian philosopher of education, Kenneth Tupper, researches the benefits of using psychedelics as cognitive tools for learning.

Commenting on Huxley’s views of incorporating psychedelics into the education system, Tupper (2014) explores the possibility of “entheogenic education.” Such a curriculum could fill a gap in the modern education system by “fostering the emotions of wonder and awe and their relationship to creativity, life meaning, and purpose” (ibid., 15; see also: Tupper, 2002).

It remains uncertain whether he advocates the learning of or the taking of psychedelics as education, students’ age in this idealized entheogenic education program, or the dosage he has in mind, but the point Tupper makes is sound: people might be able to learn about themselves through the use of plant teachers.

Being informed about psychedelics’ traditional use and previous misuse in modern society might help people handle their fears as well.

In sum, according to modernist approaches, the psychedelic Other is necessarily in control for the duration of the experience, certainly after surrendering and near peak experience.

Intoxicated self becomes the pilot of the individual’s psychic vehicle (the mind) while sober self becomes the passenger hoping the pilot does not crash the plane, which would cost them both of their lives, or rather, selves.

Similar to what Hegel argues, intoxicated self is (or might be) the sober self, but a different version thereof.

Both selves fight for recognition, but only one will win, especially as sober self approaches the experience’s peak, at which point intoxicated self forces submission and sober self gives up by force or knows beforehand of the pending surrender.

The master/teacher-student relation is as paradoxical as the previous two relations: the Other is an atypical teacher and the “class lesson” 10 I say leap of faith because no one can predict how the psychedelic experience will play out.

The seeming lack of agency on modernists’ part happens chiefly during the experience.

Certainly, the sober self has a great degree of agency before taking the substance: he or she can

  • choose whether to take the drug;
  • to choose the conditions of location (retreat, private, or public setting);
  • to choose with whom he or she will take the drug (fellow users and/or sober guides); and,
  • to educate him- or herself on the phenomenology of the experience through conferences, online media such as drug fora and YouTube, books, conversations, etc.

Therefore, according to Derrida’s views on hosts and guests, the sober self is the guest during the experience, yet, is the host prior to the experience.

One of the themes of Chapter 3 is how sober self can wield more agency through technical and technological use during experiences and when confronting the psychedelic Other.

Page 21

is likely a one-way conversation in a seemingly different language without opportunity for questions or breaks.

Next, I discuss degrees of knowability of the psychedelic experience, most importantly loss of bodily and mental control, which correspond to the loss of control found in master-subject relations, inducing fear in users.

2.2 Psychedelic matrix of knowability

During a Department of Defense news briefing, U.S. Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld (2002), made some puzzling (yet articulate) remarks over the war on terror:

Reports that say that something hasn’t happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know.

We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know.

But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don’t know we don’t know.

And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tend to be the difficult ones.

As national defense professionals, Rumsfeld, and his Department’s task, was to anticipate and hopefully subdue future threats.

To do this, they need to know what is known—things that are known but to which extent are uncertain, and how to respond to unexpected, unpredicted unknowns.

Slavoj Žižek (2006) argues that Rumsfeld forgot to add a fourth category to his analysis, that of unknown knowns.

The known category (known knowns and known unknowns) vary in degree of knowability; the same can be said about the unknown category (unknown knowns and unknown unknowns), that is to say, one might have an idea of what is known, but at some point the completely unknown takes one by surprise or leads one to speculate.

It is through this psychedelic matrix of knowability that I analyze the structure and content of individuals’ likely fears.

Analyses of knowns and unknowns have been made before in the fields of terrorism (Daase and Kessler, 2007), international sporting events (Horne, 2007), policymaking (Pawson et al, 2011), and business risk management (Fadun, 2013), to name several.

I provide a similar analysis on psychedelics.

With that said, I do not claim to be an expert in assessing risk, nor implementing and analyzing formulae, etc.; rather, I use Rumsfeld’s remarks as a qualitative framework to philosophically probe the psychosomatic effects of potentially fearful psychedelic experiences.

Along these lines, I expand upon discussions of mystical ineffability from Chapter 1 by unpacking the comparable experiences inherent to psychedelics.

I predict there is correlation between the effable-known and the ineffable-unknown since it is reasonable to assume difficulty in describing yet-seen and yet-experienced intense imagery, emotions, and ecstatic states.

Supernatural and cosmic horror fiction writer, H. P. Lovecraft, says, “The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and 22 the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown” (1973, 12).

Thus, “the (psychedelic) Fear” of individuals will be covered in succeeding sections, steering one toward the utter unknown.

2.2.1 Known knowns: Bodily surrender

“Known knowns are facts, rules, and laws that we know with certainty.

We know, for example, that gravity is what makes an object fall to the ground” (Rumsfeld, 2011, xiv).

Before addressing mental aspects of psychedelic experiences, this section underscores the body, the first feature of individuality to surrender.

Assuming the brain acts like a pivot between bodily perception and mind, one must first be willing to surrender the body to gain access to altered states, expressed as: [body—brain—mind].

Surrendering the body to the psychedelic includes bodily fluids and their possible purgation, or vomiting.

Under normal circumstances, vomiting suggests something is physically wrong, one has an illness, one must vomit out toxic substances, including associations of shame and guilt of being unable to control one’s bodily functions.

Most likely, the shaman is more familiar with bouts of psychedelic-inducing purgation, while modernists are not.

Thus, one of the best-known fears about substances such as iboga (Lotsof, 1994) and ayahuasca (Shanon, 2002) is the loss of bodily control, namely the purgative aspect.

Purgation takes on metaphorical significance, especially in ayahuasca ceremonies, notably bodily and affective effects.

According to psychologist Benny Shanon (2002), vomiting is not universal, however, some drinkers “often feel that they are pouring out the depths of both their body and their soul” (57).

For ayahuasca practitioners called ayahuasqueros or curanderos (healers), the purgative process is a curative one with multiple levels of cleansing.

First, is bodily, achieved through purgation; second, is psychological, forcing people to face their issues and problems; and third, is spiritual (religious, mystical), representing a sense of “true knowledge” attained, in addition to insights regarding ethical conduct in one’s life (ibid., 49-51, 307).

Therefore, the body and mind are cleansed, and to some extent purified, in this cathartic and surrendering moment.

In Poetics, Aristotle speaks of the tragedy in a similar fashion.

The tragedy, unlike the comedy, arouses the imitation of pity and fear in the audience, allowing the purgation or release of said emotions with the benefit of not having to experience them first-hand.

“Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude …through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation of these emotions” (Aristotle, 1922, 23).

Through imitation, and without having to suffer the consequences of the characters on stage, the tragedy serves as a learning exercise, i.e. learning through others.

In the case of the psychedelic user, he or she does experience these emotions first-hand in the moment, as well as the claimed release of preexisting traumas or repressed emotions.

The psychedelic experience can be viewed as a tragedy or comedy depending on the individual’s outlook.

Although the tragedy evokes pity and fear according to Aristotle, that is not to say all psychedelic experiences are tragic; the experience might be pleasant even in the event of inconvenient vomiting and/or diarrhea.

Page 23

Another known known is the inability to stop participating in the experience once it has started, e.g. to try purging the substance hoping that effects cease to continue.

For example, LSD produces initial effects between 20-60 minutes after ingestion and for mushrooms between 7-45 minutes (Stafford, 1992, 68, 265).

DMT, on the other hand, is active under 30 seconds after ingestion (Strassman, 2001).

One must be sure when taking these substances for it is nearly11 impossible to reverse the process.

As Shanon (2002) hints at with ayahuasca, the body is the first to surrender as it metabolizes the seldom-ingested psychedelic.

The next three sections cover the further loss of control of the human organism, primarily of the mind.

2.2.2 Known unknowns: Death, or rather, nondualism

“Known unknowns are gaps in our knowledge, but they are gaps that we know exist.  We know, for example, that we don’t know the exact extent of Iran’s nuclear weapons program. 

“If we ask the right questions we can potentially fill this gap in our knowledge, eventually making it a known known” (Rumsfeld, 2011, xiv).

It is reasonable to want an idea of what to expect during a psychedelic experience and variations in its intensity, i.e. how much of one’s self remains, changes, or dissolves.

Philosopher and cognitive scientist, Link Swanson (2018), provides a detailed overview of what one can expect:

  • perceptual effects (“sense of meaning in percepts is altered,” perceptual distortions, illusions);
  • elementary hallucinations (geometric patterns); complex hallucinations (visual scenes, landscapes, cities, human and nonhuman beings);
  • emotional effects (intensification of feelings, losing control); and
  • cognitive effects (acute changes in linear thinking and increased levels of creative thinking) (3-5).

Many fear-inducing occurrences fall within the known unknowns category because there is much that is known about psychedelic experiences, but the degree to which they manifest is unknown.

Greater instances of ego dissolution correspond to increases in dosage (Griffiths et al, 2011); thus dosage, coupled with personal lived experience, produces limitless percepts to experience.

Death is the exemplar of a known unknown.

Individuals know they are going to die without knowing the exact conditions.

The same can be said about ego dissolution in that the psychedelic user does not know to which degree his or her ego/self will merge toward and with a nondual state.

Since nondrug users also contemplate death, it seems appropriate, then, to discuss “ego death,” or the state of non-beingness.

I argue that psychedelic-induced alterations of ego/self are the focus of a category mistake unknowingly promulgated by academics’ terminological use concerning psychedelic research and conceptualization, which can be misleading and therefore conjures fear.

First, current terminology mistakenly frames psychedelics in terms of death and mental illness.

In psychiatry, psychology, and neuroscience, the following terms are used synonymously to

11 Strassman (1984) says major tranquilizers should be used as a last resort “for only the most disturbed and agitated patients” (589), and while tranquilizers calm patients down, there are no guarantees that visionary effects will be annulled.

Page 24

describe the non-ego state:

  • “ego death” (Pahnke, 1969b; Grof, 1980; Leary et al, 2007),
  • “ego loss” (Leary et al, 2007),
  • “ego disintegration” (Muthukumaraswamy et al, 2013; Lebedev et al, 2015),
  • “ego dissolution” (Masters and Houston, 1966; Dittrich, 1998 [dread of]; Studerus et al, 2010; Lebedev et al, 2015; Tagliazucchi et al, 2016), and
  • “drug-induced ego dissolution (DIED)” (Millière, 2017).

While the concept of death shares elements of awe, acceptance, and a state of non-being with mystical and psychedelic experiences, death is also often associated with pain, suffering, and reduced quality of life, which are characteristics perhaps inherent to but not definitive of mystical and psychedelic experiences (i.e. during negative experiences).

Arguably, one of the central fears of death lies in knowing that one will not be oneself or present in a physical (and possibly mental) form, that one no longer exists.

However, this is not the case with “ego death” since one comes back from the nondual experience.

Not only are these terms used in academic discourse, but also colloquially, which academicians’ usage of these terms certainly influenced popular culture.

Regarding mental illness, terms such as “dissolution” and “disintegration” referring to notions of ego/self/I/individuality, notes Lebedev et al, are reminiscent of psychiatric terms referring to cases of acute psychosis and temporal lobe epilepsy auras (2015, 1-2; see also: Stockings, 1940; Hoffer et al, 1954; Grinker, 1963; Mogar, 1970).

Usage of the abovementioned ego terminology is a carryover from psychiatric research of psychedelics in the mid-twentieth century.

Academics still cling to the term dissolution to refer to the ego when it is clear, as I argue in Chapter 1, that psychedelic experiences are more aligned with mystical states than mental illness.

Thus, in an attempt to curtail fear, academics could move away from associating the altered ego with anything to do with dissolution, disintegration, loss, death, or DIED! when discussing these experiences.

Second, dissolution and disintegration do not accurately explain psychedelic experiences.

They are “active” words, in that they are “in the process of,” neither specifying unity nor semiintoxicated states, but rather both states concurrently.

For example, dissolution is defined as “the act or process of dissolving” (Merriam-Webster, n.d.

–a) and disintegration as “the act or process of disintegrating or the state of being disintegrated” (Merriam-Webster, n.d.

–b).

It is unclear whether one had a “melting away” experience, in the words of one mystic (Stace, 1960), or a “melted” experience, whether the ego/self is dissolving or is dissolved.

Lumping the two categories together confounds exactly what is meant.

There is no clear-cut demarcation of experience as Stace (1960) makes in his analysis of mysticism, specifically regarding his criterion of unity/union.

Fears about psychedelic experiences in general might lessen when terms are conceptualized as precisely as possible.

Therefore, notions of death12 and mental illness could be dissociated from psychedelic experiences; invoking present participle (-ing suffix) and past tense (-ed suffix) 12 My use of Hegel’s struggle to the death concept in relation to surrendering may seem contradictory to my proposition to abstain from associating concepts of death and loss to psychedelic experiences.

I use the master-slave dialectic as a heuristic to construct a typology of master-subject relations, acknowledging that this might seem paradoxical to readers, but unavoidable.

25 conjugations are less erroneous; and finally, people sympathetic to the commonly used terms could at very least discriminate between ego dissolving and ego dissolved13.

2.2.3 Unknown knowns: Unconscious mind

“Things we don’t know that we know—which is precisely the Freudian unconscious, the ‘knowledge which doesn’t know itself’” (Žižek, 2006, 137).

Specifically, unknown knowns are: “…The disavowed beliefs, suppositions, and obscene practices we pretend not to know about, although they form the background of our public values” (ibid.).

Žižek rightly includes an additional category to Rumsfeld’s original three.

The collective unconscious, at which Žižek hints, impacts individuals’ unconscious minds; however, it is at the level of the individual that psychedelics agonize neuronal receptors (e.g. serotonin, κ-opioid) and can potentially terrorize the mind.

In reference to the cliché iceberg-mind metaphor, what lies in the dark abyss of the unconscious mind and of unacquainted realities, that which the conscious mind, the protruding tip of the iceberg, floats atop, and that which individuals fear?

Surely, everyone is fearful of something, whether it be an object, emotion, etc.

But what if the fear object, the psychedelic Other, originates from within oneself; what if the fear object is one’s self?

In other words, what is revealed about the self when the subject becomes the object of fear?

There are at least two ways to examine self-as-psychedelic-Other within the context of the unconscious: Freud’s theory of the uncanny and Huxley’s “Mind-at-Large.” Through these examples, the aforementioned master-subject relations become evident.

The uncanny.

What are the causes of behaviors, and are these causes so ingrained in one’s unconscious that they make up a part of the individual’s identity for better or worse?

It can be argued that everyone has something to hide from themselves and others: yet-processed intense emotional episodes, repressed memories and traumas, forgotten once known knowns, or future aspirations and dreams to which individuals aspire.

To discover what individuals fear about psychedelics is part and parcel to make the unconscious conscious.

One seemingly shared aspect of humans’ unconscious regarding the psychedelic experience is the idea of not being at home with oneself.

In German, das Heimliche (“the homely”) means “belonging to the home, not strange, familiar, tame, dear and intimate, etc.,” whereas das Unheimliche (“the unhomely”, the uncanny) stands for “everything that was meant to remain secret and hidden and has come into the open; something removed from the eyes of strangers; and notions of danger” (Freud, 2003, 126, 132-134).

For Freud, the uncanny is: “…That species of the frightening that goes back to what was once well known and had long been familiar” (ibid, 124), an “intellectual uncertainty” that arises when “the boundary between fantasy and reality is blurred, when we are faced with the reality of something that we have until now considered imaginary” (ibid., 138, 150).

Thus, 13 I resume this discussion in Chapter 2.3.

26 uncanny moments elucidate something that is hidden or secret, a reminder from a forgotten past, the blurring of boundaries even but for seconds.

Both types of trips, either physically traveling (without psychedelics) or mentally (with psychedelics), implies that one is somewhere other than home, i.e. one is not in the familiarity of one’s home.

I propose in Chapter 2.1 that the sober self’s home in this case is familiar, baseline consciousness and reality; under psychedelics, the conscious mind is temporarily not “at home” but rather in a state of disequilibrium.

Likewise, the unconscious mind is a pseudo home that some seldom venture into or never at all, with or without drugs.

Is fear of the unconscious mind under psychedelic conditions, then, a threat to sober self and conscious mind, a fear of not being at home with oneself?

One of Freud’s (2003) examples regarding the uncanny is the Doppelgänger.

Such a familiar Other may cause one to identify with and “so become unsure of his true self” (ibid., 142); that is, there is cause for a “double take,” a second look, to affirm that one is truly oneself.

Looking at a face familiar to one’s own is like looking into a mirror, yet it is not an inanimate mirror; this mirror moves and is alive and thus is uncanny.

Similarly, under psychedelic influence, the Other may not be just another Other, instead is within the individual, a part of, or a different version of, sober self.

For example, there is an adage not to trust people who do not drink alcohol.

Perhaps alcohol is viewed as a “truth serum” that reveals one’s honest inner opinions to oneself and others.

According to this view, one should not trust someone who dares not be honest and vulnerable in front of others, especially with family and friends.

With psychedelics, however, one shows one’s “true colors” to oneself.

Just as unsavory qualities exist in others, there exists negative aspects within oneself, and these, in addition to other hidden aspects, might become illuminated to sober self.

The psychedelic Other exposes the good and the bad of oneself based on whatever lurks in both conscious and unconscious minds.

In surrendering to the psychedelic Other, from the modernist’s perspective, one has little control over the experience’s narrative.

Mind-at-Large.

While there exists duality between sober and intoxicated self, and conscious and unconscious mind, Huxley seems to have considered only one part of an important equation regarding the mind.

Huxley (2013) argues that the brain and nervous system act as “reducing valves” and the ego as a “filter” to limit what is perceived of “Mind-at-Large” (pure consciousness, other realities, unlimited potential, etc.) to not overwhelm the human organism, thus to maximize survival.

If Huxley’s hypothesis is correct, he may be considering only half of the equation.

Instead of brain-asvalve and ego-as-filter acting as bottleneck in the shape of a wine bottle for example, might the mind act instead like an hourglass?

In what I call “Mind-at-Small,” the localized level plays the part of the individual’s unconscious mind.

As psychedelics increase the flow of information from Mind-at-Large to the conscious mind, it seems possible that psychedelics might also increase the flow of information from Mind-at-Small to the conscious mind.

I hypothesize in Chapter 2.2.1 that the pivot in bodily surrender is the brain expressed as [body—brain—mind].

In accordance with Huxley’s Mind-at-Large model viewed within the category of unknown knowns, the pivot in mental surrender could be the 27 conscious mind, expressed as: [(unconscious mind)—(conscious mind/ego)—(Universal mind/ego)].

This might explain the hourglass bottleneck I propose, for it seems that the unconscious mind and Universal mind affect the conscious mind concurrently.

I argue that the catalytic psychedelic shines light, or opens the doors of perception to use Huxley’s phrase, on both the conscious and unconscious minds.

Just as Huxley’s reducing valves limit what is perceived to maximize survivability of the human organism, note too, the unconscious mind hides or forgets what is unnecessary to daily survival.

Insofar as individuals fear surrendering their body to purgation and their mind to ego “death,” it seems that fear of mental pain and suffering through exploration and potential discovery of one’s behavioral causes offer a possible explanation to the unknown knowns category.

2.2.4 Unknown unknowns: Human absence and nonhuman presence

“The category of unknown unknowns is the most difficult to grasp.

They are gaps in our knowledge, but gaps that we don’t know exist.

Genuine surprises tend to arise out of this category; …The best strategists try to imagine and consider the possible, even if it seems unlikely.

They are then more likely to be prepared and agile enough to adjust course if and when new and surprising information requires it” (Rumsfeld, 2011, xiv).

As Rumsfeld and his military strategists have contingency plans, individuals should also reflect upon whom or what they encounter during psychedelic experiences.

Otherwise, how can one properly prepare for visionary content and context if one exclusively contemplates the knowns?

Philosophical analysis is an asset to psychedelic research to make informed speculations how these experiences might be understood within the realm of the unknown.

The domain of the psychedelic unknown is where academics and amateurs share a common discourse, that of speculation.

Why does the unknown, especially under psychedelics, frighten some individuals?

How can someone be fearful of which he or she does not know?

How does one find/create meaning from things one has never perceived?

Whereas inductive reasoning was used to rationalize the previous three categories of the psychedelic matrix of knowability, I endeavor to frame in this final section what the psychedelic experience could be, using conceivable fears as my guiding principle, to discuss: psychedelic entities, absence of humanness, and presence of nonhumanness.

In the process of surrendering, psychedelic psychotherapist and researcher, Duncan Blewett (1970), metaphorically states that the “ultimate fear” of the individual is locked in his or her heart and this fear reveals something previously unknown about the self: “If I should come to know myself completely and still hate and revile myself—what then?

What if the self is unacceptable, completely unwanted—an entity without purpose or meaning?” (347).

To be fair, Blewett does consider the unknown, but his view falls short in the matrix of knowability, perhaps going so far as the unknown knowns category.

The ultimate fear for Blewett is self-revealment if the psychedelic Other originates 28 from within oneself; however, might this Other be external to oneself, or a combination of within and from without the individual?

There is ample testimonial evidence that psychedelics utilize information from the subject’s psyche—i.e. the Freudian unconscious including repressed traumas and memories, and Jungian archetypes, myths, and symbols (Masters and Houston, 1966, 213-246).

However, experiential content may be something different altogether in the realm of the extraordinary, which lead academics and users to question how to regard the nature of the experience.

Huxley (1999) disagrees with the premise that the psyche 14 plays a role in the psychedelic experience (particularly regarding mescaline).

He argues that the “Antipodes of the mind”—the equivalent of Australia and its fauna: kangaroos, wallabies, duck-billed platypuses, creatures never before seen by Europeans until Australia’s discovery—is “the Other World” in which to explore these beings-in-themselves.

For example, a symbol represents the meaning of something else, yet, according to Huxley, the inhabitants of these Other Worlds are not symbols, “they do not stand for something else, do not mean anything except themselves.

The significance of each thing is identical with its being.

Its point is that it is” (1999, Ch.13).

For Huxley, visionary content do not represent something, are not symbols for something else, or invented by the psyche; rather, they allow (mescaline) users to perceive psychedelic things-in-themselves as they appear.

Anthropologists (ayahuasca: Harner, 1973; iboga: Fernandez, 1982; ayahuasca: Luna, 1984), psychiatrists (DMT: Strassman, 2001), and psychologists (ayahuasca: Shanon, 2002; DMT: Luke, 2011; Winkelman, 2018) progressively report of contact with spirit helpers/guides and ancestral spirits, and some have developed preliminary ontologies of nonhuman psychedelic beings.

Not only is contact reported of these entities but also communication with these entities.

McKenna was asked in the final interview before his death what the nature of these entities might be, what constitutes their apparent agency or communicative agency.

McKenna (1999) replies, “That’s the question that remains unanswered …that’s the grail of the thing, what is the nature of the [psychedelic] other …it’s not clear to me what it is.” Despite the essence of the psychedelic Other being unclear, McKenna (1998) states elsewhere: “These places are profoundly strange and alien” (37).

Phenomenologically speaking, reports of encountered beings during psychedelic experiences cannot be ignored since it is happening.

Psychedelic entities repeatedly manifest into human and humanoid-looking entities; whether they are hallucinatory or veridical matters not: it is a reoccurring phenomenon, one that is seeping from the unknown into the known.

The unity state described by mystics is indeed an unknown unknown for many psychedelic users; but is it the ultimate fear?

Likewise, reports of human-like and nonhuman entities would normally fall under the category of known unknowns since their existence is known, yet it is unclear who these entities are, where they come from, what they want, or how many types there are.

I include 14 Hence, Huxley’s unwillingness to consider whether the unconscious mind (Mind-at-Small) plays any role in psychedelic experiences (see Chapter 2.2.3).

29 entities in the category of unknown unknowns to argue that their presence alone is a candidate for the ultimate fear.

As previous subchapters highlight the relinquishment of bodily control, fear of (ego) death, and fear of one’s mind respectively, the philosophy of horror offers unhuman and deanthropomorphized approaches needed to fully appreciate drug and nondrug users’ fears of the psychedelic unknown in all its uncertainty.

The degree of alienness coupled with possible agency or consciousness on the part of entities involves a human absence and a nonhuman presence, both of which intensify simultaneously in philosophy of horror and unknown contexts.

Until recently, discourse on Otherness primarily focused on “Other as human.” Philosophers Eugene Thacker and Dylan Trigg, and to some extent subscribers to the recent field of speculative realism, claim that philosophy is anthropocentrically biased.

“Anomalies” of psychedelic entities, in the Kuhnian (1970) sense, are difficult to explain using the current anthropocentric paradigm: Enter the philosophy of horror.

Thacker (2011) proposes that, “Horror be understood not as dealing with human fear in a human world (the world-for-us), but that horror be understood as being about the limits of the human as it confronts a world that is not just a World, and not just the Earth, but also a Planet (the world-without-us)” (8).

When considering psychedelic experiences, it may be more effective to dissociate oneself from human rationalization, to recognize that the world is not a human world, but rather simply a world indifferent and neutral to human existence, perhaps even a world with nonhuman and nonphysical inhabitants.

Such a world could accommodate hypotheses of psychedelic entities.

Thus, a new phenomenology is needed to discern Huxley’s so-called “Other World” and its inhabitants.

Similarly, from a philosophy of body horror perspective, Trigg (2014) says, “The unhuman is closely tied up with notions of alienation, anonymity, and the unconscious,” in other words, an “unhuman phenomenology,” a “xenophenomenology,” that is “concerned with the limits of alterity” (6, emphasis added).

The psychedelic experience is an exercise in deconstructing human concepts such as symbols, language, culture, belief systems, etc.; thus, as the subject approaches the limits of alterity by merging with the Other, one’s humanness becomes increasingly absent, i.e. one is not wholly oneself.

In light of psychedelic-induced ASC, a xenophenomenology in a de-anthropomorphized world would do well to conceptualize the significance of the altered-toabsent human subject as well as psychedelic entities and the world(s) they inhabit.

Lovecraft makes use of xenophenomenology to describe nonhuman antagonists in his horror fiction stories.

Long before Marshall McLuhan coined the phrase, “the medium is the message,” Lovecraft epitomized this idea in his writing style that brimmed with outdated, strange, and incomprehensible words and that incited fear and mystique in and of themselves.

Philosopher Graham Harman (2012) analyzes Lovecraft’s stories in his book Weird Realism.

One of the trademarks of Lovecraft’s style is his ability to implicitly say something about something opaque, some cosmically horrible entity, to allude to “the spirit of the thing” or “general outline of the whole” (Harman, 2012, 237).

Lovecraft’s many unnamable creatures hearken back to Derridean hospitality in that one cannot 30 name the psychedelic Other(s).

It is unsettling to not know with whom or what one is dealing, i.e. psychedelic users get some information but not the whole picture, and hence the ineffability shared by mystics.

Moreover, according to Harman (2012), Lovecraft’s characters have sincerity—especially the nonhuman sort—meaning that they “fascinate,” “engross,” and “seem to exhibit a genuine inner life of [their] own” (44).

Inasmuch as Lovecraft’s human protagonists strain to see the outlines of appalling “noumenal beings” (Harman, 2012), psychedelic users attempt to make sense of rarely or never seen entities that exhibit an “inner life,” an agency, an intention, perhaps being conscious or intelligent.

The psychedelic user broaches a boundary where he or she enters into questionable territory: known-unknown, merging-unmerging, safe-unsafe?

One thought going through one’s mind might be “what am I merging with?” as one merges/unifies/“dissolves” toward a nondual state.

What if one does not want to merge with a nonhuman, that whomever or whatever happens to be present on that particular experience?

Especially if this entity exhibits a genuine “life of its own.”

Even though Lovecraft says one should leave their “humanity and terrestrialism at the threshold” when crossing the “boundless and hideous unknown” (Thacker, 2011, 80-81), he does offer consolation: that the beneficent aspects of the unknown have been reserved by mainstream religions, and therefore, according to religious leaders, any unknown other than what is endorsed by religious institutions is demonic (Lovecraft, 1973, 14).

Lovecraft disputes religious leaders’ claim to ownership or rights in the realm of the unknown, implying that the so-called bad or evil unknowns might not be as bad or evil as religious leaders claim them to be.

They are simply unknown.

Irrespective of the beneficence or maleficence of entities, it is the mere outlined presence of such beings that have the potential to cause fear in individuals for such beings seem alive, real, and to have a sense of agency.

Visual artist, Ivana Franke, exhibited her artwork in Berlin, Germany, from April to July 2017, entitled Retreat into Darkness.

Towards a Phenomenology of the Unknown.

One of her installations involved aluminum structures comprised of monofilament nets.

The light from the bulbs reflected off of the structures to create an eerie presence as one moved around the dark room.

Sayim and Franke (2018, 119, emphasis added) say: Such fear and discomfort were caused not only by the darkness and the need to move around and navigate in the dark, but presumably also by the presence of something unexplainable at an unclear distance that moved on its own and in response to the motion of observers, and sometimes even appeared alive.

It is in darkness, or the abundance of moving miniature lights in darkness, where one can appreciate the phenomenology of the unknown.

The incertitude of percepts allows one to experience the uncanniness, the strangeness, “where ordinary object categorization collapses” (ibid., 107), and thus the inability to categorize objects that should fit into some known category of one’s lived experience and lifeworld.

Similarly, how can the phenomena reported by psychedelic users possibly

31

manifest/exist?

The content of psychedelic experiences is a category mistake, or rather, a category needing clarification.

In the absence of light, in the absence of humanity where the presence of psychedelic entities exists, is where the ultimate fear lies.

For it is here at the limits of the known, in the dark recesses of the mind and obfuscated Other Worlds, where the psychedelic Other lingers and its intentions unknown.

It is against this backdrop of knowability, human absence and nonhuman presence, where self confronts psychedelic Others from without.

Next, I discuss implications for an understanding of self, using psychedelic ASCs as counterweights against which to compare.

2.3 The self: Narrative vs. minimal

What is the self—this first person referential point of experience of the individual, and which theory of self should be applied to the framework of fear of psychedelic experiences?

I expand upon Gallagher’s (2000) claim that the concepts of minimal self and narrative self deserve special attention as they lead to the current debate15 in cognitive neuroscience and philosophy.

Both selves are ideal candidates for a richer appreciation of mystical and psychedelic experiences depending on the individual’s level of intoxication.

To better comprehend which concept of self applies to which stage of the psychedelic experience, I continue the discussion from Chapter 2.2.2 concerning the notion of “ego dissolution” and propose a new set of terms to conceptualize the psychedelically altered self.

Whether framed in the context of drugs or not, philosophers and neuroscientists are eager to weigh in on neural correlates of consciousness and their significance for the concept of self16 (Gallagher, 2000; Lebedev et al, 2015; Millière, 2017).

Phenomenologist Dan Zahavi (2003) argues for a (phenomenological) minimal self, or “core self,” in which self and experience are integrated and have an inherent “givenness” that makes the experience unique for a particular conscious being: “…It just entails being conscious of an experience in its first-personal mode of givenness, that is, from ‘within’” (59).

Gallagher (2000) says regarding minimal self: “Phenomenologically, that is, in terms of how one experiences it, a consciousness of oneself as an immediate subject of experience, unextended17 in time” (15).

Minimal self is a concept that determines one’s sense of self in its most 15 I am aware of Damasio’s (1999) contribution to this discussion.

Although based on his writings of proto, core, and autobiographical self, and core and extended consciousness, I chose rather to focus on the most current debate.

16 Gallagher (2011) and his contributors introduce a variety of ways to consider the self: “Minimal, narrative, real, not real, existing, illusory, reduced, irreducible, embodied, psychological, social, pathological, socially constructed, and deconstructed” (1-29).

Disagreement about what the self is stresses the importance of defining self in the context of psychedelic experiences.

In addition to minimal and narrative selves I highlight in this section, the concept of no-self is relevant.

Proponents argue from neuroscientific and Buddhist approaches: neuroscientific as there is a “set of functional mechanisms that would integrate individual property-representations into a unified ‘self-representation’ or self-model,” thus does not constitute a self, and Buddhist, which argues that there is no such thing as a self, therefore, such beliefs are merely illusion/fiction (ibid., 10).

17 “Unextended in time” does not refer to Stace’s (1960) core characteristics of mystical states, such as non-spatiality and non-temporality; Gallagher refers to the immediacy of the subject’s conscious experience.

Page 32

minimal quality: a sense of presence and consciousness in and of the immediate moment irrespective of self-identity or personal meaningfulness attributed to one’s life.

In contrast to minimal self, proponents of narrative self suggest that self is autobiographical and extended in time, thus memories of one’s lived experiences and future aspirations play significant roles.

The (hermeneutical) narrative self can be viewed as two sides of the same “sense of self” coin: “Beings who lead their lives rather than merely having a history, and leading the life of a self is taken inherently to involve understanding one’s life as a narrative and enacting the narrative one sees as one’s life” (Schechtman, 2011, 395).

For one’s actions to become meaningful and significant, agency is another important quality of narrative self because it “requires that we interpret our behaviors in the context of a narrative” (ibid., emphasis added).

As I show throughout this chapter, the individual brings his or her personal narratives into psychedelic experiences.

It is equivalent to embarking on a trip: an individual does not check in at the airport naked with nothing but a passport; rather, he or she arrives clothed, usually with luggage, and has a reason/intention to travel.

As well, individuals do not begin a psychedelic experience naked, i.e. as some kind of minimal self devoid of lived experience.

Individuals bring with them historical, sociocultural, emotional, conscious, and unconscious baggage.

Zahavi places the notion of minimal/core self under the category of phenomenology, yet it is the hermeneutical-narrative sense of self that is better equipped to explain the phenomenology, and in part the meaning and root, of potentially fearful psychedelic experiences.

2.3.1 Understanding self in the presence of psychedelic Other

Pahnke (1963, 1969a) developed the Mystical Experience Questionnaire (MEQ) using Stace’s (1960) phenomenological account of mystical experience to test whether psychedelics such as psilocybin occasion mystical experiences.

In recent studies, Griffiths et al (2011) used a modified version of the MEQ to test specifically for: “unity (either internal or external18, whichever was greater), sense of sacredness, noetic quality, transcendence of time and space, positive mood, and ineffability” (653; see also: Griffiths et al, 2006).

Volunteers must have scored ≥ 60% in each of the six scales to affirm “complete” mystical experience with psilocybin.

The prescription of ratios and numerical scores is questionable, pace Pahnke and Griffiths et al, to gauge whether one had a so-called complete mystical experience.

The ratio of ≥ 60% should not be used unquestionably as to whether one had a mystical experience for: 1) Dr.

Griffiths (2018) acknowledges in a personal email communication that the 60% threshold is “arbitrary,” and 2) Pahnke does not explicate in any of his texts referring to the MEQ why he chose that number19.

Is it possible

18 Stace (1960) differentiates between two types of mysticism: extrovertive perceives outward through the physical senses to recognize unity or oneness in all things, while introvertive looks inward toward the ego/self, “in that darkness and silence, he alleges that he perceives …the wholly naked One devoid of any plurality whatever” (61-62).

19 Pahnke (1969a) cites a seemingly nonexistent article/study, or rather poorly referenced, bringing into question how and why he and his associates agreed upon the 60% ratio minimum (see: pages 153 and 162) to determine complete mystical experience, and which subsequent researchers follow de facto.

Page 33

to have a complete mystical experience without experiencing a wholly nondual state, i.e. any figure above 0.60 ratio, according to the MEQ?

Perhaps.

Although, according to the above view, it seems that if a state of oneness is the ultimate mystical experience one can have, it should be expressed by the greatest score possible: 1.0.

All things considered, threshold ratios need to be reexamined and possibly revised, or, academics could use a qualitative approach to test for mystical attainment.

Researchers are undoubtedly on the right track in testing these extraordinarily profound subjective experiences; nonetheless, a more logical way to determine complete mystical experience and conceptualize degrees of selfhood during the psychedelic experience is possible.

In a move away from psychiatric and neuroscientific terminology, I propose an alternative set of concepts inspired by the aforementioned category mistake in Chapter 2.2.2 and Stace’s (1960) universal characteristics of mystical experiences:

  • dual state (DS),
  • semi-dual state (semi-DS),
  • semi-nondual state (semi-NDS), and
  • nondual state (NDS):

list:

  • DS: complete sober state of narrative self;
  • semi-DS: pre-surrender state of narrative self;
  • semi-NDS: post-surrender state of narrative self;
  • NDS or complete mystical experience: the state whereupon the subject does not experience a sense of narrative self/ego, but there remains a minimal/core self that experiences nonduality.

This is not to say that experiences not of a nondual nature are any less interesting or important.

For Stace (1960), “borderline cases” are “cases in which some but not all of the defining characteristics appear, and which may even include features the absence of which is characteristic of typical cases” (81).

Stace acknowledges the existence of states falling between the mystical and non-mystical and that satisfy some but not all of his universal characteristics.

In consideration of Stace’s most defining characteristic of mysticism—i.e. unity (1960, 66), psychedelic experiences of a non-NDS nature (semi-DS and semi-NDS) are intoxicated states that do not satisfy a complete mystical experience.

To use an example from physics, one cannot claim to have experienced the singularity of a black hole if one is on the other side of the event horizon.

In other words, such borderline cases that approach the void but are not subsumed by it fall under the “semi” category.

Both viewing a black hole and approaching an NDS from a distance are probably spectacular even though they are not experienced directly.

Therefore, semi-DS and semi-NDS refer to some degree of narrative self presence, i.e. a “mineness” or “me-ness,” associated with one’s life story/narrative.

For this reason, I argue that narrative and minimal selves are not mutually exclusive during psychedelic experiences: narrative self represents a default sense of self that grounds individuals in sober and semi-intoxicated states, while minimal self is one’s sense of self/awareness stripped away of all (human and individual) narratives 34 during NDS, including language/symbols.

With that said, there could be something “still there20” during NDS since mystics and psychedelic users alike are able to describe their experiences, albeit not very well due to the ineffable nature of psychedelic experiences and according to Stace’s (1960) theory of unconceptualizability.

If the nature of psychedelic experiences is to be analyzed properly, not only should the psychedelic Other be considered regarding potentially fear-inducing stimuli, but also a detailed conception of self.

The terminology I propose above helps understand what kind of self most likely confronts the psychedelic Other depending on levels of intoxication.

I agree with Millière’s (2017) claim that the drug-induced ego could offer an understanding of the neurobiology of sense of self, but I disagree with his claim that minimal self is of primary importance while narrative self plays a secondary role (1-2).

Conversely, I argue that narrative self plays the primary role in individuals’ understanding of themselves, particularly when facing psychedelic knowns and unknowns.

As narrative self “short-circuits” near peak experience, minimal self takes over once the individual nears or enters NDS.

I suspect that most psychedelic experiences fall within semi-DS or semi-NDS, that is, there exists some degree of narrative self presence, diminished at varying degrees.

It is at the tipping point between semi-NDS and NDS where narrative self completely diminishes and the individual is left with a minimal self that experiences the state of unity (i.e. NDS) with the Other.

Minimal self is a kind of backup/emergency lighting system when the dominant narrative self fails to function.

The eventual metabolization of the substance returns “normal lighting” so to speak, i.e. narrative self, from dim to bright as one moves from NDS toward DS.

Lebedev et al (2015) say the brain’s default mode network (DMN) may relate more to narrative self, whereas the salience network21 may align more with minimal self (10).

Dr. Lebedev (2018) says in a personal email communication that as far as he knows, no one has tested yet whether DMN or salience network diminishes first under psilocybin, but it is possible to test.

On approaching NDS or complete mystical experience, and taking Lebedev et al’s premise to be valid, I hypothesize that narrative self (DMN), comprising one’s rich personal history and identity, diminishes first.

When DMN ceases to function, remnants of the salience network do not fully diminish leaving some trace of minimal self to experience NDS.

Therefore, not only does narrative self play more of a central role in daily (sober) life, but also in psychedelic experiences since most of the experience will occur in the ascension and declension of peak nondual experience.

Furthermore, assuming the individual’s peak experience is not an NDS, then, the entire experience is within the realm of semi-DS and semi-NDS,

Footnotes:

20 I thank Professor Nagenborg for his insight on this topic.

While there might not exist a mine-ness or me-ness in a narrative self sense during NDS, there is still a “your-ness” from a non-experiencer’s perspective.

Something is presumably still there to experience NDS, even though it pushes against the boundaries of language, conceptualizability, and categorization.

21 The DMN is “a network of functionally and structurally connected brain regions that show high spontaneous or ‘on-going’ metabolism yet a relative deactivation during goal-directed cognition” (Carhart-Harris et al, 2014, 2), while the salience network “…is hypothesized to contribute to the brain mechanisms of self-awareness, higher cognition,” and has been previously linked to dementia, impaired self-awareness, and psychosis (Lebedev et al, 2015, 3).

Page 35

meaning there was narrative self/ego presence throughout.

This is important for cognitive neuroscientists because it suggests that individuals operate with narrative self (DMN) most of the time except in intense psychedelic conditions, e.g. the nondual state.

Any experience when one’s narrative self is present suggests that one’s lived experience, whether from the conscious or unconscious mind, comes to the fore during psychedelic experiences, and thus, concerns of fear as per the matrix of knowability.

It is my estimation that nil, partial, or complete suspension of awareness and selfhood via psychedelic-surrender states could be called DS, semi-DS, semi-NDS, and NDS respectively for the reasons explicated above.

Moreover, the terminology I propose offers a nuanced understanding of the current debate in cognitive neuroscience regarding minimal and narrative self.

In the next and final chapter, I examine how individuals can regain a greater sense of agency through techniques and technologies when faced with the psychedelic Other.

The role of psychedelic symbols and technologies sets up the next discussion of (self<–>symbolico-technological<–>Other) relations.

Page 36

Chapter 3 Psychedelic Symbolico-technology

Modernists need not discard all mystical concepts since many explain psychedelic experiences well.

Regarding the abandonment of surrenderism, however, modernists can look to other prototypical drug-taking figures such as shamans on which to model their experiences.

In this chapter, I contrast mysticism’s surrender and fear outlooks with shamanism’s control and mastery to understand what modernists can glean from shamanic practices.

To be clear, I borrow from anthropological, psychological, and other academic disciplines, of which the authors come from a modern worldview like me; therefore, what modern scholars perceive to be “control” of psychedelic experiences through “techniques” and “technologies” (T&T henceforth) is either filtered through modern notions of these concepts, or, shamans do indeed engage in degrees of control, techniques, and technologies regarding psychedelics, but modern scholars aggrandize22 these concepts beyond what shamans deem them to be.

With that said, when referring to the shaman’s ability to control (psychedelic) altered states of consciousness (ASC), I mean: “the ability to enter and leave the ASC at will, and …the ability to determine the experiential content of the ASC” (Walsh, 1995, 43).

I begin my assessment of (self<–>symbolico-technological<–>psychedelic Other) 23 relations with an epistemological dispute in philosophy of religion by contrasting the largely perennial interpretation of mystical and psychedelic experiences advanced thus far by Stace and Pahnke, contra Katz’s views on epistemological constructivism.

As mentioned in Chapter 2.3.1, narrative self likely diminishes toward minimal self as one moves from DS to NDS depending on dosage; similarly, mystical, shamanic, and psychedelic experiences likely move from constructivist toward perennialist interpretations of experience, also depending on dosage.

Next, I draw on the works of Noll, Walsh, and Krippner to elucidate shamanic and modernist techniques and technologies and how they relate to controlling psychedelic experiences.

Shamans and modernists have differing worldviews, and thus, the kind of knowledge sought and technologies produced will vary.

For example, while modernists might be frightened by the psychedelic entities discussed in Chapter 2.2.4, shamans embrace “spirits” as purveyors of information and knowledge about sober and altered realities.

Finally, I apply Cassirer’s philosophy of symbolic form and technology as factors mediating reality and as sharing qualities how they interact with nature.

Inspired by shamans’ synchronous use of symbols and technologies, I expand where Cassirer left off by proffering the idea of symbolico-technological 22 For example, anthropologist Erika Bourguignon (1989) offers sobering counterarguments to the widely referenced concept of shamans’ “control” by modern academics.

Footnotes:

23 One proofreader said this relation looks similar to Ihde’s (1990) existential technological relations: embodiment, hermeneutic, alterity, and background (72-111).

Note that I am not referring to Ihde or postphenomenology here.

The manner in which I view (self<–>symbolico-technological<–>psychedelic Other) relations corresponds to Cassirer’s philosophy; unlike Ihde who views technology as mediating reality for users, Cassirer (2012) understands symbols to be non-artifactual “tools of the mind” (23) that allow users to grasp reality in new dynamic ways.

Such symbols include but are not limited to: science, art, myth, etc.

Thus, for all intents and purposes, symbolic mediation is of thought while technological mediation is of activity.

Interestingly, and to be discussed, shamans can and do combine symbols with technologies.

Page 37

relations.

How can technology and the symbol provide a greater sense of control to psychedelic users?

3.1 Epistemological framing

Adherents of perennial philosophy, such as Huxley (1947) and Stace (1960), among others, argue that all religious and mystical experiences are reducible to a common set of characteristics.

Undoubtedly, there are commonalities across traditions.

However, constructivists, such as philosopher of religion, Steven Katz (1978), argue that all experience—ordinary or mystical—is mediated by one’s culture and worldview: “There are NO pure (i.e. unmediated) experiences …all experience is processed through, organized by, and makes itself available to us in extremely complex epistemological ways” (26).

For example, the Hindu mystic’s conception and experience of Brahman will be different from the Christian mystic’s experience of God, according to constructivists, because each experience is “pre-formed” and shaped by the training that each mystic receives prior to the experience (ibid.).

Anticipation of experiential content may affect what one experiences, hence, “…the forms of consciousness which the mystic brings to experience set structured and limiting parameters on what the experience will be, i.e. on what will be experienced, and rule out in advance what is ‘inexperienceable’ in the particular given, concrete, context” (ibid., 26-27).

In the previous two chapters, I argue mainly from perennial perspectives of mysticism because Stace’s (1960) reductionist stance concerning “core” characteristics fits within the modern worldview well, e.g. Pahnke’s and Griffiths et al’s empirical studies; however, constructivist takes on mysticism allows for deeper analysis of shamanism and modern psychedelic use.

I argue that various mystical traditions/experiences become similar the closer one approaches NDS.

In Chapter 2.3.1, I ask readers to consider the possibility that both narrative and minimal self are co-present during psychedelic experiences depending on dosage, thus, affected by how distant or near one is to NDS; that is, as the individual approaches NDS, the constructed narrative self diminishes to the point of minimal self.

Likewise, from a broader epistemological view, it may be the case that mystics, shamans, and modernists start from their respective constructivist perspectives and unique worldviews/cosmologies, but as each of these three types of users approach NDS brought on by larger doses, each moves closer to a perennial/core experience.

As the parallel with narrative and minimal self suggests (again, depending on dosage), I posit that constructivists are correct when users are in semi-DS and semi-NDS, yet perennialists may also be correct as users move closer to NDS.

In addition to the considerations of constructivist and perennial epistemology, psychologist and shamanism scholar, Roger Walsh (1991), asks whether the shaman’s experience or cosmology came first: “…To what extent do spiritual practitioners create their tradition’s cosmology from their experience and to what extent is their experience created by, or at least molded by, their cosmology?

…Which is chicken and which is egg, or are they mutually interdependent?” (89).

Whether there is a written record of a tradition’s cosmology or not, Walsh’s question is unanswerable and could be 38 argued either way.

How did practitioners know what kind of experience to look for if they did not already have a cosmology that reinforced such seeking, and how did they acquire their cosmology in the first place if they did not already have the experience to know what to seek?

Walsh (1991) adds, “Why would shamans learn to journey to the upper world if they did not already believe there was one?” (90).

Four years later, Walsh proposes another similar causality dilemma regarding technologies used during shamanic experiences: “…These experiences are consistent with the worldview and cosmology of the tradition.

This suggests that there is an intriguing complementarity between a tradition’s worldview and its art of transcendence; an effective technology (set of practices) elicits experiences consistent with and supportive of the worldview.

Since worldview and expectation can mold experience, it is, therefore, an interesting question as to what extent technology or worldview is chicken or egg” (1995, 45).

Needless to say, this question cannot be answered either for certain.

Walsh opts for a middle path between short- and long-term considerations to infer the best explanation.

In referencing Mircea Eliade’s claim that experience is determined by cosmology, and Michael Harner’s claim that technique-eliciting experiences allow shamans to reach their own conclusions about their cosmology, Walsh (1991) argues for a “reciprocal determinism”: “In the short term, shamanic experience is definitely shaped by cultural cosmology.

Perhaps in the long run, the reverse also occurs so that cultural cosmology and personal shamanic experience mold each other” (89-90).

Thus, one could argue that once shamans’ cosmological foundation was set, techniques and technologies were created to further explain their worldview, broadening/co-shaping the cosmology over time.

Further development of the cosmology would have occurred with the discovery and use of psychedelics and technologies tailored to psychedelic experiences.

In the following section, technological context provides a finer understanding of shamanic practices and worldview that can enlighten modernists.

Moreover, if researchers were to look for common ground between shamans and modernists, a common interest in artifacts would be a topic of interest to which modernists could relate.

3.2 Practical insights

Walsh defines shamanism as: “A family of traditions whose practitioners focus on voluntarily entering altered states of consciousness in which they experience themselves, or their ‘spirit(s),’ traveling to other realms at will, and interacting with other entities in order to serve their communities” (1995, 28-29).

In view of numerous definitions of shamanism, I choose Walsh’s because I agree with his claims that

(1) the above definition describes a group of people that most people would agree to be shamans, and it

(2) differentiates shamanic tradition from other similar 39 traditions, such as “…mediums, priests, and medicine men, as well as from various psychopathologies 24, with which shamanism has been confused” (ibid.).

Mystical and shamanic practices differ in at least two ways that might be helpful for modernists to control and mitigate fear of psychedelic experiences.

First, mystics aim to obtain knowledge from ASCs, suggesting anticipation of unity/oneness with the divine (Stace, 1960); shamans aim25 to make contact with spirits to obtain information for members of the shaman’s community (Krippner, 2000, 93), contrarily suggesting a desire for ego presence during the experience.

Considering control is a fundamental aspect of shamanism, drug-taking shamans likely do not aim for NDS as does the mystic, but rather semi-NDS.

Second, in their attempt to unite with the divine, it seems that mystics use T&T to enter into altered states to lose control.

Shamans also use T&T to enter into altered states, but unlike mystics, their intention for T&T use is to control the experience for the most part.

The above concepts of union vs. contact/interaction and losing control vs. control are rooted in the worldview of each tradition.

Therefore, in contrast to the mystic and modernist’s surrender motif, likely (at one point) inexperienced drug-taking shamans developed methods to control the experience, including but not limited to their fears, through T&T when confronted with psychedelic Others.

What can be learned from differences between shamanic and modern T&T that contribute to a philosophy of psychedelic technology?

3.2.1 Shamans Techniques

Shamans use a number of techniques before, during, and after rituals.

Many shamanic techniques26 seem to be variations of what psychologist Richard Noll (1985) calls “mental imagery cultivation.”

This skill gives shamans a sense of increased (1) vividness (clarity and liveliness) and (2) controlledness of visions.

First, the novice is trained to block out external stimuli to focus his or her full attention on spontaneous and imaginative visions (Noll, 1985, 445).

Second, increased vividness and exposure to mental imagery such as spirits and other structural characteristics of altered states lead to increased controlledness of visionary content (ibid., 448).

The more one experiences altered perception and visionary content the more able one is to control them, according to shamans.

Before shamans can control mental imagery, they must first be able to clearly see the content.

Mental imagery training “transforms” the shaman’s eyes by developing an “inner” or “spiritual” eye

Footnotes:

24 E.g. the false claim that many shamans have schizophrenic tendencies.

See: Noll (1983) and Walsh (1995).

25 Note: To state that shamans do not or have not aimed for mystical union would be argumentum ad ignorantiam or argument from ignorance.

In consideration of shamanism’s oral tradition, Walsh (1995) says: “…Although the unio mystica is not the goal of shamanic practices, it may sometimes occur” (49-50).

Thus, a lack of reference to shamans aiming for or entering into NDS in the literature, according to Walsh, does not suggest that it is absent from shamanic tradition or experience.

26 For detailed descriptions of shamanic T&T, see: Noll (1985, 447); Walsh (1989, 36); Woodside et al (1997); and, Krippner (2000, 102).

Page 40

(ibid., 446).

Accordingly, drug-ingestion at night is practical for seeing visions.

Krippner (2000) says drug-specific practices include “sleep deprivation, restricted night-time vision, and accompanying music” to “enhance the experience’s profundity” (102).

Walsh (1989) says shamanic journeying is “done at night so that the spirits and geography of the other world can be better seen” (36).

Another central technique is the shamanic journey or soul flight, comparable to the modern notion of “out-of-body experience” (see: Monroe, 1971; Tart, 1995).

Shamans journey to “acquire knowledge or power and to help people in their community, …interacting with and controlling ‘spirits,’ …[and] while many of their fellow tribes people might claim to see or even be possessed by spirits, only shamans claim to be able to command, commune, and intercede with them for the benefit of the tribe” (Walsh, 1991, 86).

I mentioned above arguably the two most common techniques used by shamans.

My brief mention of them does not do justice to their rich tradition and the amount of training novice shamans must endure.

I add a final remark regarding shamanic training: as Buddhists must learn concepts of no-self and the workings of their spiritual practice’s cosmology before learning meditation techniques to experience the concepts first-hand, note too, shamans must learn about their spiritual practice’s cosmology and techniques before journeying to other worlds and meeting spirits (Rock and Baynes, 2005, 59).

Therefore, shamanic techniques taken out of context are perhaps meaningless unless framed within the larger cosmology; for example, a modernist who does not believe in spirits, upper, and lower worlds will likely not fare as well as the shaman using such techniques.

Technologies

Clothing decorations, rattles, and drums are significant artifacts in shamanism.

For example, mirrors and metal discs attached to garments make clanging and ringing sounds that are thought to scare away evil spirits (Matthews, 2013, 187-188).

Rattles filled with stones, seeds, or beads make “high-velocity” sounds to produce “sound landscapes” that are thought to have healing and magical powers (ibid., 192-195).

The drum is an important and ubiquitous shamanic tool.

The act of drumming serves navigational purposes: the drum, also known as the symbolic “World Tree,” guides shamans toward “upper” and “lower” worlds in altered states (Krippner, 2000, 102).

The World Tree serves as “the cosmological symbol of the connection between worlds, a connection that the shaman, alone among humans, is able to traverse” (Walsh, 1991, 89).

3.2.2 Modernists

Regarding the use of artifacts, modernists may think in terms of “set and setting,” guiding with props, and festivals.

First, set or mindset refers to the internal state of the user, and setting refers to the external conditions where drug-ingestion occurs (Metzner and Leary, 1967, 5).

Technologies are likely to be used in one’s external environment, such as music playing device, music genres stored as MP3 files, interior design of the locale, paraphernalia, etc.

Second, and related to the first, is the guide.

If the drug user is thought of as the pilot, the guide is the navigator.

The guide directs users through experiences often with props and objects so users can contemplatively analogize an aspect of 41 themselves that they want to work on in a therapeutic context (Masters and Houston, 1966).

Such objects can be used as tools to uncover something about users.

Leary et al (2007) recommend guides read passages from their book—inspired by the Tibetan Book of the Dead—to assist people with the “dying” (read: psychedelic) process.

Guides’ suggestive use of objects and other guiding techniques found in books, or perhaps music, gives the appearance of control of some aspects of the psychedelic experience.

Third, according to cultural anthropologist, Graham St John (2011), electronic dance music culture (EDMC) embodied as festivals act as “spiritual technologies”:

The use of “DJ techniques, optimized audio-visual production, performance, and participant expectations at raves” suggests that “‘technological advancements may compensate for the lack of coherent cultural signifiers’ vis-à-vis ‘the sophisticated scripted process of initiation observed in ceremonial possession’” (217; St John cites Takahashi, 2005).

Just as the drum’s beat allows the shaman to move through upper and lower worlds, the technoshamanic DJ fills a probable gap felt by modernists who look to shamans and their techniques for guidance on “proper” drug use.

3.2.3 Between two world(view)s

The gap between modernists’ surrender and fear, and shamans’ control, of psychedelic experiences suggest that modern psychedelic T&T are less efficacious than shamanic methods, lacking on three fronts—before, during, and after the experience, and perhaps a fourth encompassing front predicated on one’s worldview.

Before

The shaman must learn how to “see” and then “control” spirits, and to navigate through the altered state (Noll, 1985), but more importantly, to be knowledgeable about his or her culture’s (spiritual) cosmology.

According to Noll (1985), the shaman is a powerful member of society, acting as healer, mediator between worlds, and “mnemonic purveyor of culturally relevant material” that ensures the survival of the community (445).

Shamans are not recreational users of psychedelics; instead they enter into altered states/realms to “bargain, negotiate, or plead with spiritual entities” to obtain information on behalf of individuals or the entire community (Krippner, 2000, 101; see also: Walsh, 1995).

Shamanic T&T are used primarily for daily survival purposes (e.g. finding game animals, plants for healing, predicting weather patterns, etc.), and secondly, for spiritual uses, on which modernists place the most emphasis, according to Krippner (2000, 113-114).

During

The altruistic27 nature of shamans’ motives contrast many modernists’ “selfish” motives for taking psychedelics since shamans act as conduits to obtain information for others, while modernists seek information for themselves (e.g. therapeutically) or use psychedelics recreationally.

Tupper (2002) agrees with Albert Hofmann, the chemist who first synthesized LSD, in that recreational psychedelic use might entail unsafe circumstances and lacks the psychospiritual 27 It can be said that shamans do get something for themselves by helping others: alleged “powers” from helping spirits called “allies” (Walsh, 1995; Krippner, 2000).

Furthermore, some shamans claim to protect themselves with their powers against jealous “black”/bad shamans and against evil spirits (Luna, 1984).

Page 42

safeguards found in rituals (503).

While Tupper and Hofmann claim there may be risks associated with non-ritual, recreational use of psychedelics, there may also be risks when modernists attempt to use psychedelics in ritual contexts that call for shamanic-like techniques.

For example, Rock et al (2008) claim that individuals unfamiliar with drumming techniques—and prone to “need for order,” “childlikeness,” and “sensitivity” to name several mood types—experience higher levels of mood disturbance; therefore, “shamanic-like techniques may be counterproductive if applied in the absence of shamanic training (e.g. learning a cosmology, cultivating a mastery over mental images)” (75-76).

Rock et al (2008) add that mood disturbance may decrease after prolonged exposure to such techniques.

Modernists are caught in a dilemma: they are

(1) recommended to take psychedelics in a ritualized manner, yet

(2) shamanic T&T might be unhelpful to one’s mood, and as a result, the visionary content and experience.

After

Regarding the efficacy of psychedelics, Smith (1964) says, “Churches lack faith; …hipsters lack discipline” (529-530).

Faith refers to the potential that psychedelic visions might contain truths, and discipline to the diligent integration of said truths in daily life.

“Daily” integration and contemplation could be construed as a lifestyle, suggesting frequent psychedelic use.

Shamans and contemplative meditators diligently work on their practice and faith for perhaps decades, thus their minds are more prepared to deal with the effects during and after the experience than recreational psychedelic users (Walsh, 1989, 39).

Many modernists arguably do not devote their entire lives to the faith and discipline required for frequent psychedelic use as drug-taking shamans ostensibly do.

How do untrained modernists reconcile the abovementioned claims of shamanic ritual T&T being counterproductive to them?

“DIY [do-it-yourself] consciousness” (St John, 2011) and neoshamanic methods frankly seem less competent than traditional shamanic methods, considering academics and writers encourage modernists to surrender whether T&T are used or not (see Chapter 2.1).

Modernists have lost the tradition of institutionalized consciousness alteration, while shamans have “magico”-religious and cosmological accompaniments to aid them at all stages of their altered experiences.

Shamans operate within a worldview that supports T&T tailored to that worldview; in the following section, I unpack this statement to find out how modernists might develop and use symbols and technologies to act as prostheses favorable to their worldview that gives them more agency during psychedelic experiences.

3.3 Form and technology

An investigation of knowledge, gained through psychedelic use, would ideally take an intercultural approach.

Knowledge is contextual, in that it is determined by one’s worldview, and in the case of psychedelics, the kinds of T&T used and for what purpose.

Ernst Cassirer wrote an extensive three-volume series called Philosophy of Symbolic Forms, covering language, mythical thought, and phenomenology of knowledge.

He wrote a paper called Form and Technology shortly 43 thereafter to give some sense to the rapid mechanization of his native Germany in the 1920s.

In what follows, I use Cassirer’s philosophy to expand the current debate by extrapolating the role of psychedelic symbolic form and technology.

In An Essay on Man28, Cassirer (1956) invokes the ideas of biologist Johannes von Uexküll that all organisms have a “receptor system” that receives outward stimuli and an “effector system” by which organisms react to stimuli (42).

Cassirer argues for a third system in humans, the “symbolic system,” which acts as a mediary between outward stimuli and reactions, thereby delaying responses “by a slow and complicated process of thought,” allowing the human to inhabit a “new dimension of reality” (ibid., 43).

If symbols create new realities for humans to experience, according to Cassirer, then it is fair to say that human cultures using different symbols would have different outlooks on what reality is or could be.

Current and past members of society build the world that they perceive/perceived.

Cassirer (2012) says, “The ‘form’ of the world, whether in thought or action, whether in language or in effective activity, is not simply received and accepted by the human being; rather, it must be ‘built’ by him” (24).

Whereas animals are merely in a world, humans construct their world through thought/language and activity/tools (ibid.).

For example, Uexküll discusses the incommensurability of experience from the perspectives of flies and sea urchins; the experience and realities of each will be different (Cassirer, 1956, 41).

Shamans and modernists are certainly the same biological organism; nonetheless, their realities and worldviews differ depending on what symbols mediate each of their realities, whether these symbols are believed to have causality as they are thrown into the world in net-like fashion, and the kinds of technology that reinforce or add to such knowledge.

The modernist cannot fully understand the shaman’s world from the modern worldview and vice versa.

Considering the shaman’s worldview includes T&T that supposedly control psychedelic experiences, how might modernists treat drug-taking shamans’ T&T from the modern worldview perspective?

What clues does the shaman’s worldview give that might inspire or be appropriated by modernists?

Thought and activity “freeing” itself from nature, and by extension, individuals, can be considered as an “obligatory passage point” (Callon, 1986) to gain access to new dimensions of reality; that is to say, symbol and technology users must ally themselves with and adjust to new modes of experiencing to gain new knowledge and more control, especially for psychedelic users.

Cassirer (2012) contends that the first technologies were modeled on humans’ anatomy such as the hand; as technologies became more advanced, they eventually detached from nature’s models creating something entirely new.

For example, the problem of flight could only be solved once “technological thinking freed itself from the model of bird flight and abandoned the principle of the moving wing” (Cassirer, 2012, 39).

Regarding spoken language, it “wrestled itself free” from the metaphor of sound (connected to nature) toward the symbol of the written word (ibid.).

The above examples highlight an

Footnotes:

28 An Essay on Man is an abridged version of Cassirer’s Philosophy of Symbolic Forms (Vol. 1-3), written for English-speaking audiences.

Page 44

important aspect of Cassirer’s theory of symbols and technology: that technological and symbolic advancements create a distancing effect between humans and nature, between unmediated (read: less mediated) and mediated reality.

In other words, Cassirer’s (2012) concept of “distance” allows the symbol or technology user to foresee the means of discovering reality between the “will” and the “goal” (29-31).

Humans lose their connection to nature “…as soon as activity takes the form of indirectness, as soon as the tool comes between the human being and his work” (ibid., 39-40), and as symbols and technologies become better at predicting (one’s) reality.

In view of Cassirer’s thoughts on symbolic form and technology, it can be argued that as technology accelerates in wrestling itself free from its original form, technology users become increasingly separated from nature and natural processes (baseline reality)—a necessary concession to expose oneself to other (intoxicated) dimensions of reality.

Cassirer (2012) says that technology’s essence for the most part had escaped the realm of philosophic inquiry and that “‘abstract’ thought is unable to penetrate into the core of the technological world” (17).

Further, he unjustly criticizes non-“civilized” peoples for not understanding objective causality as understood in modern society, specifically that “the mythical-magical world still knows nothing about a sense of causality that both constructs and renders possible the sphere of objects, making them accessible to thought” (ibid., 32).

With due respect, I disagree with Cassirer on the above points because he was thinking within the realm of sober consciousness.

I use Cassirer’s philosophy against him, showing that abstract symbols and thoughts can penetrate technology’s essential core and that shamans do understand objective causality, albeit within the realm of psychedelics, a state Cassirer likely knew little of first-hand.

Cassirer’s philosophy of symbols and technology is compelling; however, he does not appreciate the ingenuity of shamanic culture that combines thought (symbol) with activity (tools) in psychedelic ASCs.

In reference to Max Eyth’s the “word and the tool,” i.e. concepts that distinguish humans from animals (Cassirer, 2012, 22-23), Cassirer speaks of thought and activity as if they were separate entities; on the contrary, they do compliment each other in their combined use.

Eyth later refers to his concept of “tool of the mind,” that “both word and tool are a product of the same fundamental mental force” (ibid).

In other words, words and tools respectively are tools of the mind, both originate from thought; thus, surely there exists overlap between them.

For example, claiming that all symbols are immaterial and all tools are material is false since there are exceptions: symbols can be scribed or stamped onto signs, and tools like language are immaterial.

All things considered, let us take as our premise that symbols represent ideas while tools represent a particular function inherent to the tool.

Further, there are at least three ways to experience psychedelics: 1) (psychedeliconly), 2) either (psychedelic+symbol) or (psychedelic+technology), and 3) (psychedelic+symbol+ technology).

I argue that psychedelics, symbols, and technologies used together reveal new applications, resulting in a wrestled-free symbolico-technological third function.

Coupling symbol with technology creates avenues of new experiences, experiences malleable by the user depending on 45 the co-equal symbolico-technological relation and how each co-shapes the created third function.

To illustrate this, imagine a vesica piscis made of one red and one blue circle.

As these circles overlap, the mandorla, the emergent almond-shaped center, becomes purple.

It is this newly created tertiary triad and its functionality wherefrom users can gain access to other dimensions of reality hitherto unknown, to revisit previously discovered realms, discover new knowledge, and exercise greater control over their experiences.

As Walsh (1991, 1995) proposes causality dilemmas regarding cosmology-or-experience and worldview-or-technology and vice versa, a new dilemma emerges through the application of Cassirer’s work regarding psychedelics: did the symbol or technology come first; did one cause the other?

The famous example given by anthropologists, psychologists, and religious scholars is the aforementioned World Tree.

The ubiquitous symbol of the World Tree, in all its variations across tribal cultures, acts as axis mundi or universal pillar that holds up the upper world and its roots securing the lower world, allowing the shaman to journey between them (Eliade, 1987, 32-42).

The cosmological symbol of the World Tree and the (drum + drumbeat) that represents it allow shamans access to the created third function, that is, the act of journeying to and experiencing of Other Worlds and their inhabitants.

At stake is: if the World Tree succeeded the drum, one must wonder whether this particular technology used with psychedelics would have eventually, or will always in similar circumstances, bear World Tree-like symbolism.

Conversely, does working with symbols like the World Tree, evolutionarily speaking, produce a drum to represent it?

The verdict is still undecided.

However, just as there are manifold psychedelic-only experiences, there are potentially other symbols and technologies just beyond grasp that may co-shape, or wrestle-free, one another into existence upon their discovery/creation.

As for reciprocal determinism in a spatial context, space between the will and goal, as in the farther or nearer one is to either, depends on one’s level of thought incubation; viz., the discovery/creation of symbols and technology being directly related to one’s level of desire (or need) to effectuate them.

For example, in consideration of the proverb, “necessity is the mother of invention,” what was necessary about transcribing speech, why did this phenomenon spring from oral tradition?

Writing allows thought to be extended through time and to be read by multiple persons spatially separated in addition to a sense of permanence of the author’s thought and self-identity.

Similarly, psychedelic users’ desire to control (goal) the experience and to reduce fears must be embodied in the kinds of symbols, technologies, and symbolico-technological relations (will) to do just that.

Regardless whether the symbol or technology came first, it is more than likely psychedelics would have been taken antecedently since symbolic and technological thought-forms presumably derive from ASCs, but more importantly, users would need to be in psychedelic ASCs to discover, test, and retest their symbols’ and technologies’ efficacy.

Deliberating on whether symbol or technology spawned the other is likely to have happened reciprocally at varying degrees.

Insofar as

Page 46

language wrestled itself free from thought, and the written word from language, what symbols or tools might wrestle themselves free from intoxicated thoughts?

They might be ideas, concepts or nonphysical objects to be used solely in psychedelic ASCs.

Determined will and set goals ultimately will coax symbolic and technological thought-forms free from intoxicated thought.

Shamans are better candidates or prototypes, compared to mystics, for modernists to model the mitigation of fearful psychedelic stimuli.

The shaman seems to know how to turn metaphor— unintelligible and incomprehensible percepts—into workable symbols.

Krippner speaks of shamans’ ability to “manipulate” symbols in altered states (2000, 102-103) and Walsh says shamans may be “‘imposers of form’ who easily create meaningful patterns from unclear data” (1991, 90).

The same shamanic symbols used during psychedelic experiences may be ineffective or not as effective in sober states, which suggests that shamans are highly trained professionals who give form to ASC and its content, hence, a degree of control over the experience.

The shaman is said to be a world builder and a reality manipulator in altered states and uses thoughtfully designed or discovered symbols and technologies when looking for a particular kind of knowledge.

In referring to technology’s ability to tease out nature’s secrets, Cassirer (2012) says, “This discovery is a disclosure; it is the grasping and the making one’s own of an essential connection that previously lay hidden” (29-30).

The human mind is a part of nature, and as such, the combination of psychedelic symbols and technology need not disclose something about one’s external environment, but rather could disclose something hidden about one’s (altered) mind or (perhaps) objective Other Worlds, allowing new meanings between “I” and world(s) to be grasped (ibid).

In order to test new hypotheses of what (altered) reality is or could be, users can assume new premises, allowing new symbolico-technologies to emerge that confront current ways of knowing by opening “new dimensions of reality.”

Section Break

Effective modern psychedelic symbols, techniques, and technologies currently do not exist, and I am not in a position to suggest specifics on their future discovery, development, and use.

However, if pressed to make an educated guess, I predict that combining a variant of mental imagery cultivation with modern sound/music technology might provide further insights into psychedelic ASC, particularly in the areas of structural acoustics, psychophysics, and cymatics that deal with frequencies, vibrations, and harmonics.

Winn et al (1989) elucidate such a step forward in their understanding of sonic driving29: “…Strong, repetitive percussive sound used to quiet the verbal, linear left-hemispheric functioning to allow symbolic, non-linear modes of problem solving to

Footnotes:

29 See also: Neher’s (1961, 1962) “auditory driving”; Monroe’s (1985) brain “hemispheric synchronization” via binaural beats; Woodside et al’s (1997) “acoustical driving”; Winkelman’s (2010) “rhythmic auditory stimulation”; and Boccolini et al (2018) regarding their work with “ghost imaging” and human perception.

Page 47

emerge—is an essential part of all shamanic practices” (69).

Initial findings from marrying psychedelics with modern technology and symbols will push known boundaries; though, I suspect over time new frontiers shall become increasingly understood, leading to greater user control and reduction of fears.

[no – rather, more und’g of control transformation & fear – mh]

Page 48

Conclusion

The present study began with the observation that many modern societies and individuals fear psychedelics.

By investigating how psychedelics threaten the idea of being a rational subject in modern society, to what extent Otherness and the unknown contribute to individuals’ fears of psychedelics, and how technologies and symbols can provide more agency and control to psychedelic users, I am confident in answering my central research question:

In what ways can modern users conceptualize the psychedelic experience that counters the current fear-laden discourse on drugs?

Using modern fears of psychedelics as my framework, and the foundations upon which those fears are based, allows for richer understanding of current conflicting views of drugs in general and psychedelics in particular.

Only when antiquated conceptions are understood can recommendations inform future direction, advancing further creation of knowledge into psychedelic realms and practices.

With that said, my philosophical inquiry has prescriptive consequences.

First, everyone should get clear about the terms they use.

In this thesis, I repeatedly redefine terms or create new ones such as the analyses I provide on psychedelic Other, (bodily and mental) surrender, known and unknown fears, notions of self, control, symbolico-technological relations, etc.

However, academics and users’ pathological descriptions, i.e. ego death/dissolution terminology, to explain psychedelic experiences deserve special attention.

This category mistake should be abandoned if fear-based concerns are to reduce.

The concept, merging, from mysticism could replace previous descriptions; therefrom, “ego merging” is an appealingly disarming term.

Pathological terminology suggests a becoming-less-than state, a description mystics and shamans do not endorse.

Past and current fear-laden discourse suggest that psychedelics make people insane, that users might lose part of what makes them a rational subject, and thus, could harm one’s self and others.

Psychedelic users claim otherwise, comparing their experiences to mystical states, moral and spiritual enhancement, and extending conscious experience beyond their five senses.

As for religious institutions fearing mystics and psychedelic users’ direct access to possible divine realms, such experiences would likely reinforce religious doctrine, not counter it.

The nearly fifty-year prohibition on psychedelics creates an atmosphere of misunderstanding.

Insofar as alcohol, nicotine, and prescription drugs are institutionalized in modern society, opening up psychedelics to research and responsible use might create a common language/framework to better explain these experiences leading to less fear among users and non-users.

Additionally, psychedelics appear to be effective means of fighting addictions to degenerative drugs such as opioids.

Second, dosage is an important variable when philosophizing about psychedelics.

Current debates in philosophy regarding the self, and epistemological debates in religion and mysticism, seem to not account for various dosage levels on oscillating and diaphanous mental states between semiintoxication and full-intoxication.

I propose a qualitative framework in Chapter 2.3.1 for philosophers and neuroscientists to assess mystical/psychedelic experiences that allow a middle path for both narrative and minimal selves to be expressed.

The framework was written with surrenderism in mind; 49 however, it can be adapted to include control aspects related to shamanic methods.

Furthermore, epistemological polarities such as constructivism and perennialism highlight the narrative-minimal self negotiation but on a broader scale.

Constructivists might be correct in their claims that mystics and psychedelic users enter altered states of consciousness (ASC) with views of their (religious) world, however, perennialists too are possibly correct when mystics, modernists, and shamans approach the nondual state, again, depending on dosage.

Scholars have researched thus far religious, psychological, therapeutic, and neuroscientific angles, to name several.

The philosophic study of psychedelics is more or less a dormant field; the more society and individuals understand psychedelic phenomena the greater chances there will be in changing discourse on drugs.

Considering philosophy of psychedelics and psychedelic technologies are still in their infancy, there is room to study these abstract realms with the criticality and logic of the philosopher’s perspective.

Also, evidence suggests that ASCs provide clues to the nature of (neural correlates of) consciousness, selfhood, and a reexamination of one’s sober self.

Third, in short-term and therapeutic contexts, surrender might be ideal for many individuals.

Surrender can be considered a form of passive control, in that surrendering to the experience is a better alternative than resisting the oncoming altered state, which could lead to bad experiences.

Surrendering entails relinquishing one’s symbolic system used for sober reality, hence new symbols are needed, i.e. “tools of the mind,” for psychedelic ASCs.

This thesis is replete with paradoxes and I suggest a final one that contrasts my proposed operationalization of shamanic control methods: modernists would benefit from surrendering their current modern rationale, to hit pause, as it were, to observe and consider alternative ways of approaching psychedelic experiences that do not succumb to fear.

I am not advocating that modernists forego their entire worldview, but instead take a respite from their commonly accepted knowledge and reality frames to learn something from non-modern psychedelic users.

Psychedelia needs philosophers more than ever; especially as advancements in neuroscience better explain neuronal functioning and indigenous drug-taking cultures and traditions continually come under threat.

Finally, identifying, understanding, and as a result, operationalizing, middle ground in the way modernists conceptualize psychedelic experiences enlarges discourse on what seems to be, from modern perspectives, magical/mythical practices found in shamanic cultures.

Psychedelic scholars and practitioners suggest modernists surrender, while other scholars reference shamans’ control of psychedelic experiences through technology; however, it appears that both academic disciplines do not interact.

To the best of my knowledge, scholars have not asked as extensively as I have whether modernists too can control said experiences.

While it is reasonable to use concepts from mysticism to intellectualize psychedelic experiences, the likely more helpful prototype in the context of fear are shamans who are said to control experiences through symbolism and technology.

Thus, modernists can borrow from both ideologies, using mysticism to explain and shamanism to control experiences for the most part.

Page 50

As I argue in Chapter 2.3.1, diminishment of narrative self leads to semi-DS and semi-NDS.

Thus, symbolico-technologies can fill the gap created by reductions in narrative/sober self; or put another way, states of intoxicated self are more conducive to using psychedelic symobolicotechnologies than DS and NDS, and intoxicated individuals can make great use of them when applied to a range of purposes, such as: controlling, navigating, and seeking new knowledge.

Symbolicotechnologies are prostheses, or crutches so to speak, in that psychedelic users are likely more able to maintain balance during uncertain and unpredictable mental conditions when they rely on these accoutrements.

Epistemologically speaking, psychedelic realms might be considered as intermediate platforms of knowledge exchange between constructivist and perennialist positions.

Symbolicotechnologies might allow users to better capture and process insights to bring back to sober reality.

I strongly defend the idea that symbolico-technological relations is how shamans control and understand their experiences and that this concept will be an extremely important research topic toward a philosophy of psychedelic technology.

The kind of knowledge modernists seek will inform the symbols and technologies they discover/develop and use according to their worldview.

Symbolico-technologies provide insightful, richer experiences of other realities that co-exist alongside humans’ increasingly estranged, according to Cassirer (2012), natural origins; the totality of reality exponentially increases as humans discover more ways of experiencing and knowing.

The conceptualization of psychedelic knowledge, the Other, and Other Worlds from modern worldview perspectives will require a redefining of knowledge and psychedelic technology.

Currently unanswerable questions arise: How will modern society cope with psychedelic knowledge; what kinds of psychedelic technologies will be developed for modern audiences; and what would it take for psychedelic knowledge to be recognized as useful or as a topic of interest to research?

Limitations

My modern perspective of the world, i.e. my American background and the Dutch education system—regarding the context of the master’s program and perspectives of the largely European/American faculty members—likely shape my thinking and processing of texts and the manner in which I frame my arguments.

Since this project is chiefly a theoretical investigation, I draw on mainly continental philosophers and secondary empirical research.

Primary research would undoubtedly provide corroboration or refutation of modern academics’ analyses of drug-taking shamans’ cultures and modern users’ applications of psychedelics.

I focus on the most likely psychedelic fears society and individuals have in consideration of brevity.

There are surely other fears that are worthy of exploration.

A more thorough investigation might involve finding out what people fear to know how to design and use psychedelic symbols and technologies per culture, perhaps even per individual.

Additionally, I group all psychedelics into a single category, albeit a category that shares many common characteristics, for example, when compared to deliriants and dissociatives.

With that said, James (2002, 300-301) alludes to the potentially unlimited altered states of consciousness to 51 explore regarding his experimentation with nitrous oxide, and likely, these experiences are dependent on countless other variables at the moment of ingestion—worldview, substance, dosage, life experience, mood, present and repressed emotional states, etc.

Future studies dedicated to specific substances and controlled variables would illuminate further insights.

Future research

There are at least two directions for future philosophical research that stem from the present study: philosophical (xeno)anthropology and/or xenophenomenology, and Cassirer’s philosophy of symbolic forms and technology.

Research into (altered) self and psychedelic Other can expand beyond this thesis to include new de-anthropomorphized and de-anthropocentric approaches; for example, in a philosophical (xeno)anthropology context, and perhaps a xenophenomenological approach to further explicate nonhuman and/or nonphysical psychedelic entities and their perspectives.

Such areas broaden the current dominant singular/sober approach to consciousness and concepts of self and Other in altered realms.

For example, what do modern users learn from intoxicated self and psychedelic entities; how do users incorporate psychedelic knowledge in their daily sober lives?

Cassirer’s philosophy of symbolic forms shows promise for psychedelic (technology) research, perhaps fusing with Ihde’s postphenomenology.

Psychedelic researchers can investigate the development of modern symbolic and technological accoutrements, i.e. symbolico-technological relations, for modern audiences.

Researchers and expert/lay users are left the colossal task of codiscovering and co-shaping psychedelic symbols and technologies according to modern worldviews since it has yet to be done as thoroughly and effectively as those of shamans according to their worldview.

Regarding shamans’ superimposition of World Tree symbolism with the drum/drumbeat, how might modern psychedelic symbolism pair with modern technologies and for what purposes?

The discovery and design of symbols offer new means of communication/ mediation with psychedelic Others, control, and navigation in altered realms respectively.

Further, when psychedelic symbols wrestle themselves free from original thought-forms, researchers might be able to reverse engineer the meaning of these symbols to understand what they represent or take raw experiential data to create new symbols.

Page 52

Bibliography

A

American Psychiatric Association.

(2013).

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-5.

Arlington, Virginia: American Psychiatric Publishing.

Aristotle.

(1922).

The Poetics of Aristotle (4th ed.).

(S. H. Butcher, Trans.).

London: MacMillan and Co., Limited.

B

Barrett, F. S., & Griffiths, R. R. (2018).

Classic Hallucinogens and Mystical Experiences: Phenomenology and Neural Correlates.

Behavioral Neurobiology of Psychedelic Drugs, 36, 393-430.

Berger, P.

L., & Kellner, H.

(1965).

Arnold Gehlen and the Theory of Institutions.

Social Research, 32(1), 110-115.

Berger, P.

L., & Luckmann, T.

(1991/1966).

The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.

Penguin Books.

Bicchieri, C., Muldoon, R., & Sontuoso, A.

(2018).

Social norms.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Retrieved October 10, 2018, from https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-norms/ Blewett, D.

(1970).

The Psychedelics and Group Therapy.

In B.

Aaronson & H.

Osmond (Eds.), Psychedelics: The Uses and Implications of Hallucinogenic Drugs, (342-357).

Garden City, New York: Anchor Books.

Boccolini, A., Fedrizzi, A., & Faccio, D. (2018).

Ghost imaging with the human eye.

arXiv preprint arXiv:1808.05137.

Bourguignon, E. (1989).

Trance and Shamanism: What’s in a Name?  Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 21(1), 9-15.  Brodwin, E. (2017, May 9).

“Scientists are about to find out how Silicon Valley’s LSD habit really affects productivity.” Retrieved November 30, 2018, from http://uk.businessinsider.com/microdosing-lsd-effects-risks-science-2017- 5?r=US&IR=T

C

Callon, M. (1986).

Some elements of a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and the fishermen of St Brieuc Bay.

In J. Law (Ed.), Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge?, (196-233).

London: Routledge.

Carhart-Harris, R.

L., Leech, R., Hellyer, P.

J., Shanahan, M., Feilding, A., Tagliazucchi, E., Chialvo, D.

R., & Nutt, D.

(2014).

The entropic brain: a theory of conscious states informed by neuroimaging research with psychedelic drugs.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, 20.

Cassirer, E.

(1956/1944).

An Essay on Man: An Introduction to a Philosophy of Human Culture.

Garden City, New York: Doubleday.

Cassirer, E.

(2012).

Form and Technology.

(W.

M.

Dunlavey & J.

M.

Krois, Trans.).

In A.

S Hoel & I.

Folkvord (Eds.), Ernst Cassirer on Form and Technology: Contemporary Readings, (15-53).

Palgrave Macmillan.

[Originally published as: Cassirer, E.

(1930).

Form und Technik.

In L.

Kestenberg (Ed.), Kunst und Technik, (15-61).

Berlin: Wegweiser.]

D

Daase, C., & Kessler, O.

(2007).

Knowns and Unknowns in the ‘War on Terror’: Uncertainty and the Political Construction of Danger.

Security Dialogue, 38(4), 411-434.

Damasio, A.

1999.

The Feeling of What Happens: Body and Emotion in the Making of Consciousness.

Harcourt.

Derrida, J.

(1995/1992).

The Rhetoric of Drugs.

In E.

Weber (Ed.) & M.

Israel (Trans.), Points…: Interviews, 1974-1994, (228-254).

Stanford University Press.

Derrida, J.

(2000/1997).

Of Hospitality.

(R.

Bowlby, Trans.).

Stanford University Press.

Dittrich, A.

(1998).

The Standardized Psychometric Assessment of Altered States of Consciousness (ASCs) in Humans.

Pharmacopsychiatry, 31(S 2), 80-84.

53 Drug Enforcement Administration.

(2017).

Drugs of Abuse: A DEA Resource Guide [PDF].

Produced and published by the U.S.

Department of Justice.

E

Einstein, A.

(1931).

In H.

G.

Leach (Ed.), Living Philosophies.

New York: Simon & Schuster.

Eliade, M.

(1987/1957).

The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion.

(W.

R.

Trask, Trans.).

New York: Harcourt, Inc.

Elster, J.

(1989).

The Cement of Society: A Study of Social Order.

Cambridge University Press.

F

Fadiman, J.

(2011).

The Psychedelic Explorer’s Guide: Safe, Therapeutic, and Sacred Journeys.

Park Street Press.

Fadun, O.

S.

(2013).

Risk Management and Risk Management Failure: Lessons for Business Enterprises.

International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 3(2), 225-239.

Fernandez, J.

W.

(1982).

Bwiti: An Ethnography of the Religious Imagination in Africa.

Princeton University Press.

Foucault, M.

(1988/1961).

Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason.

(R.

Howard, Trans.).

New York: Vintage Books.

Freud, S.

(2003/1919).

The Uncanny.

(D.

McLintock, Trans.).

Penguin Books.

Frosch, W.

A., Robbins, E.

S., & Stern, M.

(1965).

Untoward Reactions to Lysergic Acid Diethylamide (LSD) Resulting in Hospitalization.

New England Journal of Medicine, 273(23), 1235-1239.

G

Gallagher, S.

(2000).

Philosophical conceptions of the self: Implications for cognitive science.

Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 4(1), 14-21.

Gallagher, S.

(2011).

Introduction: A Diversity of Selves.

In S.

Gallagher (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of the Self, (1-29).

Oxford University Press.

Gehlen, A.

(2003/1983).

A Philosophical-Anthropological Perspective on Technology.

In R.

C.

Scharff & V.

Dusek (Eds.), Philosophy of Technology: The Technological Condition: An Anthology, (213-220).

Wiley-Blackwell.

Gerard, R.

W.

(1956).

Neuropharmacology: Transactions of the Second Conference.

Josiah Macy, Jr.

Foundation.

New York, NY.

Giddens, A.

(1990).

The Consequences of Modernity.

United Kingdom: Polity Press.

Giddens, A.

(1991).

Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age.

Cambridge, United Kingdom: Polity Press.

Girón, S.

(2013).

Working with Trauma: Psychedelic Harm Reduction and Transpersonal Psychotherapy.

MAPS Bulletin, Vol.

23, No.

3, 2013 Annual Report, 47-49.

Graham, G.

(2010).

The Disordered Mind: An Introduction to Philosophy of Mind and Mental Illness.

New York: Routledge.

Griffiths, R.

R., Richards, W.

A., McCann, U., & Jesse, R.

(2006).

Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal meaning and spiritual significance.

Psychopharmacology, 187(3), 268-283.

Griffiths, R.

R., Richards, W.

A., Johnson, M.

W., McCann, U.

D., & Jesse, R.

(2008).

Mystical-type experiences occasioned by psilocybin mediate the attribution of personal meaning and spiritual significance 14 months later.

Journal of Psychopharmacology, 22(6), 621-632.

Griffiths, R.

R., Johnson, M.

W., Richards, W.

A., Richards, B.

D., McCann, U., & Jesse, R.

(2011).

Psilocybin occasioned mystical-type experiences: immediate and persisting dose-related effects.

Psychopharmacology, 218(4), 649-665.

Griffiths, R. R. (2018). Personal email communication on October 24-25, 2018.

Grinker, R. R. (1963). Lysergic Acid Diethylamide. Archives of General Psychiatry, 8(5), 425-425.

Page 54

Grob, C. S., Bossis, A. P., & Griffiths, R. R. (2013). Use of the classic hallucinogen psilocybin for treatment of existential distress associated with cancer. In Psychological Aspects of Cancer (291-308). Boston, Massachusetts: Springer.

Grof, S. (1980).

LSD Psychotherapy.

Pomona, California: Hunter House.

Guttmann, E.

(1936).

Artificial Psychoses Produced by Mescaline.

Journal of Mental Science, 82(338), 203-221.

H

Harman, G.

(2012).

Weird Realism: Lovecraft and Philosophy.

Winchester, United Kingdom: Zero Books.

Harner, M.

J.

(1973).

The Sound of Rushing Water.

In M.

J.

Harner (Ed.), Hallucinogens and Shamanism, (15-27).

Oxford University Press.

Hegel, G.

W.

F.

(1977/1807).

Phenomenology of Spirit.

(A.

V.

Miller, Trans.).

Oxford University Press.

Hoffer, A., Osmond, H., & Smythies, J.

(1954).

Schizophrenia: A New Approach.

II.

Result of a Year’s Research.

Journal of Mental Science, 100(418), 29-45.

Hogan, E.

(2017, September 1).

“Turn on, tune in, drop by the office.” Retrieved November 30, 2018, from https://www.1843magazine.com/features/turn-on-tune-in-drop-by-the-office Horne, J.

(2007).

The Four ‘Knowns’ of Sports Mega-Events.

Leisure Studies, 26(1), 81-96.

Huxley, A.

(1947).

The Perennial Philosophy.

London: Chatto & Windus.

Huxley, A.

(1999).

Mescaline and the “Other World.” In M.

Horowitz & C.

Palmer (Eds.), Moksha: Aldous Huxley’s Classic Writings on Psychedelics and the Visionary Experience, (Ch.

13).

Rochester, Vermont: Park Street Press.

Huxley, A.

(2013).

The Doors of Perception & Heaven and Hell.

United States: Important Books.

(Original works published in 1954 and 1956 respectively.).

I

Ihde, D.

(1990).

Technology and the Lifeworld: From Garden to Earth.

Indiana University Press.

Ihde, D.

(2004).

Philosophy of Technology.

In P.

Kemp (Ed.), Philosophical Problems Today, Volume 3: World and Worldhood, (91-108).

Springer-Verlag.

J

James, W.

(2002/1902).

The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature.

Routledge.

Johnson, M.

W., Richards, W.

A., & Griffiths, R.

R.

(2008).

Human Hallucinogen Research: Guidelines for Safety.

Journal of Psychopharmacology, 22(6), 603-620.

K

Katz, S.

T.

(1978).

Language, Epistemology, and Mysticism.

In S.

T.

Katz (Ed.), Mysticism and Philosophical Analysis, (22- 74).

Oxford University Press.

Krippner, S.

(2000).

The Epistemology and Technologies of Shamanic States of Consciousness.

Journal of Consciousness Studies, 7(11-12), 93-118.

Kuhn, T.

S.

(1970/1962).

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (2nd ed.).

University of Chicago Press.

L

Leary, T., Metzner, R., & Alpert, R.

(2007/1964).

The Psychedelic Experience: A Manual Based on the Tibetan Book of the Dead.

New York: Citadel Press.

Lebedev, A.

V., Lövdén, M., Rosenthal, G., Feilding, A., Nutt, D.

J., & Carhart-Harris, R.

L.

(2015).

Finding the Self by Losing the Self: Neural Correlates of Ego-Dissolution Under Psilocybin.

Human Brain Mapping, 36(8), 3137- 3153.

Lebedev, A.

(2018).

Personal email communication on October 26, 2018.

55 Lerner, M., & Lyvers, M.

(2006).

Values and Beliefs of Psychedelic Drug Users: A Cross-Cultural Study.

Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 38(2), 143-147.

Lewin, L.

(1924).

Phantastica: Die betäubenden und erregenden Genussmittel für Ärzte und Nichtärzte.

[Phantastica: Narcotic and Stimulating Drugs, Their Use and Abuse; English translation, 1931.] Berlin, Germany: Verlag von Georg Stilke.

Lotsof, H.

S.

(1994).

Ibogaine in the treatment of chemical dependence disorders: Clinical perspectives.

MAPS Bulletin, Vol.

5, No.

3, 16-27.

Lovecraft, H.

P.

(1973/1945).

Supernatural Horror in Literature.

New York: Dover Publications, Inc.

Luke, D.

(2011).

Discarnate Entities and Dimethyltryptamine (DMT): Psychopharmacology, Phenomenology and Ontology.

Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 75(902), 26-42.

Luna, L.

E.

(1984).

The Concept of Plants as Teachers Among Four Mestizo Shamans of Iquitos, Northeastern Peru.

Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 11(2), 135-156.

M

MAPS.

(n.d.).

MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy.

Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies.

Retrieved November 30, 2018, from http://www.maps.org/research/mdma Masters, R.

E.

L., & Houston, J.

(1966).

The Varieties of Psychedelic Experience.

New York: Dell Publishing Co., Inc.

Matthews, J.

(2013).

The Shamanism Bible.

London: Octopus Publishing.

McKenna, T.

(1983).

Alien Love.

Shared Visions Bookstore, Berkeley, California.

Transcript of lecture downloaded July 23, 2018, from http://terencemckenna.wikispaces.com/ (now defunct), linking to https://terencemckennaarchives.com/transcription-project/ (still active).

McKenna, T.

(1998).

True Hallucinations & The Archaic Revival.

New York: MJF Books.

(Original works published in 1993 and 1992 respectively.).

McKenna, T.

(1999, October-November).

Terence McKenna Vs.

The Black Hole a.k.a.

Terence McKenna’s last interview.

McKenna’s house, Big Island, Hawaii.

Interview by Erik Davis.

Transcript of interview downloaded July, 23, 2018, from http://terencemckenna.wikispaces.com/ (now defunct), linking to https://terencemckennaarchives.com/transcription-project/ (still active).

Merriam-Webster.

(n.d.

–a).

Definition of dissolution in English by Merriam-Webster Dictionary.

Retrieved, October 22, 2018, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disintegration Merriam-Webster.

(n.d.

–b).

Definition of disintegration in English by Merriam-Webster Dictionary.

Retrieved, October 22, 2018, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disintegration Metzner, R., & Leary, T.

(1967).

On Programming Psychedelic Experiences.

Psychedelic Review, 9, 5-19.

Mill, J.

S.

(1996).

From “On Liberty.” In R.

M.

Stewart (Ed.), Readings in Social & Political Philosophy (2nd ed.).

Oxford University Press.

(On Liberty first published in 1859.) Miller, S.

(2011).

Social institutions.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Retrieved October 10, 2018, from https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/social-institutions/ Millière, R.

(2017).

Looking for the Self: Phenomenology, Neurophysiology and Philosophical Significance of Druginduced Ego Dissolution.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 11, 245.

Mogar, R.

(1970).

Psychedelic States and Schizophrenia.

In B.

Aaronson & H.

Osmond (Eds.), Psychedelics: The Uses and Implications of Hallucinogenic Drugs, (257-276).

Garden City, New York: Anchor Books.

Monroe, R.

A.

(1971).

Journeys Out of the Body.

New York: Doubleday.

Monroe, R.

A.

(1985).

Far Journeys.

New York: Broadway Books.

Móró, L., Simon, K., Bárd, I., & Racz, J.

(2011).

Voice of the Psychonauts: Coping, Life Purpose, and Spirituality in Psychedelic Drug Users.

Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 43(3), 188-198.

56 Musto, D.

F., & Korsmeyer, P.

(2002).

The Quest for Drug Control: Politics and Federal Policy in a Period of Increasing Substance Abuse, 1963-1981.

Yale University Press.

Muthukumaraswamy, S.

D., Carhart-Harris, R.

L., Moran, R.

J., Brookes, M.

J., Williams, T.

M., Errtizoe, D., Sessa, B., Papadopoulos, A., Bolstridge, M., Singh, K.

D., Feilding, A., Friston, K.

J., & Nutt, D.

J.

(2013).

Broadband Cortical Desynchronization Underlies the Human Psychedelic State.

Journal of Neuroscience, 33(38), 15171- 15183.

N

Neher, A.

(1961).

Auditory Driving Observed With Scalp Electrodes in Normal Subjects.

Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 13(3), 449-451.

Neher, A.

(1962).

A Physiological Explanation of Unusual Behavior in Ceremonies Involving Drums.

Human Biology, 34(2), 151-160.

Noll, R.

(1983).

Shamanism and schizophrenia: A state-specific approach to the “schizophrenia metaphor” of shamanic states.

American Ethnologist, 10(3), 443-459.

Noll, R.

(1985).

Mental Imagery Cultivation as a Cultural Phenomenon: The Role of Visions in Shamanism.

Current Anthropology, 26(4), 443-461.

O

Osmond, H.

(1957).

A Review of the Clinical Effects of Psychotomimetic Agents.

Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 66(1), 418-434.

Osmond, H.

(1970).

On Being Mad.

In B.

Aaronson & H.

Osmond (Eds.), Psychedelics: The Uses and Implications of Hallucinogenic Drugs, (21-28).

Garden City, New York: Anchor Books.

P

Pahnke, W.

N.

(1963).

Drugs and Mysticism: An Analysis of the Relationship between Psychedelic Drugs and the Mystical Consciousness (Unpublished doctoral dissertation).

Harvard University: Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Pahnke, W.

N.

(1969a).

Psychedelic Drugs and Mystical Experience.

International Psychiatry Clinics, 5(4), 149-162.

Pahnke, W.

N.

(1969b).

The Psychedelic Mystical Experience in the Human Encounter with Death.

Harvard Theological Review, 62(1), 1-21.

Pawson, R., Wong, G., & Owen, L.

(2011).

Known Knowns, Known Unknowns, Unknown Unknowns: The Predicament of Evidence-Based Policy.

American Journal of Evaluation, 32(4), 518-546. 

R

Rock, A. J., & Baynes, P. B. (2005). Shamanic Journeying Imagery, Constructivism and the Affect Bridge Technique. Anthropology of Consciousness, 16(2), 50-71.

Rock, A. J., Wilson, J. M., Johnston, L. J., & Levesque, J. V. (2008). Ego Boundaries, Shamanic-Like Techniques, and Subjective Experience: An Experimental Study. Anthropology of Consciousness, 19(1), 60-83.

Ruck, C. A. P., Bigwood, J., Staples, D., Ott, J., & Wasson, R. G. (1979).  Entheogens.  Journal of Psychedelic Drugs, 11(1- 2), 145-146.

Rumsfeld, D. (2002).  DoD News Briefing – Secretary Rumsfeld and Gen. Myers.  U.S. Department of Defense. Retrieved October 5, 2018, from https://archive.defense.gov/Transcripts/Transcript.aspx?TranscriptID=2636 Rumsfeld, D. (2011).

Known and Unknown: A Memoir. New York: Sentinel.

Page 57

S

Sayim, B., & Franke, I.

(2018).

Towards a Phenomenology of the Unknown.

In H.

C.

Mertens & K.

Naie (Eds.), Ivana Franke: Retreat into Darkness – Towards a Phenomenology of the Unknown, (107-135).

Berlin, Germany: Spector Books.

Schechtman, M.

(2011).

The Narrative Self.

In S.

Gallagher (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of the Self, (394-416).

Oxford University Press.

Sessa, B.

(2012).

The Psychedelic Renaissance: Reassessing the Role of Psychedelic Drugs in 21st Century Psychiatry and Society.

London: Muswell Hill Press.

Sewell, R.

A., Halpern, J.

H., & Pope, H.

G.

(2006).

Response of cluster headache to psilocybin and LSD.

Neurology, 66(12), 1920-1922.

Shanon, B.

(2002).

The Antipodes of the Mind: Charting the Phenomenology of the Ayahuasca Experience.

Oxford University Press.

Shipley, M.

(2015).

Psychedelic Mysticism: Transforming Consciousness, Religious Experiences, and Voluntary Peasants in Postwar America.

Lexington Books.

Smith, H.

(1964).

Do Drugs Have Religious Import?.

The Journal of Philosophy, 61(18), 517-530.

St John, G.

(2011).

Spiritual Technologies and Altering Consciousness in Contemporary Counterculture.

In E.

Cardeña & M.

Winkelman (Eds.), Altering Consciousness: Multidisciplinary Perspectives, Volume 1: History, Culture, and the Humanities, (203-225).

Praeger.

Stace, W. T. (1960). Mysticism and Philosophy. London: MacMillan and Co., Limited.

Stafford, P. (1992/1978). Psychedelics Encyclopedia (3rd ed.). Berkeley, California: Ronin Publishing, Inc.

Stockings, G. T. (1940).

A clinical study of the mescaline psychosis, with special reference to the mechanism of the genesis of schizophrenic and other psychotic states.

Journal of Mental Science, 86(360), 29-47.

Strassman, R. J. (1984). Adverse Reactions to Psychedelic Drugs: A Review of the Literature. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 172(10), 577-595.

Strassman, R. (2001).

DMT: The Spirit Molecule: A Doctor’s Revolutionary Research into the Biology of Near-Death and Mystical Experiences.

Rochester, Vermont: Park Street Press.

Studerus, E., Gamma, A., & Vollenweider, F.

X.

(2010).

Psychometric Evaluation of the Altered States of Consciousness Rating Scale (OAV).

PloS one, 5(8), e12412.

Swanson, L.

R.

(2018).

Unifying Theories of Psychedelic Drug Effects.

Frontiers in Pharmacology, 9, 172.

T

Tagliazucchi, E., Roseman, L., Kaelen, M., Orban, C., Muthukumaraswamy, S.

D., Murphy, K., Laufs, H., Leech, R., McGonigle, J., Crossley, N., Bullmore, E., Williams, T., Bolstridge, M., Feilding, A., Nutt, D.

J., & Carhart- Harris, R.

(2016).

Increased global functional connectivity correlates with LSD-induced ego dissolution.

Current Biology, 26(8), 1043-1050.

Takahashi, M.

(2005).

Spirituality through the Science of Sound: The DJ as Technoshaman in Rave Culture.

In M.

J.

Gilmour (Ed.), Call Me The Seeker: Listening to Religion in Popular Music, (239–266).

Continuum International Publishing Group.

Tart, C.

T.

(1995).

Toward the Objective Exploration of Non-ordinary Reality.

Journal of Transpersonal Psychology, 27, 57-67.

Thacker, E.

(2011).

In The Dust of This Planet: Horror of Philosophy, Vol.

1.

Winchester, United Kingdom: Zero Books.

Thompson, H.

S.

(2005/1971).

Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas: A Savage Journey to the Heart of the American Dream.

London: Harper Collins Publishers Ltd.

Trigg, D.

(2014).

The Thing: A Phenomenology of Horror.

Winchester, United Kingdom: Zero Books.

58 Trulson, M.

E., & Jacobs, B.

L.

(1979).

Alterations of Serotonin and LSD Receptor Binding Following Repeated Administration of LSD.

Life Sciences, 24(22), 2053-2061.

Tupper, K.

W.

(2002).

Entheogens and Existential Intelligence: The Use of Plant Teachers as Cognitive Tools.

Canadian Journal of Education/Revue canadienne de l’éducation, 27(4), 499-516.

Tupper, K.

(2014).

Entheogenic Education: Psychedelics as Tools of Wonder and Awe.

MAPS Bulletin, Vol.

24, No.

1, Psychedelics and Education, 14-19.

W Waldman, A.

(2017).

A Really Good Day: How Microdosing Made a Mega Difference in My Mood, My Marriage, and My Life.

New York: Knopf.

Walsh, R.

(1989).

Shamanism and Early Human Technology: The Technology of Transcendence.

ReVision, 21, 34-40.

Walsh, R.

(1991).

Shamanic Cosmology: Psychological Examination of the Shaman’s Worldview.

ReVision 13(2), 86–100.

Walsh, R.

(1995).

Phenomenological Mapping: A Method for Describing and Comparing States of Consciousness.

Journal of Transpersonal Psychology, 27, 25-56.

Winkelman, M.

(2010).

Shamanism: A Biopsychosocial Paradigm of Consciousness and Healing (2nd ed.).

Praeger.

Winkelman, M.

(2014).

Psychedelics as Medicines for Substance Abuse Rehabilitation: Evaluating Treatments with LSD, Peyote, Ibogaine and Ayahuasca.

Current Drug Abuse Reviews, 7(2), 101-116.

Winkelman, M. J. (2018).

An ontology of psychedelic entity experiences in evolutionary psychology and neurophenomenology.

Journal of Psychedelic Studies, 1-19.

Winkler, P., & Csémy, L.

(2014).

Self-Experimentations with Psychedelics Among Mental Health Professionals: LSD in the Former Czechoslovakia.

Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 46(1), 11-19.

Winn, T., Crowe, B.

J., & Moreno, J.

J.

(1989).

Shamanism and Music Therapy: Ancient Healing Techniques in Modern Practice.

Music Therapy Perspectives, 7(1), 67-71.

Woodside, L.

N., Kumar, V.

K., & Pekala, R.

J.

(1997).

Monotonous Percussion Drumming and Trance Postures: A Controlled Evaluation of Phenomenological Effects.

Anthropology of Consciousness, 8(2-3), 69-87.

Y

Yaden, D.

B., Le Nguyen, K.

D., Kern, M.

L., Belser, A.

B., Eichstaedt, J.

C., Iwry, J., Smith, M.

E., Wintering, N.

A., Hood Jr., R.

W., & Newberg, A.

B.

(2017).

Of Roots and Fruits: A Comparison of Psychedelic and Nonpsychedelic Mystical Experiences.

Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 57(4), 338-353.

Z

Zahavi, D.

(2003).

Phenomenology of Self.

In T.

Kircher & A.

David (Eds.), The Self in Neuroscience and Psychiatry, (56- 75).

Cambridge University Press.

Žižek, S.

(2006).

Philosophy, the “unknown knowns,” and the public use of reason.

Topoi, 25(1-2), 137-142.

Page 59

End Quote

And now we stand on that threshold, hand in hand with this strange new partner; out of historical change comes the unexpected.

The problem of the Other, the need for the Other, the presence of the Other, the nature of the Other—these are the questions and the concerns that will drive the next order of human knowing (McKenna, 1983).

Critiques by Michael Hoffman

The Entrenched “Unitive” Model is NOT “mystical experience”

Corrupt terms that cannot be used b/c tainted w/ connotation network:

  • ego dissolution [ = covert nondual Neo-Advaita wrong model; the term, as always used, is always networked and embedded in a paradigm, unity = mystical revelation. instead of in the correct paradigm, which is “control transformation = mystical revelation”.

Houot participates in the dominant confusion: the Unitive model of “mystical experience”.

Actual mystical experience is not Unitive, but rather, control transformation.

At best – most charitably – the Unitive model is too vague and not focused on the driving dynamic.

Shamans Do NOT Have Control that Mystics Lack

It has NOT been established in this paper, the claim that “Shamans have control, unlike mystics” (in the sense Houot means).

The Egodeath theory (analogical psychedelic eternalism with 2-level, dependent control) is a model of how the mind transforms, whether mystic or shaman.

The altered state is NOT “non-rational”

Houot participates in the dominant confusion:

  • rational = ordinary state
  • non-rational = altered state

In fact, tight cognition & loose cognition are both rational.

The difference is not rational vs. non-rational. The difference is two POVs and two experiential states.

Motivation for this Page

I need the full text of the dissertation, to analyze and comment on, here.

Formatting:

  • Ignored paragraphs; para. breaks are not indicated here.
  • 1 sentence per paragraph (WordPress block).
  • Lost italics on document titles.
  • Footnotes not all formatted eg superscript.
  • Biblio needs concat’n.

This dissertation covers important topics.

I already started a Houot dissertation page:
Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control (Houot 2019) – my orig. page with comments, not full text.

I’ve been listening to Houot read aloud at Houot’s Iboganautics podcast:
https://amhouot.com/iboganautics/
eg:
https://open.spotify.com/show/6rWQ4xFHadAcyFJvKyxJpE

Podcast Episodes:

  • 1.3 – Intro (starts at mm:ss)
  • 1.4 – Ch. 1
  • 1.5 – Ch. 2
  • 1.6 – Ch. 3
  • 1.7 – Conclusion (addendum starts at mm:ss)

See Also

Site Map section:
https://egodeaththeory.org/nav/#Alan-Houot

Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control
A. M. Houot, 2019
https://www.academia.edu/38583547/Toward_a_Philosophy_of_Psychedelic_Technology_An_Exploration_of_Fear_Otherness_and_Control

Toward a Philosophy of Psychedelic Technology: An Exploration of Fear, Otherness, and Control (Houot 2019) – my orig. page with comments, not full text.

Desert Dwellers, Paul Stamets

YouTube channel: Desert Dwellers
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCjiBc42IDok3Yy9RQ4CDy0w

About 10 church people went to the D.D. show Sep. ~8, 2025.

They blew everyone away, including my producer friends.

Met Paul Stamets, got photos with him.

Got vids & pics of show & ppl.

Scored a reserved booth.

Met the Dwellers & David Starfire.

Some dubious person on the street beforehand claimed Stamets is here.
Stamets was here.